Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

short term disability

Since I'm checking home insurance rates it got me thinking about short term disability rates.  We've had a policy for a few years now on DH but it never hurts to look around.  What provider do you have yours with if you buy it separately like we do?

Re: short term disability

  • hoffsehoffse member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited January 2017
    We self-insure for STD (bad abbreviation, sorry), but we have a separate policy for LTD.

    Our LTD has a 6 month waiting period, but we have enough assets in Roth accounts to last a couple years without income.  It wouldn't be ideal, but we could survive 6 months no problem, so we don't have a separate STD policy.

    We use Guardian for our LTD.  It's kind of pricey, but I did a lot of research on this before buying the policy, and they get excellent reviews.   Our income is insured up to the legal limit, our policy is portable, and there is a COL adjustment plus retirement contribution protection as part of it.

    I know you guys are self-employed, but for those who are not... when you buy your own disability policy that's unaffiliated with an employer, any money that pays out under the policy is tax-free.  Whereas money paid out from a group disability policy provided through an employer is ordinary income.  This reduces the net amount you can receive under the policy dramatically.

    Something like 25-30% of all workers become permanently disabled before normal retirement age.  And depending on the type of disability it can require a significant outlay of personal resources (more so even than premature death) since it may require long-term care.  H and I figure that our most valuable asset is our ability to produce income, so it should be insured just like all of our other assets.  At some point we will be self-insured for LTD too, but we aren't there yet.

    FYI our LTD policies required a medical exam like you get for life insurance, and they did ask about pregnancy.  I got this policy set up in the fall, when I could honestly say I wasn't pregnant.  I suspect my rates would have been higher if I had been pregnant while going through the exam.

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I have it through my work with Colonial Penn.  I pay $29.43 a paycheck, but it isn't subsidized by my employer at all.  I paid half that at my old company but it was employer subsidized.  Honestly, I'm only planning on keeping it until we have a kid, then I'll probably dump it.  I'm not the main breadwinner and we could survive without my income altogether if we absolutely had to.  
  • yeah this would only be on DH as he's the one making the most money.  He currently has short term.  I think it would be a good idea to look into long term as well.  you never know.
  • I have a STD policy through work, but it is paid post-tax so our benefit is still tax free.  I pay about $20 a month I think for the policy, but I've had it for about 3 years and just used it for the first time for maternity leave.  I came out ahead with what they paid out...

    Once we are done having kids I will probably stop paying for the policy (that is our only way of paid maternity leave longer than 2 weeks).  I work from home on a laptop so it would have to be a very serious illness/accident to make me incapable of doing my job.  Plus we are somewhat self-insured since we can meet our obligations on DH's salary alone and we have a lot of money in ROTHs and non-retirement stocks that we can cash in if we absolutely need to.
    Formerly AprilH81
    photo composite_14153800476219jpg

  • AprilZ81 said:
    I have a STD policy through work, but it is paid post-tax so our benefit is still tax free.  I pay about $20 a month I think for the policy, but I've had it for about 3 years and just used it for the first time for maternity leave.  I came out ahead with what they paid out...
    My work pays for ours, but it's charged as "imputed income".  Supposedly makes the paid benefit should you ever use it tax free.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • julieanne912julieanne912 member
    Fifth Anniversary 500 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    edited January 2017
    Yeah I forgot to say that mine is taken out post-tax too.  

    Honestly if I were self employed and the breadwinner, I would, without a doubt, get long term disability insurance.  You never know what can happen.  My dad was working one day (self employed as a landscaper and also retail at a hardware store), and disabled the next, and then died 3 months later... at the age of 51/52.  You can always apply for SSDI but that's a long process and could take longer than you have savings for, and that money isn't very much even when you do get it.  
  • I would actually look into long term disability over short term.  It's cheaper, and most of the time you can use savings to get you by in a short term but not a long term period.
    We don't have short term on either of us and only long term on my H.  I work at a desk so it would take a lot for me to become permanently disabled.  My H works in a factory and it's physical labor all day.  Even just a sore back affects his work.  So we took the plan his employer offers and have them take the premium out post-tax so the benefits wouldn't be taxed.

    TTC since 1/13  DX:PCOS 5/13 (long, anovulatory cycles)
    Clomid 50mg 9/13 = BFP! EDD 6/7/14 M/C 5w6d Found 11/4/13
    1/14 PCOS / Gluten Free Diet to hopefully regulate my system. 
    Chemical Pregnancy 03/14
    Surprise BFP 6/14, Beta #1: 126 Beta #2: 340  Stick baby, stick! EDD 2/17/15
    Riley Elaine born 2/16/15

    TTC 2.0   6/15 
    Chemical Pregnancy 9/15 
    Chemical Pregnancy 6/16
    BFP 9/16  EDD 6/3/17
    Beta #1: 145 Beta #2: 376 Beta #3: 2,225 Beta #4: 4,548
    www.5yearstonever.blogspot.com 
                        Image and video hosting by TinyPic

  • vlagrl35vlagrl35 member
    500 Comments 100 Love Its First Anniversary Name Dropper
    edited January 2017
    brij2006 said:
    I would actually look into long term disability over short term.  It's cheaper, and most of the time you can use savings to get you by in a short term but not a long term period.
    We don't have short term on either of us and only long term on my H.  I work at a desk so it would take a lot for me to become permanently disabled.  My H works in a factory and it's physical labor all day.  Even just a sore back affects his work.  So we took the plan his employer offers and have them take the premium out post-tax so the benefits wouldn't be taxed.
    but would long term provide us benefits say if DH got in a car accident and was injured and couldn't work for a couple months?  currently we have enough to get us bare bones budget for 3 months but I really would hate to deplete and and be stressed thats why I like short term.
  • vlagrl35 said:
    brij2006 said:
    I would actually look into long term disability over short term.  It's cheaper, and most of the time you can use savings to get you by in a short term but not a long term period.
    We don't have short term on either of us and only long term on my H.  I work at a desk so it would take a lot for me to become permanently disabled.  My H works in a factory and it's physical labor all day.  Even just a sore back affects his work.  So we took the plan his employer offers and have them take the premium out post-tax so the benefits wouldn't be taxed.
    but would long term provide us benefits say if DH got in a car accident and was injured and couldn't work for a couple months?  currently we have enough to get us bare bones budget for 3 months but I really would hate to deplete and and be stressed thats why I like short term.

    No, LTD doesn't kick in until 6 months.
    It's most definitely a personal decision, but I'd personally prioritize LTD over short term. Just because STD stops paying out after only so many weeks (depending on plan).  To where LTD doesn't stop paying out.  With savings you can usually cushion to float for those 6 months, but if he were to be permanently disabled there would need to be a very substantial nest egg to be able to pull from to keep going financially.

    TTC since 1/13  DX:PCOS 5/13 (long, anovulatory cycles)
    Clomid 50mg 9/13 = BFP! EDD 6/7/14 M/C 5w6d Found 11/4/13
    1/14 PCOS / Gluten Free Diet to hopefully regulate my system. 
    Chemical Pregnancy 03/14
    Surprise BFP 6/14, Beta #1: 126 Beta #2: 340  Stick baby, stick! EDD 2/17/15
    Riley Elaine born 2/16/15

    TTC 2.0   6/15 
    Chemical Pregnancy 9/15 
    Chemical Pregnancy 6/16
    BFP 9/16  EDD 6/3/17
    Beta #1: 145 Beta #2: 376 Beta #3: 2,225 Beta #4: 4,548
    www.5yearstonever.blogspot.com 
                        Image and video hosting by TinyPic

  • brij2006 said:
    vlagrl35 said:
    brij2006 said:
    I would actually look into long term disability over short term.  It's cheaper, and most of the time you can use savings to get you by in a short term but not a long term period.
    We don't have short term on either of us and only long term on my H.  I work at a desk so it would take a lot for me to become permanently disabled.  My H works in a factory and it's physical labor all day.  Even just a sore back affects his work.  So we took the plan his employer offers and have them take the premium out post-tax so the benefits wouldn't be taxed.
    but would long term provide us benefits say if DH got in a car accident and was injured and couldn't work for a couple months?  currently we have enough to get us bare bones budget for 3 months but I really would hate to deplete and and be stressed thats why I like short term.

    No, LTD doesn't kick in until 6 months.
    It's most definitely a personal decision, but I'd personally prioritize LTD over short term. Just because STD stops paying out after only so many weeks (depending on plan).  To where LTD doesn't stop paying out.  With savings you can usually cushion to float for those 6 months, but if he were to be permanently disabled there would need to be a very substantial nest egg to be able to pull from to keep going financially.
    This.  6 months is nothing when you are talking about potentially years or decades of unemployment.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • hoffse said:
    brij2006 said:
    vlagrl35 said:
    brij2006 said:
    I would actually look into long term disability over short term.  It's cheaper, and most of the time you can use savings to get you by in a short term but not a long term period.
    We don't have short term on either of us and only long term on my H.  I work at a desk so it would take a lot for me to become permanently disabled.  My H works in a factory and it's physical labor all day.  Even just a sore back affects his work.  So we took the plan his employer offers and have them take the premium out post-tax so the benefits wouldn't be taxed.
    but would long term provide us benefits say if DH got in a car accident and was injured and couldn't work for a couple months?  currently we have enough to get us bare bones budget for 3 months but I really would hate to deplete and and be stressed thats why I like short term.

    No, LTD doesn't kick in until 6 months.
    It's most definitely a personal decision, but I'd personally prioritize LTD over short term. Just because STD stops paying out after only so many weeks (depending on plan).  To where LTD doesn't stop paying out.  With savings you can usually cushion to float for those 6 months, but if he were to be permanently disabled there would need to be a very substantial nest egg to be able to pull from to keep going financially.
    This.  6 months is nothing when you are talking about potentially years or decades of unemployment.
    oh I hear ya which is why I also want to look into long term disability.
  • takmjstakmjs member
    Seventh Anniversary 10 Comments 5 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited January 2017
    Just wanted to mention that some LTD policies may kick in before 6 months. My LTD policy (through work) starts at 60 days. With my first pregnancy, I had bed rest and then a c-section, and I was medically required to be off work for a total of 13 weeks, so I received both short and long term disability pay.

    Something to think about when looking at whether you want/need to get STD is how long you would need to pay your own expenses (if you don't have STD) before LTD kicks in. 60 days vs. 6 months could be a huge difference.
  • I have both STD and LTD provided by my employer.

    Probably something I should look into if/when I become unemployed, but I've always assumed I'd be turned down because of my medical issues.  Still, I guess it doesn't hurt to check.

    Even UE, I do have a significant p/t job that isn't that physically demanding, but does require driving and frequently getting in/out of the car.

  • Very interesting discussion. Are STD and LTD only for employed people? Could a SAHM get it? I don't earn an income but if I became disabled, it would be a big burden for DH with child care and household stuff, he'd likely need to hire help.
  • @MommyLiberty5013 - that I'm not sure of.  The policy we have currently for DH is a one time payout of $60k for an injury that would prevent him of doing his job (photography)
  • Very interesting discussion. Are STD and LTD only for employed people? Could a SAHM get it? I don't earn an income but if I became disabled, it would be a big burden for DH with child care and household stuff, he'd likely need to hire help.
    I think not only because STD and LTD typically pay out a percentage of your income not a predetermined dollar amount. However if you were injured and there was a resulting lawsuit the value of your services and the cost to replace them would be calculated as part of the damages if you were to win (at least in Massachusetts - perhaps other states are different?)
  • Very interesting discussion. Are STD and LTD only for employed people? Could a SAHM get it? I don't earn an income but if I became disabled, it would be a big burden for DH with child care and household stuff, he'd likely need to hire help.
    I think not only because STD and LTD typically pay out a percentage of your income not a predetermined dollar amount. However if you were injured and there was a resulting lawsuit the value of your services and the cost to replace them would be calculated as part of the damages if you were to win (at least in Massachusetts - perhaps other states are different?)

    I've always wondered that also because I know it is based on income.  Or if it works similarly for someone who is self employed.
  • vlagrl35vlagrl35 member
    500 Comments 100 Love Its First Anniversary Name Dropper
    edited January 2017
    Very interesting discussion. Are STD and LTD only for employed people? Could a SAHM get it? I don't earn an income but if I became disabled, it would be a big burden for DH with child care and household stuff, he'd likely need to hire help.
    I think not only because STD and LTD typically pay out a percentage of your income not a predetermined dollar amount. However if you were injured and there was a resulting lawsuit the value of your services and the cost to replace them would be calculated as part of the damages if you were to win (at least in Massachusetts - perhaps other states are different?)

    I've always wondered that also because I know it is based on income.  Or if it works similarly for someone who is self employed.
    Our policy just gives us a flat 60k - its not based on our income.  I decided I would call the broker that provided this policy to us and get some quotes on LTD and go from there as to what we should do.  I don't think we can afford to have short and long.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards