April 2010 Weddings
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Help settle a debate.

DH and I were debating this the other day and I'm curious what other people would think.

He was telling me how his office is taking up a collection for his boss's Christmas gift and that they were going to get him a gift card some place. He said the total would probably be around $150-200. Now I understand wanting to thank your boss and give him a gift, but the problem I have is that he's also the owner of the company. He signs their paychecks and all they work they do goes almost directly into his pocket. I don't feel like they should give him a cash gift because of this. I think something smaller would be appropriate, like a nice card and maybe a small box of chocolates or something, but not a large gift card. If it was a large corporation and he was just a supervisor who had nothing to do with their pay and was not directly benefiting from their work, I wouldn't have a problem with the gift.

 So what do you ladies think? And please explain why you picked what you did, I would love to hear a different opinion on this subject.

 [Poll]

 

image
Lilypie First Birthday tickers

Re: Help settle a debate.

  • why don't they get him a new calendar for his desk for next year - or a "work humor" trinket? is there a reason? did something recently happen or is his birthday near that they are contributing for that as well? $150-$200 is triple the limit my husband and i have set for one another - let alone it being an amount given to one of our bosses!
  • imagejenif:
    why don't they get him a new calendar for his desk for next year - or a "work humor" trinket? is there a reason? did something recently happen or is his birthday near that they are contributing for that as well? $150-$200 is triple the limit my husband and i have set for one another - let alone it being an amount given to one of our bosses!

     

    It's a collection from the whole company, so it's probably about $10 per person, but still. It rubs me the wrong way.

    image
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • I definitely see your point.  It's kinda like the whole "don't tip the owner" rule.  But, if he's a great boss, and his employees just wanna show their appreciation, then they might be really happy to contribute towards a cash gift.

     

  • I didn't vote b/c I just don't know!! One the one hand, like Allison said, if he is a wonderful boss and it's only taking a small amount per person, it makes sense. Also sometimes it's just easier to get cash/gift card than to try to come up with a gift idea.

    But I also see your point. They make him all his money and he's obviously much wealthier than they are, so why should he profit more from that? I guess it all turns on whether they are doing it because they really appreciate him, or whether it's just a standard "boss" gift.

  • I actually picked the last one because while I think there's no need to give him a cash gift, he's still the boss so giving him a gift in general would be a good gesture.

    Depending on what he likes, I would go with a gift that he can most likekly eat or drink; a gift set for a nice liquor with some glasses....a summer sausage, cheese and cracker set....a gift basket with different foods and drinks in it

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagefestivegal2008:

    I actually picked the last one because while I think there's no need to give him a cash gift, he's still the boss so giving him a gift in general would be a good gesture.

    Depending on what he likes, I would go with a gift that he can most likekly eat or drink; a gift set for a nice liquor with some glasses....a summer sausage, cheese and cracker set....a gift basket with different foods and drinks in it

     

    This is what I would prefer happen. I don't have a problem with a gift in general, but I do have a problem with such a large gift. It just seems off to me. Why can't they buy the guy some chocolates or something? 

    image
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • I think that something small to show appreciations is nice, but there is no need for everyone to put in $10 to give a cash like gift.
  • imagefestivegal2008:

    I actually picked the last one because while I think there's no need to give him a cash gift, he's still the boss so giving him a gift in general would be a good gesture.

    Depending on what he likes, I would go with a gift that he can most likekly eat or drink; a gift set for a nice liquor with some glasses....a summer sausage, cheese and cracker set....a gift basket with different foods and drinks in it

    This! I also picked the last one...it doesn't need to be so much, but a gift from all of the employees seems fair, especially if he does treat them well!

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagefestivegal2008:

    I actually picked the last one because while I think there's no need to give him a cash gift, he's still the boss so giving him a gift in general would be a good gesture.

    Depending on what he likes, I would go with a gift that he can most likekly eat or drink; a gift set for a nice liquor with some glasses....a summer sausage, cheese and cracker set....a gift basket with different foods and drinks in it

    This!  I also picked the last option.  I think it's always a good idea to show appreciation, if it is deserved!  I think they should pool their money and have a party or something - so that everyone will benefit and they can show the boss that they are appreciative.  I agree that cash is a terrible idea given that he is the owner of the company 

    ~Margaret (and Nick)~
    Post-Wedding Life Blog!
    A10 Siggy Challenge: Next Vacation Destination: San Francisco!
    image
    image
  • imagefestivegal2008:

    I actually picked the last one because while I think there's no need to give him a cash gift, he's still the boss so giving him a gift in general would be a good gesture.

    What about collecting $$ and give it to a charity in his honor? May be he has a cause that he's interested in or there may be a local charity that could use a boost. With this terrible economy I think it's very appropriate to give to those who are less fortunate. I'm sure that the boss/owner would be touched knowing that his employees have such big hearts. 

     

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Sweet moment with SD Image and video hosting by TinyPic Me & Dad Image and video hosting by TinyPic Image and video hosting by TinyPic May Siggy - Favorite Flower : Yellow Jonquill Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • imagencsu4ganne:
    imagefestivegal2008:

    I actually picked the last one because while I think there's no need to give him a cash gift, he's still the boss so giving him a gift in general would be a good gesture.

    What about collecting $$ and give it to a charity in his honor? May be he has a cause that he's interested in or there may be a local charity that could use a boost. With this terrible economy I think it's very appropriate to give to those who are less fortunate. I'm sure that the boss/owner would be touched knowing that his employees have such big hearts. 

     

    I vote for this idea if they want to spend that much!

    Otherwise I think a smaller gift would be appropriate.   He's making the big bucks already. 

    ~Melissa~
    Shmel's Blog
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards