Cleaning & Organizing
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

It's just shoes!

We are a shoe free home, ingrained in me from my childhood and my years living overseas. Why can;'t people respect our wishes and just take their dmned shoes off when they come over. My inlaws think i'm crazy even after my husband has asked them to not wear their dirty shoes in my home! and they still do it! My father in law says i'm too emotional and need to get over it!

 I'm at home recovering from thyrpid sugery so i can't move too much and yet my inlaws and their relatives have popped by to visit and they are all wearing shoes!

 

why can't epople just respect your wishes?!

 

is it me? haha

Re: It's just shoes!

  • I feel you.  It is a battle I will lose, but I am hoping I can at least say no shoes in the 3rd floor.

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
  • kipnuskipnus member
    Ancient Membership 100 Comments 5 Love Its Combo Breaker
    The "shoes in the house" thing is always something I've found shocking when visiting the U.S.! It's so bizarre to me...yuck!
  • it blows my mind. i even have taken it so far as to why people can't respect wishes of the homeowner. i've gotten everything from guests should be comfortable in a home, to well i just don't want to. seriously!
  • I hear ya!  Most of our condo is unfortunately carpeted with beige carpet so we take our shoes off.  Especially after rain or snow on the winter, do people think I want the salt from the snow all over my place?  They have their rules at their place, please respect mine!
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Lilypie Fifth Birthday tickers Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
  • I haaaate this! My in-laws do not understand the "no-shoe" policy either. When they come over they walk right past our shoe pile and sometimes go as far as trying to put their feet on our table and have accidentally touched our couch/couch pillows with their shoes. Grosssss!! I don't get how the no shoe policy is not a more widely accepted thing. Common sense, people!
    Anniversary
  • My ILs understand. My parents don't.

    What I have done for parties is to have a specifc mat placed by the door and as guests come in I say, "May I take your coat? etc. Oh and we're placing shoes on the mat over there."

    I don't ask. I tell them. And, I also place a pair of our own on teh mat so they can see that it is already being used and that "some other guest" already removed their shoes.

  • Wow! That's so disrespectful. Even if they don't feel the same way as you do, they should follow your wishes. It's your house!
    Visit The Nest! Visit The Nest! image PitaPata Cat tickers image
  • I can't even imagine walking into someone else's home and not taking my shoes off.  Even if someone tells me that I can leave my shoes on, I take them off.

    Although my in-laws do not respect our wishes to remove shoes in our home. We have white carpet in the living room, and re-finished Victorian hardwood that we are very proud of. So I am a stickler about shoes.

    Here are a couple of different ideas for signs that you could hang up on your door or entryway.

    "Leave your worries (and shoes) at the door." We have this as a cute sign in our entryway next to a bench and rack of shoes.

    "Keep our home neat. No shoes on your feet."
    "Life is made up of choices. Take your shoes off, or scrub the floor."

    TTC since 1/13  DX:PCOS 5/13 (long, anovulatory cycles)
    Clomid 50mg 9/13 = BFP! EDD 6/7/14 M/C 5w6d Found 11/4/13
    1/14 PCOS / Gluten Free Diet to hopefully regulate my system. 
    Chemical Pregnancy 03/14
    Surprise BFP 6/14, Beta #1: 126 Beta #2: 340  Stick baby, stick! EDD 2/17/15
    Riley Elaine born 2/16/15

    TTC 2.0   6/15 
    Chemical Pregnancy 9/15 
    Chemical Pregnancy 6/16
    BFP 9/16  EDD 6/3/17
    Beta #1: 145 Beta #2: 376 Beta #3: 2,225 Beta #4: 4,548
    www.5yearstonever.blogspot.com 
                        Image and video hosting by TinyPic

  • brij- we have the last one on a cute little sign next to a basket of brand new slippers, flip flops and socks in many sizes and colors.:) and the best part is you can take them when you go! and still my inlaws just look at me and dare me to say anything.

    we too put in hardwood and lighter caroet upstairs. as a joke i bought shoe covers for my father in law because he comes by sometimes to give my h a hand on our nedroom remodel and wears the nastiest shoes he can find. he just gives me a look and heads right up my stairs.

    it's a losing battle. and so i drink wine:)

  • The concept of taking your shoes off in someone's house was a foreign concept to me until I met my in-laws who require guests to remove their shoes in their house.  No one seems to have a problem with it and now I instinctively take off my shoes when I go to their house.

     I do however discourage people from taking their shoes off in my house since the floors aren't cleaned often.

    Maybe some people are self concious about their feet and would rather wear shoes.  However when you're in someone's house you should honor the host's wishes to keep their home clean.

  • imageMalvagia:

    The concept of taking your shoes off in someone's house was a foreign concept to me until I met my in-laws who require guests to remove their shoes in their house.  No one seems to have a problem with it and now I instinctively take off my shoes when I go to their house.

     I do however discourage people from taking their shoes off in my house since the floors aren't cleaned often.

    Maybe some people are self concious about their feet and would rather wear shoes.  However when you're in someone's house you should honor the host's wishes to keep their home clean.

    I hear you. But at least for me it's a sanitation issue. People walk through all kinds of bad stuff every day...oils, trash, mud, germs...hospital floors...I don't want that stuff tracked into my home.

  • I think there will come a point to which you just have to ask them to leave if they can't take off their shoes. 

    I live in Japan where wearing shoes indoors is unheard of. Guests are offered slippers to wear in the house. What if you got some slippers for your guests? Maybe that would put them at ease?  

  • funny thing is we do... :)

    a basket of brand new slippers, flip flops and socks in many sizes and colors.:) and the best part is you can take them when you go!

    we actually lost a friend because she just thought i was so ridiculous and no one was going to tell her what to do.

  • i grew up in a 'shoe' house, but i'm a kind of person who HATES wearing shoes (as soon as the snow is gone, i'm in my flip flops!).  I always take my shoes off at other people's homes unless we're partying outside or i'm told to leave them on.

    our home has new beige carpet, so people have been pretty good about taking their shoes off -- especially since they see me with no shoes on around my house and a few pairs of our shoes at the door.

    Every once in awhile someone keeps them on (me too, since we have to walk through most of our house to get to the garage and there isnt a good 'shoe spot' there.), and I just make sure to vacuum within a day or so.   It's tough to remind people...but i figure if they're REALLY animate about leaving them on, and you're THAT worried about it -- what about those hospital bootie type covers? =)

  • I agree with you. I have the same rule in my home. If guests don't listen, just tell them that a person's home should be respected. Also, there are too many germs from the outside to drag into the house. No one should be afraid to voice their opinion on their own home. The guests who don't respect the host should be embarrassed. Not the other way around. 
  • OtterJOtterJ member
    Fourth Anniversary 100 Comments 25 Love Its Name Dropper

    I think we all have to show a little love and understanding towards other people, their cultures, and their backgrounds. 

    I do think that when you enter another person's home it is respectful to abide by their requests, and I am always happy to remove my shoes when asked.  I grew up in a home where we took off our shoes, but we didn't demand it from our guests, and this is how I run my home today.  We have a shoe area near our front door, and guests are welcome to take off their shoes if they feel comfortable doing so.  I do understand, however, that there are people that feel uncomfortable removing their shoes (either for cultural, or personal/embarrassing reasons), and would rather keep them on. 

    I realize that as a host, it is my responsibility to clean up after a visit, and a little extra vacuuming or cleaning is probably a good idea anyway.  Since you're recovering, cnderella, maybe you could enlist some extra help from your husband, or a friend...or even your in-laws (maybe once they see that you need help cleaning right now, they'll be more inclined to make less of a mess!).

     People have posted about slippers that they provide, and shoe covers, and I think these are all wonderful ideas.  I don't think that it's wrong to ask guests to remove, or cover their shoes.  As a host, the thing to keep in mind is this:  if a guest does not want to remove their shoes, and they are quite persistent, what do you value more?  The person, or your floors?  Once you figure this out, the rest is easy.  If you value the person more, then happily allow them to wear their shoes.  If you value your floors more, ask them to leave.

     In life, it's generally a good idea to treat others with consideration, regardless of your role, or theirs - host, or guest.  When both parties are stubborn, neither wins.

  • fsumomfsumom member
    Fifth Anniversary
    I tried to do this at a previous home but soon realized that people just became annoyed when asked to remove their shoes.  Thankfully we have hardwood floors through the main areas and tiles in the bathrooms so usually shoes are only on those floors that can be cleaned more easily.
    ~Jessica~
  • I visited a no shoe home once, and rather than them asking me to take my shoes off, they made a statement so it wasn't optional, and I didn't feel uncomfortable at all. This is how it went: Hi there, welcome, come on in, we leave shoes right here at the door. 

     

    This didn't make me feel comfortable at all, but also let me know that they would like their rules to be respected even by their guests, which I was ok with. 

  • I would be much more comfortable being asked to wear shoe booties (shoe covers) over my shoes instead of being asked to take off my shoes.

    Of course with rain, mud or snow, I don't trod through someone's house with my boots on, I carry slippers to change into, but in the Northeast most of us should be aware of this anyway?
  • Try providing slippers? It's a common thing they do in Japan, China, and Taiwan (probably more countries, but those are the ones I know do it for sure). Get a bunch of different sizes, put them by the door. Tell them to swap the shoes their wearing with a pair of slippers. Some people just don't like being barefoot or in socks. 

    I grew up in a shoe free home as well (my mom's Chinese). 

    What works best is just to "command" them to. So instead of "would you please take your shoes off" removed the would you and say "Please take your shoes off"  That way it's not seen as an option.
  • mimiphinmimiphin member
    10 Comments
    edited September 2013

    Living in Canada I always wondered why people on TV never took their shoes off when they entered a home. I would be more than offended if my guest wanted to wear their shoes in my house. I have only ever had to ask one person (the lady from Welcome Wagon mind-you) to remove her shoes. If I'm just popping in or out with someone I will casually just say leave your shoes on.

    Growing up we were taught that if you keep your shoes on it means you think the house is to dirty to walk in and as such is an insult.

    I would hate to live in the USofA (or anywhere else) where people just traipsing around outside then track all that crap into my nice clean house.

  • My family never made shoes a big deal when I grew up. My father never took his shoes off ever, and my mom was always barefoot, but she left her shoes all over the house. I didn't really think about it much unless I went to a friend's house. I always took my shoes off at others' houses automatically. Now that I'm an adult with my own home, I know how it can be important to someone who cleans those floors and couches. I noticed our female friends tend to take their shoes off, but our male friends tend to leave them on, even when literally dirty. My husband never takes his off either and I've argued with him about it millions of times. I do agree with otterJ on this one. Speak your mind, but weigh your options here. Is this issue really worth ruining a visit from family or a few friends? That goes for the visitors as well, of course. ;)

  • Growing up, I wasn't ever taught to remove my shoes indoors unless they were truly disgusting from snow, mud, etc. I hate wearing shoes though so most of the time I took mine off in places I felt comfortable. I used to get annoyed when I'd be asked to take them off at others' homes, because baring my feet to strangers was uncomfortable, and my feet get cold really easily. It just isn't "done" here (the US) and it can be a divisive topic. We just bought our first home so I understand now, and plan to be shoe free as well--we just bought a mat to put behind the door--but I'm not sure how easy it's going to be to enforce.
    imageimage
  • I completely understand!  When I was a kid my granddad wouldn't let anyone in his house with shoes on, I didn't understand that then, but now I see how dirty carpets and floors can be such a pain!  Maybe keep some disposable shoe covers handy?  You can buy some from abatix.  (They're also anti-skid;P)  Here is a link to one of their products which comes with 150 disposable covers: ["http://www.abatix.com/default.aspx?page=item+detail&itemcode=IES3100-3XL&catlist=715#" Poly-Pro Anti-Skid Shoe Cover 150 PR/Cs]  Good luck!
  • The thing is, as a host, you're supposed to make your guests feel comfortable. You don't know if someone is self conscious about their feet. If you're going to force people to remove their shoes, then the polite thing to do is provide alternate footwear for them since not everyone wants to go barefoot. 

  • That is crazy to me, living in Canada! The other day, the electrician came and even put on those little plastic booties on before coming in. I guess because we have so much extreme weather, we're really worried about dirt, snow, mud, etc. getting into the house. Everyone takes off their shoes here. I like the idea of putting a cute little sign with a basket of booties. My parents will even sometimes bring slippers over when they go to other people's houses. Sometimes I do find it kind of weird in the summer when I'm wearing sandals and everyone takes their shoes off and I have to walk around someone's house barefoot. 
  • When I was a kid, many of my friends houses had a "no shoes" rule and I never thought anything of it.  Our home is all tile with the exception of the bedrooms, so it has never really crossed my mind to have that rule at our house. I have not been a guest as an adult and been asked to take off my shoes, but I still wouldn't mind it.  Maybe consider getting rid of the carpet if you are so concerned?
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards