Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

The kid question & MIL issues

Hi ladies!

 

My husband and I have been married for 2 years, and we both want kids, but not yet. I'm finding it increasingly difficult to answer the question "when are you going to have a baby?" without losing my cool. Especially since it IS something that I want. My mother-in-law has made some comments lately that I find appalling...such as telling my husband to "prove he's a man", and asking him if he's "shooting blanks". I'm a very private person and think it's no one's business. My husband laughs it off and tells me that everyone has to deal with it, and when people get to a certain age and start thinking about their mortality, they get a little pushy with things like this. I can see that, but I don't think I should have to deal with it.

On top of that, we've had a difficult few years. My husband was lied to at his previous job and had money withheld. We had to file a wage complaint with the state and deal with threats, lawyers, and badmouthing to finally get the rest of the money owed to him. We'd like to be a little more financially stable before even thinking about starting a family. His parents know everything we had to deal with, and don't take that into account.

As a final cherry on the top, my MIL demands that my husband kiss her on the lips when we see them, coming and going. I think this is gross, and at a certain age (we're both in our 30s), she could accept a hearty hug and/or a kiss on the cheek. It almost feels a little disrespectful to me as his wife.

I'd love to hear anyone's thoughts....

 

 

Re: The kid question & MIL issues

  • Unless your MIL is holding a gun to his head or a cattle prod to his testicles then he is going along with kissing her on the lips, I think it's weird but others don't. The only person who can stop this is your DH.

    I'm quite confrontational, so every time she made an inappropriate comment I would call her on it. The other thing you can do, is every time she brings up baby, stop, look her in the eye and tell her that the topic is not open for discussion, then change the subject or walk away, again DH has to be part of this solution
  • OP, your MIL's comments are wildly inappropriate and your H's excuse of 'everyone has to deal with it' - while sometimes true, I've never heard of anyone having those kinds of comments thrown at them. Your H needs to shut that shit down. And you have every right to shut it down too. I would even go so far and say that you guys should cut off any visits to her (and vice versa) until she cuts the crap. And if you are with her and she does say something, get up and leave. You shouldn't even have to explain yourselves as to why you are waiting because that is NONE of her business (or anyone elses). 

    As far as the kissing on the lips thing - that's just weird. But I have no advice for you there because your H needs to be the one to put a stop to that. Have you ever told your H how you feel about that? If not, then speak up!
  • elle621elle621 member
    First Anniversary First Comment

    I love both responses! I think I need to become a little more confrontational myself, and "shut that shit down" ;)

    I have told him that the kissing on the lips bothers me, but he says it's not a big deal...that she's a 60-some year old woman who wasn't too affectionate growing up, and is probably trying to make up for it now.

     

     

  • elle621 said:

    I love both responses! I think I need to become a little more confrontational myself, and "shut that shit down" ;)

    I have told him that the kissing on the lips bothers me, but he says it's not a big deal...that she's a 60-some year old woman who wasn't too affectionate growing up, and is probably trying to make up for it now.

     

     

    Idk - I personally think that is a cop-out on your H's part so he doesn't have to deal with it. What is he more concerned with - upsetting his mommy or upsetting you, his wife? I'm not sure it's a hill to die on type of thing, but I know that if I didn't like something my IL's were doing and I told my H, he would deal with it. But the other thing - your MIL saying all of that stuff to your H about babies - that is wrong. Very very wrong. What kind of man is he? How about what kind of mother is she to say those things to her son?  
  • Every time she asks you the question, I would probably just refuse to engage with it either way and change the topic.  "When are you having kids?" "Oh, I don't know.  How has work been going MIL?"  I would, however, want H to address with her privately that the conversation is closed.  Yes, it's a common thing to deal with, but that doesn't make it okay.  I'll never understand why other people's reproductive choices (and basically sex lives!) are considered an "ok" thing to ask about!

    There are members of both of our families that do the kiss on the lips thing, too.  I feel super awkward about it but have always just tried to go along.  Lately I've tried to head them off at the pass by kissing on the cheek first, but some of these ladies are quick! I actually didn't realize this wasn't normal; I just thought I was the weird one for being so uncomfortable about it.  I'm very close with my parents but in a more "professional" way (quick hugs hello and goodbye) and I just wasn't raised with stuff like that.  I'm also a pretty private person like you describe yourself.  Thanks for validating my non-craziness!
  • VORVOR member
    Eighth Anniversary 500 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    On the baby front- tell your DH that if he isn't going to shut it down, YOU will.  And then do it.  She asks - I'd tell her "That's none of your business".  "if you keep asking, I'm leaving", etc.  Tell her it's NOT a topic of conversation. 

    On the kissing - let that go.  It's NOT "disrespectful" to you.  She's his MOM - she's not a romantic partner.  Is it weird?  To many people, yes.  I'm not a big kisser w/ other adults. I don't like my FIL kissing me (even on the cheek).  I get it.  BUT that's entirely between your DH and his mom. It has nothing to do with you - NOTHING. 

    If you want your DH to hear you when it comes to his mom, you HAVE to pick your battles.  The baby talk - that's about you, it affects you, it's rude.  That's a battle.  Them kissing each other?  Let it go.

    If you start to get too picky about what she says and does and you tell your DH about it- there will come a point where he's going to stop caring because he's going to feel like his mom can do nothing right in your eyes.  If you want him to care, be choosy about what the real issues are.
  • I was going to say pretty much what VOR said.  I would tell you DH that if he doesn't talk to his mom about the baby issue, you will and you promise you won't be nice about it.

    The kissing thing ?  A bit weird but I wouldn't push the issue. 
  • VOR said:

    If you start to get too picky about what she says and does and you tell your DH about it- there will come a point where he's going to stop caring because he's going to feel like his mom can do nothing right in your eyes.  If you want him to care, be choosy about what the real issues are.

    THIS! Start with the baby comments, what she's saying it out of line period. I'm suprised he's not offended by her comments, but I don't know their relationship. As PP's have said, if he doesn't stand up, or she doesn't listen to him just tell her "I'm sorry it's not your business", it's much easier said than done, but it won't stop until you put an end to it. I'm not a big fan of lying and saying you can't have a child to end the conversation since a lot of people don't know if that's true until they try, but it's a final issue to shut her up. I'd just be careful with that, sounds like she'll make a nasty comment about you as a woman if you can't produce grandchildren for her. Ugh good luck!

  • elle621elle621 member
    First Anniversary First Comment
    edited May 2015

    Thank you all ladies...very good advice here!

    I spoke with my hubby and even had a nice little victory: we're looking at buying a house, and put in an offer recently. He told his parents about the offer, and said that out of respect to me and my desire for privacy, he wouldn't go into any other details - especially financials.

    I've also gotten better with the baby question. My MIL said we should consider schools, and I changed the subject like a pro. :)

  • elle621 said:

    I spoke with my hubby and even had a nice little victory: we're looking at buying a house, and put in an offer recently. He told his parents about the offer, and said that out of respect to me and my desire for privacy, he wouldn't go into any other details - especially financials.

    I'm glad to hear he's finally coming around. Just be careful house shopping not to put too much out there to anyone. You'll find everyone has an opinion on the town, school, particular house you're looking at. Sometimes you'll lose an offer or something could come up with the house that makes the deal fall through. If people don't know until you've bought the house they can't make comments. Good luck with the search!


  • elle621elle621 member
    First Anniversary First Comment
    Thanks dutchgirl76!
  • VORVOR member
    Eighth Anniversary 500 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    elle621 said:

     He told his parents about the offer, and said that out of respect to me and my desire for privacy, he wouldn't go into any other details - especially financials.


    Ok, great, he didn't disclose too much info.  That's good.  But he should NOT PUT IT ON  YOU as to why he isn't telling them more!!!  That's so not fair and makes YOU the bad guy!  Whatever he says, it needs to show you all as a team.  This, the bolded, does not.
  • Are they from another country/culture?  I ask becasue I know some cultures think NOTHING of kissing on the mouth and it would never occur to them that it was out of line.  As far as the rest of it goes I am like wow- his own mother accuses him of shooting blanks?  Yikes!  I'll also say that my parents got a little hostile waiting for grandkids becasue my mom was afraid she wouldn't be young enough to enjoy and care for them and honestly I know it is tough on her when I leave my boys with her because she was about 65 when I had the first kiddo and watching a 4 and 7 year old is rough at her age.  She said a lot of things to me that she didn't realize were hurtful becasue she didn't know we were struggling with infertility for two years and all I wanted to do was get pregnant- while she constantly nudged me about grandkids.  Not sure I have any great advice though since I lucked out with a MIL that lives a 30 min plane ride away and NEVER visits- kind of sad since she has only met one of her grandkids twice and the other not at all but I guess you win some you lose some. 
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards