Cincinnati Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Church Question

I know it's a long shot because not too many Nesties live down in BUFU where I do, but...

DH and I are looking for a new church. I'm Catholic, he's Baptist, but only because we liked the respective churches we grew up in and not because of the doctrines. Neither of the churches we currently attend are close to our house in Crittenden, so we're looking for something in Crittenden/Walton/Verona. Doctrinally, we'd like something that's Christian and isn't too evangelical - we don't get too hung up on the denominational labels so we don't care what type of church. We don't mind small or big. It's just a little scary to "church shop" when you don't know what to expect, KWIM?

Also, does anyone happen to know what the Violet Ridge Church of Christ is like? It's literally a mile from our house but neither of us have ever been to a Church of Christ so we aren't sure what to expect.

Thanks, ladies!

ETA: I know All Saints Catholic Church is down here in Walton, but I think DH doesn't really care for the Catholic worship style, so we're looking to go outside of our respective "boxes" and try something more suited to both of us.

Two Blue Pillars
Baby Blue Eyes
image

Re: Church Question

  • I was in a similar spot as you a few years ago. I grew up southern baptist, and DH grew up catholic. Neither of us were active in our churches, b/c we didnt agree with everything, more political things within the church and how they were run. We both felt strongly on finding our own church family, so we tried everything from non-dem, baptist, lutheran, and catholic. Our rule of thumb was to try each church twice, just in case the service we attended wasnt their "norm." We ended up finding our current church, which is methodist. Its a great mix of what we were looking for. It has the sermon's I was use to, and more of the rituals DH was use to. We have become very active in our church, and really feel at home. Its in milford, other wise I'd recommend it, it would be a long drive for you guys every week. DH's family was less than pleased about him leaving the catholic church, however its not about them, its about us finding our way. HTH
  • Thanks for the suggestions - that is a good idea to try each church twice. I didn't think about that. And luckily, my family isn't too worried about which church I go to as long as I'm going to church (although, I couldn't have said that 10 years ago because it would've been a big deal then - my grandmother and subsequently everyone else have finally realized that it's not so much about the specific religion).
    Two Blue Pillars
    Baby Blue Eyes
    image
  • Churches of Christ are pretty conservative/fundamental.  I don't want to say that they're like Baptist churches but they're probably closer to Baptist than Catholic (since that's what the two of you know).  Each church can pretty much determine their style compared to something like the Catholic church that's pretty tightly controlled by a diocese or Rome.  DH & I were both brought up Catholic & we go to a United Methodist Church.  Some are more traditional, some are modern, it just depends on the pastor/congregation (our old pastor was a liberal thinker but did pretty low key services.  Our new pastor is a young woman who has a more evangelical style & her husband likes to shout out "Jesus!" or "Amen!" from the back of the church.  Scared us to death the first few times! Meanwhile the UMC church were we were married was very crunchy/liberal-almost reminded me of a Unitarian church).  Lutherans are probably the most similar to Catholic churches, Presbyterians are pretty main stream & would probably be comfortable to you as a Catholic. 
    Visit The Nest!baby development PitaPata Dog tickers image
  • I'm really happy to hear you and your DH want to go to church.  I think it's great that you are living your faith.

    You also mentioned that you are Catholic.  So I want to suggest, totally out of a heart of charity towards you, to consider going to a Catholic church.  I know that the worship at Mass is difficult to get used to and even confusing for non-Catholics, but if the Catholic faith is important to you and you truly believe in the Church, then the Eucharist is the center of the Mass and also the center of your faith.  You will want to get this sacrament as often as possible.  I am also not hung up on denominations or labels, as I believe that all people are equally children of God.  But it is a fact that the Eucharist where it is believed there is the True Presence of Jesus in body and blood is not available in any other church except for the Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Church.  You will be missing out on this if you were to choose any other church.

    I will respect whichever church you and your DH choose to go to. :)

    Follow Me on Pinterest

    BabyFruit Ticker
  • all I have to say is, Whoa.

    Amanda, I would just go check it out since it's so close, but you run the risk of it being one of those churches where they corner the new people.  LOL.  At least they probably have free donuts. 

    I feel like you should abide by the "the family that prays together, stays together" motto here, and find a place of worship where both of you are happy.  If that takes months, then at least you will have stories to tell about your adventures in church hunting. 

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I grew up catholic and H's family didn't do church. He was not a fan of Catholicism and how they worshipped. We compromised and go to a non denominational church in Burlington that we love! 

    Good Luck finding something you both like and can agree to.  

  • imageclearheavens:

    I'm really happy to hear you and your DH want to go to church.  I think it's great that you are living your faith.

    You also mentioned that you are Catholic.  So I want to suggest, totally out of a heart of charity towards you, to consider going to a Catholic church.  I know that the worship at Mass is difficult to get used to and even confusing for non-Catholics, but if the Catholic faith is important to you and you truly believe in the Church, then the Eucharist is the center of the Mass and also the center of your faith.  You will want to get this sacrament as often as possible.  I am also not hung up on denominations or labels, as I believe that all people are equally children of God.  But it is a fact that the Eucharist where it is believed there is the True Presence of Jesus in body and blood is not available in any other church except for the Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Church.  You will be missing out on this if you were to choose any other church.

    I will respect whichever church you and your DH choose to go to. :)

    TBH, I don't necessarily believe in the Catholic doctrines, I just felt really comfortable with the worship style growing up. DH and I believe more in the general principles of Christianity rather than denominational principles, so when we look for a church, we are looking purely at comfort level with the worship styles for both of us.

    imagemeg41028:

    all I have to say is, Whoa.

    Amanda, I would just go check it out since it's so close, but you run the risk of it being one of those churches where they corner the new people.  LOL.  At least they probably have free donuts. 

    I feel like you should abide by the "the family that prays together, stays together" motto here, and find a place of worship where both of you are happy.  If that takes months, then at least you will have stories to tell about your adventures in church hunting. 

    See, that's what I'm worried about - getting cornered or being made the center of attention, or dressing really differently and standing out like a sore thumb. Then we'll feel so uncomfortable that it will be hard to go back for a second test try.

    We definitely agree, though, with the prayers together thing - even though we haven't been to church in months, we both still pray and keep our faith and we've tried really hard not to lose that. We aren't looking for faith - we have that - we are just looking for a place to help us express that faith.

    Two Blue Pillars
    Baby Blue Eyes
    image
  • imagedaves_sweetpea:

    Churches of Christ are pretty conservative/fundamental.  I don't want to say that they're like Baptist churches but they're probably closer to Baptist than Catholic (since that's what the two of you know). Each church can pretty much determine their style compared to something like the Catholic church that's pretty tightly controlled by a diocese or Rome.  DH & I were both brought up Catholic & we go to a United Methodist Church.  Some are more traditional, some are modern, it just depends on the pastor/congregation (our old pastor was a liberal thinker but did pretty low key services.  Our new pastor is a young woman who has a more evangelical style & her husband likes to shout out "Jesus!" or "Amen!" from the back of the church.  Scared us to death the first few times! Meanwhile the UMC church were we were married was very crunchy/liberal-almost reminded me of a Unitarian church).  Lutherans are probably the most similar to Catholic churches, Presbyterians are pretty main stream & would probably be comfortable to you as a Catholic. 

    Thanks for the information - we had heard that Methodist or Lutheran are probably going to be close to a marriage between what we would both like, but we hadn't seen any in the area. We'll look at Presbyterian, too, then.

    Two Blue Pillars
    Baby Blue Eyes
    image
  • I myself haven't been to any Pres. services so don't take my word 100%!  There was a split a while back & some are very tradtional in their beliefs, some are much more progressive (same for Lutherans).  Churches that market themselves as non-denominational or just "Christian" can be a wild card.  In my experience (ok, based on where my parents go!) they might have a casual, modern feel but very conservative theology.  It doesn't work for me but others might be happy with it.

     

    Visit The Nest!baby development PitaPata Dog tickers image
  • But it is a fact that the Eucharist where it is believed there is the True Presence of Jesus in body and blood is not available in any other church except for the Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Church. You will be missing out on this if you were to choose any other church.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • oops, sorry about that.  In reference to the above though... Disclaimer: I am not knocking the Catholic faith as I have many friends who are Catholic, but I have never heard this before.  If we have Jesus Christ living inside of us through His Holy Spirit, then why is it important to have some symbol of Jesus's body in a church?  Please understand, I ask this completely out of curiousity.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageAndrea&Scott:
    oops, sorry about that.  In reference to the above though... Disclaimer: I am not knocking the Catholic faith as I have many friends who are Catholic, but I have never heard this before.  If we have Jesus Christ living inside of us through His Holy Spirit, then why is it important to have some symbol of Jesus's body in a church?  Please understand, I ask this completely out of curiousity.

    Catholics believe in transubstantiation, that the Host (the Communion wafer) is transformed into the actual body of Christ, and that the wine becomes the actual blood of Christ.  So it's not a symbol of body and blood, it's actual body and blood (that look like a cracker and wine).  

    Anyway, I don't want to hijack this or turn it into a religious debate, when poor Amanda is just trying to find a new church for her burgeoning family. 

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I would HIGHLY recommend my church and it isnt too far from where you live (i think)-- its off the Mt.Zion exit on 71/75--its called Grace Fellowship Church (www.graceky.org) and its technically Evangelical Free but it really has a unique style--If you go to the website there are some of the sermons uploaded so you could listen to one or two and see if you like the preaching sermon. I think our Pastors are great! I grew up Catholic but didnt really agree w/ many of the Catholic church teachings and this was the church my DH grew up going to (he started going when it was only like 5 families now it is much larger) There are 3 Sunday services (8:15 9:45 and 11:30)  and the part I really like is that our church has small groups to help you meet and stay connected with other people in your church community throughout the week (they say instead of having a wed. night service or sat. night service we have small groups that meet every night of the week where you get to intimately know and have fellowship with other church goers) My Dh and I actually run the Welcome Center at Grace so feel free to send me an email if you have any questions LaurenRGlenn at gmail dot com HTH!
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • I would HIGHLY recommend my church and it isnt too far from where you live (i think)-- its off the Mt.Zion exit on 71/75--its called Grace Fellowship Church (www.graceky.org) and its technically Evangelical Free but it really has a unique style--If you go to the website there are some of the sermons uploaded so you could listen to one or two and see if you like the preaching style. I think our Pastors are great! I grew up Catholic but didnt really agree w/ many of the Catholic church teachings and this was the church my DH grew up going to (he started going when it was only like 5 families now it is much larger) There are 3 Sunday services (8:15 9:45 and 11:30)  and the part I really like is that our church has small groups to help you meet and stay connected with other people in your church community throughout the week (they say instead of having a wed. night service or sat. night service we have small groups that meet every night of the week where you get to intimately know and have fellowship with other church goers) My Dh and I actually run the Welcome Center at Grace so feel free to send me an email if you have any questions LaurenRGlenn at gmail dot com HTH!
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  •  I'm Lutheran, we were married at Gloria Dei Lutheran in Crestview Hills. I know it's not close to you, but it's a very friendly congregation. We liked it very much.
    image Ready to rumble.
  • imageMeg41208:

    imageAndrea&Scott:
    oops, sorry about that.  In reference to the above though... Disclaimer: I am not knocking the Catholic faith as I have many friends who are Catholic, but I have never heard this before.  If we have Jesus Christ living inside of us through His Holy Spirit, then why is it important to have some symbol of Jesus's body in a church?  Please understand, I ask this completely out of curiousity.

    Catholics believe in transubstantiation, that the Host (the Communion wafer) is transformed into the actual body of Christ, and that the wine becomes the actual blood of Christ.  So it's not a symbol of body and blood, it's actual body and blood (that look like a cracker and wine).  

    Anyway, I don't want to hijack this or turn it into a religious debate, when poor Amanda is just trying to find a new church for her burgeoning family. 

    Ditto Meg on this (transubstantiation, not wanting to hijack A's post)!  I had another response earlier this morning but I dd that b/c I was getting snippy.  Anyway Andrea, as to your comment, your observation hit on a HUGE point of contention between Catholics & Protestants, one that's been going on for 500 years (yeah, I'm not just a former Catholic, I'm a geeky history major too).  Anyway, I'm mostly just a jaded heathen supporting my Methodist husband, so I'm going to step away from any more talk of religion!

    Visit The Nest!baby development PitaPata Dog tickers image
  • Thank you for explaining it to me.  I've never heard the term transubstantiation.  Like I said, I was just asking simply out of curiousity. 

    Amanda - I wish you and your husband the best in finding a church home - one that you can both be comfortable in while growing in your faith at the same time.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Oh, wow, I created a little bit of drama there. Oops.

    For any future responses: I do NOT want to continue going to a Catholic church. I don't think I can say it any more clearly lol but apparently the giant hints of, "it makes my husband uncomfortable," and, "I joined because I liked the church itself and not necessarily because I believed the doctrines," didn't work lol. And neither did the hint, "we don't like churches that are super evangelical," because I still got evangelized to lol.

    Thanks to everyone who listened and gave good feedback :-) I'm just nervous about going to someplace completely unfamiliar, ya know?

    Two Blue Pillars
    Baby Blue Eyes
    image
  • I would also like to suggest Lutheran.  My family is Lutheran and my husband's family is also Lutheran.  I have found that Lutheran churches overall, especially ELCA Lutheran, are very open and accepting, and since you were raised Catholic the service will feel familiar, but it's definitely more relaxed than Catholicism.  Lutheran's are also not super evangelical, but they are big givers to society, rather than trying to convince everyone to be Lutheran. 

    Good luck!

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards