Relationships
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

I feel like I lost my brother to his new GF

I don't know if I'm being unreasonable.  Maybe  I am but I cannot help the way I feel.  I know it sounds like I'm jealous or something but I really am not!  My bro has been in a LT relationship before and I was very happy for him.  Of course, I want nothing more but my brother to be happy.  But what do you do if you don't trust his new SO.  I cant be a hypocrite and act like I like her when I really don't.  I don't get a good feeling about her.

A few months ago he began dating a girl with a LOT of baggage from her past.  You will not believe the crazy things that happen to her. It seems like he is the unluckiest person in the world.  First she was in a pretty bad car accident where her friend died.  She was left with a lot of pain. Then her ex-boyfriend kidnaps.  My brother got her pregnant just a couple of months into dating.  During that time another ex-boyfriend breaks into her house and rapes her. Then she finds out she has to have an abortion because she has a blood infection.  But they keep misdiagnosing her going back and forth from kidney failure to blood infection. In the mean time, she insist she cannot tell her family because they are very religious and she doesn't want to disappoint them. They go through with the abortion so she can be able to take her meds.  Like three weeks after the abortion my brother has gotten her pregnant again.  Now just two days ago, one of the crazy exboyfriend's breaks into her house with a gun, beats her and tries to kill her.

I know you should give people the benefit of the doubt but all this is hard to believe.  The way the whole abortion thing happened seemed very suspicious to me.  Not once was my brother able accompany her to the doctor for some reason.  Every time she went it was as an emergency due to some symptom, she will just tell my brother after and make him worry about her diagnosis. It just sounds very strange.

I also started to resent my brother because he started putting her above everyone & everything.  Its not only that but its like he will walk all over us to please her.  He caters to her every need and doesn't see an issue using us.  For example, he borrowed money from me to take her for this expensive first date yet I don't think he's going to even pay me back.  He doesn't even currently work. My father just gives him money and he takes this girl out all the time with my dads money.  He doesn't have a car so he uses my mom new car which she is still paying to drive her around.  My mom is left with an old van.  I know this is also my parents fault!!!! While my sister and I pay our own way for everything, my dad spoils my brother for being his only son.  Even paid for the girls abortion because he was told she was very sick.  My dad is not doing him any favors but thats another story.  Anyway....

My brother has gone mad about this woman, lol. It seems like he doesn't even thinking rational anymore.  I pointed out that its strange if she has all these medical issues causing her to need an abortion yet he never goes with her to the doctor to hear it himself.  An abortion is a big deal!  It was his babies, Apparently it caused him to have doubts about what was going which I guess he expressed to the girl.  She dumped him and he was so devestated. He blamed me for poisoning his relationship. I apologized & promised I was never get into his business but I asked him not to tell me about it anymore. 

Just today he tells me she's pregnant again.  I reacted by asking how could he get her pregnant after just weeks that she had the abortion. He got all defensive of course.  I told him ever since this whole thing we've been drifting apart.  He told me I was very judgemental and he doesn't want to be close to me anymore.  His GF comes first and if I don't like her then I'm out.  I told him its fine & I understand.  I just don't know how I can save my relationshio with my bro when his world now revolves around her.  I hardly see him, he's always with her.  I do want him to be happy but she seems very needy.  I just wonder if she seeks attention or if she really has this unfortunate luck.  Am I wrong for distancing myself from my bro b/c of her?

Re: I feel like I lost my brother to his new GF

  • edited February 2014
    I don't know if I'm being unreasonable.  Maybe  I am but I cannot help the way I feel.  I know it sounds like I'm jealous or something but I really am not!  My bro has been in a LT relationship before and I was very happy for him.  Of course, I want nothing more but my brother to be happy.  But what do you do if you don't trust his new SO.  I cant be a hypocrite and act like I like her when I really don't.  I don't get a good feeling about her.

    A few months ago he began dating a girl with a LOT of baggage from her past.  You will not believe the crazy things that happen to her. It seems like he is the unluckiest person in the world.  First she was in a pretty bad car accident where her friend died.  She was left with a lot of pain. Then her ex-boyfriend kidnaps.  My brother got her pregnant just a couple of months into dating.  During that time another ex-boyfriend breaks into her house and rapes her. Then she finds out she has to have an abortion because she has a blood infection.  But they keep misdiagnosing her going back and forth from kidney failure to blood infection. In the mean time, she insist she cannot tell her family because they are very religious and she doesn't want to disappoint them.

    How old IS this young woman?

    Sounds like everybody in this scenario is rather young.

    Somebody also needs to tell Bro about birth control and WHY to use it.

    Same goes for the young woman in question.


    They go through with the abortion so she can be able to take her meds.  Like three weeks after the abortion my brother has gotten her pregnant again.

    Yep...he needs to be told about birth control. Uh, stat.:(

     Now just two days ago, one of the crazy exboyfriend's breaks into her house with a gun, beats her and tries to kill her.

    Probably not an exboyfriend. She's got him, your brother and probably a few other guys, at the minimum.

    I know you should give people the benefit of the doubt but all this is hard to believe.  The way the whole abortion thing happened seemed very suspicious to me.  Not once was my brother able accompany her to the doctor for some reason.  Every time she went it was as an emergency due to some symptom, she will just tell my brother after and make him worry about her diagnosis. It just sounds very strange.

    The whole thing may be a crock of crap ---- something seems to be weirde here indeed.

    I also started to resent my brother because he started putting her above everyone & everything.  Its not only that but its like he will walk all over us to please her.  He caters to her every need and doesn't see an issue using us.  For example, he borrowed money from me to take her for this expensive first date yet I don't think he's going to even pay me back. 

    End this bullshit NOW. Give him no more money -- he needs to get a job.

    This is already a mess. And do NOT give him any more money.

    He doesn't even currently work. My father just gives him money and he takes this girl out all the time with my dads money.  He doesn't have a car so he uses my mom new car which she is still paying to drive her around. 

    Yes this is your parents' fault...and yours.

    They call this enabling.

    And you need to stop enabling him.

    Give him no more money and no more lip service.

    If possible, restrict contact with him. That's for his own good -- and if you cannot do that, DO NOT give him another dime. And tell him why: "I am not your lender; you do not have the financial means to repay any more of my loans. Sorry, John"  and let him go chew on that.

    My mom is left with an old van.  I know this is also my parents fault!!!! While my sister and I pay our own way for everything, my dad spoils my brother for being his only son.  Even paid for the girls abortion because he was told she was very sick.

    I would like to know what kind of a physician and surgeon performs an abortion on somebody "very sick."

    How about it? Anyone here have an answer for that one?:(

    Something ain't adding up here. You don't have to be Columbo to figure out something is flakey.

      My dad is not doing him any favors but thats another story.  Anyway....

    My brother has gone mad about this woman, lol. It seems like he doesn't even thinking rational anymore. 

    A nice piece of ass will do that.

    I pointed out that its strange if she has all these medical issues causing her to need an abortion yet he never goes with her to the doctor to hear it himself.  An abortion is a big deal!  It was his babies, Apparently it caused him to have doubts about what was going which I guess he expressed to the girl.  She dumped him and he was so devestated. He blamed me for poisoning his relationship. I apologized & promised I was never get into his business but I asked him not to tell me about it anymore. 

    Just today he tells me she's pregnant again.  I reacted by asking how could he get her pregnant after just weeks that she had the abortion. He got all defensive of course.  I told him ever since this whole thing we've been drifting apart.

    He told me I was very judgemental and he doesn't want to be close to me anymore. 

    Great! Then that means he can get lost and you don't have to listen to his bullshit anymore! Let him do ya a big favor!!!


    His GF comes first and if I don't like her then I'm out.  I told him its fine & I understand.  I just don't know how I can save my relationshio with my bro when his world now revolves around her.  I hardly see him, he's always with her.  I do want him to be happy but she seems very needy.  I just wonder if she seeks attention or if she really has this unfortunate luck.  Am I wrong for distancing myself from my bro b/c of her?
    It is possible that child may NOT even be your brother's.

    If, that is, she was ever expecting a blessed event at all.

    Toots, nobody is this fecund. Nuh uh. I am willing to bet even money that this chick was never pregnant ever (which sucks for Bro because now he's thinking this "kiddo" is his) Nobody has all of these multiple pregnancies, like, all in a row in short succession.

    It is possible also that she may even be lying about her medical ills or be a rabid hypochondriac --- unless she was in hospital when all of this was going on, in which case that's another story.

    I don't know where he met her but he needs to send her back to wherever it was -- and make sure she stays there.

    As I said, you are enabling your brother. This is also not healthy for you -- iit's a codependency. Not a healthy relationship between you and Bro.

    I have a brother who is rather peculiar --- same thing like your brother --- he dated this girl and within a week, he was off looking at engagement rings with this chick.  The relationship coughed and spluttered on and off for 5 years; eventually she took a powder --- good for her, I say.

    He's done other peculiar things --- it's hard to believe that these are full grown men.

    This girl your brother is seeing may be here today and gone tomorrow.

    I'll betcha she's got other boyfriends in a flight pattern and somehow she is pinning all of these alleged pregnancies on your brother -- he may not be the father if she was ever pregnant --- and she may not even BE pregnant.

    Has he asked for proof that 1-she is pregnant and 2- proof that he is the father -- ie, can she prove he is the only guy she is seeing?

    I will also bet she's into drugs or something else illegal.

    This whole situation is a mess.

    And so is Bro.

    Exercise TOUGHLOVE.

    I strongly advise you to steer clear of him --- he's a mess because of all the family enablement -- what the what??? He has no job??? WHY????

    Give him no more money and tell him you're no longer interested in hearing about his soap opera relationship. And then curtail contact with him to a very bare minimum.

    Let him fall on his ass and fall HARD.  And maybe then he will get it that this chick is no good for him.

    Good luck --- siblings can be odd and flighty and not very smart. Been there; I've seen it up close and personal myself. Exercise toughlove.
  • If she is lying and fabricating all of these pregnancies --- this is a terrible onus to slap onto your brother.

    He must be guilty as hell ---- what a rotten thing to do to somebody -- and all for what reason?

    A dime says she's taking the abortion money and is spending it on who knows what, perhaps drugs.

    YOur brother needs to button up and cover up. Whether it's with this young woman or others, he needs to use a condom at all times --- of course you know this. But he doesn't care -- he is leaving himself wide open to get just about any STD that's on the books -- and oh yeah, there is a risk of unwanted pregnancy.

    Better yet, he needs to keep it zipped and in his pants. But that's not gonna happen.
  • Disneygeek77Disneygeek77 member
    Ancient Membership 2500 Comments 500 Love Its First Answer
    edited February 2014
    Honestly, this is what I would do.  Well if I had the money.

    I would pay a PI to follow her around for a week or so.  I would then give all the evidence to your father to let him know that the life saving abortion went to drugs or to other boyfriends ( or whatever else might be going on because I also highly doubt her story ).

    I would then have a conference with other family members and possibly a family therapist on how best to tell your brother about this.  I also think a therapist would be good for your father too so he too can realize he is only hurting your brother by giving him money.  

    Your brother would be very angry at first but hopefully in time he will know you did it out of love and concern.  

    Or you can go to the police with anything illegal and let him learn about her that way.  

    Perhaps the relationship with your brother won't be fixed, but if it can get your parents to stop giving him money, then she will probably dump him anyways.  
  • Also when was the last abortion ?  Because it might not even be possible for her to get pregnant again so quickly.  
  • Buy him a box of condoms, then go with the PI advice above.
  • As much as this situation sucks, I don't think it's your place to interfere. Your brother is a grown man, and your parents are grown ups too. I have a very troubled sister who constantly makes terrible decisions and dates terrible people, but I've realized that there's nothing I can do about it. She has the right to do what she wants, even though I don't like it. My parents give her money too, and while I hate it and feel like she's using them, I also recognize that they are adults and can do whatever they want with their money. They know my sister lies and manipulates them, but they choose to give her money anyway, because she's still their daughter and she does need help. It's not my place to tell them they can't do that. I think you might have to take the same approach. All you can control is how you react and how much you want to be involved. If this means you don't want to be around your brother until the crazy GF is out of the picture, that's totally fair and up to you. But you can't change or control what your brother does. I do hope for everyone's sake that he figures out what condoms are for, but hey, you just can't make people behave rationally. Take care of yourself and do what you need to do for yourself to deal with this situation, and try to let go of what's outside your control. I know it's not easy, but it's worth it. Good luck to you, and I hope your brother sees the light on his own, and fast!
  • Disneygeek77Disneygeek77 member
    Ancient Membership 2500 Comments 500 Love Its First Answer
    edited February 2014
    @Leftie22- I understand what you are saying.  In fact, I was ready to give the same response when I read the title; however, in my opinion the OPs brother and family are being conned by this woman.  She will keep having " life saving abortions " if she knows it works.  That is why I mentioned a PI.  Perhpas her dad needs to see photographic evidence that this woman is buying drugs or making out with other men for it to register that he needs to stop giving his son money.

    Actually, it might not even have to be a week.  Find out when she gets more money and then have a PI follow her for a couple of days to see how she spends the money.  If the PI sees her doing anything illegal, call the police.  

    Now, even if after all of that, her parents continue to give her brother money to spend on this girl, then yes she needs to let it go and let her parents make their own decisions, but they will be making those decisions with their eyes wide open.  
  • edited February 2014
    Also when was the last abortion ?  Because it might not even be possible for her to get pregnant again so quickly.  
    What I said. Nobody anywhere is this fertile and fecund.

    This whole thing sounds like a soap opera -- and the OP's brother isn't smart and he is not making wise choices nor is he making wise decisions.

    I still vote for "let him fall on his ass". And I vote we neuter him - a box of condoms? Judging by the action this dude is getting, that box of condoms will be depleted in a week or so.
  • Ok, I missed the part where you said just three weeks after an abortion she got pregnant again.  I'm not a medical professional, but I think that is highly unlikely.  A fertilizied egg would just be implanting itself into her uterus and I highly doubt she would have enough of the pregnancy hormone in her system to get a positive pregnancy test.  

    I'm also a little confused.  Has your brother gotten her pregnant two or three times now ?  How many times has your dad given her money for an abortion ?  
  • When I first read the title of this post I thought "let's see what overprotective sister has against perfectly fine girlfriend". Holy shit I was wrong! 

    This chick is a nut and your brother is even nuttier for believing her. I am so sorry you and your family are dealing with this. You need to talk to your parents. If everyone agrees not to give your jobless brother money, she may just go away (after convincing him he needs to giver her money for babies that don't exist...if he's lucky). 

    I'd distance myself from the situation. Accept you're not getting your money back. Try to get your parents on board with not financing this mess.
  • Has she ever reported the attempted kidnappings, break ins, beating and especially the rape to the police ?  
  • It is indeed possible she isn't just nutty or flighty -- she may indeed have a mental problem.

    The only cure for this: for Bro to drop her like the proverbial bad habit and stay away from her. But I don't see that happening at all anywhere sooner or later.

    For his own good he needs to steer clear of her.
  • Unfortunately, your brother feels invested in this woman. Probably the knight-in-shining-armor syndrome all guys seem to go through at some point. 
    As the saying goes, you can't control anyone but yourself. You can't make your brother stop seeing her; you can't make your parents stop enabling your brother. All you can do is decide how you want to handle it.
    Personally, I'd take a step back from the whole thing. I'd tell brother that I love him, but I can't stand by while he's taken advantage of. I'd let him know that I'll give him moral support, but no financial or material support. I'd also STRONGLY advise him to make sure he wraps it up every time he has sex with her, otherwise he's going to end up a daddy. But that's the end of it.
    He's definitely being taken advantage of, and he may even know that she's not on the up-and-up, but for whatever reason he's not ready to put an end to it. But if you keep bringing up the holes in her stories, he's going to cut you off. If you've had your say about her, you have to let it go. It's on him now, and here's hoping he gets out before there's any little ones involved.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Great suggestion, Mrs. Rad --- wow and yikes --- he needs to lay flaming skid marks before there really IS a kiddo involved!!!

    I can only imagine what that would be like if she really did get pregnant and decided to bring that child into the world. WOW, she'd take him for all he's got...or shall I say all that your parents have????
  • I knew a girl in high school, I can't even remember how times she supposedly was pregnant. She would get serious with a guy & if things started to seem like they were going bad, she would say she was pregnant, like your brother's GF she never showed the guys a pregnancy test or would let them go to the dr with her. Everytime she was supposedly pregnant, she would miscarry at 3 months, right before you would start showing. I think she had 3-4 miscarriages in less then 2 years, but doctors never put her on bed rest for possible high risk pregnancy. Eventually the guys started catching on. But if the guys used protection (even though I know it's not 100%) they wouldn't have to worry about this so much.

    I think all you can do is step back and be there when he falls. Maybe try to encourage him to get job & hopefully one with benefits so that when it does happen that he can support his child financially. But maybe you would have more luck trying to reach out to your parents and appeal to them, don't they want him to get a job & take care of himself, how long do they want to be financially responsible for him and possibly a baby one day soon. Are they willing to give up their current/future retirement to continue to support him?

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards