Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Gift giving for spouses.

@hoffse reminded me of something I wanted to get feedback on.

Our 2nd anniversary is on Monday (January 25th, exactly one month after Christmas), then my birthday is on Feb 8th, and Valentine's Day follows right after that.

When we set a date for our wedding I told DH that we didn't need to "celebrate" all of those events with big gifts and spending a lot of money since those four events all happen in under two months.

Last year we went on vacation for our anniversary and didn't do anything but exchange cards and go to a nice restaurant (nicer than what we normally go to but dinner and drinks was still less than $100).  This year we are going to a hockey game and going out to dinner but I told DH that we really don't need to exchange gifts since we are going on vacation again in a few weeks and spent more than we normally do at Christmas.  

I'm also not a fan of Valentine's day...

Am I being a total buzzkill?  I'm not a super romantic person but making a big to-do out of our wedding anniversary seems a little silly until it is a "milestone" like 5, 10, 15 years.  I might feel a little different if it didn't fall so close to Christmas and I'm usually out of gift ideas after his birthday in September and Christmas.


Formerly AprilH81
photo composite_14153800476219jpg

Re: Gift giving for spouses.

  • I don't think you're being a buzzkill at all.  That's a lot right in a row.

    H and I usually splurge on a nice restaurant for our anniversary.  We eat pretty well on his firm's dime throughout the year, but our anniversary is really the only time it's just us, and we get to pick the restaurant.

    I could see us doing something more special for 5-year milestones, but otherwise I really like just having a nice dinner and not worrying about the budget with it.

    We have never done Valentine's Day because I have always found it sort of awkward.

    I think that going on vacation or doing something nice for both of you as a joint Christmas/anniversary/Valentines/bday thing is totally fine.

    I'm not romantic either.  I've actually been known to forget our anniversary date....
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I don't think you're being a buzzkill either.  Our anniversary is 3 days after my birthday.  We actually like to plan our annual trips around our anniversary (although not this year) and that's what we consider our anniversary gift to each other.  Oftentimes we have been on a trip over my birthday, so we'll use that night to go out to a nice dinner, or H might get me a little souvenir or a massage.  If we're not traveling around that time, such as this year, we usually do dinner but not gifts. 

    We sometimes go to dinner for Valentine's day, but H has never been a fan of the holiday so we don't really celebrate it much, which is fine by me.  Last year we went on a snowshoeing/food tasting adventure for Valentine's Day.  It was a fundraiser for a local nonprofit, and it was super fun and way better than dinner and chocolates :)


  • Happy early anniversary!! I don't think you're a buzzkill. I'm a fellow January anniversary (21st) and we also have a lot in a row. My birthday is in November, Christmas, anniversary, Valentine's Day. I get it. We exchanged gifts and went out to dinner for our first anniversary, because it felt special. Now every other year, on the evens, we go do something big (long weekend or something along those lines.) On the odds we exchange cards and maybe go to dinner. I did get H a gift for tomorrow, but it felt big because it's our 5th anniversary. I know that's not a really long time, but it feels milestone-ish. But his gift is small and it'll go along with a nice card. The every other year thing has helped us feel like we're still doing something special to celebrate, but we spread out the spending.
  • It is a lot in a row. I wouldn't like having to think of that many gifts. I get hit with Father's Day, dh birthday and our anniversary usually all in the space of a month, and that is rough. Usually gifts get combined.

    Not celebrating Valentine's Day isn't a big deal to me. It's too commercialized, restaurants are too busy, so honestly I would rather go out another night if we were going to do a nice restaurant. This year it will be under 2 weeks after baby, so absolutely no Valentine's Day this year.
    image
  • We celebrate our anniversary but we don't do a specific thing to celebrate. It just depends on the year. This year is our 9th wedding anniversary. I'm guessing it'll be lower key since we are saving up to sell/buy a new house.

    Next year for our 10th we would love to go on a special vacation!
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers
  • Another vote for definitely not a buzzkill.  Poor H has a similar stretch in December with his mom's birthday, my birthday, and then Christmas.  I'd be okay with only doing gifts for Christmas, but gift giving is clearly a "love language" for him so he is very sweet and gets a small gift for my birthday too.  We definitely go biggest with our Christmas gifts.  Birthday is usually a small gift and a dinner.

    I'm not into Valentine's Day either.  I was single through most of HS and college and it bred some seriously bad associations.  Since we love going out to eat we will sometimes use it as an excuse, but never on the day-of.  Our anniversary is more meaningful to us but so far, we still just do a dinner.  
  • Another vote for definitely not a buzzkill.  Poor H has a similar stretch in December with his mom's birthday, my birthday, and then Christmas.  I'd be okay with only doing gifts for Christmas, but gift giving is clearly a "love language" for him so he is very sweet and gets a small gift for my birthday too.  We definitely go biggest with our Christmas gifts.  Birthday is usually a small gift and a dinner.

    I'm not into Valentine's Day either.  I was single through most of HS and college and it bred some seriously bad associations.  Since we love going out to eat we will sometimes use it as an excuse, but never on the day-of.  Our anniversary is more meaningful to us but so far, we still just do a dinner.  
    February is almost as bad as Christmas for us.  My birthday, his mom's birthday, my mom's birthday, my twin niece and nephew's birthday, Valentine's Day and then while it isn't in February my other nephew's birthday is March 2nd.  
    Formerly AprilH81
    photo composite_14153800476219jpg

  • I don't think you're a buzzkill! We don't really do Valentine's Day plus my birthday is the next week anyway. We do anniversaries but not in a huge way, maybe a $25 gift or dinner out.
  • We don't buy each other gifts for anything. We go out for a nice dinner for our anniversary, and we try to do some fun stuff for our birthdays, but no gifts are exchanged. We get the things we want throughout the year. Plus, my bday is the week before Christmas, then Christmas, then my H's bday is a few days after Christmas, and when we were dating our anniversary is just after New Years. It is just too much all at once.

    This year we did an Escape room for my bday and went to a playable arcade museum for my H. For Valentines and New Year we make surf and turf meals at home.
  • AprilZ81 said:



    Another vote for definitely not a buzzkill.  Poor H has a similar stretch in December with his mom's birthday, my birthday, and then Christmas.  I'd be okay with only doing gifts for Christmas, but gift giving is clearly a "love language" for him so he is very sweet and gets a small gift for my birthday too.  We definitely go biggest with our Christmas gifts.  Birthday is usually a small gift and a dinner.

    I'm not into Valentine's Day either.  I was single through most of HS and college and it bred some seriously bad associations.  Since we love going out to eat we will sometimes use it as an excuse, but never on the day-of.  Our anniversary is more meaningful to us but so far, we still just do a dinner.  

    February is almost as bad as Christmas for us.  My birthday, his mom's birthday, my mom's birthday, my twin niece and nephew's birthday, Valentine's Day and then while it isn't in February my other nephew's birthday is March 2nd.  

    Phew! It's so funny how birthdays tend to cluster in families.
  • We celebrate anniversaries by going out to dinner.  And exchanging cards.  Our 5 year is next year, and we're planning on going back to our honeymoon destination (Moorea and Bora Bora).  We said at the time it was a once in a lifetime trip, but we loved it so much that we're prioritizing and saving to return.  But years 6-9 will be dinners as usual.  :)  

    We also do not really do anything for Valentine's Day.  We'll exchange cards and DH will get me flowers.  We'll go out to eat either the weekend before or after (never on the day or weekend itself!)
  • Not a buzzkill.  In the six years we have been together, we have only exchanged xmas gifts 3 years.  The other three we found other things we wanted to do instead of gifts (like ummm have a wedding one year haha).  We have done bday gifts maybe 50% of the time? On our dating anniversary we always went out for a nice dinner, because thats what we love to do. My bday was the next day so we never really did anything for that since we would do the anniversary dinner.  Last year for our first wedding anniversary we went back to where we got married in Florida, but that was less about our aniversary and more about it being the only week we could go on vacation since he was a teacher at the time.

    We have never done ANYthing for valentines day - no cards, no candy, no even saying "happy valentines day"  

    Funny story - the first year we were dating my husbands coworkers (almost all females) told him I was tricking him and he was so stressed out about doing nothing and was afraid I would break up with him for failing to do anything.  Of course, he was also afraid I would break up with him if he didn't listen to me and did something.  
  • Not a buzzkill.  In the six years we have been together, we have only exchanged xmas gifts 3 years.  The other three we found other things we wanted to do instead of gifts (like ummm have a wedding one year haha).  We have done bday gifts maybe 50% of the time? On our dating anniversary we always went out for a nice dinner, because thats what we love to do. My bday was the next day so we never really did anything for that since we would do the anniversary dinner.  Last year for our first wedding anniversary we went back to where we got married in Florida, but that was less about our aniversary and more about it being the only week we could go on vacation since he was a teacher at the time.

    We have never done ANYthing for valentines day - no cards, no candy, no even saying "happy valentines day"  

    Funny story - the first year we were dating my husbands coworkers (almost all females) told him I was tricking him and he was so stressed out about doing nothing and was afraid I would break up with him for failing to do anything.  Of course, he was also afraid I would break up with him if he didn't listen to me and did something.  
    DH finally understands if I say "no gifts" that it isn't a trick.  Same thing that if I put a vacuum on my Amazon wish list for Christmas that means that I won't be angry to get a vacuum for Christmas.
    Formerly AprilH81
    photo composite_14153800476219jpg

  • AprilZ81 said:
    Not a buzzkill.  In the six years we have been together, we have only exchanged xmas gifts 3 years.  The other three we found other things we wanted to do instead of gifts (like ummm have a wedding one year haha).  We have done bday gifts maybe 50% of the time? On our dating anniversary we always went out for a nice dinner, because thats what we love to do. My bday was the next day so we never really did anything for that since we would do the anniversary dinner.  Last year for our first wedding anniversary we went back to where we got married in Florida, but that was less about our aniversary and more about it being the only week we could go on vacation since he was a teacher at the time.

    We have never done ANYthing for valentines day - no cards, no candy, no even saying "happy valentines day"  

    Funny story - the first year we were dating my husbands coworkers (almost all females) told him I was tricking him and he was so stressed out about doing nothing and was afraid I would break up with him for failing to do anything.  Of course, he was also afraid I would break up with him if he didn't listen to me and did something.  
    DH finally understands if I say "no gifts" that it isn't a trick.  Same thing that if I put a vacuum on my Amazon wish list for Christmas that means that I won't be angry to get a vacuum for Christmas.
    haha I am the exact same way! If I wanted a vacuum or a kitchen appliance...I actually want it.  

    For the record, he did nothing for me that valentines day.  He said that he didn't want to be with someone who played games so he wasn't going to play them (we had only been together 6 months at the time).  He has trusted my word since
  • AprilZ81 said:



    Not a buzzkill.  In the six years we have been together, we have only exchanged xmas gifts 3 years.  The other three we found other things we wanted to do instead of gifts (like ummm have a wedding one year haha).  We have done bday gifts maybe 50% of the time? On our dating anniversary we always went out for a nice dinner, because thats what we love to do. My bday was the next day so we never really did anything for that since we would do the anniversary dinner.  Last year for our first wedding anniversary we went back to where we got married in Florida, but that was less about our aniversary and more about it being the only week we could go on vacation since he was a teacher at the time.

    We have never done ANYthing for valentines day - no cards, no candy, no even saying "happy valentines day"  

    Funny story - the first year we were dating my husbands coworkers (almost all females) told him I was tricking him and he was so stressed out about doing nothing and was afraid I would break up with him for failing to do anything.  Of course, he was also afraid I would break up with him if he didn't listen to me and did something.  

    DH finally understands if I say "no gifts" that it isn't a trick.  Same thing that if I put a vacuum on my Amazon wish list for Christmas that means that I won't be angry to get a vacuum for Christmas.

    The "it's a trick" thing is so frustrating! Drives me bonkers. Even this year, with a big trip and TTC on the horizon (i.e. many great reasons not to spend money) H brought this up when I suggested skipping Christmas gifts.
  • We are no gifts for the most part.  Sometimes we'll get something very small, like a sweet from the bakery, but that is irregular.

    We put effort into finding nice cards and we use our anniversary as an excuse to splurge on a nice dinner out.
  • Not a buzz kill, for our anniversary all we do is go out for a nice dinner. Like you, something a little nicer then what we would normally do. Our birthdays aren't usually a big to do either. And depending on finances, we have even skipped presents at Christmas. For valentines day my husband will usually send me flowers at work, and you will all laugh at this, he knows I work in an office of caddy jealous women. So he knows how they act when someone gets flowers. So he likes to send me flowers for valentines day so everyone comes over to see them & gets jealous. I know, not very romantic, but it's more of a comedy thing for us.
  • AprilZ81 said:
    Another vote for definitely not a buzzkill.  Poor H has a similar stretch in December with his mom's birthday, my birthday, and then Christmas.  I'd be okay with only doing gifts for Christmas, but gift giving is clearly a "love language" for him so he is very sweet and gets a small gift for my birthday too.  We definitely go biggest with our Christmas gifts.  Birthday is usually a small gift and a dinner.

    I'm not into Valentine's Day either.  I was single through most of HS and college and it bred some seriously bad associations.  Since we love going out to eat we will sometimes use it as an excuse, but never on the day-of.  Our anniversary is more meaningful to us but so far, we still just do a dinner.  
    February is almost as bad as Christmas for us.  My birthday, his mom's birthday, my mom's birthday, my twin niece and nephew's birthday, Valentine's Day and then while it isn't in February my other nephew's birthday is March 2nd.  
    That's how our February/beginning of March are as well.  Feb 8th - H's birthday, Valentines Day, Feb 16th - DD's birthday, March 2nd - My dad's birthday, March 3rd - Mine

    We really don't do anything for any birthdays, Christmas, nor anniversaries.  I'm probably a complete buzzkill, but we will buy things we want jointly and go on vacations without it needing to be a special occasion.
    We leave for Hawaii on Feb 5th.  H will turn 30 while we're there.  Neither one of us even realized it until I went to book the Luau and asked if he wanted to do that on his birthday. We also said Hawaii would be our 5 year anniversary trip.  It will be 4 years this August.  So we're not even doing that as a celebration. 
    For the most part, we cook a nice dinner or go out to a nicer restaurant. 

    TTC since 1/13  DX:PCOS 5/13 (long, anovulatory cycles)
    Clomid 50mg 9/13 = BFP! EDD 6/7/14 M/C 5w6d Found 11/4/13
    1/14 PCOS / Gluten Free Diet to hopefully regulate my system. 
    Chemical Pregnancy 03/14
    Surprise BFP 6/14, Beta #1: 126 Beta #2: 340  Stick baby, stick! EDD 2/17/15
    Riley Elaine born 2/16/15

    TTC 2.0   6/15 
    Chemical Pregnancy 9/15 
    Chemical Pregnancy 6/16
    BFP 9/16  EDD 6/3/17
    Beta #1: 145 Beta #2: 376 Beta #3: 2,225 Beta #4: 4,548
    www.5yearstonever.blogspot.com 
                        Image and video hosting by TinyPic

  • For our anniversary we like to have an experience together instead of giving gifts. One year that was dinner and a Broadway show. We still get each other cards but the experience is our gift to each other.

    We do exchange gifts on birthdays and Christmas, but how much we spend depends on the year/circumstances. We don't usually do much more than cards for Valentine's day, however this year H's client has February 15th off for President's day and I'm thinking it would be nice to take a little getaway somewhere. We both could use it.
  • I don't think it's a buzzkill at all.  We don't do birthday gifts anymore... I'll cook him a nice dinner on his birthday (ie like nice steaks or something nicer than the usual dinners I cook), and the one time a year he cooks for me, is on my birthday.  Vday is just another day, and we do something small for Christmas... he got me winter boots that were like $60, and I got him a new bathrobe that was like $35.  

    Otherwise we just do little nice things throughout the year, and TBH, he foots the bill for most of those... ie the new TV we got on Black Friday, and he also pays for the hockey season tickets.  I "pay him back" by buying him a beer at the game... not an even trade at all but it works for us.
  • Nope, you are not a buzzkill :D
  • BTW H got me a steam mop for Christmas a couple years ago.  His mom was completely dumbfounded by it and asked me if I was mad.  I was like nope, I put that on my Amazon wishlist for a reason!!  I was so stoked to get it LOL!
  • He made the argument that restaurants are crowded on that night, which makes the staff more grumpy and the food more likely to be worse than normal.  I thought that sounded great.

    Our families started moving holidays around for this reason years ago.  Mother's/Father's Day gets done either the week before or the week after.  V-day depends on our work schedules.  Etc.  Sure, we might miss the specials for that event, but we have a much nicer evening that doesn't involve a 2-hr wait for a table in a restaurant that doesn't have the staffing to actually handle a full house.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • I don't think you're a buzz kill! H and I have a really hard time buying gifts for each other because for the most part we just buy the things we want and need.

    For birthdays we usually go away to the beach, his mom has a condo that we get to use for free. Our birthdays are 4 days apart so it works well.

    Valentines Day we use as an excuse to get hibachi! Somehow this tradition started years ago in high school and we've just kind of kept it up. But usually we only do small gifts, like I buy him reese hearts because he loves holiday reeses.

    Christmas we pretty much always buy each other something, but usually it's $100 or less.

    And Easter I usually try to make him a (very) small Easter basket so he doesn't feel left out when the dog gets one... Let's be honest, she's the most spoiled in our house.

    And I mentioned before I have no idea what we did for our 1st anniversary, but we'll probably just go out to eat. Maybe take a trip for the big ones.


Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards