Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

MIL and Family photos

So my DH's family has NEVER had family portraits done.So I decided that since we just had our little man and we are leaving in February, the time was due. My dh is going into the Army btw and I think his mother has some hard feelings against me, even though it was his decision.

ANYWAY, we are taking pictures when she says, I haven't ever had just MY family together, so they take a picture with out me and the baby.Totally Fine. After a few other poses, she tells me and my mother ( I had my family come to get some shots together)  to get out and give the baby to my Dh so the entire family can take a picture together -with out me. I was in udder shock. So I said "He came out of me you know...." and she got upset and ran around the barn and cried. I wrote her a letter in a card explaining why I said what I said and other things, such as supporting her son in this big decision. So we will see how she reacts to that......

I know how I feel about this but I definitely would like an outsiders view!! TIA

Re: MIL and Family photos

  • It's *utter* shock, but since you were in a barn, maybe it was udder shock.  (Couldn't resist.)

    IMO it would be OK to have just the immediate family (MIL/FIL/your DH) for one picture.  That wouldn't bother me one bit.  But to have a pic with them and your baby and not you seems rude to me.  

    You were well within your right to not let them have the baby in the picture without you, but were you snarky?  Your comment as posted here has a bit of edge to it.  It would have been better to politely say, "If 'baby' is in the picture, I'd like to be, too."   

     

  • Good one! I didn't realize I did that!! oopsTongue Tied

    I may have had a bit of attitude, but I had apologized directly after when she was walking away.

     

  • What did your husband say when his mother demanded a picture with your baby but not you?
  • imagecasmgn:
    What did your husband say when his mother demanded a picture with your baby but not you?

    I'm also curious about this.

  • He did not say anything to her, his mother has this kind of affect on him :( I was a little disappointed in him for that... and let him know.
  • If she had wanted say all the men (FIL, DH, son) I could totally see that.  But to have the whole fam *except* you.... not cool.

    I think it was good to say something in the moment rather than let it fester.  Whether it came out sounding mean, or whether she was just hyper sensitive to it bc she knew she was in the wrong...  well who cares, you apologized, time for her to move on IMO. 

  • While your MIL was rude, like most other problems it comes down to being a DH problem. If your DH won't tell his mother to stop being rude to you, then it's never going to stop. And he needs to tell her in the moment - i.e. "Mom, we're not taking a picture with baby if Ashley is not in the picture"
  • OMG just asked DH what he would do in this situation, he said "I can understand. It's HER kids and HER grand-kid". I'm mortified. He said he doesn't think it would ever happen, idk. You were totally justified.
  • Also, if it's not too late do not send the letter. Letters never end well - it's too easy for someone to read a tone that isn't intended into a letter.
  • I thought Army guys were supposed to be tough.  Why does he turn into such a wiener around mommy?

    Sounds like he needs to be informed that if he wants to remain married, he WILL start putting his wife before his mom. 

  • 1st: I love that you said the baby came out of you lol that exactly what I would have said lol

    2nd: you should be seriously pissed at ur H for not taking up for you. one pic I get but not several and not any with your baby and not you hellzz no! If its his family causing the issue he should fight the battle for you IMO that is

  • ALL your anger should be directed at your H.

    Your response was perfect! I certainly wouldnt be apologizing to the drama queen.



  • Your MIL wasn't crying b/c her feelings were hurt.  She was crying b/c you weren't allowing her to get her way and exclude you. 

    You did the right thing.  You've sent the letter, now stop apologizing.  You're just giving her more power and more attention than she deserves. 

    PS:  Who paid for the photos?  If there are any with the baby and not you that WERE taken, I would not allow them to be available.

     

  • imagesuzymarie:

    If she had wanted say all the men (FIL, DH, son) I could totally see that.  But to have the whole fam *except* you.... not cool.

    I think it was good to say something in the moment rather than let it fester.  Whether it came out sounding mean, or whether she was just hyper sensitive to it bc she knew she was in the wrong...  well who cares, you apologized, time for her to move on IMO. 

    Exactly this. And I would be clear to H that no only was he wrong to not speak up, but he will be speaking up at the next instance or his wife and baby would be leaving such future event.
  • OMG, REALLY???? Running around the barn crying because you put her in her place for something you were definitely in the right to do?? She sounds like a serious drama queen. I'd have been pretty pi$$ed too, if she tried not to let me be in the photo with my husbnad AND child. But I'm pretty appalled that your DH didn't stick up for you when she told you to "get out." Sounds like he needs to grow a set when it comes to his mommy.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • She cried over that?  Did anyone tell her to can it with the histrionics?
    image
  • I was the one that paid for photos, and i planned the whole event I am going to have the photographer delete the one that is with out me. Im glad I was on the right page, although my husband was not, we got into it about it and he learned his lesson. If this instance pops up again, he WILL know what to do.

    Thanks ladies!!

  • I hope everything works out for you and he stands up for you next time, but it's extremely troubling that your husband had to be told that it's not okay for his mom to treat you that way. You should be more upset about the fact that he is arguing with you over your right to be treated with human decency than you are about your MIL's actions.
  • I would be in complete disgust that my husband didn't say anything when he was asked to have my child in a family picture without me.  It makes it even worse that you are the one who organized and paid for the photographer.  Honestly, I'd have a hard time even giving his family copies.  I'd probably just choose one or two of the whole family and give her those and nothing else.  I'm glad you're deleting the one without you.  I hope you stand by that decision.  It might be a little different if this was her photography project- but it was yours.  And the baby thing...there is NO excuse for that.  Seriously, why did you apologize?  Are you speaking to your husband right now?  Has he addressed this behavior with his mother? 

     

    imageAshleykay32:

    I was the one that paid for photos, and i planned the whole event I am going to have the photographer delete the one that is with out me. Im glad I was on the right page, although my husband was not, we got into it about it and he learned his lesson. If this instance pops up again, he WILL know what to do.

    Thanks ladies!!

  • imagelipstick101:

    I would be in complete disgust that my husband didn't say anything when he was asked to have my child in a family picture without me.  It makes it even worse that you are the one who organized and paid for the photographer.  Honestly, I'd have a hard time even giving his family copies.  I'd probably just choose one or two of the whole family and give her those and nothing else.  I'm glad you're deleting the one without you.  I hope you stand by that decision.  It might be a little different if this was her photography project- but it was yours.  And the baby thing...there is NO excuse for that.  Seriously, why did you apologize?  Are you speaking to your husband right now?  Has he addressed this behavior with his mother? 

     

    imageAshleykay32:

    I was the one that paid for photos, and i planned the whole event I am going to have the photographer delete the one that is with out me. Im glad I was on the right page, although my husband was not, we got into it about it and he learned his lesson. If this instance pops up again, he WILL know what to do.

    Thanks ladies!!

    I agree that you were well within your rights saying 'No' to the picture because you paid for them. Whoever pays, has the last say in what pictures are taken. You shouldn't have let your MIL take any charge during the session.

  • imagePumpkin30:
    imagelipstick101:

    I would be in complete disgust that my husband didn't say anything when he was asked to have my child in a family picture without me.  It makes it even worse that you are the one who organized and paid for the photographer.  Honestly, I'd have a hard time even giving his family copies.  I'd probably just choose one or two of the whole family and give her those and nothing else.  I'm glad you're deleting the one without you.  I hope you stand by that decision.  It might be a little different if this was her photography project- but it was yours.  And the baby thing...there is NO excuse for that.  Seriously, why did you apologize?  Are you speaking to your husband right now?  Has he addressed this behavior with his mother? 

     

    imageAshleykay32:

    I was the one that paid for photos, and i planned the whole event I am going to have the photographer delete the one that is with out me. Im glad I was on the right page, although my husband was not, we got into it about it and he learned his lesson. If this instance pops up again, he WILL know what to do.

    Thanks ladies!!

    I agree that you were well within your rights saying 'No' to the picture because you paid for them. Whoever pays, has the last say in what pictures are taken. You shouldn't have let your MIL take any charge during the session.

    Even if MIL were paying for the photos, the OP was well within her rights to say that no pics of the baby were happening without her in them.  Nobody takes a pic of my kid without my permission. 

    image "Before you diagnose yourself with depression or low self esteem, first make sure you are not, in fact, just surrounded by assholes.
  • Your MIL only started boo-hooing because you busted her bubble of "OMG, I can't wait to have a happy little picture of my darling son holding my darling grandbaby with me and my lovely husband while we all pretend that I am still the #1 woman in their lives!" You are absolutely not in the wrong here- but your H allowed this to happen. If she wants a picture like this so badly, I would think that she would take the initiative to at least pay her own photographer. Delete the picture and send her ONE copy of a complete family portrait.
  • imageAshleykay32:
    He did not say anything to her, his mother has this kind of affect on him :( I was a little disappointed in him for that... and let him know.

     

    I would think you woudl be, he needs to step up and stop letting her have this effect on him.

     

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Jessbess24Jessbess24 member
    Third Anniversary First Comment
    edited August 2013
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards