Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

would this effect credit rating or mortgage rate?

We bought our home 6 years ago with the hope that we would live here and fix it up, flip it, and move out within maybe 3 years. and here we still are.  still hoping to move out soon but we can't guarantee that will happen.  since we were hoping to live here temporarily we took out 2 mortgages.  i think it was one for 80% and one for 15%.  the one for 15% is at a higher interest rate (i think 8%).  

here is the question. should we pay off the second mortgage at the higher interest rate since we have the cash? if we were planning on living here for a while it would make sense (and would have made sense to do initially had we realized we'd still be living here 6 years later).  at this point i'm worried about if we pay it off (i think its like $12K) how that may effect anything with trying to buy a new house.  for instance getting a mortgage...would it look better to have $12K cash in the bank instead of paying off this mortgage? what else could be effected? credit rating??? what are your thoughts? what would you do?

thanks for your help!

Re: would this effect credit rating or mortgage rate?

  • To really answer your question, I need a little bit more information. If you were to pay off the second mortgage, would you have any cash left in savings? I would make sure you have at least a 3 month emergency fund. If $12K is all you have in savings, then I would work on saving up some more before you pay it off.

    If you do have that plus an e-fund, then I would definitely pay it off. 8% is a pretty high interest rate. When you are purchasing a home, many banks like to see 3-6 months payments reserves in your accounts (this can include retirement accounts that you have access to). Also, assuming you would sell your house for enough to cover both mortgages, the bank wouldn't be too concerned about the second mortgage on your credit report. I would personally be more concerned about the amount you are paying in interest that you could potentially be investing.

    As far as your credit rating, it shouldn't affect it much that I am aware.

  • thanks so much for your input. yes, we would have a 3 month emergency fund even paying that off..... i guess another reservation of mine is  we have had a hard time finding a house in the area we want and when we find it we are probably going to go for it without a mortgage contingency or selling our house contingency to be more competitive b/c we have $ saved.  i guess i worry that we might need that money if we did that and ended up paying 2 mortgages while trying to sell our current home....
  • I don't think I'd be buying a house without the contingency on the sale of my current home.  What you might want to do is start looking at apartments and get an idea of one you might like.  Put your house up for sale.  Once you have an accepted contract, then start looking for houses and if you don't find one, move into one of the previously selected apartments.  At that point, you could still have the contingency on the sale of your prior home, but more sellers will accept it because you're already under contract.  That's how we just did it on the house we sold and bought.

    Otherwise, you run the risk of owning two houses with two mortgage payments.

     

    As for the second mortgage.....if you're seriously looking to sell, I'd keep the cash in reserves and actually get the house listed.

    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • edited December 2013
    I would talk to a bank that has someone who specializes in home loans. Without knowing your whole financial picture its hard to give advice, but if you are really serious about moving, that would be my first step. Good luck!


    Edit: I say this because they may be able to tell you right off the bat if you could even buy a home without selling your current one. That way you don't waste your time looking at houses you can't buy. They may have other options as well!
  • Ditto - check out your lending options first - lending standards have tightened.
    People - please stop looking at your house as a money maker (flipping and making money )or a cash cow (pulling out equity to fund your life). What do THEY want to see from you to qualify for a mortgage?


  • we do have a large pot of money from selling our rental house. we really want our next home to be our forever home. When good houses come on the market in the little area we are looking at it is really competitive to get them so we wanted to have that pot of money to be able to make a competitive offer. And we are waiting to put our house on the market until something comes up rather than rush into buying a house we really don't want if our house goes under contract. i'm glad so far we haven't listed our house since the inventory in the area we are looking at is so low we only found 1 house and we really should have gone for it... ugh.

    Over the summer we actually were under contract for a house but decided there were too many things wrong with it that could never really be fully fixed so we walked away from it. there were 5 other offers on the house but we didn't have a contingency so that's why we got it...  i'm assuming based off of this that our mortgage lender is letting us buy a home without selling our current one but i will double check that. thanks for the advice on that. 

    My husband just suggested maybe refinancing to get a lower rate on both our low rate loan and our high rate loan.  we should have done this years ago but at least maybe this will help for now without hogging up our cash which we may need to carry 2 mortgages....i'm going to explore this route too...  

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards