Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Husband's Aunt (Very Long)

H and I just got married and have been together for 2 years. Right away I was excepted into his family. They are the most caring and open hearted people that I have ever met. This includes his aunt, that is until about a month ago.

His 17 year old cousin just gave birth to her second child. the first child is being adopted by my H's brother and his wife. They couldn't however adopt the second baby. My H and I have decided that we will adopt the baby. I know we haven't been married long but we have been raising my sister's kids for just about as long as we have been together. So it won't be much of a change. (no, neither of us have any kids of our own). Well, because the first baby was taken by CPS, the second one was as well. We will be getting her in our care as soon as everything clears and we have a home inspection.

Since the babies birth, something has changed in his aunt. She is treating me like crap. Always has something to say about the way I do things. She got mad because I didn't bring my attorney to the hospital when CPS took the baby. I told her 3 or 4 times that my attorney couldn't stop CPS or do anything that would change the outcome of them taking the baby. She still wouldn't stop bringing it up every chance she could get. I finally had to yell at her.

Recently H & I went out of town and she babysat for us. When we got back we found out that H's cousin (who is into drugs) has... ewww... scabies... So we of course took the kids right away to the doctors and yep they have them... I have been cleaning like crazy and it still seems like its not enough! I had to put medicated lotion on the kids and it burned and they cried, then I cried because it hurt them! Ugh. When my MIL told H's  aunt she wasnt allowed at the house because of the scabies she got pissed. Said that she and the cousin got them from our house and that I was the one that picked them up somewhere! WTF! Then She proceeded to tell my MIL that scabies are no big deal, her and the cousin have had them 3 times before! REALLY?!?!!!! UGH I am so done with this woman and her antics.

Re: Husband's Aunt (Very Long)

  • I want to know how your H has been reacting to her bullshit. Does he call her on it? Does he stand up to her for you? Because if he's not doing that, you have an H problem here.
  • A few questions, are you going to adopt the baby 100% legally as your child? Do you plan on keeping Aunt and cousin in the babies life? Under what role? Do you see that you and your H adopting her grandchild is making her think she now has a say in your life? Do you want her to have a say? Is this an open adoption?
  • edited September 2013
    Why didn't somebody talk to the 17 year old way back in the day and tell her "Sex is only for mature 2 people in love with a commitment and if you are having sex, you use birth control no questions asked"???

    2 kids out of wedlock? Really? Wonder who will adopt the third one???

    Nope. DON'T adopt the baby! The 2 of you just got married and *by fact of that* your marriage is on shaky ground because you just got married. You need to adjust to being married and by yourselves, not with a kiddo in tow.

    This is also too close for comfort given this is the baby of a close relative. ALSO why it is not a good idea.

    And why it is the worst idea, ever: because of the interference with the grandmother -- and what about this 17 year old who can't seem to get it she needs to practice restraint?  Will she still be *in contact* with the child??

    If she had a child removed by CPS she is bad news. No way she's changed her ways.

    IF you want to do it, I suggest you get intensive counseling before you do. A counselor will probably advise against it.

    Why this is not a good idea, also:

    I know we haven't been married long but we have been raising my sister's kids for just about as long as we have been together. So it won't be much of a change.

    I am guessing that the aunt is the grandmother of all of these unwanted babies. She needs a good lecture for not making sure her daughter adequately knew the facts of life before she was of puberty age.

    This is a great big mess, all of it...and this family he's got? Don't ask me what I think of that.

    You're going to have your hands full with this bunch. Where did you find them, anyway? You need them like you need a broken arm.

    Very doubtful that this is an open adoption, considering the birth mother's history. If a child is removed by CPS, it's neglect or drugs or abuse or something horrific. She is probably not permitted to have contact with the child -- being you and he are going to adopt that baby, how do you plan on enforcing that edict?

    This is quite the can of worms you and he are going to open. What a funky bunch in general; it would be best if you moved far away and excluded every last one of them from your lives.
  • @TarponMonoxide

    I see you are wondering what I am! Also, can't the scabies be used against the OP even getting the baby? This Aunt sounds like a complete train wreck who I wouldn't let watch my child. The social worker isn't going to like her involvement of your currant children much less this baby.
  • I want to know how your H has been reacting to her bullshit. Does he call her on it? Does he stand up to her for you? Because if he's not doing that, you have an H problem here.
    He Lets me vent and agrees with me but he usually isnt around when she says these things. His cousin was one time  (the one in the post) and she said right in front of her mom, "I usually just ignore her when she starts acting like this." and that shut her mom up the rest of the day.
  • MLE2010 said:
    A few questions, are you going to adopt the baby 100% legally as your child? Do you plan on keeping Aunt and cousin in the babies life? Under what role? Do you see that you and your H adopting her grandchild is making her think she now has a say in your life? Do you want her to have a say? Is this an open adoption?
    We are going to 100% adopt the baby. We do plan on keeping them in the baby's life but we are going to have to sit the aunt and cousin down and set some ground rules. They will be considered aunts to the baby, we all have already agreed upon that. Although I think that will be difficult for H's Aunt. I think his aunt wants to be in control and she cant be and that's making her mad. I'm not sure why she is taking it out on me except that I'm involved in the situation as well.
  • So, his 17 y.o. cousin has 2 kids she's not fit to raise to the point of CPS taking them away immediately after birth. On top of that you are raising your sisters kids. What?!

    I can't comment on your family since I don't know why you are raising your sisters kids. As for the rest, where the heck did you find this much dysfunction? Why would you then decide it would be a good idea to go ahead and immerse yourself in it? 

    This is crazy. It's not going to get better. I would head for the hills if I were you. 
  • Why didn't somebody talk to the 17 year old way back in the day and tell her "Sex is only for mature 2 people in love with a commitment and if you are having sex, you use birth control no questions asked"???

    2 kids out of wedlock? Really? Wonder who will adopt the third one???

    Nope. DON'T adopt the baby! The 2 of you just got married and *by fact of that* your marriage is on shaky ground because you just got married. You need to adjust to being married and by yourselves, not with a kiddo in tow.

    This is also too close for comfort given this is the baby of a close relative. ALSO why it is not a good idea.

    And why it is the worst idea, ever: because of the interference with the grandmother -- and what about this 17 year old who can't seem to get it she needs to practice restraint?  Will she still be *in contact* with the child??

    If she had a child removed by CPS she is bad news. No way she's changed her ways.

    IF you want to do it, I suggest you get intensive counseling before you do. A counselor will probably advise against it.

    Why this is not a good idea, also:

    I know we haven't been married long but we have been raising my sister's kids for just about as long as we have been together. So it won't be much of a change.

    I am guessing that the aunt is the grandmother of all of these unwanted babies. She needs a good lecture for not making sure her daughter adequately knew the facts of life before she was of puberty age.

    This is a great big mess, all of it...and this family he's got? Don't ask me what I think of that.

    You're going to have your hands full with this bunch. Where did you find them, anyway? You need them like you need a broken arm.

    Very doubtful that this is an open adoption, considering the birth mother's history. If a child is removed by CPS, it's neglect or drugs or abuse or something horrific. She is probably not permitted to have contact with the child -- being you and he are going to adopt that baby, how do you plan on enforcing that edict?

    This is quite the can of worms you and he are going to open. What a funky bunch in general; it would be best if you moved far away and excluded every last one of them from your lives.
    The other children we have in our care are my sisters kids. 

    The rest of my H family are very supportive of us in everything my H and I do. They even treat my niece and nephew like family. The kids call my H's parents grandma & grandpa.

    The baby will grow up knowing the truth and she will know that the first baby is her sister. We know this adoption is the right thing for us and the baby and no amount of crap from his aunt is going to change my mind about the adoption. I couldn't let this baby leave the family. She already has our last name and we picked out her first name. I was there for her birth and was the first to hold her.

    If the court says the aunt and cousin cant see the baby before the adoption and while in our care, we wont allow it. H and I already discussed that.

  • MLE2010 said:

    A few questions, are you going to adopt the baby 100% legally as your child? Do you plan on keeping Aunt and cousin in the babies life? Under what role? Do you see that you and your H adopting her grandchild is making her think she now has a say in your life? Do you want her to have a say? Is this an open adoption?

    We are going to 100% adopt the baby. We do plan on keeping them in the baby's life but we are going to have to sit the aunt and cousin down and set some ground rules. They will be considered aunts to the baby, we all have already agreed upon that. Although I think that will be difficult for H's Aunt. I think his aunt wants to be in control and she cant be and that's making her mad. I'm not sure why she is taking it out on me except that I'm involved in the situation as well.


    I'm going to warn you:

    This isn't going to work. Good luck. You and your H seem to have huge hearts and have love to give. I just don't see this working with them. Always remember: you are responsible for that child and what you says go. If they don't follow that, they are OUT of your lives.
  • Im going to warn you:

    This isn't going to work. Good luck. You and your H seem to have huge hearts and have love to give. I just don't see this working with them. Always remember: you are responsible for that child and what you says go. If they don't follow that, they are OUT of your lives


    There are simply too many hands in the soup, plus too much outside interference AND the 2 of you just got married.

    No, it won't work.

    And before you legally commit to doing this:

    Consider what happens if the adoption doesn't pan out? What if something happens, either with you and he and all this interference plus the whacky crazy family situation?

    What if you and he split up?

    Let the child be adopted by a parent or parents who can give this child a fantastic, stable home -- with none of this craziness like there is with your family situations. It's best for the child and all involved.
  • There is nothing unstable about our home or our marriage. My husband has stood by my with raising my sister's kids. just because we just got married doesn't mean that we haven't lived like a family for the past almost 2 years. We as a family have talked about the adoption; this includes H's mother, my mother, H's brother/SIL (who are adopting the first child) and we all agree it is the best situation. Please don't judge the family on his aunts behavior. The rest of us are mature and caring people.
  • This seems like a really bad idea.
  • It gives me a headache just trying to follow that. Have these people never heard of birth control?
  • This whole situation sounds like a heaping spoonful of WTF. I don't know if you're ignoring how completely convoluted and crazy this all sounds, or of you really think this is normal. Either way, good luck. I'm with @TarponMonoxide give this baby to people who really want a baby. The best thing for it would be to get the hell away from this mess and live a truly normal, stable life.
  • The baby will be with people who really want her. I agree that his aunt is crazy but that doesn't mean my husband and I are. We are more than capable of raising children. We do it everyday and the kids are healthy and happy. This post was a rant about his crazy aunt and not a request for people to talk me out of adopting the baby.

  • The baby will be with people who really want her. I agree that his aunt is crazy but that doesn't mean my husband and I are. We are more than capable of raising children. We do it everyday and the kids are healthy and happy. This post was a rant about his crazy aunt and not a request for people to talk me out of adopting the baby.
    I think the reason people are trying to talk you out of adopting this baby is BECAUSE the aunt and cousin are so crazy that they are VERY unlikely to respect boundaries and your authority as legal guardians for this baby.

    Add to that the fact that you're ALREADY raising your sister's kids AND are newly married, it seems likely that this adoption will lead to an exorbitant amount of stress on you and your relationship.

    I kind of agree that adopting this baby may not be the best thing for you, or for your relationship's longterm well-being.
  • edited September 2013
    The baby will be with people who really want her. I agree that his aunt is crazy but that doesn't mean my husband and I are. We are more than capable of raising children. We do it everyday and the kids are healthy and happy. This post was a rant about his crazy aunt and not a request for people to talk me out of adopting the baby.
    Hon: "People who really want her" are not always people who can provide the best for a child --- and that's the best in all senses of the word: healthy family life, the promise of a stable future, upcoming fine education, supportive parents and supportive family, to name a few.

    The kids in that family are not healthy and happy and forget the family itself. Your/his aunt is a nutcase, the birth mother can't seem to learn her lesson regarding restraint and birth control and CPS has been in on the whole affair. The entire situation with the family surrounding the baby is volatile as it gets.

    Please consider what I said about letting a person -- whether it's a single person or a married/dedicated couple ---  who can provide the best of everything adopt that baby.
  • I don't doubt that you and your husband are qualified to adopt/raise children. But THIS situation, THIS child... Bad idea.
  • edited September 2013
    I think the reason people are trying to talk you out of adopting this baby is BECAUSE the aunt and cousin are so crazy that they are VERY unlikely to respect boundaries and your authority as legal guardians for this baby.

    Add to that the fact that you're ALREADY raising your sister's kids AND are newly married, it seems likely that this adoption will lead to an exorbitant amount of stress on you and your relationship.

    Why are you everybody's babysitters??? Why are you and your H party to being the family playground for every kid they've got?

    I vote that you and your H forget the idea of adopting your niece and move far far away and write this entire divisive and dysfunctional bunch off for good. Lose contact with them and let it stay that way.

    Youth is against you. You and your H haven't got the mettle or the guts to stand up to this crazy bunch and stand your ground on what's right. You should have told the aunt to stfu when she started this mess and he should have beein in your corner backing you up on that one all the same --- how in heck are you going to handle all the family interference if you adopt this child? My guess is you won't. This is a can of worms you sholuldn't even touch.

    And what is the 17 year old going to do? No doubt crank out another kid? What happens then? who gets to adopt  that one???

    Say no to adopting that child. The circumstances and time is all wrong and so is the bunch that's involved in the family.

    Something else important to consider:

    The mother is 17 and irresponsible.

    How do you know what she wasn't into -- drugs or alcohol or some other substance? Very doubtful there was even regular prenatal care -- suppose the child is disadvantaged or develops a problem along the line? Are you and your H going to be able to handle that?

    Resources are not always at the ready or easy to obtain. Programs and funds may be restricted or tight in your school district; do you and your H have adequate enough medical coverage for the baby, also -- and more than adequate funds if there is a big problem with this child's health or development later on, due to something that happened prenatally?

    It isn't just money: it's also tenacious to cope with emotionally. Are you and he prepared for that?
  • Why are you raising your sister's kids? Stop letting your aunt and by extension your cousin babysit. Seriously they aren't fit to watch them.
  • ClaryPax said:
    Why are you raising your sister's kids? Stop letting your aunt and by extension your cousin babysit. Seriously they aren't fit to watch them.
    The aunt isn't fit to babysit a pet rock, judging by what you have told us, OP. No way I'd let somebody so divisive and so nasty babysit anybody.
  • MLE2010 said:
    @TarponMonoxide I see you are wondering what I am! Also, can't the scabies be used against the OP even getting the baby? This Aunt sounds like a complete train wreck who I wouldn't let watch my child. The social worker isn't going to like her involvement of your currant children much less this baby.
    The scabies could indeed be used against the OP. Scabies are never found under normal conditions.

    Whatever social worker it is must be getting ready to tear his or her hair out --- and if anything, no adouption should be okayed until the courts have a very lengthy period of discussion.

    I am also surprised the courts didn't order the op and her H to undergo some type of family counseling -- to see if they were fit enough parents to adopt the kiddo.

    Maybe this whole issue is already falling through the cracks. We don't even know the whereabouts of the birth mother; if anything, I am guessing the courts will ensure that she has NO CONTACT with the child --- this is the purpose of a CPS confiscation of a child.

    We don't even know if the birth mother will be out of the picture completely.
  • His aunt is not a reflection of  how I raise children. The reason we let her babysit was because it was already a set plan before the second baby was born. I was under the impression that the reason she couldn't raise the first baby was because her house wasn't fit for a child. After this last incident she is no longer allowed in my house and will no longer allowed to babysit. I for sure learned my lesson with that.

    I don't know why I am being put on the block here. There is nothing wrong with my home or my marriage. as soon as I found out about what was going on I took all the proper steps that I needed to in-order to fix the problem.

    As far as the adoption goes, the Child is going to grow up healthy and happy. she will grow up knowing that she has parents that love her very much. she will get the education that she needs and deserves. she will never go without the things she needs. If this means I need to cut my H's cousin and aunt out of the picture, than that's what we will do. My H and I already talked about it. My family all live 2 1/2 hours away and if we need to we will sell our house and get one by my family.

    None of you people ever had a bad seed in your family? Your telling me that you all would let your family members be adopted out just because of 2 bad seeds? Like I said before, the rest of the family is very well grounded and stable.

    I do see your concern but you don't know the whole story nor do you know how responsible my husband and I are.

    This will be my last post because I don't want to be told anymore about how I am a bad parent; when none of you know how well I'm raising my sisters kids (who I love as if they were my own and that's why I have no problem "being their daycare").
  • I think the point people here are trying to make is that you're neck deep in unfit parents and unstable relatives on both sides of your family and that there's no indication that will stop.  You can't keep taking in children indefinitely.  This girl is 17 and on her 2nd kid.  Obviously having the first one taken away didn't convince her to use birth control.  She'll likely have 4 more before she hits 25.  It's good that it's worked out with your sister's kids for 2 years but you're in a VERY new marriage with a lot of stress.

    They're just saying that there are couples or singles out there who have struggled for years and years and are devastated that they can't have their own children.  You seem to be taking this baby out of obligation because you don't want her to leave the family.  Why not concentrate on your marriage and the children you're already raising and let this baby make a clean break from the insane family and have a new life in a family free of this drama?
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • I don't doubt that you are a good parent. Not at all, nor do I think that you are irresponsible. If I'm honest I think that you are young and although you have been put into an unfortunate situation, you have risen to the challenge with a lot of grace and strength.

    I do think, though, that if you adopt this child there will be some unnecessary hardship down the road. How are you going to explain it to them when they get older that their mother didn't want/couldn't care for them and their grandmother didn't want / couldn't care for them - and then still see them on holidays and for family functions? For a child to grow up knowing that their own mother didn't want them and then to see them so often would be like rubbing salt in an open wound. It doesn't matter how wonderful of a mother you are to them - kids often put their birth mother on a pedestal ( I certainly did) an you are now the bad guy.

    The mother and your husband's aunt are very toxic, unstable people. Would the child not be ultimately better off growing up away from these people, also with a loving family, and introduced back to these toxic people if the child wants and if the child is ready?

    There is a lot to consider. Just because you can and would provide an ideal home for this child doesn't meant that the family dynamic that this involves would be ideal. For you, or for the baby. Or for the mother. Or the aunt. Or for your other kids. Or for the child's other siblings.

    I think that before you make this decision you should talk to some social workers, adoption agencies or ideally other people that are in your situation - adopting a child within the family - with toxic family members involved, and see how that went for them as the kid got older.
    image

    Chronically hilarious - you'll split your stitches!
    I wrote a book! Bucket list CHECK!
  • I don't doubt that you are a good parent. Not at all, nor do I think that you are irresponsible. If I'm honest I think that you are young and although you have been put into an unfortunate situation, you have risen to the challenge with a lot of grace and strength.

    I do think, though, that if you adopt this child there will be some unnecessary hardship down the road. How are you going to explain it to them when they get older that their mother didn't want/couldn't care for them and their grandmother didn't want / couldn't care for them - and then still see them on holidays and for family functions? For a child to grow up knowing that their own mother didn't want them and then to see them so often would be like rubbing salt in an open wound. It doesn't matter how wonderful of a mother you are to them - kids often put their birth mother on a pedestal ( I certainly did) an you are now the bad guy.

    The mother and your husband's aunt are very toxic, unstable people. Would the child not be ultimately better off growing up away from these people, also with a loving family, and introduced back to these toxic people if the child wants and if the child is ready?

    There is a lot to consider. Just because you can and would provide an ideal home for this child doesn't meant that the family dynamic that this involves would be ideal. For you, or for the baby. Or for the mother. Or the aunt. Or for your other kids. Or for the child's other siblings.

    I think that before you make this decision you should talk to some social workers, adoption agencies or ideally other people that are in your situation - adopting a child within the family - with toxic family members involved, and see how that went for them as the kid got older.
    image

    Chronically hilarious - you'll split your stitches!
    I wrote a book! Bucket list CHECK!
  • Tofumonkey said it well.

    You and your husband sound like lovely, stable, caring people.  I have no doubt you guys would make great parents.

    But this particular situation is problematic.  There is no distance in the adoption process here.  The unstable presence of the aunt/niece (who are in fact mother and grandmother to the child) in your lives will add a whole level of drama to your lives that you guys just don't need.  

    These are people with a poor grasp of boundaries.  They will no respect your authority as parents and will interfere in your raising of your child, because they really won't see you guys as the parents.  They will make your lives immeasurably more complicated than it needs to be.  

    An adoption by an unrelated couple will make the situation cleaner and less intertwined.  

    None of this is a statement about your ability as parents but on your aunt/niece not to be unstable, drama laden, freak shows in your lives.
  • Tofumonkey said it well.

    You and your husband sound like lovely, stable, caring people.  I have no doubt you guys would make great parents.

    But this particular situation is problematic.  There is no distance in the adoption process here.  The unstable presence of the aunt/niece (who are in fact mother and grandmother to the child) in your lives will add a whole level of drama to your lives that you guys just don't need.  

    These are people with a poor grasp of boundaries.  They will no respect your authority as parents and will interfere in your raising of your child, because they really won't see you guys as the parents.  They will make your lives immeasurably more complicated than it needs to be.  

    An adoption by an unrelated couple will make the situation cleaner and less intertwined.  

    None of this is a statement about your ability as parents but on your aunt/niece not to be unstable, drama laden, freak shows in your lives.
    These are not just "bad seeds." YOu're in a bit of denial if you think these "bad seeds" are something to more or less "live with." Nope.

    If you adopt this child, she'll also grow up under a lot of strain and stress. You have no idea how much more the dynamic will worsen. My guess is that they will get worse over time -- and I don't doubt that the 17 year old will crank out a 3rd unwanted baby, and perhaps more.
  • His aunt is not a reflection of  how I raise children. The reason we let her babysit was because it was already a set plan before the second baby was born. I was under the impression that the reason she couldn't raise the first baby was because her house wasn't fit for a child. After this last incident she is no longer allowed in my house and will no longer allowed to babysit. I for sure learned my lesson with that.

    I don't know why I am being put on the block here. There is nothing wrong with my home or my marriage. as soon as I found out about what was going on I took all the proper steps that I needed to in-order to fix the problem.

    As far as the adoption goes, the Child is going to grow up healthy and happy. she will grow up knowing that she has parents that love her very much. she will get the education that she needs and deserves. she will never go without the things she needs. If this means I need to cut my H's cousin and aunt out of the picture, than that's what we will do. My H and I already talked about it. My family all live 2 1/2 hours away and if we need to we will sell our house and get one by my family.

    None of you people ever had a bad seed in your family? Your telling me that you all would let your family members be adopted out just because of 2 bad seeds? Like I said before, the rest of the family is very well grounded and stable.

    I do see your concern but you don't know the whole story nor do you know how responsible my husband and I are.

    This will be my last post because I don't want to be told anymore about how I am a bad parent; when none of you know how well I'm raising my sisters kids (who I love as if they were my own and that's why I have no problem "being their daycare").

    OP, I hope you're still reading these because I get where you're coming from. I seem to have the opposite opinion of others posters. I completely understand why you would want to adopt this baby and not let it go to strangers. I think it's really loving and brave, especially considering the crazy relatives involved. Every family has bad seeds, and there's no guarantee where this child would end up or what crazy people might be involved if s/he is with strangers. If you adopt her, you know she's in a loving home, you're prepared for the crazy and you'll do your best to minimize it. You can take legal action if needed. And s/he will get to know the sibling. I think that's really important and great. And yes, I have bat-shit crazy family members and in-laws. I chose to marry my DH knowing it meant a lifetime of dealing with his crappy family. It's not easy, but it's worth it. Good luck, OP.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards