Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

MIL Mad Because We Didn't Visit for Christmas

So, I'm sorry in advance that this is rather long... it has a lot of history behind it.

Last night my husband came home from work, walked in the door and I could hear him on the phone with his mom, apologizing and doing the "it's going to be okay" tone of voice.  My MIL tends to do this... freak out and then call my husband and cry on his shoulder.  It's rather aggravating.  Anyways, the topic this time:  we didn't see them for Christmas and she's upset about it.  Oh dear.

She's right, we didn't go see them for Christmas for many reasons, none of which have anything to do with us not liking them.  First, they live over three hours away from us.  While that might not seem like a big deal (for those of you that live in another state from your MIL), we're divided by a set of mountains that requires you to go over a pass.  If you're not familiar with passes, they mean two things:  loads of snow and uphill driving.  We own small cars, that weigh nothing, and I am freaked out to drive the pass in the snow.  We did it one year, got stuck (even with chains on) and almost was hit by a semi-truck.  I'm now scarred for life.  The thought of the pass in the snow makes me sweat profusely.  My husband is not a fan either, so we opt to not go see them between November and January.  We've told them this, and they say they understand.

Secondly, I'm in nursing school full-time.  This means I'm busy 24/7, even during breaks.  I barely have time to see my husband, let alone drive three hours to see my MIL.  My husband does go see them by himself every few months, since there's no way I can get out from the pile of books I'm under, and I always make it a point to see them during the Summer, since it's my real time off.  Then there's also the fact that though I graduate this Summer, once I get a job I'll more than likely get the crap shift working nights and all holidays.  New nurses have to pay their dues.  So even then, I cannot promise I can go see her during holidays after I get a job.

Here's the kicker, we've invited them to come over and see us more times than I can count.  My FIL is not a people-person, therefore doesn't leave the house, let alone the city.  For our wedding, it was like pulling teeth to get him to come and even then he refused to wear a suit or shave.  I kid you not.  My MIL says she's too afraid to come drive this way by herself because we live in a "big city".  For the record, she thinks any city greater than 5,000 people is a big city.  I also kid you not.  They live in such a small town, that driving out of it gives her a panic attack.  Our city is fairly small and the drive is highway the entire time.  I'm losing my mind.

She's also upset that we often spend Christmas with my parents, since they live fifteen minutes away.  It's completely not because I just want to be greedy and spend all my time with them, they're just close and it's convenient.  Last year we even ran away by ourselves for Christmas to Canada just so no one could pull this on us.

I need some advice.  While she's being "understanding" about the time our lives are in right now, she's also demanding to my husband and then he feels bad because it's his mother.  What am I supposed to do???

Re: MIL Mad Because We Didn't Visit for Christmas

  • Nothing. Let her be mad. Sounds like no amount of reasoning is going to help. So as long as your husband is on the same page as you, he needs to come up with a standard reply "sorry mom, so how's the weather?" or something to change the subject whenever she brings it up.
  • Yup.  She is allowed to be disappointed she didn't see her son on Christmas, I would be too.  That's ok.  However, that doesn't mean you have to fall over yourself to make her happy again.  Let her be upset and disappointed.  I'm sure your husband was disappointed his family didnt make the effort to visit with you guys as well, but it is what it is.  Circumstances being what they are, you couldn't see them during Christmas.  It happens.  To all of us.  

    FWIW, my ILs are the same way.  My husband moved from his hometown 13 years ago and we have gone out there to visit them many times.  They have been here twice.  Once for our wedding and once for our daughter's funeral.  That's it.  They didn't even meet DS until he was 2.5 years old.  No amount of asking, pleading and trying to accomodate them will make them visit us.  They just don't wanna.  So if they want to see us, we have to be the ones to visit them. Hey, that's fine, but don't give us a hard time about not seeing your grandchildren or going on vacation's that aren't to his hometown.  My husband figures that planes fly both ways ( or in your case, roads go both ways) so it is time they come and visit us.  Don't wanna ?  Then don't complain.  
  • My MIL tends to do this... freak out and then call my husband and cry on his shoulder.  It's rather aggravating.  Anyways, the topic this time:  we didn't see them for Christmas and she's upset about it.  Oh dear.

    Stop adding to the histronics and guilt.

    You should have let her message go to voicemail.

    That somebody's not tough enough to let her tough it out is the majority of the problem. Sheesh...if you called her, that should have been fine. And if she wanted a  visit? Let her pick up the phone and say "Gee if you guys can't come out today, I'd like to see you during the holidays sometime; pick a day; we will meet for lunch or you guys can come here."
  • I agree with the others.  You can't control HER feelings. Stop trying.  Stop feeling you have to make up for this. 

     

    And seriously- I hope you don't list off all those reasons to her.  While all valid, it doesn't matter - you didn't go.  Period.  You don't need to explain your decisions to her. You REALLY don't.  Trust me - she's going to try and poke holes.  Giving a simple "We can't make it this year" is going to give her a lot less ammunition.

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • I agree with PPs. There is really nothing you can say or do. DH's parents live 6 hours away and the road travels both ways. We stopped scrambling to drive there for holidays years ago. Made them happy, made us stressed out with the travel and limited time off from work. They could come here but often opt not to. FIL is a chain smoker and feels uncomfortable smoking outside. We don't smoke...how rude of us. Oh well.
    Anniversary Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • We didn't go back to our hometown for Christmas either, and I'm sure my inlaws were mad. But we don't have the money for the flight, our hometown is ridiculously cold in the winter, and I'm in my third trimester of pregnancy. Are my ILs mad? Probably. That's their problem. If they won't even leave their city, why would you drive over a scary pass (I live in the mountains now too, and I totally get what you're saying) to see them? Just make sure your DH is on the same page, and isn't apologizing to his mom or letting her guilt him. I know it's easier said than done. My DH is often fine with a decision we've made until he gets "the phone call" from his mom all about how life was so much better when they were a family and he lived at home. It's manipulative and maddening. Hang in there!!
  • I really appreciate everyone's insight.  My husband and I are definitely on the same page about this.  While he feels bad that his mom feels bad, he also isn't bending over backwards to try and accommodate her or allow her to make him feel like we have to make a guilt travel trip.  I just feel so bad for my husband, because his own Mom doesn't make the effort to come see him, but then complains if we don't.  Ugh.

    I actually just sent my MIL and e-mail inviting her to my graduation this Summer and trying to make her included in our lives.  I even invited her to stay for a few days and join in on the party my parents are throwing for me.  I may regret this later.  I really do try, but I agree with everyone that says I just have to let her be disappointed.  It's hard to do, but I'm trying.

    Again, thank you guys.  Much appreciated!!! :D
  • na41313na41313 member
    Third Anniversary 10 Comments 5 Love Its
    edited January 2014
    We haven't seen my in laws in years. They weren't even at our wedding. If people want to have their own pity party, hoping to ruin your fun, at some point you need to let them. My in laws did this to my husband all the time while we were dating. Eventually, for this and hundreds of other reasons, he decided to ignore them all together. Good luck!
  • I don't think you need any advice. It's not your problem for two reasons: 1) your DH is handling it and 2) your MIL is entitled to how she feels. It doesn't mean you did anything wrong. 

    If, however, you would like to be proactive (rather than "reactive" and so defensive), you could reach out to your MIL. Tell you missed her at Christmas, DH told you she was upset, and you'd like to see them soon. Send her a care package or a card just to let her know that you're thinking of her. Dear God, she lives with an antisocial recluse in a town with - apparently - 5 other people. She's dying for some attention.
  • Offer to do Christmas in March or some other time of year when the roads are not impassable. She's the one with the problem, and its probably more to do with her resentment at her husband for not driving her to see you than it is for your not going to see her. Let her be upset, then make plans for feb or march, so she can look forward to then.
  • I don't blame you for not wanting drive in snow. She's being selfish and putting her wants before your safety.
  • What about hosting another holiday at your home? MIL & I don't get along AT ALL but I love my husband and have been trying to make an effort. Last year I started hosting the 4th of July party at our home, since its a celebration there is almost no way my MIL can find something to get depressed over and I realized through the help of the amazing ladies on here, you can't choose how your MIL acts but you can control your reaction.
    Best of luck doll!
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards