Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Taxes on Gifts?

Happy Friday!!

I'm planning to open a savings account for my niece who turns a year old in a few days as part of her birthday gift. The goal is to put $50 in it for Christmas/birthdays and $25 for Easter. I'd also start an allotment for $5-10 a pay check to go in there. I would then gift her the balance of the account when she turns 21 (if she's responsible enough at that point). Roughly $5000-8000 depending how much I contribute every pay check.

I'm wondering if anyone can tell me if I would screw her (or myself) with taxes by doing this? I'd hate to be saving all this money for her and then find out she has to pay taxes on it when I gift it to her. Would it be better to just put it in a envelope under the bed and call it day? LOL

I considered a 529 plan but I'm honestly not convinced she'll go to college, so I don't want that money to be wasted/penalized if used for purposes other than college. I know I sound awful saying she likely won't attend college, obviously I hope for the best for her, but that side of the family (ex-step mom's side) does not have a strong track record.

I appreciate any help!



Re: Taxes on Gifts?

  • According to what I can see, the current gift exclusion level is $14,000, so your $8000 would be well under this.  From what I can tell, it also looks like the donor is the one that pays the taxes.

    https://www.irs.gov/instructions/i709/ch01.html#d0e307

    Just a note.....if you think she'll go to college, you may want to consider holding the money and not giving it to her until after she does her FAFSA for senior year if she could potentially qualify for anything as the gift would be counted as her assets.

    Just a second note....I asked my financial advisor about the 529 accounts and pulling money.  She said it's just a 10% "penalty", but if you look at it this way, normal taxes on investments would be 15%, so technically, you're getting a 5% discount on non-educational use of the money.

    Even if you don't use a 529 account, you might want to look at investing it at least in some sort of target date investment account.  Savings accounts aren't paying diddly at this point.

    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • hoffsehoffse member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited February 2017
    No, you guys would be fine.

    The gift tax doesn't hit until (1) you have exceeded the annual limit (this year it is $14,000 per person per year) and (2) you have exceeded your estate tax exemption limit ($5.49 million/person in 2017).

    It doesn't need to be reported until it's over the $14,000 limit, and you don't pay taxes on it currently until your lifetime limit is used up.  It coordinates with the estate tax.

    You and your H together can gift $28,000/year per individual (since each of you has $14,000).  If you ever gift over $14,000 but less than $28,000 then you have to file the form in order to split the gift between you guys, but it still won't be taxable or reduce your estate tax exemption.

    Contributions to 529 accounts are considered made the year in which the contribution occurs, not the year in which the beneficiary takes a withdrawal.  They also have some special rules allowing you to frontload contributions - so you can do $70,000 ($14,000 x 5) in a single year but then make no further contributions for the next 4 years, and it won't be taxable or reduce your estate tax exemption.  
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Ugh, formatting.  I'm sorry.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • hoffsehoffse member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited February 2017
    Also, FYI the recipient never pays gift taxes.  Gifts are not considered income and are therefore can always be excluded from the recipient's tax return.  The rare times gift taxes arise, it's the giver who files the gift tax return and pays any taxes.  The giver and the recipient may have some deal between them that shifts the tax burden to the recipient, but from the IRS's perspective the recipient is never responsible.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • hoffse said:
    Contributions to 529 accounts are considered made the year in which the contribution occurs, not the year in which the beneficiary takes a withdrawal.  They also have some special rules allowing you to frontload contributions - so you can do $70,000 ($14,000 x 5) in a single year but then make no further contributions for the next 4 years, and it won't be taxable or reduce your estate tax exemption.  
    Forgot to also note that 529s are tax deductible against your state income tax.  At least here in VA.....your mileage may vary.....
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • hoffsehoffse member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited February 2017

    Yep, deductible here too, up to $10K/year.  It's kind of annoying because front-loading usually yields better outcomes from an investment/return standpoint, but then you may miss out on the tax savings.  I have a theory that 529 contributions are going to eventually become deductible federally too.  That would be viewed by some as a compromise between mass student loan forgiveness and refinancing vs. leaving things as the are.  
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • hoffse said:

    Yep, deductible here too, up to $10K/year.  It's kind of annoying because front-loading usually yields better outcomes from an investment/return standpoint, but then you may miss out on the tax savings.  I have a theory that 529 contributions are going to eventually become deductible federally too.  That would be viewed by some as a compromise between mass student loan forgiveness and refinancing vs. leaving things as the are.  
    Damn I'm jealous of that - Massachusetts just started letting you deduct $2k this year. 

    Abrewer5 I would also discuss a 529 plan with the child's parents first because I've heard that sometimes well-meaning family members can damage the student's financial aid package because it is distributed to the student and then counts as their income (where the parents' 529 is counted as parental income). The 529 plan I will be opening after this little one is born has an option for family and friends to contribute to the plan we set up through a separate login (so they can give straight to the account, but can't see the balance or our investment options). Grandparents will NOT be allowed to open their own separate 529 for our kid. 
  • hoffse said:
    Yep, deductible here too, up to $10K/year.  It's kind of annoying because front-loading usually yields better outcomes from an investment/return standpoint, but then you may miss out on the tax savings.  I have a theory that 529 contributions are going to eventually become deductible federally too.  That would be viewed by some as a compromise between mass student loan forgiveness and refinancing vs. leaving things as the are.  

    Lucky.  We only get $4k/year.  The federal deduction would be nice.

    Personally, I have issues with student loan forgiveness.  But I also have issues with how student loans are essentially just handed out.  Like there should be verification that a students expected career path matches expected annual salary.

    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • jtmh2012 said:
    hoffse said:
    Yep, deductible here too, up to $10K/year.  It's kind of annoying because front-loading usually yields better outcomes from an investment/return standpoint, but then you may miss out on the tax savings.  I have a theory that 529 contributions are going to eventually become deductible federally too.  That would be viewed by some as a compromise between mass student loan forgiveness and refinancing vs. leaving things as the are.  

    Lucky.  We only get $4k/year.  The federal deduction would be nice.

    Personally, I have issues with student loan forgiveness.  But I also have issues with how student loans are essentially just handed out.  Like there should be verification that a students expected career path matches expected annual salary.

    I like that idea! I also think a major problem is that we don't teach high school students any level of personal finance and many don't get those lessons at home either. When you're 17 and super excited to just get going to college many kids don't pay attention or understand what they are really getting themselves into. I had on 8th grade algebra teacher that did a week long lesson plan on finances, but it wasn't part of the regular curriculum and if you had the other math teacher you missed out. I still remember that class and how quickly I went bankrupt because I had no concept of how much things cost and how far a dollar really goes. Good thing I did it for pretend before I was let loose on the world with a real paycheck! 
  • hoffse said:

    Yep, deductible here too, up to $10K/year.  It's kind of annoying because front-loading usually yields better outcomes from an investment/return standpoint, but then you may miss out on the tax savings.  I have a theory that 529 contributions are going to eventually become deductible federally too.  That would be viewed by some as a compromise between mass student loan forgiveness and refinancing vs. leaving things as the are.  
    Damn I'm jealous of that - Massachusetts just started letting you deduct $2k this year. 

    Abrewer5 I would also discuss a 529 plan with the child's parents first because I've heard that sometimes well-meaning family members can damage the student's financial aid package because it is distributed to the student and then counts as their income (where the parents' 529 is counted as parental income). The 529 plan I will be opening after this little one is born has an option for family and friends to contribute to the plan we set up through a separate login (so they can give straight to the account, but can't see the balance or our investment options). Grandparents will NOT be allowed to open their own separate 529 for our kid. 
    I like that idea.  I would love it if that was set up for our niece/nephews. 
    Our oldest nephew might get a job in the next couple of years because he is getting to that age.  When that happens I will look into Roth IRA options and discuss with his parents.
  • @hoffse @jtmh2012 & @LillibetteV

    Thank you guys so much!! 

    It's highly unlikely I'll go with the 529 plan because I really don't know if she'll go to college, her side of the family doesn't tend to place high importance on education, unfortunately. :/ and I would hate to tie up money intended for educational expenses when it may not be used that way. The financial aid income claim is a concern too, so I think another savings option might be better in this case.


  • abrewer5 said:
    @hoffse @jtmh2012 & @LillibetteV

    Thank you guys so much!! 

    It's highly unlikely I'll go with the 529 plan because I really don't know if she'll go to college, her side of the family doesn't tend to place high importance on education, unfortunately. :/ and I would hate to tie up money intended for educational expenses when it may not be used that way. The financial aid income claim is a concern too, so I think another savings option might be better in this case.


    I think you can use 529 plans on trade schools and the like...  So if she wants to be a hair dresser or an electrician the funds can be used for that without penalty.
    Formerly AprilH81
    photo composite_14153800476219jpg

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards