Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

traveling for a funeral- worth the cost?

My husband lost his grandfather yesterday - he was sick for a while so he kind of saw the writing on the wall.

Here's the problem - its a lot of money to just go up for the funeral. All our family lives in NJ which is where the funeral is - and we're in NC. He didn't go to his grandmothers funeral and now he really *should* go to his grandfathers. I know its the right thing to do and i'm the one encouraging him that we need to go. - and he's the one stressed out about the cost. Ironic? yea. well now i'm stressed out about the cost too. Would this count as an "emergency"? Would you eat the cost and just go because its a funeral and its the right thing to do? Theres a good chance we'll have to dip into our emergency fund to do so. but we could pay it back after we get paid. We're looking at about 700 for the two of us... 150 for gas, 275 for dog hotels, 150 in loss of income because he has to take off of his second job. (we get bereavement on our 2 full time jobs), and then about 100-125 for food up there. The dogs are clearly the expensive part. We only leave them once a year and usually its only for a few days. We don't know our neighbors, no family around, our friends are about 30 minutes away. theres only one friend i'd ask because she has a teenage daughter we know likes animals and needs the money. But even then she'll be in school a few days and its mothers day so she's not going to be able to come 3 days a week for 5 days... and i'm really starting to second guess hiring a professional dog walker to supplement because we wouldn't even be able to interview or meet them first..and i'd give them the keys to my house?! no.

For DH to go without me it would save us about 200. - so 500 instead. But for the 200 bucks it made sense to just make it a "visit" and actually see our family while we're up there so we don't have to go back for atleast another year. hopefully.

Its like 600 to leave our house at all - this is why we don't go anywhere - like ever. Oy!

 

Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

Re: traveling for a funeral- worth the cost?

  • I would go. I think this does qualify as an emergency and a slight dip into that fund/pause on your snowball would be appropriate. I'm so sorry for your loss.
  • I would go because I would regret it.  I never got the chance to go to my first H's funeral which was in ATL (i'm in MO), I was not in the right mind to deal with all of that.  Shortly after DH and I got married, he suggested that I go because I still had a lot of "what ifs" in my mind.  As soon as we got to the grave site, I felt a huge weight lifted off my shoulders and that wasn't a cheap trip.  I"m so glad I did it though.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I would go and I do believe this would qualify as an emergency. My grandfather passed about a year and a half ago and it was a little unexpected. I would have had to get a flight ($1500) in order to get there, and decided not to go. It's something I"ve regretted ever since. I thought it was too expensive, and was hoping my long term substituting job would turn into a 'real' job and so I didn't want to take the time off- well it didn't so it wasn't worth it.

    Ultimately it is something only your DH can decide. Will he regret not going?
    image
  • hoffsehoffse member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    I would go.  Honestly, this is why I dislike the $1,000 in an e-fund thing.  Things like this happen, and you need to have enough to be able to handle it.  Last minute trips are not cheap.

    My grandmother passed away this morning.  We're not sure if my grandfather is going to hold a funeral for her (she didn't want one), or if they are going to do a memorial service later on this summer.  Whatever he decides to do, H and I will go.  It will probably cost $1,000+ because we will need to buy last-minute flights, but I would regret it forever if I wasn't there.  

    I honestly don't think that kind of regret is worth a $700-$1,000 savings.  I just don't.  Some things are worth spending money on.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • hoffse said:
    I would go.  Honestly, this is why I dislike the $1,000 in an e-fund thing.  Things like this happen, and you need to have enough to be able to handle it.  Last minute trips are not cheap.

    My grandmother passed away this morning.  We're not sure if my grandfather is going to hold a funeral for her (she didn't want one), or if they are going to do a memorial service later on this summer.  Whatever he decides to do, H and I will go.  It will probably cost $1,000+ because we will need to buy last-minute flights, but I would regret it forever if I wasn't there.  

    I honestly don't think that kind of regret is worth a $700-$1,000 savings.  I just don't.  Some things are worth spending money on.
    Sorry about your grandmother hoffse :(
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • hoffsehoffse member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    vlagrl29 said:
    hoffse said:
    I would go.  Honestly, this is why I dislike the $1,000 in an e-fund thing.  Things like this happen, and you need to have enough to be able to handle it.  Last minute trips are not cheap.

    My grandmother passed away this morning.  We're not sure if my grandfather is going to hold a funeral for her (she didn't want one), or if they are going to do a memorial service later on this summer.  Whatever he decides to do, H and I will go.  It will probably cost $1,000+ because we will need to buy last-minute flights, but I would regret it forever if I wasn't there.  

    I honestly don't think that kind of regret is worth a $700-$1,000 savings.  I just don't.  Some things are worth spending money on.
    Sorry about your grandmother hoffse :(
    Thanks.  It's been a rough morning.  Luckily my mom got to spend the last two weeks with her, and they parted on very good terms (that's not always been the case in the past).  H is also here, so that helps a lot.  It would be a lot harder if I was still by myself.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Do you both need to go? Just looking at this from another angle.

    Personally, I would have the both of you go. It's just part of life. Plus, there's something about a funeral for an immediate family member being more important than a wedding in the family (I know you don't have a wedding to deal with, I'm just saying funerals are in some ways more important than weddings). Paying respects and having that closure are both healthy emotional endings to observe a life.

  • @hoffse so sorry as well. Lots of T&P to both of your families!
  • I'm so sorry to hear about your loss. I completely understand where you're coming from on this. My Grandma died a couple of years ago and I wasn't able to make it, and I wish I had. DH's grandma passed away last year and we were faced with the same dilemna. DH wanted to go but wasn't sure if we should spend the money to fly halfway across the country. We decided to go and I'm glad we did. I think DH felt more at peace being able to see his family and say goodbye to his grandma, and he later said he was glad I was there to support him (we had talked about just him going initially).

    If you can, I would try and go. Ultimately it is something only you and your DH can decide. Will he regret not going? Do either of you have coworkers you might be able to ask to dog-sit? That's what we do when we go out of town. Or if you're driving, maybe look into taking the dogs with you. That might save you some money as well.

    @hoffse, I just saw your note, and I'm so sorry for your loss. Sending lots of internet hugs to both your families.
  • SisugalSisugal member
    Eighth Anniversary 10000 Comments 100 Love Its Combo Breaker
    Another possibility - Have him go alone - and you stay home. (no doggie hotel, and only only one airfare.)
    DH's brother attended a family funeral without his wife (traveled from VA to MI)  and it was no big deal to anyone.

  • I guess it depends on how the family would react. If I didn't attend my H's grandparents funerals, it would be a giant slap in the face to his family. I understand all families are different, but this is what e-funds are for. 
  • I would qualify this as an emergency, and try to convince your H of that. if it made you both feel a little less stressed about cost, H could go without you. 

    I'm currently trying to convince my H he needs to take a weekend an go visit he Aunt who is ill, I don't know her well, but H went to college near her home and spent a lot of time with her while he was there. 

    She is currently in hospice care, so I'm pushing him to go sooner than later


    Sorry for both your families' losses,
    Me: 28 H: 30
    Married 07/14/2012
    TTC #1 January 2015
    BFP! 3/27/15 Baby Girl!! EDD:12/7/2015
  • So sorry for your loss. I do think this qualifies as an emergency. I would probably encourage my husband to go without me. If he really wanted me there, I would go with him. My DH's Grandfather passed away a couple of years ago when I was extremely pregnant with my first child. We had to fly 2000 miles to the funeral. I went because it was important to my husband. I'm glad I did.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • WulfgarWulfgar member
    500 Comments 100 Love Its Second Anniversary Name Dropper
    I am regretting to a degree not to go back for my grandmother's funeral but we had just visited her in the hospital a few days before she died.  My family has a bad habit of not communicating well so I was planning on going back if my brother did, I was never informed that he had made up his mind.  I have missed other funerals of grandparents for other reasons so my suggestion would be to at least have him go by himself to the funeral.

    I am sorry for both your loss and Hoffse's loss.
  • spalkospalko member
    Fourth Anniversary 500 Comments 100 Love Its Name Dropper

    I am so sorry for your loss!

    Have you checked with your vet to see if they board dogs? $275 seems like a lot of money to spend on boarding dogs. I love my dogs more than anything and they are completely spoiled rotten but I would look into another option. I work for a vets ofice and every once in awhile I will watch dogs for clients of ours. Whether it's stopping by the house or having the dogs stay at my house, I've done it both ways. Or maybe ask them who they woud reccomend to watch your dog in this situation.

    Hey, Hey Hockeytown!photo hockeytown_zps6a7377b0.jpg
  • Mom987Mom987 member
    100 Comments 25 Love Its First Anniversary Name Dropper
    I also think it would feel like closure and good to visit family. We would probably do it but try to find some friends to watch dogs.
  • Thanks everyone. I talked to my husband and we are gonna go. He figures that we are going to have to go up to visit family/friends anyway at some point anyway so its not worth missing his grandfathers funeral over. I think it will be good for him to go. He needs to be there for his dad - DH will also have to go over his grandparents house and find anything he wants to take because they are gonna be putting it up for sale.

    With the dogs unfortunately since we live in the sticks and its last minute a pet hotel is really our only option. Plus my puppy has to stay in a crate so my husband doesn't feel comfortable leaving him in a crate for 5 days- even if we could get multiple people to take shifts and let the dogs out 3 times a day - its still a long time to spend in the crate - even sharing a 4foot by 10 foot space is better then a crate.  plus its a lot to ask to have someone drive 30 minutes to our house every day - multiple times a day.  (did i mention how much i hate living so far away from everything!!) Once the puppy can behave in the house on their own we will probably try to do friends/dog walkers instead but unfortunately thats not the case right now.

    My grandma passed away 2 months ago and I went but my husband stayed home. I'm glad I went and it was okay that DH wasn't there because most of my sisters went without their husbands anyway so we were able to be just sisters and her grandchildren again which is rare. Plus i drove up with my sister to NY (we didnt even go to NJ) so we split the cost of gas and it wasnt' too bad pricewise. My husband had never met my grandma either- ive known his grandfather for the past 5 years because they lived in town.  

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • My condolences to both of you, KatieCutie05 and hoffse!

    I see you already made the decision, but still wanted to throw in my general two cents.  To be the different one in the group, I didn't go to my grandfather's funeral because of the cost and never regretted it at all.  I loved my grandfather and was close to him in life.  I would have liked to have been there, but funerals are for the living.  For me personally, not saying this is true for everyone of course, I just didn't see the point in spending a large chunk of money to say good-bye "in person".  I did not need that closure so I did not go.

    On the flip side of the coin, I did make the trip when that same grandfather and my grandmother had their 50th wedding anniversary a couple years earlier.  That was money spent to spend time with them on a joyous day.  I guess a little bit in my clunky way I'm trying to say I'd rather spend money on extra trips in someone's lifetime, than after they have passed.

    But many/most people feel the need for a last visitation and this is exactly the type of thing that e-funds are for.

  • Mom987Mom987 member
    100 Comments 25 Love Its First Anniversary Name Dropper
    I'm sure it'll work out great. :)
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards