Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Advice wanted please=)

Hello,

First time poster.  Just wanted to get some in laws advice.  About 4 years ago I overheard my in laws insulting my family to my husband. This has happened many times before, but I think after 10 plus years of this behavior I had reached a breaking point. Basically is was about how they are not a good influence because they do not attend church. My parents are actually probably the best people I know, and the best role models I could ask for.  They also have an extremely loving an committed marriage. It became a blow out and I have not spoken to my in laws since.  My husband rekindled the relationship about 2 years ago, but it is a strained relationship, and luckily for our sake they do not live close by.  My life is a lot easier with them not around, but for my husband's sake, I feel I need to forge a relationship again eventually. I have hesitations because they have said terrible things about me in the past which are hard to swallow but I feel guess I can live with them (I will never be a good wife and/or mother, I could lose a few pounds, etc), I just do not want their negativity to affect my family and eventually children we will have. I am not really sure as to how rekindle things, as they will not cop to any argument even occurred. Any thoughts are appreciated.

Re: Advice wanted please=)

  • I would have DH tell them that they have this one ONE chance to start treating you politely and with respect.  That is all.  If they blow this one chance by speaking negatively about you or your family, then it will be over and they will miss out on being involved with their son and grandchildren. 
  • I would have DH tell them that they have this one ONE chance to start treating you politely and with respect.  That is all.  If they blow this one chance by speaking negatively about you or your family, then it will be over and they will miss out on being involved with their son and grandchildren. 
    I have to agree with this. They need to respect you and your family.

    I'm not a religious person in the conventional sense. I remember asking my dad why we didn't go to church. This conversation was on our sailboat on a Sunday afternoon. He said "if a God isn't here, I don't know where he is." That sentiment was repeated more than once and if you've ever spent a Sunday afternoon on a sailboat, I dare you to disagree. 

    It may not be conventional, and we may not give 10%, but I would not allow anyone to question my families faith, or even their lack there of. It's none of their business. 
  • Why DO you feel the need to forge a relationship with these people?  


    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I am not really sure as to how rekindle things, as they will not cop to any argument even occurred. Any thoughts are appreciated.

    IMO, if they can't begin with: "We said inappropriate things and we apologize. Can we start again?" then there is nothing to "rekindle." If they just want to act like nothing ever happened, you can expect it to happen again and keep happening in the future.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I agree with Disney, but I'm also asking what Ilumine asked.  They aren't nice people.  You've been with your DH about 14 years?  And after 10 (TEN) years of this behavior - you finally cut them out?

    Do you REALLY think they are going to suddenly change and be nice?  Maybe to your face they will.  MAYBE they won't say anything to your DH.  But don't kid yourselves.  Even if they don't say that shit to either of you, they are still saying it. 

    I can GUARANTEE you that it's been 4 years of "SEE!  we knew she was no good!  It's because of her that we don't see our son!  It's because she and her family don't go to church!  If they were God fearing people, this wouldn't have happened!  SEEEEE!!!!!!".  

    If anything, they will be even MORE assholish over this than they ever were. 

    I don't see why being "family" gives them a pass.  I don't see why being "family" means you have to have a relationship with them.

    Their negativity WILL affect you all.  Again.  I really, really don't know why your DH would want to welcome this back into your lives.  I don't know why he isn't putting you and your feelings first. 

    If you do what Disney suggested, my approach would be to my DH actually- YOU are giving them ONE chance.  If they show their true colors even once, then you are done, done, done.  You'll try ONCE for him.  But that's it.  It's on him to either kowtow to them or to defend you.
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • Yes, I believe you are correct. My husband has had arguments with them like this over and over. They correct the bad behavior for a minute but eventually go back to their usual antics.
  • Dh actually doesn't care to have a relationship with them. He goes between letting them go and just having a very limited relationship. I would imagine that even if you didn't like your parents it would be hard to cut ties. Thanks you everyone. It has confirmed what I was thinking. One more shot, and if they can't be respectful, it will be their loss. Thank you!
  • I'm going to stress to you - your DH needs to not explain or "argue" with them.  It needs to be a very, very simple statement:  "If you want us in your lives, you will treat neeckola, myself, AND our marriage with respect.  If you do anything but this, then we are out of your lives.  this is YOUR choice and your choice alonel.".  PERIOD.

    They come back, THEY start to argue?  "If you want us in your lives, you will treat us w/ respect".  Period.

    Over and over and over.  "But she did ____ and blah blah blah".  DON'T TAKE THE BAIT.  Respond with "If you want us in  your lives....". 

    And then he needs to either hang up or get up and leave.  He needs to show that there is NO room for argument.  Respect - period.  They can't do that? THen that's on them. 
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • Dh actually doesn't care to have a relationship with them. He goes between letting them go and just having a very limited relationship. I would imagine that even if you didn't like your parents it would be hard to cut ties. Thanks you everyone. It has confirmed what I was thinking. One more shot, and if they can't be respectful, it will be their loss. Thank you!
    If your H doesn't want to have a relationship with them, why are you stressing about having a relationship with them? If he's not interested, it sounds a lot like a get-out-of-jail-free card. I'd just take your H's lead. If he's not interested in having a relationship with them, and you try to force one, that puts him on the defensive. Like PPs have said, someone doesn't get to treat you badly just because they're family. 
    DH has a rough relationship with his bio dad. FIL was horribly abusive when DH was a kid, but over the last few years has been trying to have a relationship. It really bothers me, because it looks like he's just trying to sweep things under the rug. DH has been torn for years about maintaining the relationship. If it were me, I'd have cut FIL off long ago, but that's DH's call to make. I told him I'd have his back whatever he decided to do, and that's what I suggest you do with regard to your ILs.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards