Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Thanksgiving chaotic...already :/

My Husband and I bought a house at the end of January so this is our first year doing holidays in our new house. When we bought the house we decided that we would do all holidays home (Thanksgiving and Christmas). We had discussed this with our parents when we bought the house but refreshed their memories recently by saying "we are going to do Thanksgiving home this year, you guys are more then welcome to join us". Well my side of the family said yes to joining us as well as my husbands side but then my BIL's wife posted a nasty Facebook status saying I was refusing to leave my house and calling my family a bunch of douche bags (she's met my family once). Apparently I wasn't suppose to see this status but I did and I sent it to my MIL saying "...I just wanted a nice Thanksgiving, not have my family bashed" to which my MIL apologized for what her other DIL had said and proceeded to ask her other DIL why she would do and say that. Well, apparently it was an accidental Facebook status that was meant to be a text message to someone - is that an excusable reason? because I'm still slightly sour about it.

Re: Thanksgiving chaotic...already :/

  • Truthfully, I think I would ignore it. If she comes over for Thanksgiving, I'd be politely social, like if she were a stranger to you. If she says anything directly to you about Thanksgiving, I'd be tempted to tell her to feel free to stay home, but I don't know that I'd actually do that.
    And, no, the fact that it was meant to be a text rather than a FB status doesn't make a difference. I'd be sour, too.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I wouldn't like this either, but I also feel bad for your MIL. Why would you tell her and have her talk to the DIL instead of dealing with it yourself? It's not your MILs fault or responsibility to deal with it, and takes it to another level of drama. If I were you I would have just asked the DIL directly what was going on, and told her she didn't have to come if she didn't want to. She sounds like a weirdo, but don't put your MIL in the middle!
  • Leftie22 said:
    I wouldn't like this either, but I also feel bad for your MIL. Why would you tell her and have her talk to the DIL instead of dealing with it yourself? It's not your MILs fault or responsibility to deal with it, and takes it to another level of drama. If I were you I would have just asked the DIL directly what was going on, and told her she didn't have to come if she didn't want to. She sounds like a weirdo, but don't put your MIL in the middle!

    ^^^ This. But, what's done is done. Have SIL come if she wants to and ignore it. I would be ticked too, but it really isn't your problem. Who knows what her deal is and really who cares.
  • Leftie22 said:
    I wouldn't like this either, but I also feel bad for your MIL. Why would you tell her and have her talk to the DIL instead of dealing with it yourself? It's not your MILs fault or responsibility to deal with it, and takes it to another level of drama. If I were you I would have just asked the DIL directly what was going on, and told her she didn't have to come if she didn't want to. She sounds like a weirdo, but don't put your MIL in the middle!
    100% this.

    Also, while your SIL was rude, at the same time, why couldn't your "message" be "Hey- it's our first Thanksgiving in our new home.  We really want to host this year - please join us" instead of "we're staying home. You can join us if you want.".

    You're SIL is in the wrong, but the way your post reads, you're not coming across as being overly welcoming.  You sound more commanding and "it's our way or the highway" and that may be rubbing people wrong.
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • Leftie22 said:
    I wouldn't like this either, but I also feel bad for your MIL. Why would you tell her and have her talk to the DIL instead of dealing with it yourself? It's not your MILs fault or responsibility to deal with it, and takes it to another level of drama. If I were you I would have just asked the DIL directly what was going on, and told her she didn't have to come if she didn't want to. She sounds like a weirdo, but don't put your MIL in the middle!
    100% this.

    Also, while your SIL was rude, at the same time, why couldn't your "message" be "Hey- it's our first Thanksgiving in our new home.  We really want to host this year - please join us" instead of "we're staying home. You can join us if you want.".

    You're SIL is in the wrong, but the way your post reads, you're not coming across as being overly welcoming.  You sound more commanding and "it's our way or the highway" and that may be rubbing people wrong.
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • I sent it to my MIL because in the past my BIL's wife  and I haven't exactly gotten along and she is known for bending my words,so It was my preventative measure to make sure I wasn't the one who came off like an a-hole. I haven't approached my BIL's wife about the whole status at all because I'm nervous if I did it would give my Husbands parents a reason not to show up to our Thanksgiving. Also the reason we did the whole laid back "we are staying home this year for Thanksgiving and you're welcome to join" is because my family is spread thin with divorces, girl friends and boyfriends and we didn't want to feel like we were forcing people to come to our house.

  • Leftie22 said:
    I wouldn't like this either, but I also feel bad for your MIL. Why would you tell her and have her talk to the DIL instead of dealing with it yourself? It's not your MILs fault or responsibility to deal with it, and takes it to another level of drama. If I were you I would have just asked the DIL directly what was going on, and told her she didn't have to come if she didn't want to. She sounds like a weirdo, but don't put your MIL in the middle!
    100% this.

    Also, while your SIL was rude, at the same time, why couldn't your "message" be "Hey- it's our first Thanksgiving in our new home.  We really want to host this year - please join us" instead of "we're staying home. You can join us if you want.".

    You're SIL is in the wrong, but the way your post reads, you're not coming across as being overly welcoming.  You sound more commanding and "it's our way or the highway" and that may be rubbing people wrong.
    I agree with this. Yes, your SIL was wrong to post on FB (and frankly, I don't buy the text message excuse). But I think you're coming across as pretty rigid, and I don't blame her for feeling annoyed. 

    You said you wanted to do "all holidays" at home. Did you mean just this year? Or do you mean you want to spend ALL Thanksgivings and Christmases every year, at your home from now on?  I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and assume we're just talking about this year. But the fact is, even if it's just this year we are talking about, every time you say, "We're staying home. You can join us if you choose," you're basically saying that it's more important for you stay home (i.e. have your way) than it is to see everyone else. And don't get me wrong, you have a right to say that--you just have to realize that it's going to be off-putting to some people.


    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Yes, I mean just this year and I understand what you are saying.
  • It was still wrong to drag your MIL into this. Ultimately you just exacerbated the drama. It was a shitty thing for your SIL to say, no doubt about it. But your MIL didn't need to know, let alone be responsible for fixing the problem. Your reasoning doesn't really make sense either... It was a preventive measure because your SIL twists your words? But then you go on to say you haven't addressed it with her and kind of implied you had no intention to ever discuss it with her. If you weren't going to speak to her she would have no opportunity to twist your words, right? To be honest, this is reading like you had an opportunity to throw your SIL under the bus and make her look bad. She sounds like an asshole but don't stoop to that level. It does you no good and clearly it's causing rifts among the whole family now. Let stupid shit like this go. It's not worth your energy.
  • Look- you clearly have a history with this girl.  As such, she probably LOOKS for things to be pissy about when it comes to you.  As such, IGNORE. 

    It's fine if you wanted to make sure MIL understood what was going on, but be careful of making her feel like you're putting her in the middle. And really- if they "give in" to this girl, that's on them.  Somewhere in this, you have to recognize that everyone is an adult and I'm SURE they know what your SIL is like.  It's up to them to decide for themselves what they want to do. 

    YOU need to just back away from your SIL, though, and ignore her antics. 
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • Considering you don't get along with SIL, I'm not sure why you're surprised, why you have her on your Facebook, or why you reacted at all. In the future I suggest you ignore any attempt on her part to engage you and block her Facebook.
  • If I saw that kind of crap on facebook I wouldn't say anything to anyone. Your BIL's wife is just making herself look bad and everyone can see how immature he is without you running to MIL about it. 
  • Not excusable because it was nasty, uncalled for, and not true. Personally, I hold people to their actions and would expect an honest apology. Someone who talks smack about me or my family is not welcome in my home.
    photo May2014.jpgphoto MomTatWhiteNew40.jpg
    BabyFetus Ticker
    BabyFruit Ticker
    May 2014 November Siggy Challenge
    The Griswold’s Christmas Vacation
    photo GriswoldChristmas.jpg
  • I got a message from her on FB saying

    "Ever since I realized that I accidentally posted that text to my Facebook , I've been trying to figure out what to say or how to apologize. I've got no excuse, it was a poorly worded venting text to my friend because I was upset about spending thanksgiving with people who make me super uncomfortable. It wasn't going to your house, but the fact that I feel super awkward around your family because of all the stuff that went on when we were fighting. I know you knew how that feels. I feel about one inch tall. The whole reason I didn't want to not go to your thanksgiving is because I was worried about offending you guys, and instead I ended up doing so much worse. I'm heartbroken over my own impulsive stupidity because I really was enjoying getting to know you better, and now in one stupid text I ruined it."

    I replied with

    "It is what it is and what's done is done. The truth is, is that my family was excited to have everyone together under one roof. They feed off me and my actions or respect toward someone - you and I were doing so well and so they were cool. Regardless of this situation you guys are more then welcome to join us on Thanksgiving - it's a day for family after all ."

     

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards