Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Cover your plate

So since this is a money page I wanted to here what you all have to say about this. I read a post on facebook from The Knot about "covering your plate" with the amount of your cash gift when going to a wedding. Some people who posted said that they had never heard of this. Others said it's rude not to give the couple a gift that is equal to or more then what they spent per plate to host you. One person even went so far to say that if you can't afford to "cover your plate" that you should decline the invite to the wedding.

My opinion is that if you can't afford a wedding without having to worry about people covering their plate expense, you shouldn't have planned a wedding of that cost. If I'm invited to a wedding, my gift will be what I can afford from my budget. I do leave so much aside each month for birthday, Christmas & misc. gifts, but don't plan to clear it out for any one gift. And maybe I'm in the wrong, but I don't believe in messing up my budget & not being able to pay for something else just to give someone a gift.

What are your thoughts? Have you heard of wedding guests "covering their plates" and what if the guest can't afford that?

Re: Cover your plate

  • I have heard of this, but I don't feel like it's a hard and fast rule. We usually try to do it when we are invited, but it all depends on where they are having it too. It hasn't happened but if it does where a friend hosts at a country club or something that you know is $50/ plate we wouldn't be able to do that. I would go anyways because they decide what type of venue they want. When we were planning our wedding, I never considered or expected people to 'cover their plate'. Gifts are just that, a gift. I'm sure there are people at our wedding who weren't able to do a gift or just did a card. There is nothing wrong with that. So I guess I see both sides, but I don't think weddings are planned (at least I hope not) on the fact that well, we are going to receive X from our guests, so we can afford y because of that!
    image
  • DH and I always give $200 for weddings- it's just been our standard for a while now. I think the most # of weddings we went to in 1 year was 4 and there's really only 1 wedding that I can think of that our $200 may not have covered our plates or came very close to it (my previous boss' wedding). Like you said, if someone is that worried about guests covering their plates, then maybe they should elope or have something much smaller. 
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • I've heard of this, but I think it's ridiculous.  Just because a bride and groom decides to have a high end wedding, that doesn't mean their guests should automatically gift based on what they spent, especially since that could be out of the budget for many people based on how much some weddings cost these days.  Plus, sometimes you never know how much something really costs, so how are you supposed to know what amount "covering your plate" actually is?

    And, just because they spent a lot doesn't mean it was a good meal.  In fact, some of the worst wedding meals I've had were at expensive venues where I'm sure they paid a large amount.

    As with everything else, spend what you can afford on a gift.  And, if you can't afford a gift, a nice card will do just fine.
  • als1982als1982 member
    1000 Comments 500 Love Its Third Anniversary Name Dropper
    edited April 2016
    I think it's absolutely rediculous. A gift is never required of a wedding guest. We spent right at $200 per person, and I never in a million years would have expected or wanted people to spend that much on us. On average, we spend about $50 on wedding gifts, maybe even less if we gave a shower gift. The growing entitlement of brides and people in general is just amazing and abhorrent to me. 

    ETA: I also think this is a very regional thing, not something you'd hear in the heartland as much as you might in the upper northeast.
    HeartlandHustle | Personal Finance and Betterment Blog  
  • I've heard of this. I think it's most common in New England, and much of the rest of the country doesn't follow it.

    I agree that you should get something you can afford.  There doesn't need to be an even exchange, and besides... how would you even know exactly what it costs?

    After TK I concluded that gift giving varies a lot by region and by social group.  In the south physical gifts are still very much the thing to give.  Hardly anybody gives cash or gift cards.  Honeymoon registries also don't go over too well down here because people don't know what they are.  I remember people on TK talking about gifts and being like, "Well just use the cash you get to book a trip later if you can't afford it now."  And also some people who insisted that they would get enough cash back from guests to cover things like the bar tab at the wedding.  

    H and I had around 300 people attend our wedding, and we received less than $400 in cash.  But we received every single piece of fine china we registered for (even the coffee pot and soup bowls), all of our crystal and serving items, and most of our silver.  

    So I think the other silly thing about the "cover your plate" idea is that people getting married might overextend themselves and book things they can't afford because they think guests will give them cash back in that amount.  Nope, not always.  Even if we had returned all of our gifts, store credit at Macy's isn't going to pay the bar tab.


    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • cbee817cbee817 member
    Ancient Membership 250 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    edited April 2016
    hoffse said:
    I've heard of this. I think it's most common in New England, and much of the rest of the country doesn't follow it.

    I agree that you should get something you can afford.  There doesn't need to be an even exchange, and besides... how would you even know exactly what it costs?

    After TK I concluded that gift giving varies a lot by region and by social group.  In the south physical gifts are still very much the thing to give.  Hardly anybody gives cash or gift cards.  Honeymoon registries also don't go over too well down here because people don't know what they are.  I remember people on TK talking about gifts and being like, "Well just use the cash you get to book a trip later if you can't afford it now."  And also some people who insisted that they would get enough cash back from guests to cover things like the bar tab at the wedding.  

    H and I had around 300 people attend our wedding, and we received less than $400 in cash.  But we received every single piece of fine china we registered for (even the coffee pot and soup bowls), all of our crystal and serving items, and most of our silver.  

    So I think the other silly thing about the "cover your plate" idea is that people getting married might overextend themselves and book things they can't afford because they think guests will give them cash back in that amount.  Nope, not always.  Even if we had returned all of our gifts, store credit at Macy's isn't going to pay the bar tab.


    That is crazy! We had 80 people and got over $8,000 for our wedding almost 10 years ago. I didn't have a shower (already owned a condo) so we didn't have a registry.. for us, the cash helped out a lot and we didn't want china or crystal or anything like that. After DH's grandpa passed away, we did get his grandmother's china set that I absolutely love and we use it every Thanksgiving and holiday we host at our house. DH's mom is always so happy when she sees it on our table and is so glad that we use it. Like you said, it definitely depends on what area of the US you live in. 
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • cbee817 said:
    That is crazy! We had 80 people and got over $8,000 for our wedding almost 10 years ago. I didn't have a shower (already owned a condo) so we didn't have a registry.. for us, the cash helped out a lot and we didn't want china or crystal or anything like that. Like you said, it definitely depends on what area of the US you live in. 
    Yeah, I will admit that ours is a pretty extreme example, but that's what happened.  Totally fine of course - we had several large registries because we were not established, having just come out of law school.  Everything we had before the wedding was mismatched and old hand-me-downs, so we were thrilled to have our registries mostly bought out.  We really needed some of everything, and we got set up with some very high quality items.  I debated the china thing, but I actually do use our formal stuff when people come over and for special occasions.  I'm glad we have it, and I made sure that our other serving pieces blend well with both our formal and everyday so we weren't storing two completely different sets of stuff. 

    But yeah, the thousands of dollars in cash thing definitely did NOT happen for us.  If we had relied on it when planning the wedding (or honeymoon) we would have been toast.

    There are no hard and fast rules, and people need to be appreciative of whatever they receive.  Also, couples need to take a step back and realize that the gift is entirely at the discretion of the guest, both the kind of gift and the value of it.  Whatever the guest wants to give is what that couple will receive.  We had a few people go off-registry, and they were some of our best gifts.  H's uncle restored an antique anniversary clock for us.  We wind it on our anniversary every year.  My parents got us a beautiful Lladro wedding figurine.  Those gifts were even better than what we picked out for ourselves.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I'd never heard of it until I started on TheKnot.  We got some cash for the wedding.  Most of it as a wedding gift from my parents and my brother.

    I think the other thing to remember is that TK and sites like it exist to perpetuate the big wedding business and they do that by trying to convince everything guests and the couple alike to spend more and more money.

    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • emily1004emily1004 member
    Eighth Anniversary 500 Comments 100 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited April 2016
    Erikan73 said:

    My opinion is that if you can't afford a wedding without having to worry about people covering their plate expense, you shouldn't have planned a wedding of that cost.

    SITB

    I don't think it has anything to do with the couple having to cover the expenses. At that point the wedding is already paid for. IMHO I think it is a good rule of thumb, as for etiquette of "wedding gift giving". If I'm going to a friend or families wedding, the reception part is for me and the other guests. If I'm going to eat their food, drink their drinks, use their photo booth, etc., I feel I owe it to them to give them a nice gift, not just in return, but to help celebrate the couples life together. For example, if the couple is having a destination wedding and I can pay for the trip, but I can't afford to give them a nice gift, then yeah, I will send my regrets.

    Edit: Even when I send my regrets, I still send a gift.

  • emily1004 said:

    Edit: Even when I send my regrets, I still send a gift.

    I do this too.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I am in the northeast and at least in my area the norm is a physical gift off of the registry for the shower and a cash gift at the wedding.  We haven't been to a wedding in a few years but we used to spend $50 on the wedding gift plus $25 on a shower gift.  Close family was $100 on the wedding gift and $50 on a shower gift.

    I could definitely not afford that with our current financial situation so I'm not sure what I would be able to give.  If it was hinted at that guests should cover their plate I would happily RSVP "no".  
  • give a gift if you can afford it - if not just get a card - why does it have to be so complicated?
  • vlagrl35 said:
    give a gift if you can afford it - if not just get a card - why does it have to be so complicated?
    Amen!  I live in New England, and most weddings I attend are either in Boston suburbs or semi-destination weddings in VT and NH.  I don't know of anyone who takes "cover your plate" seriously, and I don't either.  My gifts are more based on how close I am to the couple.  A work friends' wedding where we need to get two nights of hotel, the gift might only be $60.  Meanwhile, for my best friend's shower I'm toying with getting her a $120 knife she registered for because I LOVE fancy kitchen gadgets and her mom shut me out of helping with the shower (which I'd offered to host) so that freed up some money I would have spent otherwise.  

    I just don't waste time worrying about this.  We got gifts of all size for our wedding, plus a few card-onlies, and it was all good.  I prefer to give physical gifts unless I really drop the ball on getting to the registry early, only because it's more fun for me and I find shuffling money around between same-age peers to feel a little silly.  I did give cash at the one wedding I went to where the couple was much younger.  
  • vlagrl35 said:
    give a gift if you can afford it - if not just get a card - why does it have to be so complicated?
    Amen!  I live in New England, and most weddings I attend are either in Boston suburbs or semi-destination weddings in VT and NH.  I don't know of anyone who takes "cover your plate" seriously, and I don't either.  My gifts are more based on how close I am to the couple.  A work friends' wedding where we need to get two nights of hotel, the gift might only be $60.  Meanwhile, for my best friend's shower I'm toying with getting her a $120 knife she registered for because I LOVE fancy kitchen gadgets and her mom shut me out of helping with the shower (which I'd offered to host) so that freed up some money I would have spent otherwise.  

    I just don't waste time worrying about this.  We got gifts of all size for our wedding, plus a few card-onlies, and it was all good.  I prefer to give physical gifts unless I really drop the ball on getting to the registry early, only because it's more fun for me and I find shuffling money around between same-age peers to feel a little silly.  I did give cash at the one wedding I went to where the couple was much younger.  
    what should be important is that your friends are there supporting your marriage - not the size of gift you get - its just ridiculous to me and I don't have the patience for it LOL
  • csuavecsuave member
    Seventh Anniversary 500 Comments 250 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited April 2016
    I have heard of this but I think it is very confusing advice and not necessarily good advice.  How do you even know how much a plate costs?

    But in a way I kind of think it is how I arrived at my standard gift giving amount.  You see my mom is a very traditional kind of person and concerned with having good manners and etiquette.  I believe when I was a kid I heard mom and dad talking about how much to give for a wedding gift and what it would cost per plate.  I'm pretty sure covering the plate figured into the equation of how they do wedding gifting.

    A lot of people will say "give what you can afford."  This is great advice and I agree with it but for some people it doesn't really answer the question of how much to give.  I, like my mom, want to just set a flat amount and have it as my wedding gift standard.  I want it to be affordable but also a nice and appropriate gift.  When I became old enough to give my own wedding gifts I asked my mom how much was appropriate and took her advice which may have been in some way informed by cost per plate.  Ergo, my set amount may have some roots in cover your plate but more importantly is an affordable amount and an amount I feel happy with giving for a wedding gift.

    For anyone that is interested in the statistics, my standard amount was $50.  DH had the same standard when I married him so now we are $100 as a couple.  We got nearly all cash gifts in a wide range of amounts but the most frequently occurring amount was $50 per single or $100 per couple....same as what we do.  Our pricing per person had some other things included so hard to say how much the cost per plate for the dinner was, but I think it was not too far off from $50 per person for food and drinks. 
  • I've also heard of the "cover your plate" idea, though more from the side of a guest feeling that is what they should do, rather than the bridal couple (thank goodness).  But it is kind of silly.  As some others pointed, the dollar amount for "covering your plate", would only be a rough guess at best.

    I personally don't even think about or try to guess how much my "plate" will be.  Depending on my budget, I generally give $50-$100 in cash/gifts for close friends and family members.  $25-$50 for everyone else.

    And yes, time and time again I've seen stories on TK where a couple is having a wedding they can't afford or are really struggling to afford.  It's just not necessary and I don't understand why people do that.  I think the wedding industry is just so pervasive in our society that people get these ideas that weddings are "supposed" to be like "this" and must include "x,y,z".  And then it starts snowballing and getting complicated.

    When, really, a couple just needs to host their guests appropriately.  Like someone would do for any party.  If that means they need to invite fewer guests to accomplish that.  Great.  Or invite a lot of guests, but to something more casual like a backyard BBQ, than that's great too.  But people have this vision that their reception needs to be at night, with a DJ and dancing.  Towering multi-tier cake, flowers everywhere, centerpieces, and favors.  And they have to invite all their second cousins who they haven't seen since they were 5.  Then wonder and stress how they will ever afford all of it.

    Not knocking a traditional, larger wedding!  But, if that is what a couple wants and can't afford it, than they just need to save for it and wait longer to get married.  Another valid choice.    

  • I've also heard of the "cover your plate" idea, though more from the side of a guest feeling that is what they should do, rather than the bridal couple (thank goodness).  But it is kind of silly.  As some others pointed, the dollar amount for "covering your plate", would only be a rough guess at best.

    I personally don't even think about or try to guess how much my "plate" will be.  Depending on my budget, I generally give $50-$100 in cash/gifts for close friends and family members.  $25-$50 for everyone else.

    And yes, time and time again I've seen stories on TK where a couple is having a wedding they can't afford or are really struggling to afford.  It's just not necessary and I don't understand why people do that.  I think the wedding industry is just so pervasive in our society that people get these ideas that weddings are "supposed" to be like "this" and must include "x,y,z".  And then it starts snowballing and getting complicated.

    When, really, a couple just needs to host their guests appropriately.  Like someone would do for any party.  If that means they need to invite fewer guests to accomplish that.  Great.  Or invite a lot of guests, but to something more casual like a backyard BBQ, than that's great too.  But people have this vision that their reception needs to be at night, with a DJ and dancing.  Towering multi-tier cake, flowers everywhere, centerpieces, and favors.  And they have to invite all their second cousins who they haven't seen since they were 5.  Then wonder and stress how they will ever afford all of it.

    Not knocking a traditional, larger wedding!  But, if that is what a couple wants and can't afford it, than they just need to save for it and wait longer to get married.  Another valid choice.    

    Agree with all of this.  A wedding doesn't have to be any kind of certain way.  It irks me when people think going to the JP and then out for a meal with say 5 people after isn't a "real wedding and reception."  If the bride and groom choose something small people shouldn't have anything to say about it other than congratulations.
  • I've also heard of the "cover your plate" idea, though more from the side of a guest feeling that is what they should do, rather than the bridal couple (thank goodness).  But it is kind of silly.  As some others pointed, the dollar amount for "covering your plate", would only be a rough guess at best.

    I personally don't even think about or try to guess how much my "plate" will be.  Depending on my budget, I generally give $50-$100 in cash/gifts for close friends and family members.  $25-$50 for everyone else.

    And yes, time and time again I've seen stories on TK where a couple is having a wedding they can't afford or are really struggling to afford.  It's just not necessary and I don't understand why people do that.  I think the wedding industry is just so pervasive in our society that people get these ideas that weddings are "supposed" to be like "this" and must include "x,y,z".  And then it starts snowballing and getting complicated.

    When, really, a couple just needs to host their guests appropriately.  Like someone would do for any party.  If that means they need to invite fewer guests to accomplish that.  Great.  Or invite a lot of guests, but to something more casual like a backyard BBQ, than that's great too.  But people have this vision that their reception needs to be at night, with a DJ and dancing.  Towering multi-tier cake, flowers everywhere, centerpieces, and favors.  And they have to invite all their second cousins who they haven't seen since they were 5.  Then wonder and stress how they will ever afford all of it.

    Not knocking a traditional, larger wedding!  But, if that is what a couple wants and can't afford it, than they just need to save for it and wait longer to get married.  Another valid choice.    

    Bolded. I agree. This is the first time in my life - I'm 34 - I'm hearing of a "cover your plate" concept. While I'm 34, my family, all over the nation has never ever spoken of this either. Totally new concept to me.

    A gift is a gift. It's not pay back!!! I completely think this is weird and rude (if a couple expects people to do this). If people just do it as their own self-imposed obligation, that's fine. But, a wedding reception is simply a party to celebrate the union. It' snot mandatory. Therefore, if a couple and/or their family has a reception/party, then the guests should be FREE TO BE GUESTS!!! Otherwise, they seem more like customers at a restaurant.

  • We had about 250 people at our wedding (big families). We received a lot of money but physical gifts too. H and I never asked or assumed our parents would put anything towards our wedding. We set a budget. Our parents did offer to cover a few things but we covered at least 80% off our wedding. We also planned a honeymoon that we could afford. We invited people that we wanted to share in our day with, not because of what they might gift us. I don't pick my friends based on their income. Cover your plate is fine if people want to gift that way but I don't think a bride and groom should expect that!
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers
  • I've heard of this, but always as a guideline for guests, never as an expectation of the bride and groom. We have a set amount that we give to family, and a set amount for everyone other than family. We had zero expectations at our wedding. We paid for everything ourselves and we paid upfront. We didn't go on a honeymoon, but we certainly wouldn't have if we could afford it. I wouldn't want to count on gifts as a means to afford anything.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards