Relationships
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

He loves me, he loves me not?

Hello all!

Where to begin... ?? *sigh* 

Well, for starters, I've been married for a year. Sadly, we were separated for 5 months during that year. A lot of things transpired shortly after we tied the knot and it caused a horrible amount of stress and devastation. First, I realized that my DH was a bit insecure and that he was emotionally abusive. (I didn't know it was EA at the time, but after researching, I found out.) I felt worthless and uncared for in our marriage. I began to vent to friends on FB. One of my best friends is also my ex finance and I vented a great deal to him. (BIG MISTAKE, I know...) Anyway, after the emotional abuse got to where he was becoming manipulative, verbally intimidating, door slamming and throwing things, I chose to leave. When I told him I was leaving, he said nothing... Just shrugged. I came home later that night to find all of my emails, Skype account, FB account and any other social media you could think of had been invaded. He looked through it all (EVERY FB MESSAGE, EVERY EMAIL)  then told me he agreed with getting a divorce. I left. (Sidenote: shortly after marrying, we moved to China to work. I left him in China and went back to the States) 

Fast forward 2 months. I get another job offer in China. I accept. I come back (to China). He's still here. He doesn't speak to me for months (He's a grudge holder at times) So, out of the blue... he calls me and asks to meet. He tells me he's sorry and doesn't want a divorce. (I've already settled in my mind that I don't want him back or to go back to the abuse I felt). I agree, however, to take things slow and not file for divorce just yet. So now, it's been about 2 more months and we are finally beginning to speak again. We have decided to try to work it out. Here's my problem... I feel like I'M the one doing all the work... I am the one looking for Marriage advice, I send him encouraging notes, I text him and express loving words of hope about our marriage. (And even though he texts back and watches the videos and things I send him... it's all still very "surface") I told him the other day that we need to make a decision on what we want to do (divorce or try to work it out) because I am ready to leave China if we are not going to work it out. I want to travel. So, his actions and words are not really lining up right now. I'm trying SO hard not to be prideful, but I feel like why am I the one pursuing him? Why am I the only one "crawling back" or fighting for this? I mean, we BOTH hurt each other. It takes a tremendous amount of courage on my part to even TRY to express myself emotionally to someone who neglected and damaged my heart so much in the past. How do I handle this? It's so easy to just give up and although a part of me wants to because I feel like I am just setting myself up again,  another part of me genuinely loves my DH and desires to see it work. Have any of you dealt with this? A man who doesn't pursue consistently. (In my case, he says he acts this way because I hurt him and he's scared.) Ummmmmm HELLO, I dealt with his emotional abuse until I literally felt like I was going crazy! I feel so foolish day in and day out... waiting for him to convey the same love and feelings I am. Plus now, he drinks WAYYYYY more than he ever did while dating and is into smoking "herbal" substances habitually (that was NEVER, EVER a part of our marriage or life before we were seperated.)He says he does it all because of our separation. I HIGHLY disagree. I was hurt by our separation too but my character never changed.Very confusing. Gosh, my heart hurts. Please give me your opinion ladies (and gents, if applicable). I'm not sure who else I can talk to .. Thanks for reading! 

Re: He loves me, he loves me not?

  • File for divorce. He's abusive and that behavior doesn't just magically disappear. At any point during your separation or during this period of "trying to work things out" did he attend counseling? Did you? Problems like these don't just go away. You two aren't equipped to fix this alone. You guys made a half assed attempt to hold into this marriage. It's not my intention to be mean but you're delusional if you think this marriage can be salvaged by texting encouraging notes or expressing your love for him via text message. You either really do the work (get yourselves into individual and marriage counseling) or cut each other loose. I'd opt for the latter.
  • Stop trying to make it work with him. File for divorce. Work on you by going to counseling.

    He's abusive and clearly not a good match for you. Move on and focus on you.
  • Come on. You know the answer here. Unless he goes to counseling and REALLY makes an effort to change - he ISN'T GOING TO CHANGE. He just isn't. Actions always speak louder than words, and you've said that he isn't actually ACTING on anything.
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • edited October 2013
    His claims about drinking and smoking are emotionally abusive tactics as well, because he's essentially blaming his conduct on you.  Sorry darlin, but I think you need to leave and not look back.
  • You would be a fool to take him back. 
  • Run far. And run fast.

    You deserve better.

  • He is an abuser and has not changed a bit.  You deserve better.  Get a divorce now and move on with your life.
    image
  • JemmaWRX said:
    You guys made a half assed attempt to hold into this marriage.
    That isn't fair. At all. HE made a half assed attempt (or even less than half); she has been trying and trying to get him to participate and be present.

    I have been in this situation. We never married (thank god), but it took me an awfully long time to recognize the emotional abuse and realize that no matter how much effort I put into it, it was a waste unless it was reciprocated. You try and try and try, thinking that if you keep making an effort eventually he'll join in. He won't. Not now, not ever. He is being manipulative by blaming his current behavior on the separation. It's no one's fault but his. You deserve better; get out.
    imageimage
  • I truly thank you (all) for your feedback... I want to go to counseling. He said he'd go as well. The problem is that we both live in a small town in China where there are hardly even other foreigners to speak to. I have no problem leaving and going to the States and trying to make this work but now that he had a little success here, he is hesitant to leave. Plus, he says he really hates living in the States. So... welp, there ya have it. I know to most, this sounds like a no brainer, but I come from a christian background and almost everyone that I've tried to get advice from has told me to try to work it out. :/   I want to but... I'm conflicted. 
  • I understand wanting to work it out. At the end of the day, he needs to be willing to make some major changes, and it doesn't sound like he is willing. If he will attend couple's counseling with you, I think there are some therapists who will now do sessions over Skype. Not sure how that works or where to find them but I swear I saw a news report or something once about a therapist who does most of her work over video chat.
    imageimage
  • JemmaWRXJemmaWRX member
    500 Comments Second Anniversary 25 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited October 2013


    JemmaWRX said:

    You guys made a half assed attempt to hold into this marriage.

    That isn't fair. At all. HE made a half assed attempt (or even less than half); she has been trying and trying to get him to participate and be present.

    I have been in this situation. We never married (thank god), but it took me an awfully long time to recognize the emotional abuse and realize that no matter how much effort I put into it, it was a waste unless it was reciprocated. You try and try and try, thinking that if you keep making an effort eventually he'll join in. He won't. Not now, not ever. He is being manipulative by blaming his current behavior on the separation. It's no one's fault but his. You deserve better; get out.


    I meant more so for not demanding counseling at any point while trying to work it out. Lovey text messages aren't going to fix this guy, you know what I mean? But fair enough. I've never been in that situation so it's all much easier said than done. My apologies if I offended you or the OP.

    ETA - OP, you need to do what's right for you regardless of what your friends or family have to say. This is YOUR life. As strongly as I believe you should leave, it's your decision. But keep in mind BOTH of you need to put in the effort. It takes two people to make it work. Just prepare yourself for the possibility that he won't do his part. Good luck.
  • I truly thank you (all) for your feedback... I want to go to counseling. He said he'd go as well. The problem is that we both live in a small town in China where there are hardly even other foreigners to speak to. I have no problem leaving and going to the States and trying to make this work but now that he had a little success here, he is hesitant to leave. Plus, he says he really hates living in the States. So... welp, there ya have it. I know to most, this sounds like a no brainer, but I come from a christian background and almost everyone that I've tried to get advice from has told me to try to work it out. :/   I want to but... I'm conflicted. 

    I'm sorry you're going through this. And just because you're Christian doesn't mean you have to put up with abuse and "make it work"!! Making a marriage work requires the equal effort of the partners. You don't have that. You have a husband who is blaming you for his bad behavior, instead of owning up to it, taking responsibility for being a good person and a good husband, and making an effort to deserve you. You can't make him do those things, so you can't make it work. Let yourself off the hook here and let him take responsibility for himself. Life is short and you should spend it with people who treat you with respect and love. I wish you all the best and hope you meet someone who knows what it means to be a real partner.

  • I read through the first few sentences and this is a big muddled up mess.:( Sorry for your troubles...

    Well, for starters, I've been married for a year. Sadly, we were separated for 5 months during that year. A lot of things transpired shortly after we tied the knot and it caused a horrible amount of stress and devastation.

    Maybe given the above you needed to file for an annulment. A separation during your first year of marriage isn't usual, or noneventful.

    First, I realized that my DH was a bit insecure and that he was emotionally abusive. (I didn't know it was EA at the time, but after researching, I found out.) I felt worthless and uncared for in our marriage.

    I don't want to further add wood to the fire but if somebody is treating you miserably to the point where you are having your daily routine disrupted, it's time to tell that person to pack it in and call it a day. Wow.:(

    I began to vent to friends on FB. One of my best friends is also my ex fiance and I vented a great deal to him. (BIG MISTAKE, I know...)

    You learned your lesson: NEVER disclose highly sensitive details to anyone but a therapist. Confide in nobody at all but a therapist; these are details that need to remain between you and your H.

    Anyway, after the emotional abuse got to where he was becoming manipulative, verbally intimidating, door slamming and throwing things, I chose to leave. When I told him I was leaving, he said nothing... Just shrugged.

    Actually, HE needed to be the one to go, by gentleman's agreement, not you.

    I came home later that night to find all of my emails, Skype account, FB account and any other social media you could think of had been invaded. He looked through it all (EVERY FB MESSAGE, EVERY EMAIL)  then told me he agreed with getting a divorce. I left. (Sidenote: shortly after marrying, we moved to China to work. I left him in China and went back to the States) 

    Well, too bad for him. I guess the truth hurts.

    Fast forward 2 months. I get another job offer in China. I accept. I come back (to China). He's still here. He doesn't speak to me for months (He's a grudge holder at times) So, out of the blue... he calls me and asks to meet.

    Why in the heck didn't you file for a divorce when you left??? I'm confused.

    Divorce this guy NOW. Perhaps you can get an annulment based on the fact there was abuse.

    He tells me he's sorry and doesn't want a divorce. (I've already settled in my mind that I don't want him back or to go back to the abuse I felt). I agree, however, to take things slow and not file for divorce just yet. So now, it's been about 2 more months and we are finally beginning to speak again. We have decided to try to work it out. Here's my problem... I feel like I'M the one doing all the work... I am the one looking for Marriage advice, I send him encouraging notes, I text him and express loving words of hope about our marriage. (And even though he texts back and watches the videos and things I send him... it's all still very "surface") I told him the other day that we need to make a decision on what we want to do (divorce or try to work it out) because I am ready to leave China if we are not going to work it out. I want to travel. So, his actions and words are not really lining up right now. I'm trying SO hard not to be prideful, but I feel like why am I the one pursuing him? Why am I the only one "crawling back" or fighting for this? I mean, we BOTH hurt each other. It takes a tremendous amount of courage on my part to even TRY to express myself emotionally to someone who neglected and damaged my heart so much in the past. How do I handle this? It's so easy to just give up and although a part of me wants to because I feel like I am just setting myself up again,  another part of me genuinely loves my DH and desires to see it work. Have any of you dealt with this? A man who doesn't pursue consistently. (In my case, he says he acts this way because I hurt him and he's scared.) Ummmmmm HELLO, I dealt with his emotional abuse until I literally felt like I was going crazy! I feel so foolish day in and day out... waiting for him to convey the same love and feelings I am.

    Dude, you HAVE to get rid of him, posthaste!


     Plus now, he drinks WAYYYYY more than he ever did while dating and is into smoking "herbal" substances habitually (that was NEVER, EVER a part of our marriage or life before we were seperated.)He says he does it all because of our separation. I HIGHLY disagree. I was hurt by our separation too but my character never changed.Very confusing. Gosh, my heart hurts. Please give me your opinion ladies (and gents, if applicable). I'm not sure who else I can talk to .. Thanks for reading! 

    You're pretty much messed up yourself if you can't see that this marriage is not working. LEAVE an abuser, no questions asked.

    File for divorce and do not look back. That's the only alternative you have. Nothing here to love, nothing here to save.

    And for love of God: get therapy. His behavior is not normal and that you still are interested is not normal, either.
  • I truly thank you (all) for your feedback... I want to go to counseling. He said he'd go as well. The problem is that we both live in a small town in China where there are hardly even other foreigners to speak to. I have no problem leaving and going to the States and trying to make this work but now that he had a little success here, he is hesitant to leave. Plus, he says he really hates living in the States. So... welp, there ya have it. I know to most, this sounds like a no brainer, but I come from a christian background and almost everyone that I've tried to get advice from has told me to try to work it out. :/   I want to but... I'm conflicted. 
    Abuse is a dealbreaker.

    This is whether you are spiritual or if you are an athiest; there is no two ways about it.

    You cannot stay with an abuser. Nor can you reason with one.

    And you can't counsel the abuser, either.

    Use your common sense. I do not think God would want you to stay with somebody who means harm for you.
  • We had a terrible time after we moved to China. We'd been married for three years (both working on incredibly stressful project) before we moved, but the stress of living in China still caused some very serious strain on our marriage. Luckily we were in Beijing, but there still weren't a lot of counseling options at the time, and my husband refused to go anyway. I went on my own, but I ended up at Beijing United, and their counselors are mostly rubbish (FYI). Since I moved a few ex-pats have opened private practices, and a lot of people have swarmed away from the person I saw.

    There are some serious issues in your marriage, and you're not going to be able to address them if you're not both willing to work on it. But honestly, I think your best bet is to move first. We went to China with a half dozen other couples, and today only two of them are still married.

    Things definitely got better for us after we moved to a less stressful location, but eventually we realized that there were fundamental differences between us, and we just weren't as good a match for one another as we thought we were. We are both Christian and come from traditional families, so it took us a long time to get over the stigma. Eventually I realized one day that I have decades left to live, and I don't want to spend them struggling to be happy. It might disappoint our parents, and some people view it as a failure, but why is staying in an unhappy marriage your entire life seen as a "success?" It's not too late to start over. We did, and we're both happier than we've ever been.
    image
  • All of your responses have been SO helpful. I guess a part of me needed to validate my feelings for wanting to leave. Being in a relationship where you're subtly trying to convince the guy that you're "worth fighting for" can really do horrible things in your mind. I know what to do for sure. I'm very grateful to you all for sharing your opinions and stories. I'm 27 and I don't want to feel trapped or unhappy. I have my whole life ahead of me... I want to live it. Happily! :)  
  • Get & read  "The Verbally Abusive Relationship" by Patricia Evans. It will set you on the path to freedom. Then get some council by someone who understands said book & agrees with it's principals. Pretty soon, you will get yourself free from the never ending roller coaster ride that is your DH. He is consistent at being inconsistent at best. I'm in process of divorcing same type of man. Run & don't look back. No regrets here. 11 years of misery, freedom is just around the corner. Best   day was the day I moved out. Don't waste your life pursuing someone who is never going to be on the same page...
  • I saw this on Pinterest last night and thought of you. I wish someone had shown this to me years ago.

    image
    imageimage
  • Listen, to answer your question, He doesn't love you.  THis isn't how love is.

    Please gather the courage to choose a better life for yourself. 

  • File for divorce. But I would also take part in some real introspection to understand how you got so far in the relationship with out really knowing him. At least then something positive could come from this.
  • I second the China issue, but also wonder why in the world you would go back to the same small town in China where the only other foreigner to interact with was your separated husband.

    What the hell were you thinking?!?

    We lived in China for about 6 years and though our relationship was fine, we saw the breakdown of many relationships with China being a major catalyst. The stress of living there, the limited interactions and social groups, the strain and aggressive pursuit of foreign men and women as well as the cultural (and business) views toward spouses and infidelity were major issues.

    Further to that, the loss of independence when you are living somewhere in which you do not speak the language and are suddenly illiterate (we lived in small places there as well) cause couples to easily become overly co-dependent upon each other. It brings some people closer, it tears others apart.
    image

    Chronically hilarious - you'll split your stitches!
    I wrote a book! Bucket list CHECK!
  • I have seen success with my sister who while seperated went to individual counseling and then also couple counseling, he eventually went to individual counseling too. It gave them the chance to work on their own personal issues which made it easier to deal with the marital issues. If that's not an option, at the very least you need to let him know that you need more effort from his side if he truely wants this marriage to work. Be specific on what you need from him. Then give him time to see if he does make the changes, and if he does, does he stick to them or was it a short term change. You need to be open on with him about your needs & wants and what you won't tolerate. I'm not saying don't file for divorce but with any marriage you need to have communication, neither of you are mind readers and if you don't tell each other what you want, how are you suppose to resolve things? If things continue as they were, then file for divorce. But then you can file with the knowledge you did what you could to save the marriage, it just didn't work.

  • Emotional abuse is a deal breaker for me.  I have experienced it and told the person I would leave and they changed back to normal (It was sort of a stressful situation that brought it on).  The point is they changed so that I wouldn't leave and if I had left I am certain they would have pursued me with everything they had.  

    I do feel like sometimes people claims that something is emotional abuse when it might not actually be that, but if you feel that it is then I believe you and you need to get out for good.  
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards