June 2009 Weddings
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Wedding gift cost analysis

I'm buying my sister's wedding present online.  What I've picked out is at the upper limit of what I wanted to spend.  The item is the same price at Macys or Bed Bath and Beyond. 

If I buy the item at BBB, I can use a 20% off coupon on it, saving me money (although I will have to pay shipping). 

If I buy the item at Macys, my sister will also receive a bonus gift of 2 soup bowls in her fine china pattern (I cannot find an additional coupon code, but I will get free shipping).

What would you do:  save yourself money or get her the bonus gift?

Re: Wedding gift cost analysis

  • Are the soup bowls worth more than the 20% savings less shipping costs?  If so then go that route because whether you get the benefit or she does, its still more value for your money.  Additionally, if you do it at Macy's and she signed up for the rewards program, she earns another 5% of what you spend on a gift card.

  • I'd go with Macy's for a couple of reasons:

    1) Bonus gift for the bride (and it's a useful bonus gift!)

    2) Potential 5% kick-back to the bride if she signed up for Macy's rewards (like PP said)

    3) Free shipping

    The savings of 20% at BBB will probably come close to the shipping cost. So, essentially, you get more for the "same" (or closer to the same) amount of money by buying it at Macy's.

    HOWEVER - Did she register for the item at both? Because, if so, I might switch my answer to BBB. BBB will allow exchanges for full cash value (in case she gets two of the item you're considering buying), while Macy's only gives store credit.

    Photobucket
  • I'd do Macy's because the bowls are probably worth more than what you'd save with BBB.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I'd order it from Macy's. Not only is it more goodies for your sister, but they will probably even out in the end.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Image and video hosting by TinyPicimage
    BFP #1: 6.26.12 EDD: 2.11.13 missed m/c: 7.31.12 @ 12 weeks
    BFP #2: 10.1.12 EDD: 6.11.12
    <a href="http://s205.photobucket.com/albums/bb264/chaleybeth06/?action=view
  • Despite my insistence, she did not sign up for the rewards (which means money down the drain...)

    She registered for the item at both, but I doubt she will receive 2 of them, so I'm not worried about the returns issue (plus, she'll definitely have china left to use any store credit on at either store).

    The soup bowls are ~$40 each, so two of them as a bonus gift is a better value than the 20% off at BBB.  It's just at the top of my self-imposed budget, and I'm annoyed that an additional discount I was going to use at Macys ended earlier than I realized.

  • As a wedding/shower gift aside, this is what I got her as a shower gift:

     http://www.etsy.com/listing/26651786/the-original-silver-lingerie-wedding?ref=vt_related_1

     

    She had seen the same item advertised elsewhere and didn't get it because their budget is tight.  I didn't realize she knew about the item and had seen it linked on the nest somewhere and bought her one.  She was really excited to receive it and was super surprised.

  • imagestephriz:

    As a wedding/shower gift aside, this is what I got her as a shower gift:

     http://www.etsy.com/listing/26651786/the-original-silver-lingerie-wedding?ref=vt_related_1

    She had seen the same item advertised elsewhere and didn't get it because their budget is tight.  I didn't realize she knew about the item and had seen it linked on the nest somewhere and bought her one.  She was really excited to receive it and was super surprised.

    I love this! I think I'll get one for my FSIL as a shower present and I have to admit I'm a little jealous that I didn't have one for my wedding. Thanks for the idea!

  • imagegmk1784:

    I love this! I think I'll get one for my FSIL as a shower present and I have to admit I'm a little jealous that I didn't have one for my wedding. Thanks for the idea!

    I'm completely jealous that I didn't have one for my wedding pictures.  It is the best shower gift ever, and I have a few more in the works for other people :)

  • imagestephriz:
    imagegmk1784:

    I love this! I think I'll get one for my FSIL as a shower present and I have to admit I'm a little jealous that I didn't have one for my wedding. Thanks for the idea!

    I'm completely jealous that I didn't have one for my wedding pictures.  It is the best shower gift ever, and I have a few more in the works for other people :)

    It says on the Esty site that there is an 8-10 week waiting period. Is this accurate? I may be out of luck since FSIL's shower is Aug 28th and their wedding is Sept 25

  • imagegmk1784:

    It says on the Esty site that there is an 8-10 week waiting period. Is this accurate? I may be out of luck since FSIL's shower is Aug 28th and their wedding is Sept 25

    Unfortunately, yes.  I think it took ~2 months to get mine.  You could send her a message and ask if 4 weeks is enough time, but she didn't do any correspondance with me.  She makes them all by hand and gets a lot orders.

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards