Relationships
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

How to tell the parents we're staying home for Christmas?

Last year I was not able to celebrate Christmas or Thanksgiving with my wife because I was out of the country for work. My wife and I do not want to travel this year for Christmas or Thanksgiving; we want to start a tradition of spending the holidays in our own home. We were married in 2014 and this year will be our first Thanksgiving and X-mas together. We live on opposite sides of the country from both sets of in-laws. We don't like travelling, especially during the holidays. In addition, staying at my wife's house is not comfortable - we have to sleep in a small bed, and my in-laws' cat aggravates my wife's allergies.

 The problem is that my mother-in-law often uses guilt to get her way. We're worried that our decision to stay home for the holidays will be taken as an offense and that we will be guilted into travelling to see the in-laws during the holidays. I have issues with flying and I feel very uncomfortable on planes. We have very few days off with my wife's schedule and driving is not an option with our limited vacation days.

 I have explained to my parents that we don't like traveling on the holidays, and they were understanding. They don't like traveling on the holidays either. My mother in law will not be as understanding. I am going to offer that they are more than welcome to come to our house for Christmas. (My in-laws won't want to; they hate traveling as well). My mother-in-law may see this as a slight and heave an enormous amount of guilt on my wife. My wife gets soooo stressed with the guilt. The way guilt is used is NOT FAIR TO MY WIFE.

 We just want to have a calm, comfortable Christmas together and to not travel. Any suggestions for how to tell my mother-in-law that we aren't coming to her place for x-mas? I would like to broach this in a way that won't upset anyone or cause tension. We don't want to set a precedent of going to their house every year, because it will turn into a yearly obligation.

 Any thoughts on how to broach this issue?

Re: How to tell the parents we're staying home for Christmas?

  • People only make you feel the way you allow them to, your MIL knows this works with your wife so she uses guilt. As to how to broach it, I would say , this is what we are doing this year, end of story and then don't engage in any discussion.
  • Agreed, your wife will just have to tell her and then close the subject to further conversation. It will be hard, but kudos for doing what is right for YOUR new family. You can visit MIL some other time when travel is more affordable and less stressful.
  • Tell her, when it gets closer to the holiday, you will be hosting your own Christmas extravaganza.

    If she gets mad? Too bad.
      
  • It always astounds me when people will get so upset that a family member does not want to travel...but then they aren't willing to travel themselves either.

    If I was in this situation, I would state the reasons traveling is not an option over the holidays.  Uncomfortable, more expensive, allergies, not much vacation time...all good reasons.  Repeat as needed.  And if my mom started getting naggy/guilt trip, the conversation would be shut down and would be shut down each time she brought it up.  It's just the way some people need to be treated.

    Another option, is it possible you all would be willing to visit your MIL at another time of year?  If so, offer to do that.  Like, "Mom, flights will be twice as expensive and airports twice as crowded if we travel in December.  How about we make a visit in March instead?"

    Of course, I fall in the category of "holidays are nice, but visiting family is the main thing regardless of the time of year".  I honestly don't understand the obsession some people have over celebrations/visiting HAS to be on Christmas.

  • VORVOR member
    Eighth Anniversary 500 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    People only make you feel the way you allow them to, your MIL knows this works with your wife so she uses guilt. As to how to broach it, I would say , this is what we are doing this year, end of story and then don't engage in any discussion.
    The bolded is what you need to get your wife to understand.  This is partially on your wife.  Her mom can't guilt her if your wife doesn't LET her. 

    As for telling them, honestly, I woudl NOT list a bunch of reasons. They'll look for holes. The shorter and simpler, the better. 

    And in the future when you go - allergies are a GREAT reason to stay in a hotel.

    If her mom doesn't understand that,then she's just an amazingly selfish person.
  • I would instead focus on your wife and not your MIL as I have a feeling that nothing you say to your MIL will make her behave better.  One thing I realized is that sometimes ILs are no different than toddlers.  Once they learn that throwing fits and tantrums get them what they want whether it be toys, candy or even the holidays, they will keep doing it.  And really why should they stop if what they are doing works for them ?  Your MIL learned somewhere along the line that guilt trips work on your wife and she will pull out that little card any time it pleases her.  

    So now your job is to encourage your wife.  Keep reminding her that you both have nothing, NOTHING to feel guilty for.  You have done nothing wrong.  Wanting to spend Christmas in your own home with your husband and start your own traditions is completely normal, reasonable, understandable and healthy.  She is a grown woman who made vows to " Put above all others and let no one come between " to another person and now it is time to put those vows into action as this is exactly what forsaking/ putting above all others means.  It means choosing your husband's desires, comforts and happiness over your mother's.  It also means putting your own needs first as well.  The best thing she can do for herself and her marriage right now is come to terms with the fact that her mom will be disappointed, sad and upset with her AND THAT IS OK.  It's ok to disappoint your parents as we all have done it at one point and I honestly believe it is part of growing up.  So the sooner your wife understand this concept the better she will be.  On the other hand, your MIL is entitled to her feelings to.  She is allowed to be sad she won't see her daughter on Christmas; however the burden isn't on your wife to make those feelings of sadness go away.  That is on your MIL.  So again, encourage your wife to accept the fact that her mom will be sad on Christmas, but this is something that must be done.  Trust me, you think the guilt trips are bad now ?  Imagine how it would be if you went to them every year for ten years or if you had a child.  This is the kind of thing you want to nip in the bud now and I think you both are making a very wise decision to stay home.  I know this will be hard at first, but it will get easier as the years go on.

    FWIW,  my dad had a hard time when I told him we wouldn't be there for Christmas morning anymore.  DD was 1 at the time and we wanted to start our own traditions at our own home.  He didn't like it and kept trying to get me to change my mind, but I stood firm and didn't discuss my reason for staying home.  I simply told him we were having Christmas morning at our own house from now on and didn't want to talk about it anymore.  I knew they would be sad to not see us,  but it had to be done as I am not dragging my kids all over town on Christmas day.  We will see them when we are good and ready.  Five years later everyone is fine with that decision and my parents adjusted their expectations for the holidays, but the most important lesson my dad learned..... guilt trips won't work on me.  
  • candle62 said:

    Last year I was not able to celebrate Christmas or Thanksgiving with my wife because I was out of the country for work. My wife and I do not want to travel this year for Christmas or Thanksgiving; we want to start a tradition of spending the holidays in our own home. We were married in 2014 and this year will be our first Thanksgiving and X-mas together. We live on opposite sides of the country from both sets of in-laws. We don't like travelling, especially during the holidays. In addition, staying at my wife's house is not comfortable - we have to sleep in a small bed, and my in-laws' cat aggravates my wife's allergies.

     The problem is that my mother-in-law often uses guilt to get her way. We're worried that our decision to stay home for the holidays will be taken as an offense and that we will be guilted into travelling to see the in-laws during the holidays. I have issues with flying and I feel very uncomfortable on planes. We have very few days off with my wife's schedule and driving is not an option with our limited vacation days.

     I have explained to my parents that we don't like traveling on the holidays, and they were understanding. They don't like traveling on the holidays either. My mother in law will not be as understanding. I am going to offer that they are more than welcome to come to our house for Christmas. (My in-laws won't want to; they hate traveling as well). My mother-in-law may see this as a slight and heave an enormous amount of guilt on my wife. My wife gets soooo stressed with the guilt. The way guilt is used is NOT FAIR TO MY WIFE.

     We just want to have a calm, comfortable Christmas together and to not travel. Any suggestions for how to tell my mother-in-law that we aren't coming to her place for x-mas? I would like to broach this in a way that won't upset anyone or cause tension. We don't want to set a precedent of going to their house every year, because it will turn into a yearly obligation.

     Any thoughts on how to broach this issue?

    "We want to have a calm, comfortable Christmas at home and to not travel. You are more than welcome to come to our house for Christmas!"

    image
  • If you and your wife are so afraid of her mother's guilt trips, the two of you have not learned to set boundaries in your marriage. It is time for your wife to stop allowing her mother's manipulation to control her wife. 

    I've learned that I can only be honest about what I am comfortable with. The reactions of others to my boundary setting is their problem and not mine. 

    Most husbands and wives have to learn to negotiate time with extended family and time for each other as a couple. This is a great opportunity for your wife to learn to be okay with her mother's disapproval. 
  • Just a thought, but what if you tell them that due to the cost of traveling over the holidays and the limited time off you get, you won't be visiting (which is the truth). However, maybe you can work a visit to each set of parents for say a 4 day weekend at a different time of year. Like fly in Thursday night & leave sometime on Monday? This way they can still see you and you can travel at a less expensive time and less crowded too making the traveling portion easier.

  • VORVOR member
    Eighth Anniversary 500 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    NoneForUs said:
    If you and your wife are so afraid of her mother's guilt trips, the two of you have not learned to set boundaries in your marriage. It is time for your wife to stop allowing her mother's manipulation to control her wife. 

    I've learned that I can only be honest about what I am comfortable with. The reactions of others to my boundary setting is their problem and not mine. 

    Most husbands and wives have to learn to negotiate time with extended family and time for each other as a couple. This is a great opportunity for your wife to learn to be okay with her mother's disapproval. 
    100% this. 
  • Maybe you can take turns and travel every other year? A compromise....
  • Erikan73 said:

    Just a thought, but what if you tell them that due to the cost of traveling over the holidays and the limited time off you get, you won't be visiting (which is the truth). However, maybe you can work a visit to each set of parents for say a 4 day weekend at a different time of year. Like fly in Thursday night & leave sometime on Monday? This way they can still see you and you can travel at a less expensive time and less crowded too making the traveling portion easier.


    Great idea!


  • Erikan73 said:

    Just a thought, but what if you tell them that due to the cost of traveling over the holidays and the limited time off you get, you won't be visiting (which is the truth). However, maybe you can work a visit to each set of parents for say a 4 day weekend at a different time of year. Like fly in Thursday night & leave sometime on Monday? This way they can still see you and you can travel at a less expensive time and less crowded too making the traveling portion easier.


    Great idea!


    I also agree with this idea. As a compromise offer your home to anyone willing to travel, hopefully one year of the IL's traveling will make them understand why you're staying home.
  • You two are no longer children in the nest. You are married, which makes you your own family, with your own traditions. You should function as a unit. If you put more value in your extended families than in each other then there is a problem.
    There is nothing to feel guilty about. Your MIL is manipulating you. Don't let her.  If your wife is THAT affected she may require counseling. 
    I would suggest you have your own holidays and offer an open invitation to anyone who would like to join you.  YOu can also celebrate with family at different times that are more convenient....Christmas in June can be lots of fun! 
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards