Buying A Home
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Appraisal came back low

Hello everyone!

I tend to frequent theknot quite often (even though our wedding was 8 months ago) but I figured it was time to head over here!

Anyways, just want to vent about our current home buying situation.  H and I found a house we love (had to compromise on a few things, but that's life!). Everything seems to have been going pretty smoothly for the most part and I keep thinking about decor and what I want to do and getting real excited!

Well the appraisal came in today and it's much lower then our offer! And now the bank wont finance the house! The seller is having the appraisal reviewed because they feel it's value is higher. Now we have to wait a few days to see what the review says. Once we get that there will be 3 different outcomes that could happen;

1. They accept our new offer at the current appraisal that the bank approves (this would actually be awesome because now we are paying less for this house! Lowering our down payment and monthly payment.

2. They say "no" and hold firm at offered price and we have to come up with the difference out of pocket (WHICH WE DON'T HAVE) so we...

3. Walk away

This was a flipped house so there is no sentimental value for the seller and it's all about the bottom line. If the bank says it's only worth X amount then they will have the same problem with anyone who wants to purchase it, unless they have the out of pocket cash (which in that case I would think they would be buying a nicer house!) Waiting for the housing values to go up in the area will take time all the while they are continuing to pay for it (house is empty as they don't live there). So I would think #1 is the best option for both sides.... but who knows! Please send positive vibes our way as we really LOVE this house and are REALLY excited for this next phase in our life together!
image

Re: Appraisal came back low

  • This happened to us.  Accepted offer was $27k higher than appraised value.  We were not willing to pay more than the house was appraised for, they didn't want to come down that low, so we ended up walking away.  

    The buyer ended up paying for another appraisal which came back $7k more than the first appraisal.  They offered us that price and we accepted.  (We ended up going with a new lender also, who appraised the house for the new contract price! Score!)

    Ultimately we bought the house for $20k less than what we first agreed on! 

    Hold firm!  If it's meant to be, it'll happen!
    Married 5.7.11 | Me: 31 | DH: 32
    TTC Countdown to 8/2015

    image
    image
  • If you have a copy of the appraisal, take a look at it. For some stupid reason, some appraisers write to the "contract price" rather than the actual value of the property. So at the end you don't know what the property is actually worth, just that it supports your sale price.

    The reason I mention this, when we purchased, the appraiser got the wrong contract price and underpriced the house by $15k. Both realtors sent in recent comps and the bank also found the error in the appraisal. The appraiser ended up revising his appraisal.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • juliebeannn thank you for your story! It felt good seeing it worked out for you! And as for your advice I couldn't agree more! As hard as it will be to walk away from this house I have the faith deep (deep deep deep) down that it just means it's because there is another house out there for us.
    image
  • I'm so glad that you guys are keeping a positive mindset.

    Just to give you another story, a friend of ours was under contract on a house they loved but it appraised $70k lower than the contract price.  They were heartbroken but that difference was too huge to make up on either end, so they had to walk away.  Less than a week later, they saw another place that blew the other place out of the water and they signed a contract the same day. 

    So, things happen for a reason and keep your head up!
    Married 5.7.11 | Me: 31 | DH: 32
    TTC Countdown to 8/2015

    image
    image
  • Be very careful here - you don't want to over pay for the house. On the flip side, these appraisals have turned into such jokes. I have had 2 situations that are just ridiculous. When we were house hunting about 3 years ago, we were 2 weeks away from closing on a model home in a brand new neighborhood. The appraisal came in way low. After trying to contest it (which didn't work) and trying to get the builder to come down in price (didn't work) We walked away. Literally one week later, another couple purchased the home and it appraised just fine because someone else appraised it who actually knew what they were doing. About 6 months ago we wanted to remortgage our house to go to a 15 year mortgage. We owe about $380k. It didn't even come close to appraising. We paid $420 2 years ago and it is brand new, we built it. We submitted comps which proved it was worth waaaaay more than $380 - they proved it was worth about $450 but the bank wouldn't budge. It is literally ridiculous right now. If you get someone who doesn't know what they are doing, you get screwed which is what recently happened to us. I hope everything works out for you! :)
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • daisy662.

    We wont over pay because the bank wont let us and we don't have the additional cash funds. So there is no decision for us to make, the seller takes our new offer at the new appraised price or doesn't! He will be coming down $12K (as we are not taking any closing costs now) so not a CRAZY amount to come down....

    I wrote a heartfelt letter to submit our new offer explaining how we love the home and hope to start a family soon and can see us raising our children there and specifics on the house we love. I also explained we are not taking back those closing costs to offer the highest amount possible (the appraised price). Hopefully my letter will help seal the deal! We find out today so fingers crossed!!!
    image

  • We got the house!!! The seller came down... reluctantly... but both realtors (seller and buyer) were so moved by our letter they both lowered their commission to convince the seller the accept our offer!

    I didn't know people even did that. I am so touched and moved by both these women to sacrifice their pay to help us get our first home, I almost feel overwhelmed! Of course a thank you card is in order but we want to do something more, any suggestions?
    wowwww!!! that's so wonderful!! congratulations!!!!
    Married 5.7.11 | Me: 31 | DH: 32
    TTC Countdown to 8/2015

    image
    image
  • Congratulations!  That's very exciting.  And how awesome you are getting the house less than what you originally contracted for.
  • That is amazing. Congrats!! Best of luck in your new home! As far as a gift, I like gift baskets or gift cards. Honestly though, i think it's the thought that counts so even if you baked them cupcakes, I'm sure they would be touched. I just love this story. Not enough people behave this way these days. Just awesome :)
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Enjoy your new home, but do be aware that both realtors actually did themselves as well as you a favor.  They were able to complete a sale and get their commission.  If no sale, no commission - so their pay checks were part of the consideration as well.
    No one would finance a house for more thant the appraisal value.
    The best gift you can give is telling everyone you know that you would recommend them if they need a realtor.
  • Sisugal  - I did realize that later that it does benefit them. They could take a little less now or possibly spent the next 6 months helping us buy (and for the seller to sell) and not make much more!
    image
  • As a real estate agent, it actually is a big deal to cut your commission. Of course they want to complete the sale, but when you live pay check to pay check, its still a sacrifice. 

    The single BEST way to say Thank You to your agent is to refer them to the next person you know who is buying or selling. Agents always need advocates! The more referrals an agent can get, the better they can be at their business (more referrals=less marketing time=more time spent with clients and bettering themselves!) 

    Congrats on your purchase! 


  • So we closed yesterday and already started painting! The big move is tomorrow!
    image
  • WOW!! fastest closing ever!!!

    CONGRATULATIONS!!!!! Enjoy making this house your HOME!!  :D
    Married 5.7.11 | Me: 31 | DH: 32
    TTC Countdown to 8/2015

    image
    image
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards