October 2012 Weddings
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Splitting Holidays

I know some of you live away from one set or both sets of parents.  Do you deal with guilt trips every holiday?!  What do you do?!

We split holidays based on when H gets the kids.  So this year we got them Thanksgiving, so Christmas is with my family.  Next year, it'll switch.  MIL is giving H so many guilt trips, and he mentioned last night that past 4-5 times he called her, she ended up hanging up on him.  I know the first time was over his neice and how they were treating her about being gay.  But when I asked last night, he said some was about Christmas.  I know he didn't want to upset me, so he didn't give details.  I just want a holiday with my family without feeling bad.  I know we live 12 miles away from them, but does that mean I have to give up all holidays?  MIL mentioned coming down for Christmas while we were visiting in Sept and glared at me.  H said, well we'll be down that weekend and this year we have Christmas with my family.  I chimed in that we have to share. I got a death stare.

Oh and biomom asked H to take the kids Christmas eve a few hours, then she'll get them back for Christmas.  WTF?!  Why tease them with a few hours?! 

H is great, and understands I need holidays with my family and he stands up for me.  We feel this is fair, but I feel bad.  I feel like I'm taking away from his time when he doesn't get much. 

Eliza Mae - September 16th, 2014

Lilypie First Birthday tickers
Image and video hosting by TinyPic Image and video hosting by TinyPicImage and video hosting by TinyPic

Re: Splitting Holidays

  • Our parents live DOWN THE ROAD from each other (3 hours away from us right now, soon to be 6 hours). We still get guilt trips if we're spending too much time with one family vs the other on holidays. It has gotten better, but we've also been putting our foot down. The first few years of H and I doing the holidays as a unit (we refused to split up for holidays even before we were married) were NUTS. We ran around trying to make everyone happy, but we were miserable and did not enjoy the holidays at all. Now, we've told both families that we'll get there when we get there, and they just have to deal with it.

    H had to work Thanksgiving this year (the past few years we've hosted Thanksgiving, and our families came to us) so we didn't go home for that. He's also working Christmas, so we're going home over the weekend and won't be there for Christmas.

    I'm the past, I've suggested rotating holidays...it never went over very well, so we never did it.

    I definitely feel your stress and we don't even have kids involved.



    image
  • I am lucky that I don't get guilt trips from MIL, she's actually pretty great.  Because we have been fairly new at our jobs and therefore didn't have a ton of vacation time, we've been doing all holidays with my parents and then making a trip for some weekend after Christmas to pack it all in.  It's a 10 hour drive to Athens, PA where his mom lives.  

    This year we are leaving Jan 1 for PA and then driving back to Indy that Sunday.  Next year we'll have more days off and try to even things out a bit.  When we have kids I'll definitely make a point of getting out there more to see his Mom--she's really a wonderful grandma to his sister's kids.  

    Funny, it never crossed my mind growing up that my husband would be from Vermont/PA so splitting holidays is a strange little adjustment to make!
    image
  • We decided before we were even married that we would alternate years with each family. Luckily we don't get guilt from any of them. We do one year with my family, the next with H's in NC and the third in VA with his local family and just us. So, the last time we were in my hometown for Christmas was 2010.  But, every year when our family is opening gifts and stockings, we facetime so we can see them and still feel like we are kinda part of the day.

    If your MIL is throwing that big of a fit about it and has to see you, why can't she come up for a day or the weekend or something? It's completely childish for her to be guilt-tripping your H about it. Ugh, I'm annoyed for you!

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic

    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
    image

  • I look forward to the days when we have kids and can sometimes say "No, you come to us!" LOL
    image
  • We started splitting when we got Engaged. So this is the third year of it. I was hoping it'd get easier. I dread when we have kids...
    WillyH19 said:

    If your MIL is throwing that big of a fit about it and has to see you, why can't she come up for a day or the weekend or something? It's completely childish for her to be guilt-tripping your H about it. Ugh, I'm annoyed for you!

    She did offer to come up with the kids after Christmas, if Jeff couldn't get off work again.  It was nice, but I really want to go down and spend sometime with my mamaw.  Which as I type this, might be why she's hanging up on Jeff... we plan to go down Friday night/Sat morning get the kids, then go see my Mamaw (2 hours away) Sun morning - Monday Night... and then have Tuesday/Wednesday with MIL.  Honestly, she can suck it up.  My mamaw is 84, so who knows how much longer we will have her around. 
    Eliza Mae - September 16th, 2014

    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Image and video hosting by TinyPicImage and video hosting by TinyPic
  • We are lucky enough to not get any grief from either of our parents.  We kind of just play it by ear each year depending on how the schedule works out with the kids.

    This year, we had them for Thanksgiving and she'll have them for Christmas and New Years (we'd normally have them for New Years too, but she is getting married on New Years eve and the girls are in the wedding).  So, we will drive down to H's parents house this weekend and have an early Christmas with them and then spend Christmas Eve with my family.  

    We did the same thing last year even though we had them for Christmas, because there are a lot more kids for the girls to play with on my side.  We wanted them to have a fun Christmas and if we went to H's parents house, they'd just be sitting around watching TV.  We we can't go anywhere since H's dad is 83 and not in good health and it's just his Mom and Dad that are there.

    Things will change a lot when, and I hate to say it, H's dad passes away.  Right now we treat every holiday like it could be his last.  It's bittersweet.
    Newest blog post 4/23/15
    Anniversary

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • We haven't really had a problem with splitting the holidays. Although last year I thought my stepmom was going to lose it when I said that we were thinking of going to myrtle beach for Christmas with DHs grandpa. She was adamant about us needing to be there on Christmas Eve for the big family dinner. We don't end up going to myrtle beach but it was for other reasons.
    my read shelf:
    Cathy (CathyL7910)'s book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
  • So far, so good about the grief, but I can't promise that I'll be able to say the same thing in a few weeks, ha. My ILs are a family who all live very close to each other and spend every holiday together, and so far they've all been pretty good about the fact that since my family lives pretty far, we're doing what we can to do either Thanksgiving or Christmas with each family. So this is DH's first Christmas EVER without his family coming up (we did Christmas with his last year). And like I said, so far, so good... but partially because the tentative plan is to come and do a "late Christmas" at some point in January with his family. I have a feeling that they're going to be ready for us, oh, December 26th, ha, when i think it's more likely that it'll be the last weekend in January. But, who knows, maybe I'm not giving people enough credit, and tl;dr, like I said, so far, so good, but I remain doubtful. ;) 
    image
    Anniversary
  • Everyone seems fine about splitting.  We live in my parents' basement and my ILs live about 45 minutes away.  The biggest problem for us is Mother's Day.  H's family goes to his cousin's house about an hour and a half away.  It's a pain in the butt to drive there and then back here, but I would feel bad if H didn't see his mother.

    H's family celebrates Christmas Eve and mine doesn't, we celebrate Christmas Day, that's not an issue.  My family eats around 1:00 on Thanksgiving, H's around 4.  We only run into conflict on Thanksgiving if my brother has to work, like this year.  My parents ate with us and had leftovers with my brother, SIL and nephew.

    Easter isn't an issue because H's family is Jewish.  We see them for Passover. 
  • MIL complained the year we got engaged, but it was our first year refusing to split up for the holiday. Since then we've done Thanksgiving with his family since they go to FIL's parents OOT then (they don't at Christmas) and then Christmas with my family. That's what we're hoping to do this year, but we just found out H might have to work on Christmas due to some unpredictable circumstances. 
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers 
    image
    image

  • I the past we have gone to my parents for Thanksgiving (2 1/2 hours away), his parents for Christmas Eve because they do a big party every year, my parents for Christmas Day, and his parents for Easter. This year my parents are coming up to the big Christmas Eve party and we will all head down to Long Island after breakfast. Next year when the baby is here we might start asking them to come up more.
  • Usually we have no problems with the holidays. Since both of our families are from the same home town, it works out for us when it comes to visits and things. Since my parents are getting older, they haven't been doing the overboard holiday get-togethers from my youth. I know this year for Thanksgiving (because of the previous statement), we just spent Thanksgiving with DH's family. 

    I know for Christmas this year, it may be a bit stressful than in the past. We had planned on just heading into town to visit both sets of parents. And now my biological mom decided to plan a surprise Christmas day event (only reason I got wind of it was from my sister), so we have to try to figure out schedules and trying to please everybody for the first time in a long while. 
    Anniversary
    image
  • Ok, so here is why Jeff's mom is mad - we told her we would be down AFTER Christmas.  Well, she took after Christmas to be - Thursday. Therefore she planned for everyone to come over to exchange gifts Friday etc. She's pissed we won't be there, but she NEVER asked him what we were doing, just assumed. We plan to come down Friday night/EARLY Saturday morning (like leave here around 5-6pm get there are 1-2am). We're doing this so Jeff can work Thursday night to help with the after holidays back-log.

    When she talks to H on the phone, she only talks about herself.  Seriously, I laugh everytime she's on the car bluetooth, because it's ME ME ME ME ME ME MEMEMEME, Then "Hope you and Amanda are ok, bye!" Sometimes Jeff tries to say something and she talks over him.  I'm usually cracking up in the passenger seat listening to this.  But even if H tried to tell her, I doubt she would have listened.

    Jeff told her it's ok, exchange with the rest of the family without us and we'll get/give gifts later, it's NBD.  I think that's when she hung up on him the last time.  We ruined her Christmas.

    Eliza Mae - September 16th, 2014

    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Image and video hosting by TinyPicImage and video hosting by TinyPic
  • AND NOW she told H she's getting the kids this weekend to do Christmas - without us.  What a spiteful @#L$K!@$%!@#$#@$@!#$!@!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    Eliza Mae - September 16th, 2014

    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Image and video hosting by TinyPicImage and video hosting by TinyPic
  • ughhh Amanda that sucks!  I'm sorry :(  

    It's her weakness, and she is being petty.  It won't always be this way :)
    image
  • WOW! That's pretty low! Ugh, so sorry you have to deal with this.



    image
  • That's such a b*tch move!  I'm so sorry you have to deal with that.
    Newest blog post 4/23/15
    Anniversary

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • ugh, @mana8503 that's really shitty...I'm sorry!

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic

    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
    image

  • Thanks girls, I just need to place to vent.  I'm so happy I have a place like this!

    I have a feeling we will have drama while we are down there.  I've had enough of her making me feel guilty for having a holiday with my family.  This was my last straw, it's between her and me, nothing to do with Jeff and the kids.  I know I'm the only reason Jeff is in MD, but it was his choice.  His mama will have to accept this and MOVE THE F#$% ON!

    Eliza Mae - September 16th, 2014

    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Image and video hosting by TinyPicImage and video hosting by TinyPic
  • You said it! 

    Be strong! Stay firm on your priorities!



    image
  • Amanda that's so true, you have to set the precedent for the rest of your lives with her.  Of course you'd never be rude, but it's perfectly acceptable to say "this is how we, as a family, are going to do holidays."  
    image
  • Amanda that's so true, you have to set the precedent for the rest of your lives with her.  Of course you'd never be rude, but it's perfectly acceptable to say "this is how we, as a family, are going to do holidays."  
    Yea, after 3 years this still isn't computing in her brain.  I actually said almost word for word this in Sept when she mentioned Christmas.  I will try not to be rude.  

    H said she just wants to get the kids, but that Ryan doesn't understand all presents aren't his.  Which, I mean, is true.  So H told her to just put the presents in the bedroom we stay in and lock it up.  So we will see what happens.  H isn't sure if she just wants to get the kids, or it's her being manipulative.  
    Eliza Mae - September 16th, 2014

    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Image and video hosting by TinyPicImage and video hosting by TinyPic
  • :(  I hope things get better for you!
    image
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards