Getting Pregnant
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Article: Femara Better than Clomid for Women with PCOS?

I've just got a brief synopsis and comment, but I found it interesting. I think it's about time a study like this were formally undertaken, especially considering the response rates I've heard of here with ladies who've taken Clomid and Femara.

letrozole leads to higher live-birth rates than clomiphene in women with pcos

Robert W. Rebar, MD reviewing Legro RS et al. N Engl J Med 2014 Jul 10.

Study results indicate that the aromatase inhibitor letrozole should be the first-line treatment for infertility associated with polycystic ovary syndrome.

Clomiphene citrate has long been the first-line fertility treatment for anovulatory women (including those with polycystic ovary syndrome [PCOS]). This selective estrogen-receptor modulator antagonizes estrogen's negative feedback on the hypothalamus, resulting in increased secretion of gonadotropin-releasing hormone and, ultimately, stimulation of follicular development. However, clomiphene has drawbacks (e.g., high rates of failure and multiple pregnancies) and adverse effects (e.g., hot flashes, mood changes, visual disturbances). Aromatase inhibitors affect hypothalamic-pituitary-ovarian function by blocking estrogen synthesis and might be more effective for achieving pregnancy. NIH-supported investigators conducted a double-blind, multicenter, randomized trial involving 750 women with PCOS and ovulatory dysfunction. Participants received clomiphene citrate (50 mg daily) or the aromatase inhibitor letrozole (2.5 mg daily) for up to 5 cycles. Doses were escalated (up to 150-mg clomiphene and 7.5-mg letrozole) if ovulatory response was poor or absent.

Women who received letrozole had higher cumulative rates of ovulation (62% vs. 48%; P<0.001) and live birth (28% vs. 19%; P=0.007) than those who received clomiphene. Likelihood of pregnancy loss (32% vs. 29%) or twin pregnancy (3% vs. 7%) did not differ significantly between groups. Overall risk for congenital anomalies also did not differ significantly, although 4 of 102 neonates in the letrozole group and 1 of 66 in the clomiphene group had major congenital anomalies (P=0.65). Letrozole was associated with higher incidence of fatigue and dizziness, and clomiphene with more hot flashes.

COMMENT

In showing letrozole's strengths as a first-line treatment for infertile women with PCOS, these data should transform the treatment of such women (although letrozole is not FDA approved for this indication and is not yet likely to be covered by insurance for such use). The study did not address anovulation from other causes, so it remains unknown whether this aromatase inhibitor has broader superiority over clomiphene for inducing ovulation. In addition, the trial was insufficiently powered to determine if letrozole raises risk for congenital anomalies (which will require further study involving thousands of women). Letrozole is unlikely to increase this risk more than clomiphene because its half-life is much shorter than clomiphene's; moreover, the anomaly rates in both treatment groups were similar to those in the general population (5.8% of spontaneously conceived pregnancies; N Engl J Med 2012; 366:1803).

- See more at: http://www.jwatch.org/na35018/2014/07/09/letrozole-leads-higher-live-birth-rates-clomiphene-women?query=topic_pregnancy#sthash.ALo3NmAU.dpuf
imageimage
Daisypath Anniversary tickers
TTC since July 2012
BFP #1: 11/9/13; spontaneous m/c at 6w2d, 11/25/13
BFP #2: 12/31/13. B/w 12/31: betas >1000, progesterone 13.6; B/w 1/2: betas 3065, progesterone 10.2
B/w 1/8: betas 17,345, progesterone 25.6
Progesterone suppositories started 1/2. Please stick, baby!!
Fiona Elise born 9/9/14 - welcome beautiful girl!
image
Badge Unicorn
image

Re: Article: Femara Better than Clomid for Women with PCOS?

  • This only further frustrates me that my clinic won't use Femara. :(

    In Christ alone my hope is found. He is my LIGHT, my STRENGTH, and my SONG!


    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Image and video hosting by TinyPic


    T-TTC since Dec 2008. PCOS/nonexistant cycles(anovulation) and endo. HSG in '10 revealed both tubes blocked. Lap surgery in Dec '10 to correct. Failed Clomid/IUI and injectable(Bravelle)/IUI cycles so far.  


    image

  • RockABye said:
    This only further frustrates me that my clinic won't use Femara. :(
    I'd probably be shoving this study in my doc's face and asking if they'd consider it now. It's not fair to their patients to completely ignore an option that has worked better for so many women.
    imageimage
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
    TTC since July 2012
    BFP #1: 11/9/13; spontaneous m/c at 6w2d, 11/25/13
    BFP #2: 12/31/13. B/w 12/31: betas >1000, progesterone 13.6; B/w 1/2: betas 3065, progesterone 10.2
    B/w 1/8: betas 17,345, progesterone 25.6
    Progesterone suppositories started 1/2. Please stick, baby!!
    Fiona Elise born 9/9/14 - welcome beautiful girl!
    image
    Badge Unicorn
    image
  •  

    RockABye said:
    This only further frustrates me that my clinic won't use Femara. :(
    I'd probably be shoving this study in my doc's face and asking if they'd consider it now. It's not fair to their patients to completely ignore an option that has worked better for so many women.


    I wish...  They're just trying to cover their butts simply because it's not FDA approved for infertility. I can see it from their side and totally understand that reasoning, but it's also frustrating to be in my position in that I only did Clomid twice (and it only worked once) and can't do it again, so my only options are MUCH more expensive and potentially even cost prohibitive. 

    That said, if our next and last injectables cycle fails (whenever that is), we're considering finding a new clinic that does to Femara vs going straight to IVF, which I don't think we can afford to do anyway.

    In Christ alone my hope is found. He is my LIGHT, my STRENGTH, and my SONG!


    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Image and video hosting by TinyPic


    T-TTC since Dec 2008. PCOS/nonexistant cycles(anovulation) and endo. HSG in '10 revealed both tubes blocked. Lap surgery in Dec '10 to correct. Failed Clomid/IUI and injectable(Bravelle)/IUI cycles so far.  


    image

  • RockABye said:

    I wish...  They're just trying to cover their butts simply because it's not FDA approved for infertility. I can see it from their side and totally understand that reasoning, but it's also frustrating to be in my position in that I only did Clomid twice (and it only worked once) and can't do it again, so my only options are MUCH more expensive and potentially even cost prohibitive. 

    That said, if our next and last injectables cycle fails (whenever that is), we're considering finding a new clinic that does to Femara vs going straight to IVF, which I don't think we can afford to do anyway.

    I understand that perspective. Plenty of docs don't like prescribing a medication for off-label indications, but with something like this, that's been used so widely and successfully off label, you'd think the hesitation would be far less. Working on the publication I do, I've learned that most meds prescribed by dermatologists are technically off-label uses, but the rx of them for a particular dermatologic indication is so commonplace, no one really even bats an eye at it. I wish more docs would look at Femara that way.
    imageimage
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
    TTC since July 2012
    BFP #1: 11/9/13; spontaneous m/c at 6w2d, 11/25/13
    BFP #2: 12/31/13. B/w 12/31: betas >1000, progesterone 13.6; B/w 1/2: betas 3065, progesterone 10.2
    B/w 1/8: betas 17,345, progesterone 25.6
    Progesterone suppositories started 1/2. Please stick, baby!!
    Fiona Elise born 9/9/14 - welcome beautiful girl!
    image
    Badge Unicorn
    image
  • I didn't respond to Clomid at all, which was super frustrating.  But I did respond to the Femara.  I wish more doctors would consider using it!
    Anniversary 
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    ~TTC Buddies with akcrrr and amandaf6383~
    ~Knottie/Nestie Besties with *ecinereb* - Congratulations!~
    TTC since June 2011 dx: PCOS
    Clomid+IUI: Cancelled b/c didn't respond (June 2012)
    Femara+Trigger+IUI #1: BFN :-( (July 2013)
    Natural Cycle (8/7/13)- BFP!  Beta #1 (9/10/13): 509 Progesterone: 18.64  Beta #2 (9/12/13): 1118
    Baby N born 5/9/14
  • spin25spin25 member
    2500 Comments 500 Love Its Fourth Anniversary Name Dropper
    I didn't respond to Clomid at all, which was super frustrating.  But I did respond to the Femara.  I wish more doctors would consider using it!

    Same here. Well, I did respond once we got up to 150mg, but that was it. I had great responses to letrozole.
    image
  • I responded once on clomid, never on femara. It is cheap though, I don't see why all RE's won't offer it, even as a one time option to see if it works. The side effects are less as well.
    image
    TTC 24 months, IUI #3 BFP 6/4/14 Beta 6/5 58, 6/9 508, 6/11 1227 TWINS! EDD 2/15/15
    With heavy hearts, we said goodbye to our precious angels on 8/12 at 13 weeks 2 days.
    image
    IVF #1 Lup/Brav/Meno, ER 11/28 10R/10F, ET "Rudolph" 4AA embryo 12/3, 7 frosties.
    BFP! Betas: 12/12 225, 12/15 706, 12/17 1512. EDD 8.21.15
    12/29 hb 120. 1/5 perfect, GRAD DAY! 1/15 perfect at OB. NT 2/6 PERFECT, HB 158!

    Baby Girl born 8.9.15 at 38.2 due to IUGR 4lb7.8oz 17" 
    Our princess is being watched over by her older siblings every day <3
    Anniversary 

  • Fascinating. Thanks for sharing. Even though I do not have PCOS and responded to Clomid (but not well to Gonal-F), I love these studies.
    TTC #1 since Feb. '12. dx: "unexplained" IF
    After 2 shitty IVF cycles and 1 loss at 6+2 (EDD 11/7/14), DH and I are pursuing DIA.
    11/17/2014 - ACTIVE AND WAITING!
    image
    Pregnancy was never the end goal; being a mom was.
    I've been holding out on GP: I got drunk once and started a blog: Here it is (11/7 update)
    3T<3

  • arj14arj14 member
    Sixth Anniversary 250 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    This is something my OBGYN brought up to me, actually.  Also that it is more popular in Europe for women with PCOS.
    image
    Anniversary
    08/13: Started TTC  - 07/14: PCOS dx
    BFP 09/18/15 - Baby S 05/27/16
  • I don't think my RE even considered Femara, but I kind of responded to Clomid 100, then truly responded to 150 which was a strong ovulation.
  • Another plus with Femara is that it's covered by most prescription plans because it's a cancer medication (even though it's not being used for that in this instance), but clomid is not because it's only used for IF.
    image

    <3<3 "You know my name, not my story.
    You've heard what I've done, not what I've been through.
    If you were in my shoes, you'd fall the first step." <3<3


  • I didn't respond to Clomid at all (even at 150) but responded great with Femara. Wish we never would have messed with Clomid but my mom had success with it (I'm a clomid baby so I can't complain too much!). Glad my RE went straight to Femara, will definitely do that next time around if need be. It's nice to see an article specifically addressing a study as opposed to just anecdotal success stories. 

    TTC #1 Since October 2012
    DX PCOS May 2013
    Clomid 50-150mg- No Response
    Moved to RE October 2013
    Nov. 2013: IUI #1 Letrozole + Ovidrel = BFN
    Dec. 2013: IUI #2 Letrozole + Ovidrel= BFP on 1/8/2014 !! EDD 9/22/2014
    Beta #1 (12 dpo): HCG 27, Progesterone 15 (starting on supplements)
    Beta #2 (15 dpo): HCG 297, Progesterone 29
    Beta #3 (17 dpo): HCG 667, Progesterone 34
    1st Ultrasound 1/28 (6 weeks + 1) Baby measuring exactly as it should, HB 118!
    2nd Ultrasound 2/5 Baby measuring 7w4d, HB 133. Everything looks perfect!




    BabyFruit Ticker
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards