Green Living
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Help me pick a car!

Right now I drive an SUV. I know, I'm going straight to Hell. But I have two big dogs and may be starting a family in the next year or so, so I like the idea of being able to throw the kiddos in the back seat and the dogs in the back cargo area. And I take the bus to work most days, so I don't feel toooo guilty, but I do feel like a hypocrite because I preach green in every aspect of my life, and here I am driving around this big ol' clunker. I want something more EF and gas efficient.

So, what shoud I get? I was thinking of something along the lines of a Subaru Outback, but to be honest, I just don't like Outbacks for some reason. I know Audi makes something with a similar shape (the A4, I think), and I am intrigued by the Mini Cooper Clubman (the longer ones with the cargo area - though I'd have to really check it out to make sure the cargo area was big enough for my dogs). I am also thinking maybe like a Ford Escape Hybrid, though DH is convinced hybrids are bad because the engines break down a lot or something?

I always keep my eyes peeled on the road for ideas, but I just don't know what to get! What would you get in my situation?

BFP #1 10/6/11 | EDD 6/15/12 | no heartbeat 11/7/11 at 8w3d (baby measuring ~7 weeks)
D&C 11/14/11 - Goodbye, little June Bug

BFP #2 8/22/12 | EDD 5/5/13 | Good betas 8/22 & 8/25 | strong heartbeat 9/17/12 @7w1d
Perfect A/S 12/11/12 @ 19w2d - it's a BOY!

our blog

BabyFetus Ticker

PGAL March siggy challenge - Pet shaming.
image

Re: Help me pick a car!

  • I'm not sure how big it is in the back, but the marketing of the Ford Fiesta is working on me (40 mpg highway!)
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • My parent's have two Priuses. One they have had for five years, and they have never had any engine trouble.

    What size dogs do you have? 

    I personally feel that a lot of the hatchback cars have a lot more room than you might initially think and they generally get good gas mileage. 

    I love the Mazda 3

    I don't really know if it is "green," but the Kia Soul looks kind of cool,

    The toyota Scion line 

    Volvo also makes a hatchback.

    I love these smaller cars b/c they tend to get higher gas mileage and they are surprisingly roomy...you can easily get a baby in the back plus your groceries. MH is 6'3'' with very long legs. We drove around Europe in a small hatchback and he loved it. 

  • Bananers--I'm laughing at my desk because you are considering two of the cars I'm also considering for my next car.  The Outback (unlike you, I LOVE it, but hear the 2011 models are more suv-ish, which I don't like--haven't seen any on the road though to compare) and the Mini Clubman.  I haven't test driven either, I don't have dogs, but Dh and I bicycle a lot and with my job I have to haul things around.  Truth be told, though, I've managed with my Civic for 10 years, so I don't know if I can really justify the added upfront cost of those cars along with the less efficient nature of them.
  • This topic is near and dear to my heart, lol.

    We had a Toyota Matrix.  Amazing fuel economy (it is basically a Corolla wagon) and we could put the dog in the way back, and fit 3 carseats across the back.  We sold it bc my brother gave us his old Corolla, so now we have a corolla and a civic.  Both work fine for 2 or 3 kids in terms of carseat space, but not in terms of cargo space. I would kill to have the Matrix back though!

    Here is the thing though.  Once i hit 2 kids I reallllllly wanted more space.  Like a minivan.  Because not only do you have the kid, you have the stroller, then a double stroller, plus I keep some spare diapers and clothes changes for the kids, plus the diaper bag, and I always have 2 or 3 slings or baby carriers in the car, plus I keep stuff for pools (wading pools) so towel, swimsuit, etc, plus I need the sand toys for parks, and then if we are going to be at the park all day I have a cooler to pack our lunch in.

    You get the picture.

    If I KNEW I was only having 2 kids I think I would get the Mazda 5.  It is a mini-minivan.  Since we might have a 3rd, we are probably going to just go for the van.

     

  • I reread that and realize I sound crazy re. all the crap in my car.

    But, I am a SAHM right now, and most days we hit a park, and sometimes if we are out doing errands, we will spur-of-the-moment decide to stop at a wading pool or something.  So all the crap that I haul around gets used regularly.  And if I had to pack and unpack it from the house every time I would never be able to get out the door and always be forgetting something.

    And to make me sound even nuttier, DS is potty training so I also have a potty in the trunk for emergnecy side of the road poop breaks.  Oh the joys of motherhood.

  • imageJennybeeb:

    The Ford Escape engines don't break down a lot :-P  There are actually lots and lots of people on these boards who always recommend them (some saying they're going to purchase another one when they want a new car)

    So I would definitely recommend looking at those.

     

    I'm one of those people! I said this in a PP but I love my truck now, 05 Ford Escape, have had minimal problems and get 20-23 mpg. Now that I'm more eco-conscious I totally want the new hybrid. I figure give them a year to work out the kinks (like with any new model) and then I'm in! Plus they're wicked sporty-mom-stylish. 

  • imageJennybeeb:

    The Ford Escape engines don't break down a lot :-P  There are actually lots and lots of people on these boards who always recommend them (some saying they're going to purchase another one when they want a new car)

    So I would definitely recommend looking at those.

     

    I'm one of those people! I said this in a PP but I love my truck now, 05 Ford Escape, have had minimal problems and get 20-23 mpg. Now that I'm more eco-conscious I totally want the new hybrid. I figure give them a year to work out the kinks (like with any new model) and then I'm in! Plus they're wicked sporty-mom-stylish. 

  • Sorry, don't know why that posted twice Confused
  • I really love my 2007 Prius, we're planning on keeping it when we have kids.  I don't know why the OP's husband thinks hybrids engines break down a lot, I've never heard that.  Mine has 60K miles on it, and my boss's 2007 Civic hybrid has 120K, with no engine problems whatsoever.

    Hatchbacks have a lot more space than you think.  I regularly fit 5 adults comfortably.  Most sedans say they fit 5, but really they fit 4. I can fit 2 carseats in the backseat, there's anchors built in and everything.  The trunk part under the hatchback is flat and large, so we're going to put the dog back there.  The backseat fold flat, and I've fit (separately of course) 4 chairs, 2 bicycles, and a 8ft X-mas tree back there.  Every single person who gets into my Prius for the first time goes "Whoa, it's really roomy in here."

    I get 46 MPG, it's pretty much the same for city and highway.  My iPod plugs right into the dash, and the steering wheel has radio and A/C controls on it, which is super helpful in rush hour traffic when I can't take my eyes off the road for a second.  It's the best car I've ever owned, period.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • My mom has a Ford Escape and absolutely loves it! She wants to trade it in soon and get a hybrid one.
  • We have a Clubman S and I really like it, but depending on the size of your dogs and how they travel, it may not be the best bet.  The dogs would fit if you didn't have them in crates and they were small, but when we take both of ours (a pug and pug mix), one is crated and we have to fold at least one of the seats down to fit it in there.  If you have bigger dogs, it may be uncomfortable for them.  The backseat definitely has enough room for two carseats, though.  I love having the third door :)  It gets SUPER good gas mileage and is surprisingly great in the snow- but we have heated everything on it, so that helps.  
    BFP #1: 3/20/10, EDD 11/22/12, DD born: 11/20/12
    BFP #2: 8/26/12, EDD 5/3/12, M/C 9/4/12
    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
    Living Simple Blog
  • Chevy and GMC make hybrid SUV's too by the way. I will say I work for GM and driving around in that thing with the engine off is pretty cool.

     I drive a 2006 saab 9-3 wagon and it fits 100lbs of puppies in the back. The back seat isn't fit for adults, but I get great mileage and the turbo charger gives plenty of power. The dogs love it, I love it, and it was pretty cheap (I got it used) considering the leather, sunroof, ipod, turbo, and 25-30mpg I get.

  • We're in the same boat. We're up to three dogs and doing IVF soon, so multiples are a very real possibility. I got a Jetta diesel wagon last year. We drove it across the country last month and averaged 42mpg. All three dogs fit in the back (the two big ones are very comfortable) and we have a factory pet divider for everybody's safety.
    Twin boys due 7/25/12
  • imagebeltonjc1:

    Chevy and GMC make hybrid SUV's too by the way. I will say I work for GM and driving around in that thing with the engine off is pretty cool.

    Any ideas if they're going to make hybrids for the Traverse or Arcadia?  Sorry, I figured I'd try.  DH and I love Travese/Arcadia/Enclave.  DH is 6'5" and not only do we have to worry about fitting 2-3 kids (we don't have any yet), a dog, and my mother in the car, By far, these vehicles fit what we want with the features we're looking for.  The Cx9 is a close second for me.  But the gas mileage isn't that great. 

     OP Audi has a Q7 with turbo disel that might work if you'll have the 3rd row down all the time.  If you need someone to sit in the 3rd row, I'll be tight.  I couldn't get back there and I'm 5'4". 

  • It's not a hybrid, but have you checked out the 2011 Ford Explorer?  I just read an article that it's 85% recyclable and offers navigation that will tell you the most fuel-efficient route to get to your destination. 
  • Jetta TDI wagon or Audi A3 TDI.

    We have an '09 Jetta TDI (sedan) and it's great. I drive mostly on the highway and it's super easy to get at least 50mpg. Around town it really varies--but I'd say in the 30-40 range is not difficult.

    If we can save up enough money, our next car will be the A3 TDI. It's really nice.

    I believe both are still eligible for a federal tax credit, too.

  • I have a Pontiac Vibe and with a lab and a rottie, I love my car!

    April is National Grilled Cheese Month. How are you celebrating? image
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards