Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Best place to sell....

I have some things I don't want any more. Some of the things are not worth much, like clothes or books. Some things would be worth more, like my wedding dress or bridesmaid dresses. I'd like to make a little money, but I don't know the best way to sell them without spending a huge amount of time. Does anyone have experience selling various things--clothes, books, shoes, wedding/bridesmaid dresses, random household things? eBay (I've seen they have a service where they post and sell things for you, but you obviously make a smaller percentage), local Facebook pages, garage sale? What's been the best method for you if you've sold anything?

Re: Best place to sell....

  • edited January 2017
    Honestly, unless the books or clothing are very unique or hard to find or of a high end name brand your best bet is to Goodwill them and get the tax deduction. Otherwise you're wasting time.

    There are some consignment places that will take bridal stuff, but only if it's been dry cleaned and is a current style. Even then, you likely won't get much money, which might make Craigslist (free) a good option.

    I have a significant amount of experience selling on eBay and even more on Craigslist. Generic AKA garage sale stuff never moves, which is why Goodwill and a tax deduction are the way to go.

    ETA: If you have furniture that's from a non-smoking home and is in good shape and clean, you might have luck on Craigslist. Things like tables, chairs, unique pieces, bed frames (not mattresses), do fairly well there as long as they are reasonably priced. 

  • My wife has an app called Varagesale on her phone.  Seems to do well.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • Look for buy/sell and yard sale groups on Facebook.  I've had success getting rid of things there.  And there is always Craigslist.
    Formerly AprilH81
    photo composite_14153800476219jpg

  • @MommyLiberty5013 , the tax deduction for donating would not make any difference to my taxes. The standard deduction is so much more for me than itemizing.
    I will look into Varagesale, and the local Facebook buy/sell group. Any more ideas, I will take them. Thank you!!
  • als1982als1982 member
    1000 Comments 500 Love Its Third Anniversary Name Dropper
    edited January 2017
    Do you have a Clothes Mentor or Plato's Closet in your area?  If your clothes and shoes are new, in good condition, and in style you can try there.  (That said, I wear my stuff forever and don't ever seem to have much luck selling them my classic vs. trendy wardrobe.)

    And what kind of books?  If they're textbooks, there are lots of resale sites.  For other books, do you have a Half Price Books nearby?  You likely won't get much, but I've found they at least give a dollar per book, CD, or DVD.

    For the bridesmaids dresses, definitely eBay, especially if they're current styles sold by major chains like David's.  Smart bridesmaids will look for used instead of paying full price for new.  A few years back I got half my money back on a David's dress.
    HeartlandHustle | Personal Finance and Betterment Blog  
  • H has had some really great luck lately selling things on the local buy/sell pages on Facebook - speaker system, DVD sets, guitars. He also used Craigslist a couple of months ago to sell a spin bike we no longer used. 

    For clothes & books, we just donated those to the Salvation Army. They have a truck every week in our local WalMart parking lot so it was the easiest route to go. I still haven't decided what to do with my wedding dress. I never got it cleaned but I have no desire to keep it.
  • I still haven't decided what to do with my wedding dress. I never got it cleaned but I have no desire to keep it.
    Same thing with my wife's dress.  It's hanging in our closet....
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • For those who don't know what to do with your wedding dresses...  Consider donating them to organizations who make burial outfits for babies.

    I'm considering doing it myself but I would like to keep some of the material to make christening gowns for our (hopefully) future children.  

    I have no personal experience with these, but found them with a quick google search.

    http://www.angelgowns.chauglie.com/
    https://newbornsinneed.org/our-work/sophies-place/ 
    http://www.marymadelineproject.org/
    Formerly AprilH81
    photo composite_14153800476219jpg

  • als1982 said:
    Do you have a Clothes Mentor or Plato's Closet in your area?  If your clothes and shoes are new, in good condition, and in style you can try there.  (That said, I wear my stuff forever and don't ever seem to have much luck selling them my classic vs. trendy wardrobe.)

    And what kind of books?  If they're textbooks, there are lots of resale sites.  For other books, do you have a Half Price Books nearby?  You likely won't get much, but I've found they at least give a dollar per book, CD, or DVD.

    For the bridesmaids dresses, definitely eBay, especially if they're current styles sold by major chains like David's.  Smart bridesmaids will look for used instead of paying full price for new.  A few years back I got half my money back on a David's dress.

    Amazon themselves buy textbooks and DVDs (not sure about CDs).  Put in the exact information in their search engine, find the same item, and there will be an area under the price that tells you what Amazon will buy it for.  I'm almost positive they pay for shipping also and will give you a label to print, but I'm not 100% on that.

    They don't give cash, but they'll give an Amazon gift card.

    For textbooks, they don't accept instructor's or international editions.  No broken bindings, water damage, or missing pages.  But some highlighting, marks in book is okay.

  • I sold clothes last year using ThredUp, it works similarly to Plato's Closet or the like, only you don't have to drag your stuff to the store..  You go on their site and request a cleanout bag and they send you a postage-paid bag to put your clothes in to send back.  You can then pay $13 to get the clothes back that they don't want, or they'll just donate them.   However, they really are only looking for items in new or excellent condition, in more "name brands"... not necessarily designer, but tshirts from Target aren't really what they want either.  
    There wasn't a lot of rhyme or reason to what they kept... like I had 2 pairs of shorts from Banana Republic Outlet, one pink, one green, both in the exact same condition, same style, purchased at the same time.  They kept the green ones and returned the pink ones.  I also sent in a bikini from Athleta that I wore one time, it was still in perfect condition.  They kept the top but returned the bottom, which made no sense because they were in a pattern that matched, and they do have bikini bottoms for sale on the site, so it wasn't a sanitary issue I don't think.  I also sent in a pair of Diesel tennis shoes, that only had very minor wear on the heel from jeans rubbing on them, and they returned those due to condition.  A few other items were returned either due to condition or seasonality... ie winter stuff that I had sent in during the summer.

    All in all though, I made about $50, so probably slightly better than I would have done if I tried to sell the stuff at a yard sale, excluding the Marc Jacobs minibag that they took in on consignment, and it eventually sold for around $155, I got $110 of it.  They take in items that are worth over a certain amount (I think $60) as consignment, instead of a direct payout, so you don't get paid until they sell.

    Anyway, I was happy with the process, and have another bag to fill up here pretty soon.   If you or anybody is interested, let me know and I can send you a referral code via email.
  • Oh and yes for selling other random stuff, I use my local Facebook Buy/Sell/Trade page, and also the NextDoor app.  I've found NextDoor is better for larger items, like furniture, and the Facebook pages good for both large and small stuff, like knick knacks, decor, CDs and DVDs (I've not sold these myself but I see them listed all the time).

    For something specialized, like a Danish modern armchair, I used Craigslist, since it was the type of thing that is a very specific style, and people would search for it based on a key word.  Plus, Danish/MCM stuff is not popular out where I live, but it is down in Denver.
  • I've sold some clothes on Poshmark but not for a ton of money. Bridesmaid dresses are impossible - nobody seems to want them! 
  • I've had decent luck on Craigslist, especially when items are priced to sell.  Since it is free it isn't a bad place to start.
  • hoffsehoffse member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited January 2017
    Honestly I usually go for the tax break unless it's something very specific.  There is a consignment store near our house where I will consign designer clothes, but if it doesn't sell there then I just donate.

    Now I did do very well selling textbooks on Amazon in law school.  My books that were marked up sold for significantly more than the ones that were blank.  I always truthfully reported my grade in the class, and if I got a good grade I could ask a really high price.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • hoffse said:
    Honestly I usually go for the tax break unless it's something very specific.  There is a consignment store near our house where I will consign designer clothes, but if it doesn't sell there then I just donate.

    Now I did do very well selling textbooks on Amazon in law school.  My books that were marked up sold for significantly more than the ones that were blank.  I always truthfully reported my grade in the class, and if I got a good grade I could ask a really high price.
    That is hilariously awesome!
  • bigger items that are worth more we sell on CL - that's actually where I sold my first wedding dress for $300.  Items that aren't worth much we donate.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards