Which one should I listen to next?

SusieBW · April 2014

I'm going to finish Unbroken in the next couple of days, and have already picked up these two audiobooks from the library. Which one should I listen to first? I'd love to hear thoughts and opinions on both, too. Thanks!

One Sweet Shannon · April 2014

I haven't listened to Silver Linings Playbook yet, although I plan to because I have heard the audio is excellent. I voted for Mr. Penumbra's because it is one of my favorites on audio.

jkfranklin · April 2014

Silver Linings Play book because I preferred that book over Mr. Penumbra.

j*&p* · April 2014

I don't have any experience with Silver Linings Playbook, but Mr. Penumbra's was really fun on audio.

fabk · April 2014

Have you watched Silver Linings yet? I loved the audiobook.

SusieBW · April 2014

fabk said:

Have you watched Silver Linings yet? I loved the audiobook.

I haven't. And part of me was wondering if this might be one of those few where I would rather watch the movie than read the book. I've heard great things about both the movie and the book, despite the differences between the two.

katienichols08 · April 2014

I thought Silver Linings Playbook was extremely difficult to read, since it was in the voice of someone with mental illness. I had to read and re-read a lot to figure things out. To me, I think it would probably be easier to listen to on audio. That being said, it was an incredibly insightful and thought provoking book. I thought the movie was great, despite the differences.

Which one should I listen to next?

Which one should I listen to next? 32 votes

Re: Which one should I listen to next?

Choose Another Board

Search Boards