New York Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

a cupcake mission!

Ok, so I know ny'ers have this obsession with "best" cupcakes...or at least I do! I craved cupcakes throughout my pregnancy and post-partum, I had cupcakes at my baby shower and ever since I had an eggnog cupcake from Sweet Revenge over the holidays I've been craving that cupcake perfection. It was OMG - so much that during insane xmas-traffic-leaving-the-city, we made a side trip in a car to pick up another one!

I know we've talked about this before, but which is your favorite bakery? I just had a friend bring over a sampling from Billy's Bakery, and although the carrot cupcake was spot on, I'm less than thrilled with their chocolate/vanilla. And no, I'm not agreeing with the awesomeness that everyone claims is Magnolias. Their cake part of the cupcake is less than perfect. Just some Thursday evening thoughts, hee hee.

And...discuss....

imageBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker

Re: a cupcake mission!

  • YAY!  I love cupcakes.  There is this place called Cupcake Cafe near Union Square - it is also a children's bookstore.  They have the most beautiful cupcakes decorated with beautiful (frosting) flowers.  They are also tasty, but they win the beautiful prize by me.

    Then there is Two Little Red Hens on the UES and they have really scrumcious old fashioned type cupcakes!  The vanilla cake with chocolate fudge is a classic and really hits the spot.  That is honestly my favorite.

    The place we went to after Essex - I thought the vanilla cake with chocolate almond frosting was amazing!  And you can't beat the price!  Although I thought the salespeople were unfriendly so I wouldn't really want to hang out there.  They are super friendly at Cupcake Cafe and Two Little Red Hens.

    When I first moved here, I had Crumbs, which I thought was really cool (great selection of unique cupcakes), but they are tooo sweet!  After trying Two Little Red Hens I was quickly over Crumbs and no longer go there!

  • Nova726Nova726 member
    Tenth Anniversary 5000 Comments 100 Love Its First Answer

    I looooved the lemon cupcake at the place by Essex.

    I have to agree with you Liz about both Magnolia's and Billy's.

    My favorite cupcake right now is the Dulce de Leche from Big Booty Bread Company on 23rd St.  They usually only have like 3 or 4 different cupcakes but the Dulce de Leche is my absolute weakness.

    Crumbs is good but I think it's overrated. The CupcakeStop truck is usually pretty good too.

    image
     Helene (Nova726)'s book recommendations, favorite quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf) 
    image
  • Is the place by Essex called Sugar Sweet Sunshine by any chance? Bc that is my favorite cupcake shop in NYC! Agreed the lemon cupcake is delicious and the pistachio one made with real pistachios! Also if you're in the mood, their banana pudding and chocolate bombs are delicious!

  • I can't eat eggs, so I can't eat cupcakes at the usual places like everyone else... boo hoo.

    Therefore the only place I can suggest is Babycakes, because they do vegan/gluten-free etc. and therefore I know they are safe for me!

  • I love crumbs but I tried the lemon cupcake from the place opposite Essex and it was like heaven!  The others from there were just, ok.

    image
    Our New Home! Renovation Underway! The Law Nest
    TTC Journey
    7/2008 - begin TTC
    7/2009 - began charting
    9/2009 - Dx Endometriosis
    10/2009 - HSG/SA (Normal)
    12/2009 -6/2010 - Lupron #1 & 2
    Sep-Nov 2010- Clomid Cycles #1&2 = BFN
    Dec 2010 - Clomid Cycle #3 = BFP (1/11/11);no h/b (2/10/11); D&C (2/23/11)
    5/11-6/11 - herbal tea regime = BFN
    7/24/2011- herbal tea regime = surprise BFP
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • Nova726Nova726 member
    Tenth Anniversary 5000 Comments 100 Love Its First Answer
    imagelilneko69:

    Is the place by Essex called Sugar Sweet Sunshine by any chance? Bc that is my favorite cupcake shop in NYC! Agreed the lemon cupcake is delicious and the pistachio one made with real pistachios! Also if you're in the mood, their banana pudding and chocolate bombs are delicious!

    I'm fairly certain that this was it. 

    image
     Helene (Nova726)'s book recommendations, favorite quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf) 
    image
  • TopangaTopanga member
    I have nothing to add about the best cupcakes but I too love cupcakes. I think they are sorely overpriced though. I have to agree with you on magnolia's. I went there expecting perfection and felt the same way. The actual cake part was dry and uninspiring. How can so many people rave about them?
  • imageNova726:
    imagelilneko69:

    Is the place by Essex called Sugar Sweet Sunshine by any chance? Bc that is my favorite cupcake shop in NYC! Agreed the lemon cupcake is delicious and the pistachio one made with real pistachios! Also if you're in the mood, their banana pudding and chocolate bombs are delicious!

    I'm fairly certain that this was it. 

    Yes, that's them!

    imageimage
     

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker    

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Nova726Nova726 member
    Tenth Anniversary 5000 Comments 100 Love Its First Answer

    imageTopanga:
    I have nothing to add about the best cupcakes but I too love cupcakes. I think they are sorely overpriced though. I have to agree with you on magnolia's. I went there expecting perfection and felt the same way. The actual cake part was dry and uninspiring. How can so many people rave about them?

    lol, I remember the first time I went there and brought a few cupcakes home.  I didn't even make a thing to DH about them being Magnolia's, but I had to laugh when he wouldn't even finish his first cupcake. He did NOT like them at all.

    and the cupcakes at Sunshine (is that what we said the name was?) were only $1.25 which is fantastic compared to everywhere else.

    image
     Helene (Nova726)'s book recommendations, favorite quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf) 
    image
  • I LUV Sugar Sweet Sunshine!  We ordered those at my office every day for a week during a trade show.  By far the best overall in my book, great prices, and different atmosphere (they aren't trying too hard to impress, just good sweets!).  My second fave is the Cupcake Stop truck - super moist, but there's something a little different about them like they are kinda muffiny.  They have some odd flavors you can't find just anywhere.  Now I'm going to have to get a cupcake this weekend after reading this thread! 
  • This weekend I am going to try out this Cupcake Stop truck you speak of!

    Yeah, prices at Sweet Sunshine were amazing!  Too bad I don't live closer to it!

  • I love Sugar Sweet Sunshine!  For me, their cupcakes are light, fluffy, taste great and have just the right amount of frosting.  I did not like Magnolia at all-- too dry and the icing was not good.I am really not into super-sweet icing mounded on, but that's just my own preference.

    I've also had sweets from Babycakes recently and that was delicious too.  Good if you are vegan or need gluten-free.

  • I am a Crumbs fan all the way.  Magnolia's sucks.  The Red Hen place makes great cupcakes also.  I need to try this Sugar Sweet Sunshine place you ladies speak of ... hmmmmm.  Great now I want cupcakes 
  • THE CUPCAKE STOP TRUCK WAS NOT THERE!!! I was so disappointed!  :(
  • Nova726Nova726 member
    Tenth Anniversary 5000 Comments 100 Love Its First Answer

    imageadozenroses:
    THE CUPCAKE STOP TRUCK WAS NOT THERE!!! I was so disappointed!  :(

    That stinks.  Did you check their site for locations and hours? I know I was upset when it wasn't at the Flatiron location, I hadn't realized that was just Tues & Thurs.

    image
     Helene (Nova726)'s book recommendations, favorite quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf) 
    image
  • imageNova726:

    imageadozenroses:
    THE CUPCAKE STOP TRUCK WAS NOT THERE!!! I was so disappointed!  :(

    That stinks.  Did you check their site for locations and hours? I know I was upset when it wasn't at the Flatiron location, I hadn't realized that was just Tues & Thurs.

    I DID!  It wasn't there :(  Is it usually where it is scheduled to be?

  • another vote for cupcake cafe! there are two locations- one on 18th st b/w 5th and 6th and one on 9th across from port authority. besides their cupcakes, they have a zucchini muffini that is TO DIE FOR!
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards