Central Pennsylvania Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Party invitation pet peeve

DH and I are invited to a party this weekend.  I don't know the couple all that well, but they are friends with friends of ours, so I will know people there.  But my pet peeve is that the invite asks you to bring a covered dish to share, if you'd like.  To me, that is just tacky.  It's a birthday party for the wife.  If you can't cover enough food for you guests, don't throw a party!

Is this acceptable now? 

Re: Party invitation pet peeve

  • I think definitely for a birthday party it's tacky.  It's normal in some circles/families though.  I wouldn't put it on the invite though and would instead allow people to bring things if they asked if they could bring anything.  I don't mind for a normal party get together to have it potluck. I usually provide everything and don't let anyone bring anything when we have a party though bc I like to have control and I love to cook.
  • I'm the same way, lindyanne - I like to have control/like to cook, so if someone asks what they can bring, I will generally say a dessert or fruit/veggie tray, or chips (but I always plan on getting this myself anyway).  I figure it's my party, I should provide the food.
  • I'm the same way - it's my party, so I'll provide everything.  The only time I'll say yes when someone asks if they should bring something is if they say, "Would you like me to make XYZ" something specific.  Or I tell them to bring lawn chairs if it's an outside party.  And usually we do our best to have as many of those as possible!

  • I blame this tackiness on the economy...
    image



  • imagelindyanne:
    I think definitely for a birthday party it's tacky.  It's normal in some circles/families though.  I wouldn't put it on the invite though and would instead allow people to bring things if they asked if they could bring anything.  I don't mind for a normal party get together to have it potluck. I usually provide everything and don't let anyone bring anything when we have a party though bc I like to have control and I love to cook.

    Ditto this.  I think alot of the etiquette rules have gone out the window.  Last month I was invited to a baby shower over Facebook.   

  • I agree, for a party I would rather make my own food. But for a picnic or something it may be a little different and I don't think it is tacky.
    imageimage Nest Bio I My Blog 2011 Races: Robbins Run 5K Trail Run- 4/23/11 Turkey Hill Country Classic 5K- 5/7/11 MHA Ladies 5K- 6/4/11 Hershey Half Marathon- 10/16/11 Amish Country Half Marathon- 11/5/11 Turkey Trot 5K 11/24/11 Jingle Bell Run 12/11/11 Kris Kringle 5 Miler 12/18/11
  • imageMe&Mr.T:
    I agree, for a party I would rather make my own food. But for a picnic or something it may be a little different and I don't think it is tacky.

    Agree with you there.  My family used to hold a lot of pot luck style picnics for our neighborhood, or our family (which is quite large), and it didn't seem tacky at all there.  BUT I think that is a totally different situation-  for a birthday party, or any non-picnic style party, I think it is a little tacky.

  • So you are pretty much expected to bring a gift AND something to eat.  I agree with previous posts . . for a cookout/picnic/reunion/gtg I can see doing this but for a bday party you are throwing for your wife I don't think its acceptable to put on the invitation.
  • imagePennyLane06:
    So you are pretty much expected to bring a gift AND something to eat.  I agree with previous posts . . for a cookout/picnic/reunion/gtg I can see doing this but for a bday party you are throwing for your wife I don't think its acceptable to put on the invitation.

    That is exactly why I think this crosses into tacky-territory.  Normally, I'd have no issue with bringing a dish.  However, if it is a situation where I would typically be giving a gift, I don't think guests should be asked to provide the food.

  • If I am hosting I like to provide the food, but if I am a guest I will always ask the host if I can bring anything. We do attend an annual summer BBQ/picnic where the hosts provide the meat to grill (burgers/hot dogs) and everyone else brings a side dish or dessert. There is usually some coordination so there are a variety of sides though. I don't mind having a pot luck type thing for a BBQ.
  • I think being asked to bring a dish to a party like that is odd.  Normally I offer to bring food to a picnic or something similar, but to a birthday party where they want gifts, I wouldn't expect to bring food as well, especially to have it on the invitation.
    My sweet boy
    imageimage
  • imagePennyLane06:
    So you are pretty much expected to bring a gift AND something to eat.

    Wow...when I read the OP this morning I must not of been awake because I didn't even think of that part!  Yikes.  These people are k-lassy!  

  • imagejjenkins:

    imagePennyLane06:
    So you are pretty much expected to bring a gift AND something to eat.

    Wow...when I read the OP this morning I must not of been awake because I didn't even think of that part!? Yikes.? These people are k-lassy!??

    I definitely didn't consider that either!?

  • UGH, I totally agree on this!!! I was invited to a 2 yr old b-day party for a friend's daughter the invitation read..."Please provide an appetizer or covered dish to share with about 30-40 people and bring chairs as the party will be outdoors...we will provide hamburgers, hot dogs and birthday cake" ARE YOU SERIOUS!!!!!!! I declined the invite ~ as torn as I was since it was a child's b-day party, and she has no control over what her parents do,  I did have an issue with the fact that she not only asked for her guests to provide the food for her daughters party but gave a specific number to provide for..that really bugged me UGH! Ok off my soap box now!
  • imageGBL77:
    UGH, I totally agree on this!!! I was invited to a 2 yr old b-day party for a friend's daughter the invitation read..."Please provide an appetizer or covered dish to share with about 30-40 people and bring chairs as the party will be outdoors...we will provide hamburgers, hot dogs and birthday cake" ARE YOU SERIOUS!!!!!!! I declined the invite ~ as torn as I was since it was a child's b-day party, and she has no control over what her parents do,  I did have an issue with the fact that she not only asked for her guests to provide the food for her daughters party but gave a specific number to provide for..that really bugged me UGH! Ok off my soap box now!

    They could have easily just said it was "cake & Ice cream" at an off-meal time and wouldn't have had to be so tacky...or had a smaller party they could afford.

    We have a big picnic/BBQ every summer for our anniversary (we try to get all of our BM's/GM's together again with our family & friends...almost like a wedding reunion).  It's nothing formal, we don't send invitations, it's mostly word of mouth or an email to those out of town.  We provide the keg & soda, meat & rolls (pulled pork and beef brisket...not burgers & hot dogs) and then everyone just brings their specialty dish or a dessert...my mom brings mac & cheese, someone brings brownies, etc.

    When I hosted a surprise Birthday party for DH 2 years ago, I didn't ask anyone to bring anything.

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards