Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

regifting

What are your thoughts on regifting?  Do you do it?  Has someone done it to you?

Re: regifting

  • I'm somewhat confident that a couple of wedding gifts we received were regifts. I ended up donating them because they were picture frames, the people who gifted them didn't live locally, and they just didn't fit in with my home.

    I've regifted a couple of random things for White Elephant exchanges that are meant to be a bit on the silly/tacky side as well. But I don't make it a regular habit and I don't think I'd ever regift something for say a wedding or baby shower or a Christmas gift for a friend or family member.
  • I think I may have once but I felt guilty because if I obviously thought it was a "good gift" I wouldn't have given it away. I see no harm in it though as long as you do it cautiously...
  • I can't think of a time when I have done it, but see no objection as long as it's something that is a good fit for the recipient, like a nice item that just doesn't match your home. 
  • I am all for it! If I get something I can't use but know someone else will like it then off it goes to a new home. If I don't know anyone that would like it I donate it. I actually got a gift for Christmas that I regifted at a Hannukah party the next day....

    I also have no problem receiving used gifts. My husband bought me a tablet for Christmas and he knows the functionality I wanted and got a great deal on a refurbished model (it looks pristine). Honestly if I would buy it used for myself why would I expect someone else to pay full price?


  • I think regifting is nice when it puts a gift with an owner that can truly appreciate or use the gift. 

    I'm not so much of a fan of regifting when it is a person giving a gift for a gift giving occasion and trying to pass it off as something they thoughtfully picked out for the giftee...but even then I'm not overly critical of it.

    Things I have regifted in the past:
    -BIL gave me a movie theater gift card for my birthday the other year....for a movie theater that is not in my region.  Best friend in another state has this theater so I told her on the phone that a gift card was coming her way courtesy of BIL's good intentions and that I hoped she could use it so it wouldn't go to waste.
    -H and I had coasters coming out of our ears after we got married.  There was one set I couldn't return to a store (I expect they came from a craft fair) so I took them to a Christmas party that Dec to be used in a bring a $10 gift for a gift exchange game
    -Someone gave me a griddle at a wedding shower that I didn't have a gift receipt for and didn't intend to use so it just got put in a kitchen cabinet.  Half a year later FIL was saying he could use a griddle.  I was like we have one we haven't used yet, it is yours if you want it.
    -We have used good quality wine and chocolates received as gifts to give to other people as hostess gifts
    -I had gotten a good quality rice steamer for free by collecting points...but I didn't need a rice steamer so I never used it.  Fast forward to a wedding shower my friend was throwing for her future DIL.  I was invited but didn't want to attend so I declined.  Normally I wouldn't send a gift in this situation but I noticed they had a rice steamer on their registry so I decided to send the one I had.

    Instances where I know I was given a regift:
    -My aunt was in the services business before she retired and sometimes instead or or in addition to an extra cash tip she would get little gifts like chocolates, hand towels, house decor.  She would give the things she thought I might like to me.
    -H and I got a wedding gift from a friend that consisted of cash, a blanket and an empty beer growler with a certificate for a fill.  The certificate had an older issue date on it so we know friend didn't buy it specifically for our wedding gift.  He doesn't drink beer but H and I enthusiastically do so I think he included it in our gift because he thought H and I would enjoy it, which I thought was nice.  The blanket was kind of random but contributed to this gift being the one we got that was kind of "off beat" and that made it fun and memorable.


  • I cautiously regift.  Making sure it doesn't go back to the giver or to someone where the giver would be able to go "I gave so and so one just like that...."
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • I'm all about the regift.  I hate waste and I hate clutter, so if I know someone else would like something that I don't need or want, I have no hesitation.  I also wouldn't be offended if anyone regifted something that they received from me.  It would pain me more to have my money go to complete waste.
    HeartlandHustle | Personal Finance and Betterment Blog  
  • A relevant recent SNL sketch about the bad kind of regifting-I promise it's funny. 

    https://www.nbc.com/saturday-night-live/video/the-christmas-candle/3435359?snl=1
  • I can't think of anything that I have regifted per se, but if I think someone can use or want something that I won't use or don't want, I will ask if he/she wants it. Not in a gift giving situation, but just to offer it. 
  • A relevant recent SNL sketch about the bad kind of regifting-I promise it's funny. 

    https://www.nbc.com/saturday-night-live/video/the-christmas-candle/3435359?snl=1
    And now I have the candle song stuck in my head!
  • I'm genuinely curious - I get that some people don't like regifting used items for gift-giving occasions, but if you had a NEW item that you didn't want/couldn't use and knew of someone who would appreciate it why wouldn't some of you give it to them at a regular gift giving occasion? 
  • If there were no holidays coming up, I would just see if there was anyone that wanted it. We don't buy many gifts for anyone in general, so if all else fails, then craigslist or consignment depending on the item
  • csuavecsuave member
    Seventh Anniversary 500 Comments 250 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited December 2016
    I'm genuinely curious - I get that some people don't like regifting used items for gift-giving occasions, but if you had a NEW item that you didn't want/couldn't use and knew of someone who would appreciate it why wouldn't some of you give it to them at a regular gift giving occasion? 
    Because of guilt.  We were invited to dinner at our friends' house and took a bottle of wine from our supply.  It was a Malbec that was gifted to us and Malbec is not my favorite so I kind of wanted to get rid of it.  My friend was all "thank you, so nice of you to pick this out.  Is it a kind that you like?"  And then I kind of had to lie and mumble something which made me uncomfortable and guilty that no I hadn't picked that bottle out for them I was just trying to unload it. 
    I knew they liked wine, wasn't sure about Malbec so I don't know if that counts as knowing that they would appreciate it. But now I feel to guilty to try and regift anything to them again (which would only be as a hostess occasion since we don't exchange gifts otherwise). 
  • csuave said:
    I'm genuinely curious - I get that some people don't like regifting used items for gift-giving occasions, but if you had a NEW item that you didn't want/couldn't use and knew of someone who would appreciate it why wouldn't some of you give it to them at a regular gift giving occasion? 
    Because of guilt.  We were invited to dinner at our friends' house and took a bottle of wine from our supply.  It was a Malbec that was gifted to us and Malbec is not my favorite so I kind of wanted to get rid of it.  My friend was all "thank you, so nice of you to pick this out.  Is it a kind that you like?"  And then I kind of had to lie and mumble something which made me uncomfortable and guilty that no I hadn't picked that bottle out for them I was just trying to unload it. 
    I knew they liked wine, wasn't sure about Malbec so I don't know if that counts as knowing that they would appreciate it. But now I feel to guilty to try and regift anything to them again (which would only be as a hostess occasion since we don't exchange gifts otherwise). 
    At least in the case of wine you could always say you've never tried it, but that the wine store suggested it.  the only down side is you may end up drinking part of it....
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • I'm genuinely curious - I get that some people don't like regifting used items for gift-giving occasions, but if you had a NEW item that you didn't want/couldn't use and knew of someone who would appreciate it why wouldn't some of you give it to them at a regular gift giving occasion? 

    Probably because it means holding on to something for an indefinite period of time while I try to find the "right" person to regift it to. I'd rather just unload it quickly in some other way.

    To me, regifting is very very different from offering something at random to a friend or family member in a "We don't need this and thought you'd like it" kind of situation versus a gift-giving occasion...or passing along a giftcard you can't/won't use to someone who can.
  • jtmh2012 said:
    csuave said:
    I'm genuinely curious - I get that some people don't like regifting used items for gift-giving occasions, but if you had a NEW item that you didn't want/couldn't use and knew of someone who would appreciate it why wouldn't some of you give it to them at a regular gift giving occasion? 
    Because of guilt.  We were invited to dinner at our friends' house and took a bottle of wine from our supply.  It was a Malbec that was gifted to us and Malbec is not my favorite so I kind of wanted to get rid of it.  My friend was all "thank you, so nice of you to pick this out.  Is it a kind that you like?"  And then I kind of had to lie and mumble something which made me uncomfortable and guilty that no I hadn't picked that bottle out for them I was just trying to unload it. 
    I knew they liked wine, wasn't sure about Malbec so I don't know if that counts as knowing that they would appreciate it. But now I feel to guilty to try and regift anything to them again (which would only be as a hostess occasion since we don't exchange gifts otherwise). 
    At least in the case of wine you could always say you've never tried it, but that the wine store suggested it.  the only down side is you may end up drinking part of it....
    Yes, true.  But I feel so guilty lying.  I'm just not used to it and I freeze up in those situations.
    My first Christmas with my ILs my MIL's sister sent gifts to their house for us.  For me she bought a necklace.  As I was opening it MIL was like she wasn't sure what you like or what to get you.  You like jewelry, right?  Well....I actually don't like jewelry and never wear it so I just pretended like I didn't hear MIL and didn't answer her question.  It was so awkward.  It would have been much easier for me to be like yeah, sure.  But I hate lying!  I need to get over it so I quit being so awkward when receiving gifts.
  • als1982 said:
    I'm all about the regift.  I hate waste and I hate clutter, so if I know someone else would like something that I don't need or want, I have no hesitation.  I also wouldn't be offended if anyone regifted something that they received from me.  It would pain me more to have my money go to complete waste.
    Not quite a regift but my cousin couldn't make it to our wedding.  Our favor was homemade wine.  My aunt and uncle (her parents) don't drink so they gave their bottle to cousin.  Cousin emailed me that she drank it and loved it.  That email made my day knowing that the wine was enjoyed rather than tossed or sitting on a shelf and that she got a little "taste" of our wedding even though she couldn't attend.
  • labro said:
    I'm genuinely curious - I get that some people don't like regifting used items for gift-giving occasions, but if you had a NEW item that you didn't want/couldn't use and knew of someone who would appreciate it why wouldn't some of you give it to them at a regular gift giving occasion? 

    Probably because it means holding on to something for an indefinite period of time while I try to find the "right" person to regift it to. I'd rather just unload it quickly in some other way.

    To me, regifting is very very different from offering something at random to a friend or family member in a "We don't need this and thought you'd like it" kind of situation versus a gift-giving occasion...or passing along a giftcard you can't/won't use to someone who can.

    Agreed 100%.  I feel like regifting is a little deceptive - the recipient thinks you spent time/money/energy picking out something just for them, and really you are unloading something you don't care about.  Totally different than if you know your friend is into whatever gift you received and you tell them that you got something you can't use, so do they want it?

    I have never regifted anything.  When we receive food, etc. we can't use then one of us brings it to the office or we donate it to a food bank.  When we receive alcohol we don't drink one of us adds it to our firm's stash - both offices go through a lot of alcohol so that would never be noticed.

    For physical items I donate them if there are no friends/family who want what we received.  And actually, I am weird in that I won't donate gifts in the same city as the person who gave me the gift just in case they see it.  My mom does the same thing - they live in a smallish town, with one salvation army, so when she donates gifts she brings them to Birmingham.  
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • hoffse said:
    labro said:
    I'm genuinely curious - I get that some people don't like regifting used items for gift-giving occasions, but if you had a NEW item that you didn't want/couldn't use and knew of someone who would appreciate it why wouldn't some of you give it to them at a regular gift giving occasion? 

    Probably because it means holding on to something for an indefinite period of time while I try to find the "right" person to regift it to. I'd rather just unload it quickly in some other way.

    To me, regifting is very very different from offering something at random to a friend or family member in a "We don't need this and thought you'd like it" kind of situation versus a gift-giving occasion...or passing along a giftcard you can't/won't use to someone who can.

    Agreed 100%.  I feel like regifting is a little deceptive - the recipient thinks you spent time/money/energy picking out something just for them, and really you are unloading something you don't care about.  Totally different than if you know your friend is into whatever gift you received and you tell them that you got something you can't use, so do they want it?

    I have never regifted anything.  When we receive food, etc. we can't use then one of us brings it to the office or we donate it to a food bank.  When we receive alcohol we don't drink one of us adds it to our firm's stash - both offices go through a lot of alcohol so that would never be noticed.

    For physical items I donate them if there are no friends/family who want what we received.  And actually, I am weird in that I won't donate gifts in the same city as the person who gave me the gift just in case they see it.  My mom does the same thing - they live in a smallish town, with one salvation army, so when she donates gifts she brings them to Birmingham.  
    I think that's where the disconnect may be. I am still thinking of the person when I decide to regift something to them, which to me is more important than how much money I spent on it. I wouldn't get something and think "oh great another scarf.....eh I'll unload it on my MIL since I couldn't think of anything else for her." I only regift something that I would have bought for them in the first place. 
  • hoffse said:
     When we receive alcohol we don't drink one of us adds it to our firm's stash - both offices go through a lot of alcohol so that would never be noticed.
    I think it's funny you have an office stash.  That just wouldn't happen at any of the places I'd work.  Gives the wrong impression.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • jtmh2012 said:
    hoffse said:
     When we receive alcohol we don't drink one of us adds it to our firm's stash - both offices go through a lot of alcohol so that would never be noticed.
    I think it's funny you have an office stash.  That just wouldn't happen at any of the places I'd work.  Gives the wrong impression.
    Both offices have full bars with catering kitchens behind them.  It's really for events throughout the year so that we don't have to rent separate space.  We host a couple events per month, so it definitely gets used.  The firm alcohol stash is not really for us, except during designated events.

    This reminds me of something kind of funny.  One of the partners my H works for actually installed a small catering kitchen in his house.  Basically they took the mudroom between garage and kitchen and converted it to a U-shaped kitchen with warming drawers, a big sink, stainless countertops, etc.  I thought it was crazy until I attended an event there with 50+ people.  As always, people congregated in the main kitchen, but the caterers had their own space where they could work without being disrupted.  It worked so well H and I have jokingly said that we need to do this in our forever house.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • The only time I've ever "re-gifted" something is a bottle of wine to a friend's birthday party.  Someone had brought it for Thanksgiving, and I ran out of time to go buy a bottle before going to the party, so I just brought one I had.  But we're talking a $10 bottle of wine here.  And I noticed the birthday girl already had a bottle of the same kind opened, so at least she likes that kind LOL!
  • I don't even consider wine regifting lol. We have a wine subscription, plus I'll sometimes buy a bottle that looks good at the store, and yet people still bring us wine so I ALWAYS grab from our stash when I'm going to someone's house. I do select a variety I know they like, but I would never remember if I bought it at the store, if it came with the subscription, or if it was a gift. We literally have at least 25 bottles in our house at all times....
  • hoffse said:
    labro said:
    I'm genuinely curious - I get that some people don't like regifting used items for gift-giving occasions, but if you had a NEW item that you didn't want/couldn't use and knew of someone who would appreciate it why wouldn't some of you give it to them at a regular gift giving occasion? 

    Probably because it means holding on to something for an indefinite period of time while I try to find the "right" person to regift it to. I'd rather just unload it quickly in some other way.

    To me, regifting is very very different from offering something at random to a friend or family member in a "We don't need this and thought you'd like it" kind of situation versus a gift-giving occasion...or passing along a giftcard you can't/won't use to someone who can.

    Agreed 100%.  I feel like regifting is a little deceptive - the recipient thinks you spent time/money/energy picking out something just for them, and really you are unloading something you don't care about.  Totally different than if you know your friend is into whatever gift you received and you tell them that you got something you can't use, so do they want it?

    I have never regifted anything.  When we receive food, etc. we can't use then one of us brings it to the office or we donate it to a food bank.  When we receive alcohol we don't drink one of us adds it to our firm's stash - both offices go through a lot of alcohol so that would never be noticed.

    For physical items I donate them if there are no friends/family who want what we received.  And actually, I am weird in that I won't donate gifts in the same city as the person who gave me the gift just in case they see it.  My mom does the same thing - they live in a smallish town, with one salvation army, so when she donates gifts she brings them to Birmingham.  
    I think that's where the disconnect may be. I am still thinking of the person when I decide to regift something to them, which to me is more important than how much money I spent on it. I wouldn't get something and think "oh great another scarf.....eh I'll unload it on my MIL since I couldn't think of anything else for her." I only regift something that I would have bought for them in the first place. 
    This makes sense.  Sometimes you see something in a store (or as you are unwrapping a gift someone gave you) and you think this would be perfect for so and so. 
  • I don't regift.  we got 3 motion activated ornaments from MIL and threw them away - they would not stop!!
  • We do but it's usually "does anyone want this before we donate it?" Not really wrapping it up and giving it to someone.
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Daisypath Anniversary tickers
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards