Sex & Romance
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Is my Boyfriend gay?

Been dating for a year…engaged. We are both very shy/reserved. He is OCD…he house is always neat and orderly, nothing out of place. He has many routines and he never deviates. He works in finance so he is very detailed. The reasons I believe he could be gay:

It takes him over an hour to get ready in the morning and about 30-45 minutes at night. He showers at night. He has specific creams/face washes …pro active, tretonin…stuff for acne (although he doesn’t have acne). Brushes/flosses/mouth wash every morning and night. He always gets upset with his hair if one little strand is out of place. He had braces a few years ago and still wears his retainer every night. I’ve seen him pluck his eyebrows before (although he tries to hide it). He shaved his legs (not all the way, more trimmed) in March for “biking” season. In all fairness…his whole family has extremely bushy uni-brows. He is not flamboyant in anyway. He likes nice/high end things. He dresses “basic”…same t-shirts/shorts from jcrew. Owns 2 pair of shoes only! He is very plain jane in clothing and food…only eats strawberry/vanilla ice cream. The other thing is our sex life. I feel its kind of awkward…but I feel it could be me. He likes sports…watching..we have season tickets to our college football team. He isnt emotional... no crier. He won’t watch Dancing with the stars or cougar town with me…he gets bored from them! He is not “manly” in my opinion though. He is VERY shy…although he always initiates. We do it 1-2 per week. I’ve never noticed anything on his computer…just started checking. He deletes is Ipad history frequently…but he does have a playboy account and over the past 8 months (the history only goes that far) he has visited the site fairly frequently. Please help…do my mans grooming habits and our awkward sex life mean he’s gay. I’m divorced (married too young) and don’t want to get divorced again I’m scared.
Flag Quote · Love it Reply
Re: Is my boyfriend gay or shy?!
Options
Mellbell22
10:10AM
Also ... I think it has been a long time since he's been in a relationship. Although he's been on eharmony off and on since 2010. We met online. He did tell me he was engaged once but she left him. We don't really talk about past relationships.
Flag Quote · Love it Reply

Re: Is my Boyfriend gay?

  • I answered you on the other board.

    That a guy is meticulous about his appearance and skin doesn't mean he is gay -- and the leg shaving is a biker thing. THey say it is for aerodynamics.

    What I would do if I were you:

    Put the wedding on hold --- you need to ask him why his engagement broke up (that's a must and that's no ifs ands or buts in his end; he needs to be honest why that was over -- it may have a bearing on YOU and your future) and you also need to ask him if he is gay or bi.

    I would ask him flat out.

    If you are having doubts of any kind at all, don't marry this guy until you get a solution that is 100% satisfactory to you. Wedding on hold until you get answers. Wishing you luck.
  • Since there is no edit key, I am adding more:

    Don't marry a guy if you are not 100% happy and satisfied with him and don't marry a guy is you are not 100% free of problems with him, either unresolved, pending or "maybe".

    Communication is key here.

    As it is in every relationship.

    You need to ask him why the engagement ended (and maybe I am a bugger for suggesting it but perhaps it would be prudent to talk to her if you can find her and get her side of the story -- I don't know what the chances are of that.) Who knows why it ended? Maybe he wasn't ready, or she was not, or any one of a thousand things.

    Whatever it is, you need to get the reason why it was over and he needs to be honest.

    If he balks at revealing the reason and he isn't immediately forthcoming with it, rethink him based on that. There should be NO secrets in a relationship -- whether it is one with your FI, your friends, your family or anybody you are close with and have a relationship with.

    As I said, I'd ask him no holds barred if he is gay or bi.

    And trust your gut --- it never fails.

    It might also help for you to talk to a therapist and perhaps a sex therapist. See what kind of advice you can get from them.

    If you are not sexually compatible with him and your sex life hasn't spiced up, despite the fact that you suggested this or that or got manuals and did your personal best, maybe it is time to move on. Sex isn't everything in a relationship but it is IMPORTANT. If you have no common intimacy, what good is this to you?
  • It sounds like he is meticulous about his appearance and has obsessive compulsive disorder.  Out of everything you said, there are no signs of him being gay.  Also, Playboy has women in it so...
    image
  • Thanks doeydo ... That makes me feel better! I know playboy has women in it so it must mean he's not gay even though he promos a lot and our sex life is so so... Right? I mean why would u have a playboy account if you were gay right?
  • Thanks doeydo ... That makes me feel better! I know playboy has women in it so it must mean he's not gay even though he promos a lot and our sex life is so so... Right? I mean why would u have a playboy account if you were gay right?
  • We've never discussed our awkward sex life... I assume he feels its lackluster too but he doesn't say. He orgasms every time and we do it about 2x a week... That's a good sign right? Plus he tells me when it feels good and stuff.
  • Thanks for the input I think I will try a therapist. I think part of my worries are that I don't want to make another mistake and be divorced again. He's perfect in every way and I know he's not the cheating type so I guess I feel the only way our marriage would fail is if he were gay... So I'm trying to rule everything out I guess. I'm a control freak if you can't tell:(
  •  I guess I feel the only way our marriage would fail is if he were gay... So I'm trying to rule everything out I guess.
    Nope.

    Marriages fail for many reasons other than just cheating!

    Have a look at these boards and others --- marriages fail because of abuse, drug use, addictions, one or both partners checking out, there are huge differences in the way each do things --- a family/couple crisis can do it too -- and other reasons are many: Guys who cannot unfailingly stand up for their wives, spouses with spending problems, cultural differences.

    I've only named a few.
  • Well, don't get married to someone that you can't talk to about everything. You need to talk about your sex life. You say your both reserved, maybe he wants to change things but doesn't want to make you uncomfortable. He might be thinking the same thing. 

    As to the grooming, most men do it in some fashion, why is that a big deal? I think you have some preconceived notions that are just ridiculous. I don't know many guys that don't pluck those random eyebrow hairs or try to maintain two. Heck my brother and husband had their sisters teach them and I have yet to meet a guy that doesn't in some form or another. Trimming body hair is also normal, DH does it for every part of his body. No one but me could possibly tell b/c it is trimmed not shaved, like between 1/2-1 inch long vs 2 (cringe). Who wants to see all that nasty pit hair?!? All those men in movies are waxed, I don't here people calling them gay. Guys read things online and in magazines, link below is almost exactly what you posted (makes me wonder if this is MUD). 


    What do the shows you mention have to do with being gay? I mean really? I don't watch those shows b/c I find them mind numbing. Are you saying b/c he doesn't he is or is not gay? Your whole post if really full of judgements and stereotypes. 
    image Nicholas loved for 28 weeks, 4/11/10
    Baby Boy loved for 15 weeks, 5/31/11
    Baby Girl loved for 16.5 weeks. 3/1/12
  • http://www.mensfitness.com/gear/fashion-and-trends/grooming-habits-every-man-should-take-up

    Here's another one from men's fitness. I seriously wonder about your past partners, either they cared very little about these things, were genetically blessed or hid their personal habits from you. 
    image Nicholas loved for 28 weeks, 4/11/10
    Baby Boy loved for 15 weeks, 5/31/11
    Baby Girl loved for 16.5 weeks. 3/1/12
  • I can name many many more reasons why marriages fail. If you think that homosexuality is the only reason that will cause a demise of a marriage, guess again.

    We had somebody here awhile ago whose husband was a peeping tom. YOu bet that marriage was over in a hurry when she found out what his game was.

    There was somebody else here whose marriage ended because of horrible cultural problems --- and the famiy did not like her. She knew all of this before she married the guy -- the marriage lasted about a year and a half before she finally called it quits.






  • he is probably metrosexual.  My first H was OCD about things and it took him longer to get ready than me.  He once bought wax strips to get the hair off of his face on top of the cheek bone area. After he did that it was red because of irritation so he bought some concealor at the store to hide the redness.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • And I am sure that there are plenty of gay men who will refuse to groom and manscape. So much for grooming meaning a guy is gay.
  • Does he get excited about going down on you? Not just willing, but excited? That's about as good a test as there is. It's hard to fake that enthusiasm.
  • I answered you on the other board.

    That a guy is meticulous about his appearance and skin doesn't mean he is gay -- and the leg shaving is a biker thing. THey say it is for aerodynamics.

    What I would do if I were you:

    Put the wedding on hold --- you need to ask him why his engagement broke up (that's a must and that's no ifs ands or buts in his end; he needs to be honest why that was over -- it may have a bearing on YOU and your future) and you also need to ask him if he is gay or bi.

    I would ask him flat out.

    If you are having doubts of any kind at all, don't marry this guy until you get a solution that is 100% satisfactory to you. Wedding on hold until you get answers. Wishing you luck.
    I totally agree with this.  You can only tell if someone is gay if they tell you.  But if you're wondering if he's gay then maybe spend some time getting to know each other more.  Good luck.
  • It seems to me you guys need more time to get to know each other. I feel like if you can't openly communicate with one another then you shouldn't be getting married quite yet. Sure, there are things you learn about each other even after you get married, but something like open communication is a must have before getting married. Based off your post, it kind of sounds like you guys are good friends - I'm not trying to say I don't think you should be engaged, no one can say that - but I think you need a little more time getting to know each other :)
  • I'm concerned why he has not already been up front about his prior engagement.

    When your relationship got serious, that is when he needed to say why he and the other FI broke up.

    It's not like he went out with her  a few times, or for a few weeks: this was an impending marriage and for an engagement to end, something serious had to happen.

    And if you cannot talk to your SO, it's bad news.  Rethink him if he won't be forthcoming about why that engagement is over.
  • Is this a joke?  He checks playboy regularly which would scream straight to me.  I don't see what any of this has to do with him being gay??  You are clearly thinking based on some archaic stereotypes.  Did you catch him making out with another man?  Then it's probably your own issues.
  • MrsF0831MrsF0831 member
    Third Anniversary 25 Love Its 10 Comments Name Dropper
    edited October 2013
    first I just want to say nothing that he does makes him "gay" everyone is diff just bc he cares about how he looks and like to be groomed doesn't mean hes gay. an the retainer thing SERIOUSLY i had braces in middle and high school and i have been out of high school for almost 10 years and still to this day wear my retainer at night as does my husband (he wears his prob one week out of a whole month bc his teeth don't shift) but if i don't wear my retainer even after all these years my teeth (mainly my gap i had before starts to come back)still shift, so your FI doesn;t want to deal with that.... not all guys like hair and bikers do trim there leg hairs, as do swimmers.a lot of non gay guys also trim or shave there brows so they dont look crazy (again comes down to caring about what they look like) he doesn't have to watch your cheesy shows if they don't interest him i watch my shows and if my husband doesn't want to watch hell put head phones on and watch something else on the computer instead of leaving the room.  and im not trying to be rude i watch a lot of cheesy and as my husband calls it AWEFUL reality TV lol
    Anniversary

    TTC Starting 8/2014 :)
    image
    My Ovulation Chart
  • Invest some time in learning about OCD and autism. Your man may have his quirks but he isn't blowing the paycheque on gambling, booze, dope and hookers.Not a slob either. Most women wish they had your problems.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards