Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Insurance

I have a question about Deductables on Car Insurance, If I have a deductable of 1000.00, and something happened to my car that I needed to repair but the damage is not close to 1000.00, would I still have to pay the 1000.00 deductable? 

Re: Insurance

  • emily1004emily1004 member
    Eighth Anniversary 500 Comments 100 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited March 2016

    Auto Insurance is different by state.

    If the repairs are under $1000.00, then don't even bother making the claim on your insurance. Just pay for the damage. If it was the other drivers fault, sometimes you can get them to pay for it. While Michigan is a No-Fault state, there is a mini tort law. It basely explains that if someone else is at fault, you can get their insurance to pay your deductible.

    Not knowing what state you are in, this is very vague information.

  • vlagrl29vlagrl29 member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited March 2016
    ditto if the repairs are less than your claim - don't file a claim.  If the accident is the drivers fault then they pay for the damage, but if its your fault then just don't file the claim on your insurance if it doesn't meet 1k.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • short+sassyshort+sassy member
    2500 Comments 500 Love Its Fourth Anniversary Name Dropper
    edited March 2016

    If the damage is the other driver's fault, than their insurance will cover all of it.  Of course, you might have to wait a few months before the other company coughs it up.

    And, to me, (the above) is also important.  My car was totaled by another driver two years ago.  There was no question whatsoever that the accident was her fault.  Yet, it took her insurance company over THREE months to pay for the damages to my car.  My deductible was $100.  Fortunately, I had comprehensive insurance.  My insurance immediately paid me out for my car...minus the $100 deductible.  Of course, I eventually got my deductible back.  But, by the time that happened, it was four months later.  So, thank goodness it was only $100 instead of $500 or $1,000, because I needed to go buy a new car almost immediately. 

    And yes, if the accident is your fault and/or the other driver is uninsured, you're responsible for the first $1,000 of repairs.  So if its a minor accident and the fender just needs to be replaced for $500, you'll have to pay for that anyway.

    Especially if coming up with the first $1,000 of repairs would be a hardship for you, I'd look into changing your insurance to lower the deductible.  It's usually a pretty negligible amount.  I live in an area with VERY high car insurance rates.  Yet, even for me, the difference between a $1,000 deductible and a $100 deductible is about $12/month.  Even lowering it from $1,000 to $500 would probably only cost you a few extra dollars a month. 

  • Yup, sadly we are going through this right now.  Our deductible is $500.  H got his window smashed last weekend (at the farmers' market of all places!) and our state does not have free auto glass replacement, so we are paying out of pocket for the repair ($312).  It took H a while to understand why we had to do this way.  Even though it wasn't our fault, we would lose our "no incident" discount if we filed, risk our rates going up even higher (15% a year is standard in our state), and gain nothing from it.  
  • Yup, sadly we are going through this right now.  Our deductible is $500.  H got his window smashed last weekend (at the farmers' market of all places!) and our state does not have free auto glass replacement, so we are paying out of pocket for the repair ($312).  It took H a while to understand why we had to do this way.  Even though it wasn't our fault, we would lose our "no incident" discount if we filed, risk our rates going up even higher (15% a year is standard in our state), and gain nothing from it.  

    SITB
    Ooooohhhh...is that a state thing?  Because I've always heard the general "oh well you're auto insurance company should always cover a windshield replacement without having to pay your deductible"...to which I've been like, "Umm...I don't know where these companies are.  I've NEVER had insurance that does that, lol."  However, at least with my company Progressive, they don't count just a broken windshield as any kind of incident and it wouldn't be counted against me. 

    Here's another little tidbit I learned from when my car got totaled.  28 states require insurance companies to include SALES TAX in the payout when a car is totaled.  But, of course, I live in a state that falls in the minority and they don't.  However, with all that said, if it is the other person's fault...sales tax is a valid claim to make against their insurance and/or will almost always be awarded in small claims court (if it comes to that). 
  • I think it must be a state thing, @short+sassy.  In MA, it is required that free auto glass replacement be offered.  I think they don't want people procrastinating getting their windshields fixed.  Apparently in RI many policies don't count auto glass towards the deductible, but ours does.  Maybe if we caught the guy we could make a claim against him somehow, but there seems to be little chance of that happening.  The goods he stole were promptly posted on Craigslist, and the police officers refused to do anything about it, even though we have serial numbers on record to prove our ownership.  Anyway....

    OP, I agree that I'd get your deductible lowered a bit, unless you're seeing major savings and/or have huge cash reserves on hand.  
  • I think it must be a state thing, @short+sassy.  In MA, it is required that free auto glass replacement be offered.  I think they don't want people procrastinating getting their windshields fixed.  Apparently in RI many policies don't count auto glass towards the deductible, but ours does.  Maybe if we caught the guy we could make a claim against him somehow, but there seems to be little chance of that happening.  The goods he stole were promptly posted on Craigslist, and the police officers refused to do anything about it, even though we have serial numbers on record to prove our ownership.  Anyway....

    OP, I agree that I'd get your deductible lowered a bit, unless you're seeing major savings and/or have huge cash reserves on hand.

    SITB
    Sorry to hear that!  It's such an upsetting thing to have happen anyway and then to not have anyone do anything about it.

    My H had an odd thing happen a few months ago.  I wasn't home, but a police officer with another man knocked on our door and my H answered.  The guy's bike had been stolen and he thought my H's bike, which was chained to our porch, was his.  Fortunately, my H had the receipt handy and showed it to the officer, so that pretty much ended things right there. 
  • I think it must be a state thing, @short+sassy.  In MA, it is required that free auto glass replacement be offered.  I think they don't want people procrastinating getting their windshields fixed.  Apparently in RI many policies don't count auto glass towards the deductible, but ours does.  Maybe if we caught the guy we could make a claim against him somehow, but there seems to be little chance of that happening.  The goods he stole were promptly posted on Craigslist, and the police officers refused to do anything about it, even though we have serial numbers on record to prove our ownership.  Anyway....

    OP, I agree that I'd get your deductible lowered a bit, unless you're seeing major savings and/or have huge cash reserves on hand.

    SITB
    Sorry to hear that!  It's such an upsetting thing to have happen anyway and then to not have anyone do anything about it.

    My H had an odd thing happen a few months ago.  I wasn't home, but a police officer with another man knocked on our door and my H answered.  The guy's bike had been stolen and he thought my H's bike, which was chained to our porch, was his.  Fortunately, my H had the receipt handy and showed it to the officer, so that pretty much ended things right there. 

    Yikes! That's great that he had the receipt. I'm not sure it would occur to me to hold on to something like that.
  • jtmh2012jtmh2012 mod
    Moderator Eighth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its
    edited March 2016

    Ooooohhhh...is that a state thing?  Because I've always heard the general "oh well you're auto insurance company should always cover a windshield replacement without having to pay your deductible"...to which I've been like, "Umm...I don't know where these companies are.  I've NEVER had insurance that does that, lol."  However, at least with my company Progressive, they don't count just a broken windshield as any kind of incident and it wouldn't be counted against me.
    We've got state farm in Virginia and they include broken windshields under their comprehensive policies.  And doesn't count against you claim wise.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards