Rhode Island Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

What was your biggest cooking snafu?

Every time I make my gravy for pasta I think of the time I thought that Bay Leaf and Basil were the same thing. 

I was about 19/20 and making a pasta recipe that called for chopped fresh basil.  I only had dried bay leaf so I chopped up the required amount and added it to the recipe.  Needless to say, it sucked.

 

So what was yours?

Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

Re: What was your biggest cooking snafu?

  • I gave my boyfriend salmonella once while trying to make chicken parm from scratch.
  • omg amy!!!  that is terrible!!!! that poor guy! nothing as bad as you two, but i tried to make a fancy soup for  my fancy bil and sil and put in wayyy too much pureed basil and olive oil. the soup turned green and tasted gross. sil was pg and starving and ate just bread. dh made pasta because he felt bad.

    mila belle 3.26.07 and isla leighton 5.12.09 image mila belle aka mimi and belle and miss isla aka ileigh : ) pregnancy calendar
  • I hate salt.

    The first time I made a cake from scratch I didn't put the salt in b/c, well, I hate salt. It tasted ok, it just looked really, really bad

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • When I was a young teen, my sister and I made a chocolate birthday cake for my Mom. After putting the chocolate frosting on the cake, we wanted to decorate it. We'd never watched Mom make her frosting, so we guessed at what she did. I loaded Mom's pastry decorating tube with Marshmallow Fluff. 

    My hand shook so bad, I couldn't believe that my Mom was able to pipe these beautiful designs with this tube! I managed to get a "snowflake" onto the cake before giving up.

    The cake wasn't pretty, but it tasted wonderful. Mom laughed when she saw what we did! She taught us how to make her frosting after that: confectioners sugar + crisco + vanilla + water... and made us clean the pastry tube really well to get all the sticky fluff out of it!! (fortunately it dissolves/melts pretty well in hot water)

    image
  • i think when i made steph's beer braised beef i accidentally bought london broil instead of chuck and though it smelled sooooooo good, the meat was so tough it was inedible.
    image
  • Hi ladies!

    I don't post much but I needed to add my cooking snafu because it is sure to get a few chuckles out of everyone.

    So I was home alone and wanted to make some of that fancy ramen soup stuff, the thai noodles kind. So I added the spices and stuff to the plastic container and put it in the microwave. Then I ran outside to take the dog out while it cooked.

    When I got back in it smelled like my house was on fire.

    I neglected to put water into the (dehydrated) soup.

    I melted the plastic container it was in. The smell was AWFUL. And my house smelled like that for DAYS! 

    It's a real good thing that my DH is a fabulous cook!!!

    -Haley

  • Oh I've got a few dooozies. Wes and I were young, maybe 23? I was making my sister's lasagna for the first time.  My dried thyme and dried basil were in very similar containers. I didn't pay any attention, and by accident put thyme (a LOT of thyme) in the sauce instead of basil. The lasagna tasted like dirt. Wes was so good and still ate it but he didn't want me making lasagna for a long time! He still hates thyme and I swear it's because of that screw up 10 years ago!!
  • For DH's last birthday he wanted a chocolate peanutbutter cake, so I found a great recipe and made it for him.  It was the middle of August, heatwave, no AC and I was also trying to get my house ready for his whole family to come over.  The recipe was very involved and had about 101 steps to it.   Well with everything else going on, I forgot to add the eggs!!!.   He ended up with Fudgy the Whale from Carvel instead.
    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • I've been MIA for a while as work has kept me hectic so I've been reading posts when I can, but I had to contribute here.

    I have 2 hilarious ones:

    1) When I was around 7 or 8 I think I tried to make peanut butter cookies from scratch for my uncle - he loved them, and I wasn't allowed to bake at home.  I mixed up tablespoon and teaspoon for the salt and sugar, so I put a tablepoon of salt and a teaspoon of sugar (The recipe called for a tablespoon of sugar and a teaspoon of salt) so the cookies were AWFUL!

    2) When I was a little older (12 or 13), I was home alone one day and wicked wanted popcorn, but we were out of the microwave bags.  We had kernels, so I decided to make it on the stove.  I didn't realize that corn syrup is different from vegetable oil and tried to use that....ha ha.  NO.  Not one pop and it ruined my mom's pan - it like burned kernals and corn syrup tar to the bottom of the pan.  To this day I don't think I've ever used corn syrup again for anything.  My mom still talks about this.  I blame it on her though since she wouldn't let me in the kitchen or teach me to cook.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I cut the tip of my thumb off making chicken soup for a sick boyfriend in a snowstorm when I lived alone.  It was fun driving to the ER in the snow with one hand all wrapped up!

    A few years ago I asked my husband to add fresh rosemary to a crockpot pork dish when he got home, since he used to work earlier day shifts.  He added like the whole bundle I got from the grocery store (seriously - a huge bunch of it).  It tasted like Pine-Sol.

    image
    It took 5 failed IUIs and a failed IVF, but our FET worked!
    My pregnancy after Infertility Blog
    Our baby girl was born on April 27, 2011!
  • I made the famous "engagement chicken" for Jay years ago when he first moved out of his parents house. Not only did it NOT end up in an engagement but lead to one of the biggest fights Jay and I have ever had to date. And when it was finally done cooking it was awful!!! It scared me away from cooking whole chickens which I have only ever done twice in my life. I am going to attempt it again this Sunday a different recipe I not dare try "engagement chicken" ever again. If you guys don't hear from me on Monday, my husband did it!!! hahaha...
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • OK, it wasn't me, and I won't share exactly WHO did this, but let me just tell you that cookie dough ice cream does not work as a substitute for milk when making mac-and-cheese... especially when you add hot dogs and tuna to it. Blegh!
    image
  • imageKris&Jay08:
    I made the famous "engagement chicken" for Jay years ago when he first moved out of his parents house. Not only did it NOT end up in an engagement but lead to one of the biggest fights Jay and I have ever had to date. And when it was finally done cooking it was awful!!! It scared me away from cooking whole chickens which I have only ever done twice in my life. I am going to attempt it again this Sunday a different recipe I not dare try "engagement chicken" ever again. If you guys don't hear from me on Monday, my husband did it!!! hahaha...

    What's "engagement chicken"??? 

  • Lemon eggs.  Nuff said.
  • imageammorgado:

    imageKris&Jay08:
    I made the famous "engagement chicken" for Jay years ago when he first moved out of his parents house. Not only did it NOT end up in an engagement but lead to one of the biggest fights Jay and I have ever had to date. And when it was finally done cooking it was awful!!! It scared me away from cooking whole chickens which I have only ever done twice in my life. I am going to attempt it again this Sunday a different recipe I not dare try "engagement chicken" ever again. If you guys don't hear from me on Monday, my husband did it!!! hahaha...

    What's "engagement chicken"??? 

    It was something silly from Glamour magazine. "Chicken so good he'll propose" Howard Stern even promoted it, haha

    http://www.glamour.com/magazine/2006/07/engagement-chicken

    Obviously I wasn't looking for a proposal just trying to cook a good Valentine's Day meal. Oh boy did it turn on me, haha.

    I obviously did something wrong because it didn't cook all the way through, and tasted too much like lemon for my taste.

    EDIT: Oh and we didn't fight because the chicken was awful. My husband would eat dirt and tell me it was good if I cooked it. This just added fuel to the fire. Didn't want you to think my husband was an asshat!!

     

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • When I was just out of college and working as a nanny, I couldn't find flour in the kids' house when we were making cookies. I use Bisquick instead and the cookies were TERRIBLE. 
  • These have been so funny to read. 
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I have managed on not 1 but 4 occasions to BURN the outside of a 'fresh' turkey and the inside didn't cook. It's gotten bad enough that my husband says "What's for dinner" I say "Turkey" and he says "Awesome, Pizza for dinner".

    And no, please don't give me suggestions on how to fix it, the damn bird just fvcking hates me no matter what temp/time I cook it for. Next time I'm deep frying the sonofabitch.

  • 1st. If I was a dude and my lady prepared me the "engagement chicken" I'd run away.  It looks like it's birthing, if you ask me.

     

    2.  I don't think I've ever had a snafu really, and not in that "I don't make mistakes" type tone.  I've made stuff that tasted awful, but it wasn't my fault.  There was some chicken crockpot recipe that was on Pam's site that I tried.. and holy hell.. it just looked and tasted like you were eating puke  Alpine chicken I think it was?   It's off the site now.

  • imagejanabanana823:

    1st. If I was a dude and my lady prepared me the "engagement chicken" I'd run away.  It looks like it's birthing, if you ask me.

     

    2.  I don't think I've ever had a snafu really, and not in that "I don't make mistakes" type tone.  I've made stuff that tasted awful, but it wasn't my fault.  There was some chicken crockpot recipe that was on Pam's site that I tried.. and holy hell.. it just looked and tasted like you were eating puke  Alpine chicken I think it was?   It's off the site now.

    hahaha, gross!!

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageach427:
    When I was just out of college and working as a nanny, I couldn't find flour in the kids' house when we were making cookies. I use Bisquick instead and the cookies were TERRIBLE. 

    Ha! This just reminded me of what my husband did just a few weeks ago (and he is an amazing cook)  On vacation he was making pancakes for M, got out the bisquick, read the directions on the box and couldn't figure out why the batter looked so strange and they weren't cooking right.  So he tried again.  same thing.  He finally realized that even though he was holding the bisquick box and reading it's directions he was measuring out a cup of regular flour instead of the mix, so basically he had made a flour & milk paste.  yum. He can be a total space cadet sometimes.

    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards