Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

'Secret' new niece or nephew

Hi there, 

About a month ago, my half-brother announced to our mother and her other son (my other half-brother) that he and his semi-steady girlfriend are expecting a baby. 

At the same time, he made sure to tell his son (my 8 yo nephew) and his ex (mother of my nephew). I am still very close to his ex, regard her a sister-in-law far more than the new girlfriend, etc. 

On that note - the only way I know about the new baby is actually via his ex. She very innocently rang me to ask if hubby and I were excited to be getting a new niece or nephew and in so doing realised that my family had actually not told me this news. 

I am not surprised my half-brother did not tell me, as we haven't been very close the last few years. There is 20 years between us (he is almost 50, I am late 20s) and I think he resents me that 'I got Mum' and he didn't (he was an early teen when Mum broke up with their Dad and left; shortly after this she met my Dad and raised me on a daily basis) 

The part that does hurt me is more that my Mum hasn't told me. She and I are pretty close or so I thought, as much as she gets her 'son time' with her boys in their own time since they don't seem to be very fond with me, she gets plenty of 'daughter and son-in-law time' with me and my hubby. 

So she would know it's not in my brother's realm of possibility to tell me about the new baby, but I thought she would let me know, look you are getting a new niece or nephew. 

I know she's not waiting until a 'safe' period in the pregnancy as the pregnant lady is 26 weeks along. So technically it's not a secret for health reasons and besides the rest of my family all already know. 

I've seen my mum heaps over the past month that she has been carrying this secret and despite me dropping hints here or there she is just not going to tell me! 

My question is do I let on to Mum that I do already know and that it hurts I am being excluded from the new baby's life? Or do I sit tight for 14 more weeks until the baby arrives and see if they really intend not telling me till it's born? 

Thanks in advance, 
Mrs D 

Re: 'Secret' new niece or nephew

  • Okay - hold the phone on this one too.

    This baby is not about you. You are some kind of step half sister of formerly divorced parents 30 years younger (I got a bit lost up there) than the expectant dad and you are not close to this guy at all. You're not really even in his immediate family. 

    But you're upset that his girlfriend's pregnancy wasn't personally announced to you?

    The proper thing to do here would be to message or email HIM saying 'Hey! I heard you are expecting! Congratulations!'

    Tell your mom (without judgement) 'Oh hey - another baby in the family! How cool!'

    and then move on with your life.

    I really doubt this is a conspiracy against you.
    image

    Chronically hilarious - you'll split your stitches!
    I wrote a book! Bucket list CHECK!
  • Why don't you just ask your mom why you weren't told and it isn't being talked about?
    Anniversary
  • VORVOR member
    Eighth Anniversary 500 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper


    I really doubt this is a conspiracy against you.
    This is what it boils down to.  And even though your and your brother aren't close, your mom may also feel that it's not her news to share.  And as your brother has gotten the "short end of the stick" when it comes to your mom, perhaps she's at a point - now that you're both adults - where she's giving him some of the undivided attention that she realizes he didn't get.  If YOU know this is an issue for him, clearly she knows too.  

    Don't make THEIR relationship about YOU.  It's not about you, and this baby announcement isn't about you either.

    But Stop playing games and "hinting" that you know.  You know so just say "Oh, mom, I heard the news about Brother!  That's awesome!".

    Stop playing games and stop making this about you.  It's so NOT about you.
  • 1) this is not your mother's information to share.  It is actually exceptionally RUDE of anyone to share this kind information without express permission of the <insert people who are actually going through the life event>. 

    The fact that you expect to be informed through your mother is kind of indicative of why your half-brother might not have jumped up immediately and called you.  I would not bother to call someone who seemed so entitled to information that has NOTHING to do with her. 

    2) how presumptuous it is of you, to have any idea what your brother thinks or feels about you.  Unless he has come right on out and told you that 20 years later (what he felt as a teenager is not a predictor of how he will feel when he is a grown adult) he still resents your presence on this earth. 

    And even if he DOES have those feelings years later, don't you think your badgering your mother over this is yet another example of how your mother chose YOU over her other children?  

    3) My solution, do nothing. To include contacting your mother about this.  Why would you put her in the middle of this?  It is not her information to share and since you believe that your brother begrudges your relationship with her, why are you looking to make it all worse?  



    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Meh. I think ya'll are being a little harsh with OPs expectation that her mom would tell her. She says she and her mom are really close. My mom would definitely tell me this information knowing that I would be respectful enough to not blab about it if I'm not supposed to. On the other hand though, if I found out about something like this, I would immediately ask my mom "hey, did you know that so and so is having a baby?" If she said yes, then I would casually ask why she didn't mention it to me. I wouldn't be playing all these mind games and getting bent out of shape.
    Anniversary
  • He sounds like the kind of guy who is "that way." Some people are like that; nothing you can do.
  • edited June 2014
    Thanks guys for your helpful replies :-)

    SmrBrd2012 and VOR, I did what you said and had a good chat with Mum last night, and TarponMonoxide you were right, even Mum said herself that he really is 'that way' and nothing anyone can do.

    She reckons our best bet in terms of having a relationship with the bub will be to foster our relationship with my bro's gf coz as she said he's not really going to change. So hopefully that will help things along as hubby and I relish our Aunty and Uncle roles with all our nieces and nephews.

    Anyway thanks again for your replies :-) cheer guys!
    Mrs D
    *edited as I stuffed up my emojis, oops*
  • VORVOR member
    Eighth Anniversary 500 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper


    She reckons our best bet in terms of having a relationship with the bub will be to foster our relationship with my bro's gf coz as she said he's not really going to change. So hopefully that will help things along as hubby and I relish our Aunty and Uncle roles with all our nieces and nephews.

    My advice- temper your expectations around this.  HOPEFULLY it will work - perhaps you'll form a decent relationship w/ his GF and you never know, maybe that will open a path to a better relationship w/ your brother.

    BUT.  Realize that his girlfriend may not have any desire to be close to you/ "have a relationship" with you.  Especially as you even said yourself that you see his ex as more of an SIL than this girl.  If you haven't been close to her/haven't made an effort up until now, she MIGHT be put off if you now suddenly show an interest in her only because she's PG. 

    YOU want to be a close, involved aunt.  That's great.  But they may not particularly want that.  Just be careful.  Watch your expectations, and also try to follow their lead too.  Try to work WITH them - don't try to bully your way into their lives, all under the guise of "but I want to be close to my niece/nephew!!". 
  • Yes, perfect, thank you VOR, I figured as much myself and hubby said the same thing :-) cheers once again for your help!! Bye for now :-)
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards