Pittsburgh Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Kindergarten and lying

Yesterday when I picked Cori up, she wasn’t very talkative and seemed a little sad or angry. (This is usual, and you’d think I’d learn to not ask how her day was, what they talked about, etc. But I miss her and would like to know, so I continue to ask.) Well, I figured I would just ask her for a hug.  She gives me a half hug and mopes more. I give her a couple of minutes and come up to her and ask what was wrong, was she sad, did something happen, etc.  She proceeds to tell me that she is sad because she was on yellow today. (Most kids have something similar – a behavior color chart where green is good, blue is really good, purple is exceptional. Yellow is a warning to make better choices and red is big trouble.) Each day I look in her folder because it shows her color for the day, and yesterday it was green. I tell her that she wasn’t on yellow, she was on green, and she tells me that she accidentally colored the square green instead of yellow (they color them and not use stickers) and her teacher said it was okay.  <?xml:namespace prefix = o ns = "urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:office" />

 

I then asked what happened, and to make a long story short, she was very hesitant to give me details, but she tells me she almost hit someone in the face because he was making fun of her and said she was stinky. She said she apologized but she was put on yellow. She finally revealed his name was Logan and she was so, so sorry and she would make better choices. So I told her okay, but as a punishment, no movies that night, and we talked about what to do when someone makes fun of you. She even asked follow up questions about “well, what if they follow you, etc”. She didn’t want me to tell her Dad, and I said okay, because you will.  When he got home, she didn’t want to tell him but I enforced it.   Fast forward a few hours and I figure I’m going to email her teacher just to see what happened, if Cori did indeed apologize, etc.

 

Turns out Cori made the whole thing up!!!!  Her teacher emailed me back to say Cori was on green all day and there was no incident and there is no Logan in the class….  What the heck?!?! I didn’t know if I should be relived or embarrassed.

 

I told Cori I talked to her teacher who said she was on green all day, and Cori proceeds to break down crying saying she is sorry she made it up. Turns out she heard that story at daycare or something… OMG I don’t know what I’m going to do with this girl, and worse off, I have no idea what I can believe anymore! Her teacher said that one of the kids in the class (who is a twin and both kids are in the class) said his sister broker her leg and was in a cast up to her hip. In walks the sister the next day.... Ugh!! Is this that common for this age, or ??

Re: Kindergarten and lying

  • So to answer your question simply, yes. EJ lies more now too!  But I have to say never in such a complex way.  Usually it is when I ask if she took her medicine (asthma inhaler preventative that she does herself).  SO I am always reminding her she cannot lie about medicine. She also likes to call people in our family and pretend she is someone else. Which is hilarious, and harmless at this point. So perhaps it is something with the age.

    She is also typically a grump after I pick her up at daycare. and I am more likely to get stories about her day out of her at bedtime than in the car ride home.
  • Wow that was some story!

    Honestly I never know what to believe sometimes with dd! Some of it is not wanting to tell the truth, but some of it is imagination, confusion, misinterpretation.

    One of the first days at dd's new after school place her teacher told me she got really upset at lunch and wouldn't stop crying and wouldn't tell her why. So I asked dd and she told me that she wanted to eat her fruit cup first and couldn't open it but her teacher wouldn't open it for her and told her she couldn't eat it first. I found that strange so I asked the teacher and she said that dd started crying before she opened her lunch. So I have no idea what happened. I'm not sure that dd was lying but maybe misinterpreted something!

    Anyways I don't think making things up is too abnormal. I would just talk to her about not lying and that she can always tell you the truth, etc
    Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers
  • Wow that was some story! Honestly I never know what to believe sometimes with dd! Some of it is not wanting to tell the truth, but some of it is imagination, confusion, misinterpretation. One of the first days at dd's new after school place her teacher told me she got really upset at lunch and wouldn't stop crying and wouldn't tell her why. So I asked dd and she told me that she wanted to eat her fruit cup first and couldn't open it but her teacher wouldn't open it for her and told her she couldn't eat it first. I found that strange so I asked the teacher and she said that dd started crying before she opened her lunch. So I have no idea what happened. I'm not sure that dd was lying but maybe misinterpreted something! Anyways I don't think making things up is too abnormal. I would just talk to her about not lying and that she can always tell you the truth, etc

    I feel like part of what you said above April is Cori 24/7!  Cori had a similiar food issue a few months bakc - told me that she was in time out at daycare because she wouldn't eat her peas and she had to miss recess. Something didn't seem right, so I called the teacher and it turns out while they do enforce the "one bite" rule, they never yelled at C or put her in time out. Apparently, hours later when they went out to recess, C took it upon herself to just sit in a chair for 15 mins??? So odd!!

    And Amanda, I had to LOL at E calling up family members pretending to be someone else - nice!!

  • "imagination, confusion, misinterpretation. "

    YUP! We still have this with Gavin. What I do is go straight to the source and ask. At this age, I'm confident that the teachers know that the kids are dramatic, confused, etc. and I'm sure they appreciate you looking for the truth (versus assuming your child is always in the right), you know?

    Sometimes, it's just for attention. It sure makes me feel like crud, that my kid has to go to extremes for attention!

    Hang in there!

    image
    My three sons!

  • DD is always making up crazy stories.  I try to let the stories go, because I do believe that it is just her overactive imagination.  Sometimes she tells stories about what she wishes would happen (like when she had the entire daycare believing that I was having another baby (in the fall, her name was going to be Darcie, etc.). Or things she thought about doing, but knew she shouldn't. 

    Maybe there was a kid bothering her, and she did think about clocking him, and her telling you the story was a way for her to judge what your reaction would have been. 

    Now--when DD makes up things like saying Nolan did something when it was really her, or says she ate her dinner when she didn't, we address those as lying incidences and remind her it isn't OK to lie.
    imageBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Tickera>
  • DD actually is really good about not lying, but I've read places that lying is developmentally normal at this age. DD is a bad liar (maybe b/c she doesn't do it often, or perhaps that's WHY she doesn't do it often), so normally I can tell when she's not being honest. She never makes up stories, but I'll ask her if she did something (brush her teeth, put her clothes away, etc) and she'll say yes when I know the answer is no, or vice versa. I just remind her that Santa Claus is watching and lying is a sure way to get on his naughty list. It works every time.

    Of course "Nathan" in her K class told her yesterday (on the day she lost her very first tooth) that the Tooth Fairy is actually her mom, so I don't know how much longer the Santa threat will work!
  • I agree with others that the line between imagination and reality and be very blurry at that age. I'd just remind her that it's not ok to make up stories like that.    
     
  • Maybe Cori will be an author some day! ;)

    DD fibs some, but it's never been very elaborate - and we always know she's doing it.  The little girl down the street seems to lie all the time, but her older brother calls her out on it every single time.

     
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards