Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

What would MM do? Basement kitchenette

The upstairs of our house is nearly finished, and H and I are starting to talk about the basement.

We have a basement that's designed to be a rental space or MIL suite.  It has a separate bedroom (with closet), full bath, living space with fireplace, and a tiny kitchenette.  The space overall is not huge, but it would be functional for one person.  It even has its own driveway and patio.  Right now, it's really shabby and needs some cosmetic sprucing up.

Practically, we will probably never rent it out.  We have used the bed/bath down there for overflow when we have multiple guests spending the night, and I don't see us wanting to give up that space to a tenant.  I think that if/when we have kids it will be most useful for a playroom because the floors are tile throughout.

One interesting thing is that there really isn't much storage space down there, even though it's a basically built as a small apartment.  The closet off the bedroom is very small, and our holiday stuff fills it up.  If we end up using it as a playroom, we will need some additional storage, and right now I would like some storage down there for craft supplies, etc.  We are thinking of using part of the kitchenette for this purpose.

Right now our kitchenette has an old set of cabinets and sink on one side (sink does not work), and a huge stove on the other.  It's a tiny galley.  We are thinking of tearing out the cabinets and re-installing lowers only with a sink and built-in beverage fridge.  Then do some floating shelves above because the upper cabinets really close in the space visually.

On the opposite wall, remove the enormous stove and install a floor-to-ceiling open shelving unit where we can put in some nice baskets.  We could use that to store craft supplies and toys in the future. With the sink on the other side, I sort of envision it being a combo craft storage/clean-up area.  

We think if we do it like this, then future owners could easily convert it back to a rentable space by removing the shelving and installing appliances instead.  It would give us some added storage in an area that's not part of the main living space.  That's important because we actually have almost no wall space in the main living area because of windows, the fireplace, etc.

What does MM think?  I really don't want to do anything that would lower the value of our house, but the kitchenette is just wasted/dead space for us right now.
Wedding Countdown Ticker

Re: What would MM do? Basement kitchenette

  • I love your idea. I like that you are planning to keep sink & put a fridge down there and basically make it for lack of better terms "a bar area". With going with your plan, you don't loose your guest space and for now you can leave the other area as a living room area/craft area and when the time comes, adjust for play area for kids.

    The bedroom area, just a thought, how many times a year does it get used as a guest room? You said you use it for guest overflow. My first thought is make it the primary guest room since there is a full bathroom down there & it would give your guests basically their own private suite with the living room area down there. Then the room you have upstairs can be utilized for something else. My other thought is if you don't want to that & don't use that room for guests very often, maybe consider installing a murphy bed so that way when you don't have guests you can use the room for something else, like your craft room. Then you just set up your craft room in a way that when you have guests, you maybe move 1 or 2 things around, pull down the bed & you have a guest room again. That would free up more space in the basement living room area for other possible storage options.

    Last thing, love the idea of a small fridge, but think, would you be better off with a regular size or apartment size fridge so you would have space needed for when you entertain or to allow you to buy in larger quantities to get better deals? 

  • cbee817cbee817 member
    Ancient Membership 250 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    edited February 2016
    I think that sounds awesome- is the neighborhood typically single family homes anyway? I would think a young family (potential future buyer?) would get way more use out of a play space than a rental unit. 

    FWIW, I love the art space in our basement for the girls- they're free to mess it up with paint, play doh, whatever and there's a huge utility sink down there that we use to clean everything once they're done. Ours is unfinished and just 1 giant room, but we painted the floors and walls which help it feel nicer. DH also keeps it super clean and our sump pump is in its own closet, so you don't see it.. although our furnace and HWT are in the middle of the basement.
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • Assuming you live in a higher end area, where a future owner likely isn't going to have a tenant, I would tear out the oven but keep a beverage fridge, sink and microwave. If your area is less affluent, that may change my opinion.
    HeartlandHustle | Personal Finance and Betterment Blog  
  • I would go for it and make the changes.  I'm not sure how it would impact the value of the house, it may depend on the market/your buyers.  I actually don't really like when a basement has a kitchenette, but I may not represent the average buyer.

    I did a quick search on ovens and there are a few in the $400-500 range. I would say do what you want with the space (you want to stay 10 years right?) to enjoy it while it's yours.  If you go to sell and can't get what you want because not having a kitchen down there has detracted from the value, you could probably redo it relatively cheap.  I doubt it would be a problem though.
  • I like your idea!! It works for you now, but keeps it open for people in the future. 
    Anniversary
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Agree with pps, it sounds like you'd essentially be creating a 'bar' area, which I think is a good idea.  Seems to be pretty popular these days, especially in basements.  Plus, by not removing the plumbing, it would be easy to convert in the future.

    I agree that I'd consider a bigger fridge.  And I also like the idea that @Erikan had to make it the main guest bedroom space, but that would depend on the situation in the rest of the house. 

    I don't know what the norm is, but speaking for myself, I'd probably never rent a room out, so having a kitchenette in a house I bought would just be something I'd want to get rid of right away.  You'd be doing me a favor :)

  • als1982 said:
    Assuming you live in a higher end area, where a future owner likely isn't going to have a tenant, I would tear out the oven but keep a beverage fridge, sink and microwave. If your area is less affluent, that may change my opinion.
    I agree with this... if you were in an urban area where renting out basements is common... I'd leave a whole kitchenette down there.  But if it's more of an area like what I think you live in... your plan is totally fine and would be a nice selling point to any families or even older empty nesters (it'd be great for visiting children).  
  • To answer some questions - 

    Our neighborhood is primarily smaller ranch houses - all single family on 1/2 acre or so lots. Quite a few of them are undergoing remodels.  We have watched at least 3 flips happen since moving in two years ago.  It's in a fantastic/affluent school district, and has always been the entry-level/bargain neighborhood for that district.  It tends to be younger families or really old people (the saying around here is "Newlywed or nearly dead.")

    We have used the extra bedroom down in the basement a couple times before.  H and I have no family locally, so whenever people visit they have to spend the night, and there have been a couple times when his parents and BIL/SIL came to stay at the same time.  Right now we have three bedrooms on the main level upstairs.  One is obviously the master.  We use bedroom 2 as the guest room and bedroom 3 as an office.  Once kids are in the picture we talked about converting the office to a nursery and moving our desk/computer to the guest room.  Bedroom 2 is actually really big.

    That said, I do REALLY like the idea of a murphy bed down in the basement. I had not thought of that before.  We don't need the extra bed down there very often, but when we need it we really need it.  Once we have kids, that space would probably function better as our office/craft room most of the time, but we could still use it for guests in a pinch.  I like that idea a lot, and it would preserve space for our office.

    Thanks for the thoughts on this.  I kind of hate kitchenettes in basements too, and I honestly don't think it's ever been used.  The finished basement - though drabby - was one of the things that sold us on the house, but it was because of the potential for a playroom, rather than a rental space.  

    My H kind of wants to tear it all out and just close it in to make it a nice big closet, but I do like the idea of keeping a utility sink in that space for clean up, and I want to be able to convert it back to a kitchenette for cheap if our realtor tells us we have to once we are ready to sell.

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • hoffse said:
    To answer some questions - 

    Our neighborhood is primarily smaller ranch houses - all single family on 1/2 acre or so lots. Quite a few of them are undergoing remodels.  We have watched at least 3 flips happen since moving in two years ago.  It's in a fantastic/affluent school district, and has always been the entry-level/bargain neighborhood for that district.  It tends to be younger families or really old people (the saying around here is "Newlywed or nearly dead.")

    We have used the extra bedroom down in the basement a couple times before.  H and I have no family locally, so whenever people visit they have to spend the night, and there have been a couple times when his parents and BIL/SIL came to stay at the same time.  Right now we have three bedrooms on the main level upstairs.  One is obviously the master.  We use bedroom 2 as the guest room and bedroom 3 as an office.  Once kids are in the picture we talked about converting the office to a nursery and moving our desk/computer to the guest room.  Bedroom 2 is actually really big.

    That said, I do REALLY like the idea of a murphy bed down in the basement. I had not thought of that before.  We don't need the extra bed down there very often, but when we need it we really need it.  Once we have kids, that space would probably function better as our office/craft room most of the time, but we could still use it for guests in a pinch.  I like that idea a lot, and it would preserve space for our office.

    Thanks for the thoughts on this.  I kind of hate kitchenettes in basements too, and I honestly don't think it's ever been used.  The finished basement - though drabby - was one of the things that sold us on the house, but it was because of the potential for a playroom, rather than a rental space.  

    My H kind of wants to tear it all out and just close it in to make it a nice big closet, but I do like the idea of keeping a utility sink in that space for clean up, and I want to be able to convert it back to a kitchenette for cheap if our realtor tells us we have to once we are ready to sell.

    As nice as a closet may be, it makes way more sense to leave the space as something that has potential to be a kitchenette.  I think that you should only make changes to the space (taking out bathrooms/bedrooms etc) if it's your forever home.  

    I just saw a house listed that said "this house is a two bedroom but a wall was recently removed on the main level to open up the living room. it could easily be put back to be a third bedroom"  why would you recently make sure a big change and not expect to lose a ton of money on it?

  • As nice as a closet may be, it makes way more sense to leave the space as something that has potential to be a kitchenette.  I think that you should only make changes to the space (taking out bathrooms/bedrooms etc) if it's your forever home.  

    I just saw a house listed that said "this house is a two bedroom but a wall was recently removed on the main level to open up the living room. it could easily be put back to be a third bedroom"  why would you recently make sure a big change and not expect to lose a ton of money on it?
    Yeah, that's my thinking too.  I want to be able to convert it back if we need to or if it happens to be something that adds value to a potential buyer for their situation (maybe extended stays from family members or something).

    I think I have convinced H that we need to keep some cabinetry and sink on the one side.  I think it's fine to off the stove - it doesn't work and is too big for that space anyway - and then do cubbies on that wall for our use.  If we stopped our renovations there, converting it back someday would be NBD.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I just saw a house listed that said "this house is a two bedroom but a wall was recently removed on the main level to open up the living room. it could easily be put back to be a third bedroom"  why would you recently make sure a big change and not expect to lose a ton of money on it?
    My guess......somebody did the change because they wanted it and planned to be there and then had an unplanned life event and now need to get rid of the house.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • I really like your idea to make it functional but also able to be a kitchenette. Depending on how much upgrading you plan to do to the space you could make it resemble a bar. I'm not sure about your area but that is a HOT selling point in ours. H is dying to have a wet bar (or any bar) in our next house.

  • I vote to keep it flexible, yet functional for your needs. ditch the oven & i like the idea of a full-size, yet smaller fridge. keep re-sale in mind if this isn't your forever home. but it sounds like a perfect space for kids, guests, in-laws or au pair.

    And even though your basement needs work, I'm SO jealous!! Ours is a complete DISASTER. Like, original to the house, built in 1885, disaster. We've been interviewing contractors and the cost is jaw-dropping.
  • jtmh2012 said:
    I just saw a house listed that said "this house is a two bedroom but a wall was recently removed on the main level to open up the living room. it could easily be put back to be a third bedroom"  why would you recently make sure a big change and not expect to lose a ton of money on it?
    My guess......somebody did the change because they wanted it and planned to be there and then had an unplanned life event and now need to get rid of the house.
    It's possible, but it's an area that is known for being starter homes. I'm also concerned about resale at every turn even though we have no intention of leaving, and there is no reason that we would ever move for jobs.  We haven't even bought and allI can think is about resale when I look at something.
  • kmurphy2131 said:

    It's possible, but it's an area that is known for being starter homes. I'm also concerned about resale at every turn even though we have no intention of leaving, and there is no reason that we would ever move for jobs.  We haven't even bought and allI can think is about resale when I look at something.
    That's not a bad thing.  While it won't guarantee a bad result when you move out, it'll greatly reduce the odds.  Honestly, myself, I'd even be thinking about it for my forever home.  Sure, I'll be dead and won't care, but what about my loved ones who now need to sell my house?
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • jtmh2012 said:

    kmurphy2131 said:

    It's possible, but it's an area that is known for being starter homes. I'm also concerned about resale at every turn even though we have no intention of leaving, and there is no reason that we would ever move for jobs.  We haven't even bought and allI can think is about resale when I look at something.
    That's not a bad thing.  While it won't guarantee a bad result when you move out, it'll greatly reduce the odds.  Honestly, myself, I'd even be thinking about it for my forever home.  Sure, I'll be dead and won't care, but what about my loved ones who now need to sell my house?
    Interestingly enough, H and I have always gone against the grain on this.  When we first decided to change our tiny 3-bedrooms into 2 less tiny bedrooms, our realtor was appalled.  She told us over and over how much value we were going to lose by getting rid of a bedroom.  Thing is, we do plan on staying in this house until retirement at least, and the 2 rooms makes the most sense for our lifestyle.  We've always thought in these terms when it comes to all of our projects--we want it to be the most comfortable house FOR US while we are living in it, and resale value is a distant thought.  I know that's completely unconventional, but we're okay with that.  It doesn't hurt that we bought when the market was really low, so we are practically guaranteed a decent profit regardless of when/if we sell and what we do to the house.
  • jtmh2012 said:

    kmurphy2131 said:

    It's possible, but it's an area that is known for being starter homes. I'm also concerned about resale at every turn even though we have no intention of leaving, and there is no reason that we would ever move for jobs.  We haven't even bought and allI can think is about resale when I look at something.
    That's not a bad thing.  While it won't guarantee a bad result when you move out, it'll greatly reduce the odds.  Honestly, myself, I'd even be thinking about it for my forever home.  Sure, I'll be dead and won't care, but what about my loved ones who now need to sell my house?
    Interestingly enough, H and I have always gone against the grain on this.  When we first decided to change our tiny 3-bedrooms into 2 less tiny bedrooms, our realtor was appalled.  She told us over and over how much value we were going to lose by getting rid of a bedroom.  Thing is, we do plan on staying in this house until retirement at least, and the 2 rooms makes the most sense for our lifestyle.  We've always thought in these terms when it comes to all of our projects--we want it to be the most comfortable house FOR US while we are living in it, and resale value is a distant thought.  I know that's completely unconventional, but we're okay with that.  It doesn't hurt that we bought when the market was really low, so we are practically guaranteed a decent profit regardless of when/if we sell and what we do to the house.
    We are buying a home that will be a starter home for us.  It will meet the criteria that if we get stuck there we won't be dreading it every day, but if we can we will move in 10 years or so.  If I was staying in a home forever I would have some concern about resale (aka wouldn't do anything completely insane), but I would make the house my own. 


  • jtmh2012 said:

    kmurphy2131 said:

    It's possible, but it's an area that is known for being starter homes. I'm also concerned about resale at every turn even though we have no intention of leaving, and there is no reason that we would ever move for jobs.  We haven't even bought and allI can think is about resale when I look at something.
    That's not a bad thing.  While it won't guarantee a bad result when you move out, it'll greatly reduce the odds.  Honestly, myself, I'd even be thinking about it for my forever home.  Sure, I'll be dead and won't care, but what about my loved ones who now need to sell my house?
    Interestingly enough, H and I have always gone against the grain on this.  When we first decided to change our tiny 3-bedrooms into 2 less tiny bedrooms, our realtor was appalled.  She told us over and over how much value we were going to lose by getting rid of a bedroom.  Thing is, we do plan on staying in this house until retirement at least, and the 2 rooms makes the most sense for our lifestyle.  We've always thought in these terms when it comes to all of our projects--we want it to be the most comfortable house FOR US while we are living in it, and resale value is a distant thought.  I know that's completely unconventional, but we're okay with that.  It doesn't hurt that we bought when the market was really low, so we are practically guaranteed a decent profit regardless of when/if we sell and what we do to the house.

    Actually, I totally agree with you.  For a forever home or a home people plan to stay in for the long haul, make the house what is most advantageous for your lifestyle, even if its not what "the market" would most want.

  • I like the plans.  It sounds like it will be most functional for you, your H, and future kids while you all are living in the house.

    For future resale, I'd think people buying the home just for themselves would also appreciate what you all are doing better than what is there now.  However, if someone wanted to turn it back into a rental, it sounds like that would be fairly easy also.  Especially if you all don't mess with the rough-ins for plumbing or electricity.

    I've installed a new kitchen for a rental twice.  Both times the rough-ins were already there.  In the present market, it costs about $3K (labor and supplies) and takes one week, tops.  It shouldn't be a deterant (sp?) for either a real estate investor or someone who just wants to earn side income renting out part of their house.  Especially since it sounds like the kitchenette cabinetry would need to be replaced anyway to attract a tenant. 

  • The biggest things you should worry about with resale are things you can't change.... ie power lines (those personally don't bother me but they bother a lot of people), backing up or on a busy street, being under the airport flight pattern, etc.  Just about everything else is fixable, or you'll still find buyers willing to deal with it (ie stuff like a townhome without a half bath on the main level, or no master bath).  
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards