Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

In Laws

I recently had my baby shower and although my own family gets on my last nerve, it ended up being a great shower.

Hubby's SIL is pregnant as well (2 months behind me) and ever since we've had our wedding (they had a courthouse rushed wedding-long story), bought our house and got pregnant, I feel she's jealous and trying to steal our shine. She's made small comments and his brother (my BIL) is extremely stand-offish and makes faces and comments all the time.

This weekend, the situation blew up! During the shower, his family sat in the back and basically had lots of side conversation, didn't play games, didn't talk to any of the other guests besides each other and BIL's best friend (who's my husband's friend as well) After the shower, my family cleaned everything up (his family sat on the couch talking). Didn't offer to help. I walked all my family out and told my mom how tired I was. My mom then asked everyone to leave. In laws refused to leave, so I just went to the master bedroom and asked my husband to ask them to leave. I was not ready mentally to confront the situation, but they waited til my entire family was gone to decide they wanted to talk about the issue.

Long story short, I ended up yelling and crying and screaming at them. His mother said I would be a horrible mother because I cussed a few times and I told her to go to h*** and get out of my house.

Now his whole family is mad at him for not "manning up" (direct quote from the texts) and even went so far as to tell him that he "knows who the problem is and until he fixes it, his life is going to be miserable." He was trying to be a mediator in the whole confrontation and didn't take anyone's side. Afterward, he told me he was disappointed in me and we had a talk.

Basically I feel like hubby is stuck between a rock and a hard place. He's been crying and I feel terrible. What do I do?

Re: In Laws

  • What exactly is 'the issue'?
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • Sounds like you have both inlaw and Husband problems my dear. Get to the bottom of this one quick. I have crappy in law problems and sometimes you just have to accept that they'll never play by your rules. Good luck!
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Aside from the screaming match, I'm not sure what you are angry about.  They showed up at your shower.  I'm not sure where it's expected that guests mingle with people they don't know (your friends and family), enthusiastically play all of the shower games, or help out. 

    If that was "the situation" that made you so angry, you need to accept that your ILS are different than you are and not very social.  Heck, they might not be very nice, but it's THEIR problem.

    What were you yelling and screaming about?  The fact that they didn't play "guess the poo (melted candy bar) in the diaper?"  That they didn't help serve or clean up?  What do your ILS think "the problem" is?

    How was the talk between you and your H resolved? 

  • This is confusing. What did they "confront" you about? Why were you yelling? Why didn't your H tell them to go home?
  • If everything you posted about the shower is true, I don't see what you are so upset about.

    Some people are more extroverted and love to mingle; others are more introverted and prefer to chat with people they know. Neither one is good nor bad, just different.

    Same with games. Some people like them, others don't. No big deal.

    You might have a bit of an inlaw problem, but I think you also have a bit of a "you" problem. Your behavior is playing a role in this conflict. Your ILs might owe you an apology, but it seems you owe them one as well.

    imageLilypie Fourth Birthday tickers
  • Were they "hosting" the shower?  In my mind, if they're not hosts, they don't have to do a thing, including cleaning.  It's awesome if they do, but certainly not expected.

    But like PPs, I'd like more information on what exactly the issue is. 

  • imageEastCoastBride:
    What exactly is 'the issue'?

    Someone is stealing her "shine".

  • They were hosts...all of them AND they didn't help clean/cook/host/serve at all. That is the issue.
  • imagebriteone007:
    They were hosts...all of them AND they didn't help clean/cook/host/serve at all. That is the issue.
    Well, I think there is a hell of a lot more to this story.  I have a feeling this isn't the first time you all have dealt w/ behavior like this, and it makes me wonder why you accepted an offer of a shower for them, and/or why you are expecting them to act any differently.

    Maybe I'm wrong, but I really just can't give any advice on what you've written. 

     

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • So your in-laws were the hosts... and they didn't send invitations, buy/serve any food, or run the party at all?  Who organized the games that they didn't participate in?  There were no refreshments at the party?
  • imagebriteone007:
    They were hosts...all of them AND they didn't help clean/cook/host/serve at all. That is the issue.
    I don't think you know what it means to "host". And I've never seen an entire family host.

    And how exactly are your BIL and SIL stealing your thunder? Are they not allowed to have a kid within a few months of you?

    Since you won't say what they wanted to talk to you about, I'm going to guess it had to do with you being a whiny b!tch about your BIL and SIL, and you being a sour puss during your shower because they didn't play games. Seriously - you told them to go to hell? Unless there is more to the story here, I agree with what your ILs told your husband - you are the problem here.

  • You like to create drama and make yourself out to be the victim don't you?

    From what you've written, you sound like the jealous one and you acted like the a$$ to your H's family at your shower (having your mom tell them to leave--seriously?)

  • Where was the shower held? Since you wanted your in-laws to leave, I'm assuming it was not at the home of anyone in your husband's family.
  • imageKaren2905:
    So your in-laws were the hosts... and they didn't send invitations, buy/serve any food, or run the party at all?  Who organized the games that they didn't participate in?  There were no refreshments at the party?
    Exactly.  this is why I just feel like we're missing a LOT.

     

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • imageEastCoastBride:

    imageKaren2905:
    So your in-laws were the hosts... and they didn't send invitations, buy/serve any food, or run the party at all?  Who organized the games that they didn't participate in?  There were no refreshments at the party?
    Exactly.  this is why I just feel like we're missing a LOT.

     

    Yeah, something is not adding up here. And yes, telling someone to go to hell because she was kind of a buzzkill at your shower is a complete overreaction, so unless your MIL did something else to provoke your outburst, I'd say you should be ashamed of yourself and I can see why your husband would be disappointed in you.
  • The "go to hell" was after the shower. And I don't need anyone judging me any further. Obviously I didn't convey the message properly. Thanks everyone. I will post elsewhere.
  • imagebriteone007:
    The "go to hell" was after the shower. And I don't need anyone judging me any further. Obviously I didn't convey the message properly. Thanks everyone. I will post elsewhere.

    ...or you could just try explaining more... 

    Just saying.

  • imageKaren2905:

    imagebriteone007:
    The "go to hell" was after the shower. And I don't need anyone judging me any further. Obviously I didn't convey the message properly. Thanks everyone. I will post elsewhere.

    ...or you could just try explaining more... 

    Just saying.

    Ditto.  we're not mind readers.  You can't realyl "convey" stories here.  You need to tell them in DETAIL if you want us to know the whole thing.
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • imagebriteone007:

     but they waited til my entire family was gone to decide they wanted to talk about the issue.

    What was the issue they wanted to talk about? You only mentioned your issue about their lack of help at the shower.
  • Yes, it's quite obvious the "go to hell" was after the shower. That's not the part that needed clarification. What we need to know is what issue it was that your in-laws were waiting around to talk to you about and what specifically it was that your MIL did or said to prompt you to tell her to go to hell. Is all of this because you felt they had a poor attitude about the shower, or was this the culmination of months or years of tension and animosity between you and your husband's family? All we're saying is that, considering the information you provided, it sounds like you were completely out of line. If there is more information that might change our perception of the situation, by all means, give it to us!

    If you're still reading instead of stomping your feet because you didn't get the validation you wanted, all I can suggest is marriage counseling. The problem is either that you have unrealistic expectations and poor communication skills, or your husband's family treats you badly and he lets them do it. In either case, it's a big problem and posting about it on a message board isn't going to make it better.

  • I think there are two "issues" here. First, the OP clearly likes to be the center of attention, and doesn't understand that HER milestone moments (like wedding and childbearing/birth) are not as important to everybody else as they are to her. She also doesn't like sharing her "shine." So, issue #1 is the OP. 

    Here's the second issue.

    imagebriteone007:

    Basically I feel like hubby is stuck between a rock and a hard place. He's been crying and I feel terrible. What do I do?

    Her H is a man-child who can't tell either his wife or his family when they need to shut up and grow up. 

    OP, what do you do? You grow the heck up. Your wedding and your childbearing is not the center of everybody's world like it was/is for you. They "hosted" a shower for you (or something, I'm still not really clear on the details), which is enough. 

    You come across as a judgmental child when you say things like, "They had a rushed courthouse wedding," and "They didn't even play the games!" 

  • I was completely on your side, OP, until you refused to explain!  I can, however, tell you that if I had a baby shower at my house (or a family member's house, since it doesn't sound like it was the house of any of your IL's) and they refused to leave DH would have a field day with them.  He'd probably end up calling the cops if they didn't leave.  If they wanted to have some "talk" for whatever reason at my house right after my baby shower that sure as hell wouldn't fly either.  Once again, he would be making them leave.  And if they made me cry at my baby shower (or anytime!)?!  He wouldn't be speaking to them for a long time.  Once again, his decision.  But then again my DH has a pair and doesn't let me fend for myself against his family.  He wouldn't be "mediating" fights between us, he'd be showing them the door.
    PitaPata Cat tickers PitaPata Cat tickers Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • imageapril77056:
    And if they made me cry at my baby shower (or anytime!)?!  He wouldn't be speaking to them for a long time.  Once again, his decision. 
    Your husband wouldn't speak to his family if they made you cry because they didn't play "baby shower bingo"?
  • imagebriteone007:

    Now his whole family is mad at him for not "manning up" (direct quote from the texts) and even went so far as to tell him that he "knows who the problem is and until he fixes it, his life is going to be miserable." He was trying to be a mediator in the whole confrontation and didn't take anyone's side. Afterward, he told me he was disappointed in me and we had a talk.

    Basically I feel like hubby is stuck between a rock and a hard place. He's been crying and I feel terrible. What do I do?

    What do they mean by manning up? There is no rock and a hard place since he is not married to his family. Why didn't he ask them to nicely leave so you could rest? Were you acting like a witch? Why is he disappointed in you? Does he expect you to be nice to them, but they can treat you like crap at your shower? Are you a sensitive person by nature?

    I don't care who is trying to steal your shine and neither should you. Why isn't your DH asking his bro what is up with the comments and faces. Also, what are these comments?

     

  • imagecasmgn:
    imageapril77056:
    And if they made me cry at my baby shower (or anytime!)?!  He wouldn't be speaking to them for a long time.  Once again, his decision. 
    Your husband wouldn't speak to his family if they made you cry because they didn't play "baby shower bingo"?

    I was referring to the "talk" afterwards.  I'm not going to cry if my IL's sit there and don't mingle at a babyshower... unless they are tears of joy.

    I still really really want to know what the talk was about.  

    PitaPata Cat tickers PitaPata Cat tickers Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • imageapril77056:

    imagecasmgn:
    imageapril77056:
    And if they made me cry at my baby shower (or anytime!)?!  He wouldn't be speaking to them for a long time.  Once again, his decision. 
    Your husband wouldn't speak to his family if they made you cry because they didn't play "baby shower bingo"?

    I was referring to the "talk" afterwards.  I'm not going to cry if my IL's sit there and don't mingle at a babyshower... unless they are tears of joy.

    I still really really want to know what the talk was about.  

    Since the OP refuses to answer that question, I have to imagine it was along the lines of "Why are you such a raging b!tch to all of us just because BIL and SIL dared to get pregnant and we chose to talk to each other today rather than sticking our noses to guess what candy bar was melted into a diaper?" Quite frankly, I don't blame them one bit if that is what the talk was about.
  • imagecasmgn:
    imageapril77056:

    imagecasmgn:
    imageapril77056:
    And if they made me cry at my baby shower (or anytime!)?!  He wouldn't be speaking to them for a long time.  Once again, his decision. 
    Your husband wouldn't speak to his family if they made you cry because they didn't play "baby shower bingo"?

    I was referring to the "talk" afterwards.  I'm not going to cry if my IL's sit there and don't mingle at a babyshower... unless they are tears of joy.

    I still really really want to know what the talk was about.  

    Since the OP refuses to answer that question, I have to imagine it was along the lines of "Why are you such a raging b!tch to all of us just because BIL and SIL dared to get pregnant and we chose to talk to each other today rather than sticking our noses to guess what candy bar was melted into a diaper?" Quite frankly, I don't blame them one bit if that is what the talk was about.

    I agree OP is an AW and BSC, but I really don't think her IL's sitting there refusing to leave after her babyshower and demanding to talk, when she doesn't want to, is right.  I think they're all wrong.

    PitaPata Cat tickers PitaPata Cat tickers Daisypath Anniversary tickers
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards