Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

I Can't Stand His "Sister"

csowle68csowle68 member
First Comment
edited February 2014 in Family Matters
Back before I started dating my fiance, I had issues with this girl. After I started dating him I find out they grew up together and she is practically his sister (no attraction at all though). I squashed all our prior issues and in the next two years I became pretty close friends with her...that is until she started dating my ex-fiance, first love, and high school sweetheart of 4 years. I found out they were dating over social networking and decided it wasn't a big deal, I had moved on, everything was peachy until I started receiving nasty texts and emails from her, then to hear she invited him as her date to my wedding! I felt she crossed the line just dating him let alone the texts and asking him to be her date to my wedding. I don't know if I am just being over-dramatic or if I truly have a right to cringe everytime someone says her name. I really don't want her at the wedding but I decided it wasn't worth the fight with the fiance even though he agrees with my frustration. Am I just being a jerk or am I justified? 

Re: I Can't Stand His "Sister"

  • csowle68 said:
    Back before I started dating my fiance, I had issues with this girl. After I started dating him I find out they grew up together and she is practically his sister (so attraction at all though). I squashed all our prior issues and in the next two years I became pretty close friends with her...that is until she started dating my ex-fiance, first love, and high school sweetheart of 4 years. I found out they were dating over social networking and decided it wasn't a big deal, I had moved on, everything was peachy until I started receiving nasty texts and emails from her, then to hear she invited him as her date to my wedding!

    I'm a bit confused: how is it she invited him as her date to your (and his) wedding? (do clarifly...maybe I'm not reading correctly?)

    The second you got divisive emails from her, he needed to tell her to buzz off and stay away from you for good. He also needed to discontinue this "friendship."

    You also could have told her where to go.  to me, that is harassment and she could have gotten herself into trouble legally, if she kept it up after you told her to cut it out.

    I felt she crossed the line just dating him let alone the texts and asking him to be her date to my wedding. I don't know if I am just being over-dramatic or if I truly have a right to cringe everytime someone says her name. I really don't want her at the wedding but I decided it wasn't worth the fight with the fiance even though he agrees with my frustration. Am I just being a jerk or am I justified? 
    He agrees with your frustration.

    But does nothing about the source of the problem: this young woman.

    My opinion?

    You need neither this young woman OR your FI.

    I suggest you bid them both adieu, him first, though. He's not a good bet for your future if he permits anybody to come between you or treat you horrifically.

    I also suspect he's got a thing for her.

    Get rid of him posthaste.
  • Not wanting her at your wedding is a bit over dramatic. Sure she did horrible things, but she's his sister! She should be at the wedding, it's not like she killed someone.

    He's your ex, you shouldn't care about the guy. She didn't cross a line in my book. If you dumped him, he's fair game. Sure, there should be some time in between, but once you've moved on, fair game. Friend, sister, etc... The guy is available. This just rings jealousy, something you shouldn't have if you're engaged.

    As for the nasty texts and e-mails... not sure what you mean by those? Is she bad mouthing you? Here is where you might have a right to be upset. Your husband should talk to his sister, tell her that it's not polite to be saying these things to his future wife.

    Other than that, get over it, he's an ex, nothing to you and if your fiance's sister wants to date him, who cares?
  • I have felt that I am overreacting and I have tried to make amends and be the bigger person. She won't speak to me in person, only though texts like the tough girl that she is.

    Unfortunately the EX works with some of my best friends and everytime I go visit them for bike parts I get the nasty texts and email and have starting avoiding the shop completely. The FI listens and understands and would ditch her if I asked but I don't want to place him in that situation. 

    I think I will just keep her out of sight out of mind until I have to see her at the wedding, I think its better for my own self that I do.
  • I see no reason why you need to be the bigger person or make amends. Taking what you said at face value, SHE's the one who should be trying to make amends. I kind of side eye your FI though. You shouldn't have to ask him to cut her out, HE should be wanting to do that on his own.
  • What does she say in the nasty texts and emails.
  • I read your OP as this chick is not really his sister. They are just really good childhood friends? What's the relation?

    If they are actual married into or blood related siblings I can see how originally not inviting her would be tough.

    But if they are friends why would you and especially your FI want someone like that in your lives? Get rid of her. Although you can't uninvited her to the wedding. And giving her a plus one allows her to bring who she wants.

    As for your ex boyfriend, if their isn't bad blood between you two there is no reason he can't come to the wedding. Now if he had abused you that would be a different can of worms.

  • Mrs.Rad888Mrs.Rad888 member
    Seventh Anniversary 2500 Comments 25 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited February 2014
    I think you are giving her too much power, and you have to realize that you and she are never going to be besties. Every time you show her she's gotten to you, she's won. Every time you avoid somewhere she or your EX are, they've won. Maybe she has a thing for your FI. Maybe your EX hasn't gotten over you. Maybe they are truly in love. None of that matters. Hold your head up, ignore the texts and e-mails, and understand that you're the better person here. If they do actually show up to the wedding, and you aren't able to avoid them, be a gracious hostess, like you'd do for any semi-acquaintance. Smile, thank them for coming, wish them well, then go dance with your new husband. I think once you show her that she can't get to you, she'll make herself scarce.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • How old are all of you? You must be super young, because this is the type of problem more likely to happen among teenagers - not full grown adults. But anyway - this girl is being mean to you. Your FI agrees that she's being mean to you. So what is there to decide? She's not related to either of you, you are under no obligation to have her in your life. Yes, your FI actually CAN disinvite her to the wedding, if he agrees that she has crossed the line and no longer has a place in his life. So if she's being a brat, and your FI agrees that she's being disrespectful to you, he can and should cut her out of his life. If he won't, and he's ok having a friend who is outright disrespectful and texts nasty things to his FI, then you have some questions to ask yourself.
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • Maybride2 said:
    How old are all of you? You must be super young, because this is the type of problem more likely to happen among teenagers - not full grown adults. But anyway - this girl is being mean to you. Your FI agrees that she's being mean to you. So what is there to decide? She's not related to either of you, you are under no obligation to have her in your life. Yes, your FI actually CAN disinvite her to the wedding, if he agrees that she has crossed the line and no longer has a place in his life. So if she's being a brat, and your FI agrees that she's being disrespectful to you, he can and should cut her out of his life. If he won't, and he's ok having a friend who is outright disrespectful and texts nasty things to his FI, then you have some questions to ask yourself.
    This! Seriously, my H would never have anything to do with anyone who sent me nasty texts. She's not really really family. 

    I can't stand it when people say, "oh, it's ok, they're like a brother/sister to me." No. Either they are a sibling or they aren't. Usually this argument is reserved for some sort of inappropriate shenanigans. Which is what this is. Inappropriate. Period. 
  • csowle68 said:
    everything was peachy until I started receiving nasty texts and emails from her, then to hear she invited him as her date to my wedding! Inbsp;

    Wait. What? She just randomly started sending you nasty texts? That doesn't make any sense. And I'm inferring that your FI still has a friendship with her? If so, what's his reasoning and what do they do together? I mean, does he see the nasty communication and then like, invite her out for a beer? I'm so confused. Has he drawn a line with her telling her the nasty behavior won't be tolerated if she wants to continue a friendship with him? If the friendship with your FI has dwindled to the point they don't communicate because of her buggy behavior, then what's the problem? She should be disinvited. She is no longer a friend and she's toxic, at that. If your FI is actually still her friend (which seems like the case from what you said), then I'd be questioning my FI's behavior.
  • Chances are you will have little or no interaction with your ex at your wedding. I'm assuming the breakup wasn't due to abuse or another serious issue of that nature else you wouldn't still go to the shop he works at (yes I realize you have other friends there) to buy bike parts. If it was an abusive relationship you wouldn't feel comfortable going there.

    All you can do it ignore her texts and if necessary, block them. Yes, be the bigger person. Part of me is wondering if there is some  jealousy on her part. Not necessarily a romantic jealousy but you are in the life of someone who is important to her (your FI) and now that takes up his time which takes away time from her. So now she can't hang out with him like she use to.

    The thing is she obviously doesn't realize that you are sharing info with FI and that it's only going to hurt their friendship in the end. Even if she makes a scene at the wedding or tries to trash you to any of your guests, she's the one that is going to be looking like a fool, not you.

    Good luck!!!

  • This is some Dawson's Creek shit.  Just stop associating with this woman you don't like and who doesn't like you.  And yeah, I'd disinvite her to the wedding; there's no way I'd be paying to feed both a woman I loathed and an old boyfriend.
    image
  • This is some Dawson's Creek shit.  Just stop associating with this woman you don't like and who doesn't like you.  And yeah, I'd disinvite her to the wedding; there's no way I'd be paying to feed both a woman I loathed and an old boyfriend.
    Oh Kuus, too funny. 

    This is how you know early mid 30's vs late 30's early 40's. I was thinking it was some 90210 shit.
  • I think you should not care if she dates your ex. you said he's your "first love" but you have a "current love," you should NOT care about this guy. I would feel bad if I was your fiance, and you told me you were upset one of his friends was dating your ex, it makes it sound like you are still hung up on him. 

    However, her rude texts and emails, are pretty fishy. If she's doing all those unprovoked, then your fiance is a jerk for not sticking up for you. I would uninvite her to the wedding, honestly, she's not even his real sister. 
  • This is some Dawson's Creek shit.  Just stop associating with this woman you don't like and who doesn't like you.  And yeah, I'd disinvite her to the wedding; there's no way I'd be paying to feed both a woman I loathed and an old boyfriend.
    Oh Kuus, too funny. 

    This is how you know early mid 30's vs late 30's early 40's. I was thinking it was some 90210 shit.
    To be honest, my first thought was 90210, too, but I thought that might be too dated a reference for the OP.
    image
  • I think some of you guys are being really harsh to the poster here.  These sort of things can happen to people of ANY AGE!  Come on now!  I can totally see something like this happening in my circle and I'm 40 (but wait, I'm young so maybe you guys are right) hahha

    ANYWAY, I think its time to cut these people out of your life.  Are you sure she didn't start dating your ex because shes secretly jealous of you or maybe secretly in love with your DH???  If shes being harassing to you its time for you and DH to cut her out of your lives.  Even with blood, if that person isn't adding value to your life then its time to cut them out. 
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards