August 2006 Weddings
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

What about Huckabee or Jindal?

I'm curious to hear from you guys.....I know you don't like Palin, but if McCain had picked Huckabee or Jindal what would you have thought?

I'm personally still wishing he had.

And so I say to you, you are Peter, and upon this Rock I will build my Church, and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against it.

Re: What about Huckabee or Jindal?

  • The reaction would have probably been the same if he chose Huckabee (claiming that he was pandering the the religious right). I'm thinking that Jindal would have been a more positive choice with regards to picking up independents, especially people who will now vote Libertarian.
  • image2Vermont:

    I'm curious to hear from you guys.....I know you don't like Palin, but if McCain had picked Huckabee or Jindal what would you have thought?

    I'm personally still wishing he had.

    Either of them would have been preferable to Palin.  I don't agree with Huckabee or Jindal on much of anything, but I don't question their intellectual curiosity or ability to think critically. 

    In case you're wondering where everyone went: http://pandce.proboards.com/index.cgi
  • I don't know much about Jindal, so I won't speak to him as an option. In regards to Huckabee, to borrow a line from Marquis, dude be crazy. I'd have been disappointed McCain picked him, but I do think he would have been a better option than Palin. A Huckabee pick may have left the dems/indep's assuming if he's pandering to the religious right, but the Palin pick has some of us speculating on his decision making process.
    Team Basement Cat imageKnitting&Kitties
  • For me (very moderate repub.) any pick that was right wing would have pushed me away from the party, I was hoping for a moderate since McCain had flopped to the ultra conservative side.  Now, I've given up hope of my party ever aligning with me so !Go Libertarians!
  • I don't know enough about Jindal to speak on him...but I would've been just as bothered by a Huckabee pick as I am about the Palin pick.

    I'm just not that conservative socially. So some of their policies are directly opposed to my feelings...

    I do think Huckabee is more likeable as a person. First off, he can laugh at himself...he actually went on Colbert, lol. And at the Republican convention, he was the only speaker that at least showed some respect towards Obama.

    My friend just keeps calling Sarah Palin a "Mean Girl" (as in like the movie) and after her speech at the convention, I have to say I kind of agree...I get that VPs are supposed to be the attack dogs, but man...the "He doesn't see the US the way we do," stuff from the other day...Are you kidding me? That made me want to scream.

     

  • Jindal is young and smart and very conservative. He has an impressive resume so he isn't as wet behind the ears as pp stated. He would have been a great pick for everyone but us from Louisiana as we were not ready to lose him as governor!  And I believe that is why he kept saying he would not take the job. He did just start his term this past January.

    As for Huckabee, I think he would been okay as well. Sure some liberals didn't like him because of his "religiousness" but he is likeable guy. In Arkansas he didn't try to rule from the pulpit and was well liked by both sides. I remember in one of my classes when we discussing the fair plan which he supports, the Obama supporters said they loved Huckabee because of his religious morals. Now these were all African-Americans and church is very big in their culture.

  • Palin IS Huckabee.  I would hope the reaction to either of them would be the same.
  • My reaction to Huckabee would have been the same. Maybe worse since he actually said he thinks the constitution should be amended to match christian beliefs.

    I do not know enough about Jindal to have an informed opinion.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • The only difference between Palin & Huckabee is that he completed his governor's term. They're the same in terms of policy. Huckabee is funnier and better at speaking (than all 4 of the candidates) but the vitrolic reaction from the left would have been equally as bad.?

    I pink puffy heart Jindal but I don't want someone of his caliber ramshackled to McCain. Jindal 2012. ?

  • imageBlackMamba*:
    Palin IS Huckabee.  I would hope the reaction to either of them would be the same.

    Now wait a minute!  I remember many a back-and-forth with you about Huckabee...you always maintained that you liked him (or at least tolerated him) and insisted that he wasn't that bad whenever I said that he was the imp of satan.  And now that I've seen Palin, Huckabee seems infinitely more appealing.  Are you saying you have the same warm and fuzzy feelings for Palin that you had for Huckabee?

    *disclaimer--I know you didn't with Huckabee on much; I'm not claiming you were a big fan.

    In case you're wondering where everyone went: http://pandce.proboards.com/index.cgi
  • I don't know enough about Jindal to speak about him.

    As far as the religious element, Huckabee and Palin seem the same to me -- both scary.  However, I am not aware of Huckabee employing the same kind of cronyism that Palin has, nor was he found guilty of ethics violations.  I don't think he'd be making the same kind of nasty "jokes" that Palin makes (and Giuliani makes as well).  I'd appreciate it if the campaign didn't have that element.  I don't see Huckabee blatantly refusing to hold a press conference like Palin -- nor would he get away with it if he tried.  Overall, I would have been more comfortable with Huckabee... but not by much.

    And just for fun: http://tinyurl.com/2awdtl


  • If they would've had Huckabee coming out and spewing hate the way Palin is, my heart would be broken.  Huckabee is my only hope that right-wing religious fanatics CAN be somewhat reasonable.  I think his good naturedness (is that a word?) is possibly why he wasn't chosen.  I disagree with his policies and his interpretation of his religion, but I think he's nicer and even smarter than Palin.  Like PP said, he's been on shows like Colbert and SNL, which have indicated a sense of reality and self-awareness that I do not believe Palin possesses.
    image
    "As of page 2 this might be the most boring argument ever. It's making me long for Rape Day." - Mouse
  • Honestly, I think Huckabee and Palin are worlds apart. ?I truly believe the Republicans missed the boat by not choosing him. ?He almost makes me cheerful that he's a major social conservative. ?And I love a true populist. ?He's personable, smart, witty, and honestly comes across genuine. ?While i feel he's misguided, I think he?genuinely?cares about people. ?Sarah Palin comes across dull, unthoughtful, etc. ?
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagezoegirlTX:

    he couldn't ahve used all these racial/ethnic undertones taht he gets away with when a nice white lady starts to question Obama's patriotism and motives. 

    I'm sorry but what the hell are you talking about Zoe? 

    A government big enough to give you everything you want is a government big enough to take from you everything you have. A new beginning Lap Band in Nov. '11
  • Hmmm, I initially defended the Palin pick, so I don't see any difference my reaction to either of them there.   I'm not sure what you are asking.  Is there a discrepancy in my reaction to either of them that you are detecting?
  • LOL you think she actually called him a terrorist. How is that racist BTW?
  • imagezoegirlTX:
    imagepvillewife06:
    imagezoegirlTX:

    he couldn't ahve used all these racial/ethnic undertones taht he gets away with when a nice white lady starts to question Obama's patriotism and motives. 

    I'm sorry but what the hell are you talking about Zoe? 

    umm...have you seen any of her rallies?  The intro speakers using his middle name, the prayers, her basically calling him a terrorist. 

    I'm confused.  Is the nice white lady Palin? 

    And no, I have not seen any of her rallies but I'm trying to go to the one around here on Thursday if I can take a personal day.

    A government big enough to give you everything you want is a government big enough to take from you everything you have. A new beginning Lap Band in Nov. '11
  • imagepvillewife06:
    imagezoegirlTX:

    he couldn't ahve used all these racial/ethnic undertones taht he gets away with when a nice white lady starts to question Obama's patriotism and motives. 

    I'm sorry but what the hell are you talking about Zoe? 

    You should watch clips from the last week or so of McCain/Palin appearances.  They are definitely inciting hateful/racist responses by invoking fear tactics. 

    They are actively painting Obama as "an other", saying he "pals around with terrorists" and trying to scare people who are bigoted towards Arabs by repeatedly using Obama's middle name, stirring up the "he's a terrorist" fears.   This has elicited the crowd calling out things like,  "terrorist," "kill him!" and "treason".   

    It's ugly.  And it's racist, no matter how you slice it.

  • imagecaden:

    The only difference between Palin & Huckabee is that he completed his governor's term. They're the same in terms of policy. Huckabee is funnier and better at speaking (than all 4 of the candidates) but the vitrolic reaction from the left would have been equally as bad. 

    I pink puffy heart Jindal but I don't want someone of his caliber ramshackled to McCain. Jindal 2012.  

    Huckabee did more than complete his term. After being elected to fill in a remainder term he then went on to be re-elected twice serving nearly 11 years as governor. That is a heck of a lot more executive experience than Palin or any of the other candidates!

  • He was reelected twice? That is a long time to be governor!
  • imagelyssbobiss:
    I don't know enough about Jindal to give you a good answer about that - but I really find Huckabee likeable as a person, even though I don't agree with him on anything.  I think he honestly has good intentions and is a good person, and I probably would've had a more favorable opinion of the campaign. 

    Ditto this. From a policy standpoint, I would probably feel the same way (i.e. PLEASE don't vote for this person!) but I have a lot more goodwill toward Huckabee as a person and I think he would have been more respectful towards Obama. I also think that Huckabee is somewhat more educated on the issues than Palin and quite frankly, he doesn't sound totally clueless when interviewed.

    "I
  • Ah, how quickly we forget!

    Huckabee has always been charismatic, that's true, but that doesn't mean he was always a respectful candidate.  Remember the subtle mormon slam?

    And let's take those extreme social conservative views.  Palin may have them, yes, but it is Huckabee who actually wanted to enforce them.

    (Note: there's a difference between Huckabee saying students should be given exposure to evolution and Palin saying schools should have the right to teach creationism.  Do you see the difference?)

    Then with regards to gay marriage, can we say covenant marriages?

     

    There's a reason I kept repeating 'dude be crazy' back in the day.  I am a Christian.  I am a conservative.  And I like Chuck Norris.  But Huckabee, as charismatic as he is, is in no way better than Palin.  I will accept those who claim they are more or less the same.  But you can't compare Palin now to Huckabee now, because Huck is no longer a candidate and is thus free to be his cheerful and charismatic self.  But if he were running, he would be an attack dog, just in a more passive aggressive way.

  • Also, re abuse of power: what about the time Huckabee's son killed a dog?  Remember that?
  • imageMeganne1164:
    imagecaden:

    The only difference between Palin & Huckabee is that he completed his governor's term. They're the same in terms of policy. Huckabee is funnier and better at speaking (than all 4 of the candidates) but the vitrolic reaction from the left would have been equally as bad. 

    I pink puffy heart Jindal but I don't want someone of his caliber ramshackled to McCain. Jindal 2012.  

    Huckabee did more than complete his term. After being elected to fill in a remainder term he then went on to be re-elected twice serving nearly 11 years as governor. That is a heck of a lot more executive experience than Palin or any of the other candidates!

    This experience and his qualifications is why I don't see how anyone can say Palin=Huckabee.  The only area that I see them the same is in the social arena....which is why I asked...why not Huckabee McCain?

     

    And so I say to you, you are Peter, and upon this Rock I will build my Church, and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against it.
  • imageMarquisDoll:
    Also, re abuse of power: what about the time Huckabee's son killed a dog?  Remember that?

    I agree this is appalling.  But there is a difference in abusing power you have as an elected executive and killing a dog.  Both are awful, but Huckabee didn't kill the dog.  Palin *did* abuse her power.

  • imagesoprano87:

    imageMarquisDoll:
    Also, re abuse of power: what about the time Huckabee's son killed a dog?  Remember that?

    I agree this is appalling.  But there is a difference in abusing power you have as an elected executive and killing a dog.  Both are awful, but Huckabee didn't kill the dog.  Palin *did* abuse her power.

    Okay, so that's a no, you don't remember.  Huckabee's son killed a dog.  Then Huckabee allegedly put pressure on the director of the state police to deny the prosecutor's request for an investigation.  7 months later, that same man was fired, and among the reasons given, he claims Huckabee said, 'I couldn't get you to help me with my son when I had that problem.'

  • imagezoegirlTX:

    imageMarquisDoll:

    Okay, so that's a no, you don't remember.  Huckabee's son killed a dog.  Then Huckabee allegedly put pressure on the director of the state police to deny the prosecutor's request for an investigation.  7 months later, that same man was fired, and among the reasons given, he claims Huckabee said, 'I couldn't get you to help me with my son when I had that problem.'

    Nice....just like Palin!

    Call me cynical but I think all politicians abuse their power. I don't mean to give a pass to it but until I find a saint running for office I have to weigh out their qualifications on other things.

    I think Huckabee would have been a better pick than Palin in terms of experience and likability. I have my doubts on how much he would have run the govt. from his pulpit. I have not done alot of research to see if he did that in Arkansas. But I do know he was a popular governor with Republicans & Democrats in his state and did a fairly good job of working across the political aisle. Of course we are talking Arkansas which like Louisiana has many conservative Democrats.

  • Ditto Meganne on the cynical view of politicians and their power. Palin did nothing illegal whatsoever. Not only did she not fire Monegan simply b/c he refused to fire a bad cop who should have been fired, her actions are limited to affecting only the few people in question. Biden's and his son's questionable role in passing banking legislation affects an industry. Obama's unethical actions in Iraq affect an entire country.
  • imageMarquisDoll:
    imagesoprano87:

    imageMarquisDoll:
    Also, re abuse of power: what about the time Huckabee's son killed a dog?  Remember that?

    I agree this is appalling.  But there is a difference in abusing power you have as an elected executive and killing a dog.  Both are awful, but Huckabee didn't kill the dog.  Palin *did* abuse her power.

    Okay, so that's a no, you don't remember.  Huckabee's son killed a dog.  Then Huckabee allegedly put pressure on the director of the state police to deny the prosecutor's request for an investigation.  7 months later, that same man was fired, and among the reasons given, he claims Huckabee said, 'I couldn't get you to help me with my son when I had that problem.'

    Wow, no, I hadn't heard those details.   Thanks for sharing.

    Abuse of power for everyone!  Whee!

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards