West Coast Florida Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

What are you thoughts on spanking?

Are you for it or against it?

Prior to having Macy, I just assumed that from time to time I would have to swat my kid (not beat them) just to get their attention.  Thankfully I haven't been forced with the decision to spank Macy thus far, but now I don't honestly know how I feel about it anymore.....

So, I just wanted to hear others thoughts :) 

image
Baby Macy is here!

12/09 - Macy (daughter) | 4/10 - Began TTC Baby #2 | 12/10 - Chemical Pregnancy | 1/12 - Miscarriage at 14 weeks | DX - PCOS & Hyperthyroidism

Re: What are you thoughts on spanking?

  • DD gets spankings as a very last resort option.  And by spanking, I mean a quick swat on the thigh or forceful pat on the diaper.  I don't drop kick her down the stairs or cane her for spilling milk.
    imageimage
  • I don't have any kids, but from my experience with my niece, there has never been a need.  Thankfully, she's a very well behaved little girl.  I feel that EVERY other discipline option must be exhausted to warrant a swat.

    PitaPata Dog tickers PitaPata Dog tickers BabyName Ticker
  • I'm fine with it as long as you aren't beating your child. I'm also fine with immediate family who watches our child to swat DS on the diaper if he acts up.
  • I'll never say never.

    DD was an angelic toddler who threw a grand total of two 15 second temper tantrums in her entire life.  I never needed to resort to a swat on the backside to get her attention.

    DS, on the other hand, is a cute but devious little toddler.  I can't rule out the possibility in the future.  Daddy can just give him a disapproving look and he dissolves into tears and sticks out his pouty lip, but if mommy tells him no, he just laughs and goes back to what he's doing.  I'll let you know if we ever have to pull out the spanking card on him.  I consider it a last resort, but if that's what it takes to get DS's attention and convince him not to do something that is very dangerous, I'm not above it.

  • I agree with pp's. It's not like I would start beating the crap out of her, like I have seen some parents do. My mom used to threaten us when we were misbehaving in public by pulling our ears close to her mouth and telling us she was going to spank our bottoms so hard we wouldn't be able to sit for a week. It was an empty threat, but for some reason we always fell for it and were pretty well behaved in public, lol!
    Anniversary Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker BabyFruit Ticker
  • Spanking yes, beating no. When DD was little and not listening I would swat her on the butt and tell her no. I never left a mark of course but it shocked her and she got the point not to do whatever it was she was doing.
  • imageChangeOfPace:

    I'll never say never.

    DD was an angelic toddler who threw a grand total of two 15 second temper tantrums in her entire life.  I never needed to resort to a swat on the backside to get her attention.

    DS, on the other hand, is a cute but devious little toddler.  I can't rule out the possibility in the future.  Daddy can just give him a disapproving look and he dissolves into tears and sticks out his pouty lip, but if mommy tells him no, he just laughs and goes back to what he's doing.  I'll let you know if we ever have to pull out the spanking card on him.  I consider it a last resort, but if that's what it takes to get DS's attention and convince him not to do something that is very dangerous, I'm not above it.

    This. We've never been in a situation where I thought it was appropriate or necessary so far, but particularly where safety is concerned (i.e., no running out in the road), I'd do what I have to do to keep her safe. I have had to forcibly take things away from her, but that's the most phsyical force I've ever felt the need to use with her. So far your basic distractions and just talking about what's nice and what's not nice have sufficed. With a timeout thrown in here or there, but not often.

    If there were some possible way that spanking would help her sleep better, I'd totally do it. Stick out tongue (OMG, so not serious about that, just in case you worried.)

    image
    My silly Lily is almost 4. BabyFruit Ticker
  • imageChangeOfPace:

    Daddy can just give him a disapproving look and he dissolves into tears and sticks out his pouty lip, but if mommy tells him no, he just laughs and goes back to what he's doing. 

    This is Macy.  I hope this doesn't become a problem in the future! 

    image
    Baby Macy is here!

    12/09 - Macy (daughter) | 4/10 - Began TTC Baby #2 | 12/10 - Chemical Pregnancy | 1/12 - Miscarriage at 14 weeks | DX - PCOS & Hyperthyroidism
  • K8- how's the tooth brushing going?
    PitaPata Dog tickers PitaPata Dog tickers BabyName Ticker
  • imagejen812:
    K8- how's the tooth brushing going?

    Only a little better. We've managed the last couple of nights, but it was painful. We've tried everything, it seems. Games of this or that in her mouth. No sweets. You brush the teeth, then mommy brushes. You brush mommy's teeth, then Mommy brushes yours. Brush the doll's teeth. Faking that I'm going to use her Cinderella toothbrush to brush Daddy's/the cat's/the doll's/whatever's teeth. I've even played dumb and asked her to tell me what to do. That worked, once, I think.  

    Last night we had this idea that I would just leave and not come back until she brushed her teeth. Well, that only seemed to traumatize her, and it didn't feel right anyway, like mommy's presence shouldn't be a tool in my arsenal. Then we tried taking a toy away, which is what worked the night before. But on top of the previous trauma, she was just too upset and it was clearly not going to work.

    What finally worked was a sticker for her chart. She has a sticker chart and she gets a sticker for every night she stays in bed after we turn the lights off. We haven't used that chart in weeks because she just started staying in her bed after awhile. So, now it's going to be a toothbrush sticker chart, I guess.  

    image
    My silly Lily is almost 4. BabyFruit Ticker
  • imagek8elee03:

    imagejen812:
    K8- how's the tooth brushing going?

    Only a little better. We've managed the last couple of nights, but it was painful. We've tried everything, it seems. Games of this or that in her mouth. No sweets. You brush the teeth, then mommy brushes. You brush mommy's teeth, then Mommy brushes yours. Brush the doll's teeth. Faking that I'm going to use her Cinderella toothbrush to brush Daddy's/the cat's/the doll's/whatever's teeth. I've even played dumb and asked her to tell me what to do. That worked, once, I think.  

    Last night we had this idea that I would just leave and not come back until she brushed her teeth. Well, that only seemed to traumatize her, and it didn't feel right anyway, like mommy's presence shouldn't be a tool in my arsenal. Then we tried taking a toy away, which is what worked the night before. But on top of the previous trauma, she was just too upset and it was clearly not going to work.

    What finally worked was a sticker for her chart. She has a sticker chart and she gets a sticker for every night she stays in bed after we turn the lights off. We haven't used that chart in weeks because she just started staying in her bed after awhile. So, now it's going to be a toothbrush sticker chart, I guess.  

    Oh good idea!  I didn't even think to suggest that.  Now that you mention it, I remember my sister having a sticker chart for all sorts of things.  If my niece filled it up at the end of the week, she rewarded her with a little surprise.

    I hope the brushing continues to get easier. 

    PitaPata Dog tickers PitaPata Dog tickers BabyName Ticker
  • I dont have a child yet but I am hoping to follow the same thought process my mom did with us which was never spanking us. I hope my child/children will be well behaved that I will never ever have to spank them but you never know. I think my mom spanked me once when I climbed up into the hall closet and got into some pills that were creme colored which matched the carpet and didnt know how many I had taken. So she spanked me.

    Like PP's I feel that if there is a situation where my child is in danger and a spanking will cause them to pay attention then I might choose to do that. Of course they will be swift taps not beating my child.

    Anniversary Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker image
  • I thought I would be a spanker...I got a swat here and there if I needed it.  DH is more of the spanker in our family and I am okay with it.  I only use it for last resort with Isaiah, but Dh has utilized it more than me if need be.  I hate the way he cries and his face crumbles when it happens so I find myself not doing it when I probably should.  He listens to DH SO well and with me he is not a great listener.
    Lilypie - Personal pictureLilypie Premature Baby tickers Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker image
  • imageFloridamom224:
    I thought I would be a spanker...I got a swat here and there if I needed it.  DH is more of the spanker in our family and I am okay with it.  I only use it for last resort with Isaiah, but Dh has utilized it more than me if need be.  I hate the way he cries and his face crumbles when it happens so I find myself not doing it when I probably should.  He listens to DH SO well and with me he is not a great listener.

    I have a feeling that this is how it will be in our house.  I have told Macy no a few times which has caused her to cry.  I was not prepared for how hard that would be on me!

    image
    Baby Macy is here!

    12/09 - Macy (daughter) | 4/10 - Began TTC Baby #2 | 12/10 - Chemical Pregnancy | 1/12 - Miscarriage at 14 weeks | DX - PCOS & Hyperthyroidism
  • We use spanking as a last resort option.  Q is generally a good kid, but can be purposefully naughty at times (purposefully being the key word).  Actually what we do probably doesn't even count as spanking, more like tapping his diapered bottom once or twice. 
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards