I bought these shoes the other day for my sisters shower and I am in love with them.

The only problem is that they seem a bit too big and I can't quite figure it out. See?
left foot

right foot (a little bigger so I always judge fit by how they fit on this foot)

Because my left foot is smaller the space in the toe is bigger, the area from my where my toes hit to the end of the shoe, so that kind of bothers me too. Do I try a half size smaller or do I pad them with Foot Petals and hope that works? I tried on a couple other pairs of heels I have in the closet and they fit so much better because they are nice and snug on my foot. Because these are so loose in the back they are hard to walk in. Not to mention I think they look silly because they obviously have some issues in the back.
Second question, the leather kind of wrinkled (you can see it in the pic) after wearing them for a little while around the house, is this normal?
Re: I'm having shoe fit issues, I need some help please
Those shoes are awesome, Belle. But you definitely need a smaller size. The foot petals won't be able to help as much as you need them too. Plus the shoes will stretch over time.
Damn, that's some fine footwear.