help me choose a fall wreath!

eacerna · October 2009

i am a little behind with decorating for fall. i bought 2 wreaths - one from World Market and the other one from Crate & barrel, but can't decide which one to keep. DH isn't much of a help. when i asked which one is nicer, he just said "whichever is cheaper". ugh!

http://tinyurl.com/yjozje5

http://tinyurl.com/yjnvher

thanks!

HulaLove · October 2009

I prefer the second one.

mrspresley · October 2009

i like the first one better but both are cute

sanae78 · October 2009

I think I like the first one better.

inamra · October 2009

i like the first one more =]

mrsdarling · October 2009

I'm in the minority, I like the second one best. They're both pretty, but I tend to like wreaths that are more dense. If I can see the door peeking through in too many spots, I feel like the wreath is going to fall apart!

lelekay · October 2009

I'll join the minority and say that I like the second one better....thought they are both nice.

peachmango · October 2009

I think both look nice but I prefer the second one more. I like simplicity and clean lines and I think the second one is cleaner looking in that regard because there are no leaves sticking out.

annasan_k · October 2009

Ohhh, tough choices. While I do think the first one is very pretty and festive, I would pick the second one for this reason: return on investment. I think over time, the silk leaves on the first one will probably show wear and tear. However, so long as you pack the faux berry one right, I think it will look good for years to come.

KShiz · October 2009

That's a tough one, I like them both... If I had to choose just one, I think I'd go for the first one. I like the shape the leaves make

vanilla15 · October 2009

i agree with pp...both are lovely, but I favor #1

msmoore27 · October 2009

Second one, definitely. I think the one with the leaves looks a little more cheap, honestly. It's easier to pull off fake berries than fake leaves.

We really seem to be split down the middle on this, huh?

SimpsonOhana07 · October 2009

They are both really nice, but I would lean more towards the first one. It seems more nautral looking, plus, think it's the very purrrrdy "Canadian" maple leaves, that really caught my eye Wink

Married2MrWright · October 2009

I like #1 the best!

redshoegirl · October 2009

I like #1 better - it's more texturally interesting. #2 is just kind of a block of berries, you know?

cecig · October 2009

I prefer #2!

eacerna · October 2009

msmoore27:

Second one, definitely. I think the one with the leaves looks a little more cheap, honestly. It's easier to pull off fake berries than fake leaves.

We really seem to be split down the middle on this, huh?

Ahh..the votes are split!! The 1st one is cheaper! I actually bought the first one first (@Crate & Barrel) but DH scolded me when he found out how much I bought it for :-P. I felt guilty so I looked for another one which ended up to be half the price of the first one. I still can't decide. There are elements in both that I like :-(.

help me choose a fall wreath!

Re: help me choose a fall wreath!

Choose Another Board

Search Boards