Relationships
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Am I overreacting?

My husband and I recently had an argument that I'm having a hard time getting over.

The backstory: 

I'd been out of town for work for 3-4 days a week for the month prior. As a result most of the housework, to include cleaning the kitchen, vacuuming, cleaning the bathrooms, laundry, etc. hadn't gotten done. I came home on a Friday night and my husband got extremely angry about the state of the kitchen. He didn't say anything but began storming around cleaning it up. He didn't ask for help and I didn't offer any, figuring that since the dishes are his responsibility and I'd already done vacuuming since I got home, I'd earned a little time to chill. He got done and started drinking. I went to bed. He never came to bed, instead stayed up drinking.

When I got up he was passed out on the couch. I started cleaning up and he woke up and went to take a shower. While he was in the shower I noticed that his phone was blinking and I checked it to make sure he hadn't missed anything important while passed out the night before. What I found were a bunch of texts to his mom and sister telling them that I was a huge slob, that he was miserable with me, and that he wanted to call another girl (who has been a friend of his for a long time) and tell her that she was the most beautiful girl in the world. He told them that he'd wanted to be with this girl for 10 years and never had the chance, he asked them how to tell me that I needed to clean up more or he was packing his stuff and leaving.

We talked about it when he got out of the shower and a little sobered up. He said it was just a fantasy and that everyone is entitled to fantasies. That he wasn't truly miserable with me and he didn't want a divorce like he'd said. Despite the fact that he said this was a fantasy, 3 years ago he'd gotten drunk and kissed this same girl. He told me about the kiss incident when it happened and we moved on, except that he never told me who it was with, he implied that it was just some random girl. 

I felt completely betrayed and cheated on, despite the fact that he didn't actually text/call this girl. I think that I would've felt better if he had, instead of filling my in-laws with this idea that I'm a complete slob. He completely neglected to mention to them that we have housework divvied up and that the kitchen is his responsibility. He didn't mention that I'd been gone for most of the month and he hadn't lifted a finger to help with any of the housework that is my responsibility while I was gone. 

I'd appreciate any advice on if I'm overreacting by feeling cheated on and betrayed, or how to handle this situation. 

Re: Am I overreacting?

  • Yeah, I'd be pissed. Why would he drag his mom and sister into this? Drunk or not, that is weird. 

    He needs to learn to talk or you if he's upset, not get drunk and complain to others.

    Does he have a drinking problem? Is he getting drunk a lot, or do you always/mostly have issues when he's drinking? If so, he needs to get some help. I'm all for responsible drinking, but if it causes fights, irrational behavior, or you can't control yourself, there's a problem.
  • I would leave him. 
    image
  • Eeeeew!  I would have been livid.  For one thing, he shouldn't be complaining to his mother and sister about your guys' problems.  For another, whoa wait a minute, I don't give a shit if it is a fantasy or what, he is way wrong in saying that he thought she is the most bla bla bla.  I understand thinking things fine, but he goes and says it to his mom and sister too...  That is weird.  You said he kissed this same girl he was talking about, 3 years ago.  Was this before you two were together?  Was this during?  Wtf? 

     I am so sorry here, and I may be wrong, but this is just me.  I would not be cool with it.  Even if things aren't meant the way they may be said, they are still said and that doesn't make the feeling go away.  It could be nothing, like he said, just he was drunk and just a fantasy.  Could be because he was upset and whatever.  But I know myself, I would try ot get ot the bottom of it a little.  I wouldn't want my H thinking about any other woman.  Even worse, telling his moma bout it...

       Image and video hosting by TinyPicimageimage

  • There is so much wrong here. 

    From his inability to keep the house straight while you're gone (divided or not - when one person isn't around/ is busy, the other ADULT in the house can fricking step up a little) to the really pretty big communication problems between the two of you.

    On one hand, I want to say "leave him", but at a MINIMUM, I think the two of you need counseling. 

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • I feel like maybe there is a lot more going on than OP is saying. The cleaning problem in no way elicits a response like that, no matter how much he has been drinking. The way he talked to his mom and sis about it was completely disrespectful to you. How did they respond in his messages? I feel like they would find his behavior unacceptable too. Did he even apologize or just brush off this behavior because "everyone is entitled to fantasies"? Whatever the case, his behavior is complete BS and I would most definitely be pissed and hurt too.
    Anniversary
  • I think you underreacted. I would have flushed the toilet while he was in the shower, so he got scalded, then when he got out I would have told him that, if being married to me was such a chore, he's welcome to fuck right off and move back in with Mommy. 
    I'll bet he already has something going on with the other girl, and he's looking for justification to break up with you. You're out of town for work a lot (and I'm not blaming you AT ALL), what does he fill his time with when you're gone? I'm thinking he's not alone.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • He sounds like such a wonderful husband *sarcasm*. 

    Why can't he clean? If he is there more than you then that makes him the slob.

    He shouldn't be complaining to mommy, he should be talking about it with you.

    And while having fantasies are okay on some level, he shouldn't go around telling other people about them. Sounds like his real feelings got out.


    This guy sounds suspicious. Maybe he's already cheating. 
  • You're underreacting, IMO. He was angry that the house was messy? He could've cleaned up himself while you were out of town. In fact, that was his responsibility while you weren't there. And to jump to wanting to leave you for another girl (being drunk is not enough an excuse IMO) because you didn't clean up his messes (since I doubt they were even halfway yours) is fucking asshole behavior.
  • My Mom always told my Dad "If you have time to bitch about it you have time to clean it". My Dad has happily been helping her clean the house for 40 years.
  • I will bet you a bajllion dollars he has already cheated and is

    1. preparing his family for the upcoming divorce and his new ( or current) relationship with his girlfriend. 

    2. justifying his affair to everyone ( including himself) by pinning it on you and your " messiness."

  • I will bet you a bajllion dollars he has already cheated and is

    1. preparing his family for the upcoming divorce and his new ( or current) relationship with his girlfriend. 

    2. justifying his affair to everyone ( including himself) by pinning it on you and your " messiness."

    THIS!  Watch out!  You husband sounds super shady.  I think the getting drunk because he's angry that he had to clean is a huge red flag.  Nothing good can come of that behavior and it's totally strange ( on top of all the other stuff).  I would at least go to counseling.
  • GilliCGilliC member
    Ancient Membership 5000 Comments 500 Love Its First Answer
    edited December 2013
    Am I the only one who thinks that's a really skeevy thing to tell your mom and sister? It's bad enough to say that to a close friend, but to your relatives? I think it would be weird to tell my dad that I think some guy is hot, even if I was single!

    And as for the cleaning... How can you be a slob if you weren't even home? Did you walk in the door and make a huge mess? If not, wouldn't he be the slob, since he's the only one who's been in the house?

    Listen to the PPs. You guys need to have some serious talks. Counseling would be good, but no matter how you do it, there are some discussions y'all need to have soon.
    image
  • Yeah, something fishy is going on here.  Almost as if he wanted her to find it.  Not enough evidence to show cheating, but enough for her to want to leave him.  I mean because if she is the one that leaves him, then he won't look like the bad guy to his mom and sister ( at least that might be what he is hoping would happen.)
  • I'm so sorry to hear that he is being a jerk. He could be creating all this drama so he can feel justified when he makes an exit. You forgave him once for being shady, but I don't buy it that he's just fantasizing about this other girl. He sounds like a mama's boy. You can do better. I hope you find a mature partner who pulls his own weight around the house and steps in & picks up the slack if you're out of town. Good luck. You deserve better than his lying ass.
  • After reading through this again, I don't see how this relationship can be salvaged.

    It doesn't sound like he even thought he did anything wrong. How can being happy hinge on telling someone to quit being a slob in one breath and wanting to be with someone else for the last 10 years in the next? I realize he was drunk but seriously, none of this makes sense. Did he give you a reason he's not capable of cleaning up after himself when you're not home? And who talks to their mom and sister about a "fantasy"?!

    This guy doesn't even know what a fantasy is. A fantasy is Mark Wahlberg showing up to fix my roof...when it's really hot out...so he can't wear a shirt...and has to come in to the air conditioning for a bit before he passes out from heat exhaustion...and well, you get the idea...

    A fantasy is not me telling my dad that I've been I love with Joe Blow down the street for the past 10 years and wish I could tell him how hot he is. That is bizarre, pathetic, and disrespectful. 

    If I were you, she could have him. Then he can text his mom and sister about how horrible she is and how much he misses you :)
  • Mrs.Rad888Mrs.Rad888 member
    Seventh Anniversary 2500 Comments 25 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited December 2013
    Yeah, something fishy is going on here.  Almost as if he wanted her to find it.  Not enough evidence to show cheating, but enough for her to want to leave him.  I mean because if she is the one that leaves him, then he won't look like the bad guy to his mom and sister ( at least that might be what he is hoping would happen.)
    I'd put my money here. When my first husband and I were going through a rough patch, and were all but split up, he'd write these sexually explicit letters to random girl back home, and leave them in places for me to "accidentally" find.
     Being the one to file divorce papers doesn't make you the bad guy, it makes you the smart one.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I think you underreacted. I would have flushed the toilet while he was in the shower, so he got scalded, then when he got out I would have told him that, if being married to me was such a chore, he's welcome to fuck right off and move back in with Mommy. 
    I'll bet he already has something going on with the other girl, and he's looking for justification to break up with you. You're out of town for work a lot (and I'm not blaming you AT ALL), what does he fill his time with when you're gone? I'm thinking he's not alone.

    ^^ all of this. I would have been pissed. There is no reason that he would be texting his mom or sister about this other girl unless something was seriously up with her. I personally don't know any guys that are comfortable telling the female members of his immediate family something like that, sober or intoxicated.

    At the bare minimum I think you should get counseling, but I'd be ready to walk. Good luck!

  • You're underreacting.
    image
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards