Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

10 year loan forgiveness

I was wondering if anyone has had any experience with the student loan forgiveness program where you can work a government job for 10 years and make the standard payments then they will pay the rest off.  My husband is currently looking for a job where he would be qualified for this program.  My question is: Do we make the minimum payments for 10 year and wait for the rest of it to be paid off, or do we work hard to try and pay it off as fast as we can.  Also were talking about 85k.

Some concerns I would have with the program is: What if he doesn't end up staying there for 10 years and goes to a different job where the program would not still qualify and then we are left with all the interest that has been piled up. Could he switch to a different government job and still qualify? 

Thanks for the advice!  I'm really trying to focus on the student loan debt since that's the only debt we have now.

Anniversary

Re: 10 year loan forgiveness

  • Others on this board can give you more targeted advice than I can because H and I don't qualify for this based on our jobs.

    Personally, I would try to pay them off.  $85K is a lot, but you can sign up for the 25-year payoff plan (to keep minimums low in case of an emergency) and then pay it off as quickly as possible.  That's what H and I have done, and it works quite well for us.  We owe significantly more than you do, and we're on track to be done in 7-8 years.  We could do it in 5 years if we chose not to travel and delay babies, but the extra 2-3 years of debt is worth it to us to not delay these things.

    Be careful about banking on government jobs.  Working for the gov can be INCREDIBLY lucrative if you manage to stay in it long enough (great benefits, pensions, etc), but I personally wouldn't arrange my financial life so that I HAD to have a gov job for the next 10 years. There are many many government jobs out there that must receive funding every year.    You just never know.
     
    Is his degree such that he could work in the private sector for more than he would make in the public sector?  If so, I would suggest he be open to those possibilities as well.  I have friends from law school who focused on getting gov jobs simply so they could get their law school debt forgiven.  The reality is they would have made way WAY more in private practice, and the amount they are saving on their debt - assuming they can stick it out for 10 years in the government - doesn't come close to making up the shortfall of income from 10 years lost in private practice.  If your husband wants to work for the government for other reasons, then by all means he should try.  If it's purely financial though, make sure you really run the numbers to see if it's the best deal.

    One last thing from me: keep in mind that forgiven debt is taxable income to you.  The year in which the remaining loans are forgiven will be the year you have to pay taxes on that amount in one go.  This student loan forgiveness thing has only been around a few years, and I'm pretty sure the first group of people to go through it haven't reached the 10-year mark yet when the taxes hit.  So I'm in thinking in 5-10 years we're going to start seeing people get in financial trouble with the IRS because they didn't know about the taxes and either failed to report it or couldn't pay it.  Debt forgiveness has always been taxable, but historically it has happened in private transactions (ie: between parents and kids) and has been kind of difficult for the IRS to track.  When the gov starts forgiving your debt, you can be certain the IRS will know about it.  

    At the end of the day, paying taxes is less than paying the full student loans, but with the taxes you have 1 year to pay and with the student loans you have 10-25 years to pay.  If you go through the student loan forgiveness thing, don't forget about this component of it and make sure to set aside enough so that you don't get screwed in year 10.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I agree with Hoffse, I would do a consolidation loan then make at least minimum payments that will pay off at least some of the debt.  The loan forgiveness is good if you qualify and stay long enough to use it.

    Before doing anything, I would research the average turn-over in the field that you husband would go into and be prepared that something will happen that he doesn't qualify.
  • Hi- I've been reading/lurking around on this board for a while and finally decided to get an account :)

    I would look at the numbers. I have a good amount of student loan debt and a have a government job..so I do "qualify" however it doesn't help me much in terms of forgiveness. Only certain payment plans qualify for loan forgiveness and those (at least for me) would pay my loans off in 10 years anyway.
    There is information on the federal loan website to tell you which payment plans qualify (income based,income contingent and pay as you earn) and loan calculators for those payment plans. You can run the numbers and see if will be beneficial for you.
  • I qualify but decided not to do it. I'm using a plan like @hoffse mentioned instead. My reasons are:

    -My job is soft money and could be refunded in a few years
    -You have to switch to FedLoan Servicing, which had horrible customer service reviews. I'm currently with Great Lakes, a nonprofit that I like.
    -Based on my total, I don't stand to have that much forgiven anyway.

    But, to answer one of your questions, yes he can switch jobs and still qualify. You need to make 120 payments while in qualifying employment, but they don't necessarily need to be consecutive. He could take two years off in a different job and then return-but if he didn't qualify for IBR/PAYE in that time his payments would increase.
  • Everyone brings up good point but I have to say that I am doing it and I love it. We decided to do it while we are focusing more on my husbands loans. He doesn't qualify. I am hoping it all works out financially. I have really enjoyed the customer service and website easy usage. Feel free to PM me with questions.
  • thanks for the advice.  My husband will be getting a job in higher education which is why we are fairly positive it will be a government job. 

    I never thought of the tax part of it before.  I just want to be debt free already

    Anniversary
  • Another devil's advocate issue-I don't think all government jobs automatically qualify.  For example, my H is a state employee working in the environmental management sector, and he doesn't.  Not sure about higher ed specifically, but I know there's a lot of fine print.  
  • One more thing, for a lot of Ed jobs, you only qualify for so much based on your degree and the field of need. I worked 5 years at a title one school and got $5k paid off. That was all I qualified for, but I also wasn't staying there for that. I stated that long because there weren't any other options for me, otherwise I would have moved jobs. Make sure you figure out completely what you will qualify for.
    image
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards