Upstate NY Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

A vent about Haiti (I'm a horrible person)

I feel horrible for what happened in Haiti, I really do.  But with everything going on with asking for donations, commercials during football games, "fundraising" (for lack of a better term) during the news, asking about it at the Golden Globes...it just makes me angry and sad to think about all of the people here, in our very own country, who need help, too. 

And I'm going to he!!.  Embarrassed

DD1: 3/31/10 DD2: 9/7/11

Re: A vent about Haiti (I'm a horrible person)

  • If you're going to hell then I'll be joining you.  It's sad to know that we don't put this much effort into raising $$ to help those in our own country....
  • I agree, and it's not just Haiti - we have done other aid and we seem for forget about things that are so bad here at home.  Everything to children who need adopting to Hurricane Katrina etc.
  • Save me a spot on the couch when you get down there.  DH and I have said the same thing.  In fact yesterday I said maybe we can get someone to donate money to finish fixing New Orleans.  We are way to quick to assist others when there are so many who need help in our own country.  It's sad, really.
  • I'll be joining you. I think it's horrible and I feel horrible. I can't even imagine something like that. It just kills me that it takes a tragedy to make the world come together, well a tradedy that is not expected.

    It also makes me so sad because there is consistant tragedy around the world and in our own country and no one unites. They only unite when it's a natural distaster. No uniting against human trafficking, geneocide etc, unless it's the fad thing to donate to. A general uniting of our world to create a better place for our future generations is all that we need.

    ***steps off soap box***

    Took 2 years & 8 months to make our baby! Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • Don't feel bad because we obviously agree with you on the board.  I feel the same way.  We have so many problems and are in a recession and yet we can spend SO much money giving it to Haiti.  I'm sad about what happened there.  I feel awful and it's certainly a tragedy but seriously, what happened to helping people in our own country?  People are starving here but we'll send money over seas to feed people in other countries instead.
  • The fundraising business here in the US raised over $306 billion dollars in 2007.  Yes - that's billions.  While obviously some of this goes to charities that do work overseas as well as here in the US, Red Cross, Doctors without Borders, etc. the vast majority of this money stays here in the US.  Yes, when these huge diasters hit it can feel like people care more about helping others overseas but the truth is we give way more to help our fellow citizens day to day.

    I think you don't see the impact the same since it's spread out throughout the year and it comes is the form of thousands of different campaigns for tens of thousands of different charities.

    But think about it - I might send $10 or $20 to help Haiti but there are several times a year I sponsor people in fundraising walks, buy tickets to galas, or give in memory of someone.  I bet this holds true for a lot of other people, making our state side impact much greater than what we give overseas.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • You make a good point Two. I think advertising and news is focused on the major tragedies so it seems that more money is going over seas. I just went to a leukemia fundraiser over the weekend and my friend is running the boston marathon and raising money. The run isn't until april and he's already raised over $5000 and that's just coming from ONE runner. But of course, this isn't nationally recognized so we don't see the totals like we do with the earthquake in Haiti.
  • Another thing to think about is how we have hundreds of thousands of troops occupying another country at war overseas... it is a huge huge drain on our country (financially, troops, etc).  I know it's sort of a whole different issue, and our decision, but I think it's easy for people to forget we have 100's of thousands of people who risk their lives out there.  (This isn't in response to anything you girls mentioned, and it is a little different than a natural disaster - just saying, our country has major major issues).
  • Haha! You're not a bad person. I keep seeing all these stars giving millions of dollars and I selfishly agree, I'd rather see that money stay "close to home".

    <<ducks from flame darts>> I think the same thing about animal charities- the money would better be used on children or disease research.

    imageimageLilypie Fourth Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • For me, I think it's a difference in scope.  First, I think there's enough money for everyone to donate to causes in the US and around the world.  My giving to charities based in the US is much higher than what I gave to Partners in Health, an organization who is working in Haiti right now.  The money I gave to them isn't money that I would have given another organization, so it's not like I'm taking away money from a cause in the US.

    While we have problems here in our country, they are nowhere near as severe as they are down in Haiti right now.  People are starving to death or dying from infections that can be easily treated.  People are having limbs amputated with only local anesthesia, if any at all.  Thousands upon thousands of people have died, there are many orphans.  Haiti is an extremely poor country, and if people around the world didn't help, it would be a colossal disaster. 

  • Ditto olivia_eve.  Haiti is one of the poorest countries in the world, if those of us with disposable income don't donate to try to help, then who will?  They certainly can't help themselves right now.

    I do agree, though, that seeing celebrities who make millions of dollars badgering me to donate to their pet charities rubs me the wrong way.  

    PersonalMilestone
  • I don't think you're going to hell, but it's certainly not the most compassionate point of view.

    I don't like to compare tragedies and human suffering, but the US hasn't had a disaster on this scale.  Yes, people go hungry in this nation.  But, we are one of the most powerful and wealthiest countries in the world, so why this happens is a mystery to me.  But I really don't think it's a lack of money.  On the other hand, Haiti doesn't have anything. 

    Extreme human suffering is extreme human suffering!  Just because they are not American does not bother me and I just don't get people who feel differently. 

  • I think you're a self-absorbed, selfish ***, and I'm not afraid to say it.
  • imagecandm:
    I think you're a self-absorbed, selfish ***, and I'm not afraid to say it.

    That was b*tch, in case there's any doubt.

  • I'm just so disappointed at the ignorance of some people.  The people of Haiti had nothing to begin with and now they really have nothing.  You can't even compare our country's problems to Haiti!
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards