Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

What is your outlook on the economy?

There has been a lot of guesses on some articles I have read about when the economy will tank again.  It can't be as bad as 2008 right?  I just wonder what you guys think about the economy.....good, bad, indifferent? Every time I talk with my mom on the phone I always end up feeling bummed out.  I can't get thru a conversation with her without her bringing up all the bad stuff.  They are planning to retire in the next couple years and she feels that it's such a sad thing what America has become whatever that means.  She is afraid "they" (govt) will rob them of their retirement money.  It's kinda frustrating for me.....today she asked me what I plan on doing to protect "our retirement money".  It does make me think about it.  I have heard that when unemployment gets to around 6.2% the feds will stop pumping money into the stock market so I've always thought that I would cash out my profits right before that happens.  Ultimately I can't say that our businesses have gotten worse since the last recession.  Both DH and I work in fields that are always needed so that has helped me think of saving more money instead of spending it and actually I think that this is the best time to be an "entrepreneur", we can always find work.  I'm kinda rambling now, since this board is strong believers in pinching pennies I thought I would ask this question.
Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

Re: What is your outlook on the economy?

  • hoffsehoffse member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited November 2013
    Honestly the idea of a future recession doesn't really bother me.  2008 was definitely bad, but we've recovered all that (and plenty more) since then.  People forget about the recessions of the 1970's and 1980's.  Unemployment was up to 9% back then.  And look what happened.  We had some huge booms after that.

    I generally believe in free market economics.  I think we should leave it alone and let businesses rise and fall as needed.  People hate to hear this, but some businesses do need to fail.  Not every idea is a good one.  And not every business model is current with an increasingly global economy.  I always find it so interesting to hear people hate on Wal-Mart because of what it has done to small businesses.  And yet, Wal-Mart employs thousands of people who probably wouldn't be able to get a job in those small businesses, and it allows plenty of generally lower-income folks maintain a decent standard of living because their flour now costs $3 instead of $5.  Is the byproduct harsh?  Sure.  But they took a hell of a business risk when they started out, and it paid off.  If people don't want Wal-Mart to survive, all that has to happen is people have to stop shopping there.

    I do think there will be another downturn.  In fact, I think there will be several more before I retire.  But I'm willing to stay in the market because I generally trust in it coming back - and I trust the free market to ensure survival of the fittest (from a business standpoint).  And in my 20's and 30's, I can afford to wait out a future recession and let it come roaring back before I get out for good.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I have been following both the economy and Politics since Michael Keaton was in love with Reagan back in the 1980's.  I have seen both parties taking away the restrictions put into place after the Great Depression.  I also watched and got caught up in the giving away of credit in the 1990's that allowed that boon.

    So far the only portion of the stock market that is still recovering is a lot of the tech stocks that were hit in the tech stock burst of the late 1990's early 2000's.

    I finally have a degree that is in need with a ton of engineers retiring over the next decade I should have good job security.

    If your parents are almost ready to retire and they are starting to freak out that means that they haven't done the proper planning when they were younger.  Both of my parents are retired and their retirement income is enough to cover all of their living expenses except for some traveling that my dad's consulting business covers.
  • I don't have the guts to ask them how much they have.  I think she is just afraid of the economy tanking in turn killing their money in the stock market.  She wants to be able to retire without stress.  she also says she doesn't trust either party (dem or repub).  She has been watching a lot of youtube so there is that.  I just logged into my account and dang everything I've been managing myself is all in the green so it must be at a high right now.  

    Side question: should a self employed person contribute the percentage to retirement based on gross or net income? $2,500 more till we get to where I want us in our efund and I'm hoping that will be the spring for us and then we will be putting money in retirement again.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • vlagrl, you generally want to use gross income as the benchmark.

    If your mom is approaching retirement, she should be mostly out of stocks.  At her age she really wants to be looking for a 5-7%-ish (or even a bit less) return on her investments.  She doesn't necessarily need to be heavily invested in stocks to do that.  I'm looking for something more than 10% at my age, and that's why H and I are so heavily invested in stocks.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I was thinking gross as well but wasn't totally sure.  with all the deductions we have it didn't seem like we should base it on the net.

    I know my mom is mostly in bonds at their age and are being very conservative.  I think she may be watching too much youtube lately.  I have quite a few stocks as well.  JPmorgan is up 100% since I first bought it.  Crazy.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • H and I were discussing this issue last night. I'm very comfortable with riding the ups and downs of the market until my early 50s or so. H worked in mutual fund customer service during 2008-2009, and was very scarred by the experience. I don't think anything like that will happen to such an extreme for a while, although the debt ceiling issues (which I *disclaimer* am still working on understanding) scare me. I'm probably more politically-liberal than many on this board, mostly for social and environmental reasons, but it still seems to me if we keep borrowing forever, something bad is going to happen.

    I think many of our generation were scared away from investing by the crash in 2008. I was chatting with a good friend the other day who said, "I don't see the point in 401k contributions. I lost most of my money in 2008 and haven't looked at it since." When I mentioned that, if she hasn't looked at it since she's probably gained all the money back and then some, she was shocked. I just look at investing as a tool I can use to make things more comfortable for our retirement. If the big rich guys can use the market to get ahead, then so can I (with reasonable investments for my level, of course).
  • H and I were discussing this issue last night. I'm very comfortable with riding the ups and downs of the market until my early 50s or so. H worked in mutual fund customer service during 2008-2009, and was very scarred by the experience. I don't think anything like that will happen to such an extreme for a while, although the debt ceiling issues (which I *disclaimer* am still working on understanding) scare me. I'm probably more politically-liberal than many on this board, mostly for social and environmental reasons, but it still seems to me if we keep borrowing forever, something bad is going to happen. I think many of our generation were scared away from investing by the crash in 2008. I was chatting with a good friend the other day who said, "I don't see the point in 401k contributions. I lost most of my money in 2008 and haven't looked at it since." When I mentioned that, if she hasn't looked at it since she's probably gained all the money back and then some, she was shocked. I just look at investing as a tool I can use to make things more comfortable for our retirement. If the big rich guys can use the market to get ahead, then so can I (with reasonable investments for my level, of course).
    Yes, my mom came to my house the weekend before the crash hit and made me move all my investments into 1 secure fidelity bond....saved me from loosing a lot!  Then I got scared to reinvest it until about a year and half ago, DH finally talked me into it and i"m glad I did.  I too also think that if we keep borrowing money then one day something really bad will happen.  They keep kicking the debt ceiling down the road and want to keep raising the limit without having any spending cuts.  I don't agree with what this administration is doing fiscally.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I worry that there is a bubble in the stock market. The growth we've seen over the last few years, and the fact that that growth is not reflected in better employment numbers worries me. I think people are investing in stocks too much and driving their value too high because interest rates are so low that other investments look bad.

    I'm still heavily invested in the market, And I don't plan to change that. I'm still around 15 years away from retirement, so we have time to wait for a recovery if there is another downturn. However, it makes my stomach churn to think of losing what we've saved so far, especially when I feel so confident it will happen one of these days. In addition to our stocks and mutual funds, we are still sitting on a lot of cash for precisely this reason. It's our hedge against a crash, to have the cash to buy low if it happens. We are split around 80% stocks and 20% cash now (not very interested in bonds with rates so low), and anticipate keeping that balance into retirement (though probably with some of the cash transitioning to bonds).
  • Yeah the debt ceiling thing bothers me a lot - that bothers me a lot more than the market.  If China ever decides to call in our debt, well then we're toast.

    Socially I'm pretty liberal but I have trouble bringing myself to pay for it.  I'm so cheap that I edge on conservative for a lot of things.  I mean, things like gay marriage, recycling, etc., sure I'm totally on board.  Because the way I see it, other people's relationships (and their trash for that matter) are absolutely none of my business.  But extra social programs?  Not as much - because the way it's done is typically so expensive and so inefficient.  I think a LOT of "conservatives" would be willing to be "liberal" if the money was managed better.  I'd be totally on board with universal healthcare if it wasn't so inefficient.  Structuring it to be done through insurance seems like a colossal waste to me.

    Anyway, I tell people I vote cheap.  I'm perfectly willing to live in a world where we all contribute our tax dollars for the better good (roads, police, education, even healthcare, etc.).  But the people in charge just toss money down the toilet.  I don't live that way, and I generally resent the government spending my money that way. 

    So yeah, the debt ceiling thing is a huge issue for me.  So many average Americans can see that this never-ending-borrowing is a terrible idea - and politicians are so afraid to be voted out on that one issue that nobody will step up and fix it.  Sigh. 
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I honestly think they should all be fired, but that's just my opinion.  I consider myself fiscally conservative, socially moderate.  I believe we need those programs in place (food stamps, wic, etc) but they need to be managed better.  Anyways even at dinner at my mom's last night she was saying it's not a good time to retire because you just don't know what is going to happen economically and I agree that it doesn't seem stable right now.  Everything always seems to be a crisis lately (debt ceiling, fiscal cliff, govt. shutdown).
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • We have rough roads ahead.  The economy will continue a very slow recovery.  Job creation will remain mostly in the low wage category. More people will drop out of the market.
    Inflation will rear it's ugly head. Taxes will increase.
  • Ditto Sisugal on inflation and taxes.

    The DOW is dancing at 16,000. But remember, usually when the market soars so high, it has a mighty crash - this growth in the economy is not sustainable. And, when you see this sort of growth and the unemployment rate not go down concurrently, then you have a bubble being formed. The money being made on the market is not a true reflection of the ingenuity of the country's businesses. Bubbles are highly dangerous (think housing bubble).

    I think we will have a crash again in the next few years and that it will be worse than 2008.

  • It is because the Federal Reserve is printing money.  When they have to start pulling this money out of the economy is when we will see the next crash as people pull money out of the stocks and bonds.  You will also see inflation start to go up even more.
  • vlagrl29vlagrl29 member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited December 2013

    Ditto Sisugal on inflation and taxes.

    The DOW is dancing at 16,000. But remember, usually when the market soars so high, it has a mighty crash - this growth in the economy is not sustainable. And, when you see this sort of growth and the unemployment rate not go down concurrently, then you have a bubble being formed. The money being made on the market is not a true reflection of the ingenuity of the country's businesses. Bubbles are highly dangerous (think housing bubble).

    I think we will have a crash again in the next few years and that it will be worse than 2008.

    Not what I wanted to hear, ML! :) I will take the profits while I can and then cash out before it crashes again.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • vlagrl29 said:



    Ditto Sisugal on inflation and taxes.

    The DOW is dancing at 16,000. But remember, usually when the market soars so high, it has a mighty crash - this growth in the economy is not sustainable. And, when you see this sort of growth and the unemployment rate not go down concurrently, then you have a bubble being formed. The money being made on the market is not a true reflection of the ingenuity of the country's businesses. Bubbles are highly dangerous (think housing bubble).

    I think we will have a crash again in the next few years and that it will be worse than 2008.


    Not what I wanted to hear, ML! :) I will take the profits while I can and then cash out before it crashes again.


    Just curious, but how would you pull it out before a crash? You can predict it that well?

  • Ditto Sisugal on inflation and taxes.

    The DOW is dancing at 16,000. But remember, usually when the market soars so high, it has a mighty crash - this growth in the economy is not sustainable. And, when you see this sort of growth and the unemployment rate not go down concurrently, then you have a bubble being formed. The money being made on the market is not a true reflection of the ingenuity of the country's businesses. Bubbles are highly dangerous (think housing bubble).

    I think we will have a crash again in the next few years and that it will be worse than 2008.

    Not what I wanted to hear, ML! :) I will take the profits while I can and then cash out before it crashes again.
    Just curious, but how would you pull it out before a crash? You can predict it that well?
    Sometimes you can see the writing on the wall if you watch it closely enough.  Though, usually not until the first part of the crash has begun.

    The 2008 one was something that some folks knew about before it happened.  Hence all the fines the banks have had to pay since then.

    The problem with people who claim they can predict crashes is that economics is very closely tied to political situations and natural occurrences/disasters that are pretty impossible to predict.  Many of the economists who predicted the 2008 crash (without the inside knowledge the banks had) are now saying we're headed toward a state of martial law and possibly a completely different form of government in the US.  Well guess what?  Not one political scientist or economist has ever successfully predicted the state of American (or world) politics 10 or 20 years into the future.  That's because something ALWAYS happens that they couldn't have foreseen - WWII, the Cold War, the invention of birth control, eradication of many childhood diseases, the civil rights laws, the internet, the EU, 9/11, Hurricane Katrina, Obamacare, etc.  And these major events always turn their predictions upside down.

    I try not to read doom and gloom because most of the time it's wrong.  Not always - and there will be other crashes, perhaps worse than 2008 - but I trust that something will then come along that rectifies the problem.  Imagine what would happen to the stock market if we found the cure to cancer?  I suspect my biomed holdings would pretty much explode.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Trying to time the market is a fool's errand. If you are that worried about losing money, get out of the stock market entirely and move into something less risky. People who study the market for a living don't do that well timing the market. Plus there are tax consequences for jumping in and out of the market which cuts into your profits.
  • hoffse said:

    Ditto Sisugal on inflation and taxes.

    The DOW is dancing at 16,000. But remember, usually when the market soars so high, it has a mighty crash - this growth in the economy is not sustainable. And, when you see this sort of growth and the unemployment rate not go down concurrently, then you have a bubble being formed. The money being made on the market is not a true reflection of the ingenuity of the country's businesses. Bubbles are highly dangerous (think housing bubble).

    I think we will have a crash again in the next few years and that it will be worse than 2008.

    Not what I wanted to hear, ML! :) I will take the profits while I can and then cash out before it crashes again.
    Just curious, but how would you pull it out before a crash? You can predict it that well?
    Sometimes you can see the writing on the wall if you watch it closely enough.  Though, usually not until the first part of the crash has begun.

    The 2008 one was something that some folks knew about before it happened.  Hence all the fines the banks have had to pay since then.

    The problem with people who claim they can predict crashes is that economics is very closely tied to political situations and natural occurrences/disasters that are pretty impossible to predict.  Many of the economists who predicted the 2008 crash (without the inside knowledge the banks had) are now saying we're headed toward a state of martial law and possibly a completely different form of government in the US.  Well guess what?  Not one political scientist or economist has ever successfully predicted the state of American (or world) politics 10 or 20 years into the future.  That's because something ALWAYS happens that they couldn't have foreseen - WWII, the Cold War, the invention of birth control, eradication of many childhood diseases, the civil rights laws, the internet, the EU, 9/11, Hurricane Katrina, Obamacare, etc.  And these major events always turn their predictions upside down.

    I try not to read doom and gloom because most of the time it's wrong.  Not always - and there will be other crashes, perhaps worse than 2008 - but I trust that something will then come along that rectifies the problem.  Imagine what would happen to the stock market if we found the cure to cancer?  I suspect my biomed holdings would pretty much explode.
    Pretty much.  I read and watch quit a bit of news and I knew the 2008 crash was going to happen and literally put everything in a bond before it tanked therefore not loosing as much money as those that left it in stocks.  What I would do is take the profit I have made in my funds and stocks and move them into my money reserve within the IRA therefore not having any tax penalty.  Buy low, sell high is my motto.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • The economy doesn't really bother me. DH and I work in fields that are always needed. (He's in oil and gas, and I'm a teacher when I return to the work force). Honestly, what we are doing for retirement so that the economy doesn't matter is to not depend upon the government. We also live well below our salaries and save a lot. We both have 401ks and an individual retirement. I won't get social security, but DH may. We aren't expecting to get a penny of that money back.
    Maybe your mom is so depressed because they were planning on that?
    (I'm replying before reading any other responses, so I don't know if you came back and said more).
    image
  • I agree with the PP who said that predicting how the market will go is a "fool's errand." I can't predict anything and the weather people cannot even get it accurate either. Side note: It's funny when they predict 6-8 inches or snow and people run to the store to stock up and we get a dusting!!!

    "Prediction" probably isn't the best word. More like reading and paying attention to the indications and focusing on the whole picture is a better approach.

    Big picture in the U.S. is a shaky economy, with the government printing money like crazy (Quantitative Easing [QE] to infinity), a ton of consumer debt, a devalued dollar, the government debts held by foreign nations (many not so 'friendly' to the U.S. [like China]), and a rapidly increasing market that is not balanced and moving concurrently with other important economic indicators. And, these are just the economic indicators.

    We have huge social collapse problems too, which are destablizing our nation - weaker families, broken marriages, abuse on the rise, suicide (DH just flew with a pilot who is a fire chief in our town. He said the most frequent things they visit are car crashes and suicides), pornography, addictions, mass shootings, government dependence and a refusal to take responsibility for one's self and one's family.

    DH and I are 30 years from retirement. We can weather storms right now. But, we are also very well diversified. We own stocks, bonds, and precious metals (both in ETFs and physically).

    We aren't counting on SS in our retirements. If it's there, great...but we don't expect it.

     

     

     

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards