Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Married With Roommates


My husband and I will have been married for a year in September. Before getting married, we discussed the possibility of roommates, and both agreed that it was important that we spend at least the first year living alone, to get used to each other.

However, my sister married my husband's brother in January, and their living situation(living with our husbands' parents) is not one that my sister is comfortable with. The parents fight all the time(with each other, and with my brother in law), and the home is not one where my sis can relax, and get her work done. She tries to keep to herself, to get peace and quiet, but even that isn't okay, because then they're mad that she doesn't spend enough time with them. My heart has been breaking for her, and I desire so badly to get her out of that situation. 

About a month ago, I went on leave from work for health issues, and my sister started staying over frequently to support me. Frequently became every day for a week, and then two, and so on. At this point my husband and I decided that we wanted to help them, and went against our earlier agreement, extending them an offer to live with us.

My sister was ecstatic! She just kept staying with us, and her husband comes and goes(returning to appease his mother, who is not happy about my sister's absence), but whenever we bring up rent, things get weird. They become really wishy-washy, saying that we never sat down to discuss rules and expectations.

The back and forth, coupled with the stress of my health issues, my husband getting a new job, trying to keep learning how to live as a married couple, and now trying to accommodate and adjust to this new presence in our home has been wreaking havoc on our relationship. I find myself taking my sister's side, or the other way around, and I feel like we're reverting to former family norms. 

Now I'm wondering if I made a mistake. I actually said that out loud last night, and they both freaked out, and said they were certain now that they want to live with us. How can I live with myself, and send my sister back to that place?! How can I live with myself, and go back on that offer? I have to protect my marriage, and I believe we can survive them living here, but I'm concerned about the cost... I need help.

Re: Married With Roommates

  • VORVOR member
    Eighth Anniversary 500 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    You are not your sister's keeper.  And for the fact that they get wishy-washy when you bring up $$?  Um... not cool. 

    WHY do they live w/ his parents anyhow?  And I side-eye the fact that he goes back there to "appease" his mom. 

    This is not a situation that's going to work out - it's simply not.  You need to tell your sister that this isn't working out.  It's becoming a problem in your marriage AND you and your DH can't afford to support her. 
  • SuesEque said:

    My husband and I will have been married for a year in September. Before getting married, we discussed the possibility of roommates, and both agreed that it was important that we spend at least the first year living alone, to get used to each other.

    However, my sister married my husband's brother in January, and their living situation(living with our husbands' parents) is not one that my sister is comfortable with.

    Why are these 2 married if they are not self sufficient enough to afford their own place? OR was there some sort of unforseen cirucumstance that warranted a move in with the parents?

    The parents fight all the time(with each other, and with my brother in law), and the home is not one where my sis can relax, and get her work done. She tries to keep to herself, to get peace and quiet, but even that isn't okay, because then they're mad that she doesn't spend enough time with them. My heart has been breaking for her, and I desire so badly to get her out of that situation. 

    I think it's best that your sis and her H figure this one out for themselves. I wouldn't get involved in this.

    About a month ago, I went on leave from work for health issues, and my sister started staying over frequently to support me. Frequently became every day for a week, and then two, and so on. At this point my husband and I decided that we wanted to help them, and went against our earlier agreement, extending them an offer to live with us.

    This is not a good idea. At all.

    You and your H should have stuck to your guns.

    My sister was ecstatic! She just kept staying with us, and her husband comes and goes(returning to appease his mother, who is not happy about my sister's absence), but whenever we bring up rent, things get weird. They become really wishy-washy, saying that we never sat down to discuss rules and expectations.

    Well, there is the reason why this is NOT a good idea!

    If you cannot pay room and board, then so sorry....you cannot live with us! Time is money and we cannot support 2 grown adults.

    Tell her that exactly.

    You're going to have the devil to pay on this one: how do you get her out of there without a lot of consternation and confrontation. Maybe talk to the landlord -- if you rent -- and maybe he can tell Sis and BIL to hoof it.

    The back and forth, coupled with the stress of my health issues, my husband getting a new job, trying to keep learning how to live as a married couple, and now trying to accommodate and adjust to this new presence in our home has been wreaking havoc on our relationship. I find myself taking my sister's side, or the other way around, and I feel like we're reverting to former family norms. 
    Which is BAD:

    You are supposed to be a team with your H. He should be positively livid and I do not blame him.

    Without fail: They are to go. Within the week and too bad.\

    Now I'm wondering if I made a mistake. I actually said that out loud last night, and they both freaked out, and said they were certain now that they want to live with us. How can I live with myself, and send my sister back to that place?! How can I live with myself, and go back on that offer? I have to protect my marriage, and I believe we can survive them living here, but I'm concerned about the cost... I need help.
    Get rid of them.

    I was blunt about it. Now get into action and get them the heck out of there.

    This is why it is never a good idea to live with other people and a worse idea to more or less do buisness with family members: this is going to be arguments and possible bad blood.

    Get them out of there. You are not their free hotel, their concierge, their cook, their cleaning staff, their wine sommoliers, their entertainment staff and you are NOT their free ride.
  • Here is where you have jeopardized your marriage:

    How can I live with myself, and send my sister back to that place?! How can I live with myself, and go back on that offer? I have to protect my marriage, and I believe we can survive them living here, but I'm concerned about the cost... I need help.

    Excuse me but how can you WHAT?!?

    You are also developing a codependency with Sis. Not healthy and not good and yes, you jeopardized your marriage....your husband comes first, not your sister, because now he is YOUR FAMILY.

    Not Sis and not BIL and not your parents...you and your H are one family unit.

    She is over 21 and and adult. She can figure this out for herself.

    And if they cannot afford to pay for their own place, yes, why are they even married at all? Do they think they can live on love? haah -- let 'em "start livin"....because the Hotel SuesEQue is now CLOSED!
  • Emmy1493Emmy1493 member
    10 Comments First Anniversary
    edited June 2014
    I would tell them that it's nothing personal, but they need to start looking into finding their own place. STAT. I find it hard to believe that as adults, they cannot find a place of their own. I mean, what about their marriage? They need to think about that as well as you and your marriage as well.

    It will not get better, unfortunately it will get worse. They need to help pay bills. Things aren't free in this life. Adjust your expectations with them for the rest of their stay and you and H need to stick to it. 
  • You are not actually helping your sister, not at all.  She and her husband need to learn how to budget, save and sacrifice.  It appears that the only way they will learn that difficult life lesson is if they are on their own.  By having you or their parents as a safety net, you all are impeding their growth and their maturity and they will never learn how to do this.  

    I also want to ask what your wedding vows were ?  Was there anything along the lines of " To put above all others and let no one come between " ?  Well if so, then this is what those vows mean.  It means putting your husband, his needs, his comforts and his feelings above those of your original family.  

    Oh and they are clearly taking advantage of your kindness.  
  • crystaldblcrystaldbl member
    25 Love Its Second Anniversary 10 Comments
    edited June 2014
    SuesEque said:

    My husband and I will have been married for a year in September. Before getting married, we discussed the possibility of roommates, and both agreed that it was important that we spend at least the first year living alone, to get used to each other.

    However, my sister married my husband's brother in January, and their living situation(living with our husbands' parents) is not one that my sister is comfortable with. The parents fight all the time(with each other, and with my brother in law), and the home is not one where my sis can relax, and get her work done. She tries to keep to herself, to get peace and quiet, but even that isn't okay, because then they're mad that she doesn't spend enough time with them. My heart has been breaking for her, and I desire so badly to get her out of that situation. 

    It is not your responsibility to get her out of the situation. Your sister should desire so badly to get herself out of this situation.


    About a month ago, I went on leave from work for health issues, and my sister started staying over frequently to support me. Frequently became every day for a week, and then two, and so on. At this point my husband and I decided that we wanted to help them, and went against our earlier agreement, extending them an offer to live with us.

    My sister was ecstatic! She just kept staying with us, and her husband comes and goes(returning to appease his mother, who is not happy about my sister's absence), but whenever we bring up rent, things get weird. They become really wishy-washy, saying that we never sat down to discuss rules and expectations.

    The back and forth, coupled with the stress of my health issues, my husband getting a new job, trying to keep learning how to live as a married couple, and now trying to accommodate and adjust to this new presence in our home has been wreaking havoc on our relationship. I find myself taking my sister's side, or the other way around, and I feel like we're reverting to former family norms. 

    Now I'm wondering if I made a mistake. I actually said that out loud last night, and they both freaked out, anthey were certain now that theo live with us. How can I live with yself, and send my sister back to that place?! How can I live with myself, and go back on that offer? I have to protect my marriage, and I believe we can survive them living here, but I'm concerned about the cost... I need help.
    What you need to do at this point is have a discussion with your husband & figure out if you still want them to stay with you. If so you need to sit them down & discuss what you expect from them. Let them know how much you want for rent, when rent is due each month, how much they are to put toward groceries ect. ect. If they do not like these terms than they can not stay with you. 

    Anniversary

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards