Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Mom moving in, need advice

My mom is having trouble with her finances. Since my dad passed away, she has squandered a lot of life insurance money and sold her house and now she is getting into lots of debt. I recently bought a house with the intention of letting her stay with us to help her save money without actually giving her any money which I fear she would not be able to spend properly. She has a job, but it doesn't pay well. In any case, she has been wanting to bring pieces of furniture over to put in various rooms of our house without me really wanting those pieces. We have very different taste and I do not like her taste. Also, her house is smoky from my sister staying with her and smoking indoors and I am about to have a baby and don't really want smoky smelling furniture around. I expected her to confine her belongings to her room, but she seems to feel entitled to put them anywhere she wants and has even bought plants to plant in the yard without consulting me about it. When I asked her not to change a blind that was custom to her bedroom to a cheaper vinyl blind she bought at Target (that matched her bohemian style) in her bedroom, she became enraged that I was trying to control what she did in her bedroom and said she felt like one of my children. She told me to lose her phone number. This was very upsetting to me as she is close to my children. I don't want to have a lot of drama in the house, but I feel as if my mom is too late in life to learn how to take care of herself financially (my dad has always helped her). She is 3 years away from being able to collect Social Security. How do I tell her I don't want her to decorate outside her room without being too controlling and making her feel like she is not welcome? I want to avoid drama.

Re: Mom moving in, need advice

  • I think the only chance of peace here is to have a lease agreement written out so she's clear on your expectations, including a timeline on the living situation. If she gets mad I'd say that's on her. She put herself in this position by not acting responsibly. It is going to be hard and if your mom has any other options it will probably be easier on both of you. Could she afford a place with a roommate? Stick to a budget that you help her create? I would say that furnishings in her room I'd stay out of, but it sounds like she'll need to find storage for her other furniture.
  • She is trying to manipulate you with her hysterics and her drama. I mean, she told you to lose her number over vinyl blinds ? She is clearly trying to show you who is head honcho in your own home. Don't fall for it. Calmly put her stuff back in her room every time. She throws a fit ? Tell her you that you can see she is upset right now and you will speak to her when she is feeling better and walk away. She continues to act a fool, calmly let her know that the furniture is not up for discussion and walk away. Do this every time and whatever you do, do not fall for her dramatics. She is behaving no differently than a toddler in the middle of the toy aisle. Somewhere along the way she learned that she can get whatever she wants by throwing a temper tantrum. If you wouldn't tolerate that kind of behavior from your toddler, don't tolerate it with your mother.
  • Yeah, maybe she is manipulating me. She really confuses me. I don't understand her at all. But I guess I shouldn't feel so pressured to let her put her furniture everywhere and plant whatever she wants in my house. I don't want to be a difficult person, but isn't it reasonable to expect that when I offer for her to stay with us for her financial well being that that doesn't mean she gets to decorate my new house to suit her style? I really feel like I want it to be mine and my husband's to decorate, but everyone keeps telling me to just let her do what she wants so that I don't cause drama.
  • Don't listen to them. This is your home that you own and you are a grown woman. This is your right so dont let her emotionally blackmail you. She does not get to decorate your home with her stinky furniture. Trust me, it won't stop with this. Before you know it she will be bringing in pets and kicking you out of your bedroom. I also suspect a personality disorder based on her over reaction. If so, giving in to her nonsense will only make things worse.

    In addition, are you married ? If so then that is quite disrespectful to your husband as this is his home too.
  • edited November 2015
    My mom is having trouble with her finances. Since my dad passed away, she has squandered a lot of life insurance money and sold her house and now she is getting into lots of debt

    Did you ask her why she is in debt and ask her what happened to all of the money?

    None of this sounds good. She could have a spending addiction or something else going on.

    I recently bought a house with the intention of letting her stay with us to help her save money without actually giving her any money which I fear she would not be able to spend properly.

    This is the whole thing it all hangs on --- why is she having such money problems? You need to get to the root of all of it.

    Maybe there was another situation she won't talk about that's not a spending addiction -- you never know what goes on behind the scenes. People are funny that way and it's a matter of pride.

    She has a job, but it doesn't pay well. In any case, she has been wanting to bring pieces of furniture over to put in various rooms of our house without me really wanting those pieces.

    I can suggest a bedroom set that she has --- she can bring it to your place and put it in her room but I am sure you have furniture, too and there will simply be no room for it. She will likely have to put it into storage until she is able to get her own place.


    We have very different taste and I do not like her taste. Also, her house is smoky from my sister staying with her and smoking indoors and I am about to have a baby and don't really want smoky smelling furniture around.

    I am wondering if your sis is the root of your mother's spending problems. Something isn't right here --- how in heck is she in debt?


    I expected her to confine her belongings to her room, but she seems to feel entitled to put them anywhere she wants and has even bought plants to plant in the yard without consulting me about it.

    When I asked her not to change a blind that was custom to her bedroom to a cheaper vinyl blind she bought at Target (that matched her bohemian style) in her bedroom, she became enraged that I was trying to control what she did in her bedroom and said she felt like one of my children. She told me to lose her phone number.

    This was very upsetting to me as she is close to my children. I don't want to have a lot of drama in the house, but I feel as if my mom is too late in life to learn how to take care of herself financially (my dad has always helped her).

    She is 3 years away from being able to collect Social Security. How do I tell her I don't want her to decorate outside her room without being too controlling and making her feel like she is not welcome? I want to avoid drama.
    The garden is a minor thing --- give her a corner of the garden to fool around with and plant what she wants to plant.

    Point of it all:

    This is YOUR home and she is to follow your rules. If you moved into her home, it would be the same: her rules and you follow them.

    I do not think any of this will work. It's going to be too many crossed horns. Your mother is going to have to find a way to be on her own, even if it means living in a studio apartment or getting a 2 bedroom apartment and having a roommate to share expenses.

    Above all, do not give her money. Something is wrong with this whole picture...and speaking as one who has a sibling who was in a pack of money problems, none of this looks good for her.

    Wishing you luck.  I would simply say, "mom, sorry: we can't lock horns on these problems that crop up. For lack of a better way of putting it: this is my home and there are rules here; it would be the same if I moved into your home. You can either live wqith the rules or get your own place; the choice is yours" and let her take it from there.

    As Disney pointed out: are you married? How come your H approved of this? THis is something you and he should have talked over --- and if you did this minus his input, this is not good.

    Would you like it if he zoomed out and bought a home and had his mother or father or whoever move in....

    Just to help the person out?

    I don't think you would.

    You can also be stuck with her permanently.

    Take back your home ---- if she doesn't like the rules, the door is open.

  • Uhmmmmm, how can you not see that she is manipulating you. She told you to lose her number over a stinky old chair and blinds. What you are doing for her is incredibly kind and generous, almost bordering on enabling. She should be down on her knees thanking you for rescuing her from homelessness, not treating you like you are less than human. She is not allowed to treat you like this. Anyone who disagrees are probably the same people who created this monster.
  • edited November 2015
    That is a small child in our profile --- I am guessing you are married and have an H and a kiddo or at least one child...

    So tell us how this was okay for your H to merrily allow *you* to run out and buy a home with the sole purpose of having your mother move in with you...

    And not to mention a mother whose spending habits are alarming and questionable...and whose reason behind the spending is unknown to you. And also unknown to your husband, the doormat.

    (my gosh, the 2 of you need to learn how to make decisions together! You go "My mom is moving in with us" he goes "okay" and you go "okay I will also be buying a house, just to accommodate her"???

    Wow...she needs but one room! Wot "new house" for your mother to be accommodated in????

    This is already whackadoo. You never should have said yes to this arrangement --- help your mother find an apartment she can afford (either by herself or with the help of a roommate or 2; lots of adults have roommates, believe it or not)....but never permitted her to move in with you. She isn't even abiding by your rules! by rights she is a guest in your home.
  • I wouldn't let her move in. There's no way she doesn't try to take over your home and life, and create all sorts of havoc.
    You only live once, but if you do it right, once is enough. ~Mae West
    image
  • Erikan73Erikan73 member
    1000 Comments Fourth Anniversary 250 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited November 2015
    I think this is a matter of picking your battles. Battle to let her win is let her put up the blinds she wants in her room & put the custom ones you have away until she moves out. I'm assuming you are hoping for this to be a temporary situation. In regards to the furniture she wants to bring in, explain to her that with a baby on the way, before long you'll have baby stuff around the house and if she adds furniture to different rooms, the space will become crowded with stuff. Let her put the things she wants into her room and if it smells of smoke, have it professionally cleaned. Yes, that would cost you money, but I personally would rather pay for the cleaning then have to smell the smoke or fight with mom. For the rest of the items, try to find an affordable storage unit for her to put her stuff into. This way when she is in a better situation to go live back out on her own, she won't have to start from scratch. Also if she knows she can put her stuff into storage and not have to give everything away, maybe she won't try so much to bring stuff into your home. On the plants, if they don't go with your yard, try to convince her to give them away, or gee darn, wouldn't it be a shame if you accidentially sprayed them with round up when you were spraying for weeds? I know that's horrible. But before you get rid her plants, make sure they don't have special meaning. Like some people plant rose bushes in for each child when it's born or in memorial to someone. If any of the plants are for reasons like that, maybe you can help find a spot in your yard that she can plant it that will work with your yard design. The last thing is to get your mom enrolled in budget planning & retirement planning courses. Check out your local library, senior center or even community college and work with her to create a budget & savings. This way when she is collecting Social Security, hopefully she can afford to move out to a modest apartment nearby. You've got 3 years to help her get prepared. Many people of that age, the women never learned how to deal with budgets as that was something husbands normally did. When something happens later in life like death or divorce, many older women are at a lost on how to survive.
  • I agree w/ Erikan - pick your battles.  If putting up her own blinds in "her" room will make her happy, then just let her.

    But past that - you're going to have to be firm and you're going ot have to let her get mad.  She ISN'T entitled to do whatever she wants in your home.  And the people telling you to just lether??  WTH?  This is YOUR and your DHs home. NOT hers.  And really- I wouldn't have a problem reminding her of this.  And may even tell her "These are the rules.  If you don't like them/ don't want to abide by them, then you can find somewhere else to live.  This is my home.". 

    As said, she acts the way she does because she thinks she'll get her way.  You're going to probably have to treat her like a child to a certain degree. 
  • I think for me the mother's reaction is the big deal here.  I mean who in their right mind tells her pregnant daughter to get lost because she didn't want a toxin filled chair or blinds in her own home as she was kind enough to let you live there.  Now if her mother was somewhat respectful or considerate,  yeah I can see letting some things go, but she seems like a " give an inch she will take a mile "kind of lady.  I know in my own experience with those kind of people, you have to be very firm with them,  very firm, especially when they throw a fit.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards