Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

MIL babysitting issue

I'm having an issue with MIL babysitting DD and I don't know how to say this to DH without making him feel bad.  First of all, I like my ILs.  They love DD so much and we always have fun when they visit.  My parents live a 2 hour plane ride away, and my ILs live a 1.5 hour drive away.  My parents are retired, my ILs are still working.  We have a nanny and part of her contract is 2 weeks paid vacation.  She already took one of the weeks and my mom came down to watch DD.  Now, our nanny is planning her next week of vacation, and DH wants his mom to watch DD during that time.  I think this is not a good idea.  MIL's health is not good.  She only works part time and that drains her.  She has to take a nap every day if she's not working.  I don't think she can keep up with a walking toddler for a week.  She has a hard time lifting and walking and DD is 21 lbs.  Also, my MIL is not the type of person to admit to her weaknesses.  She will insist that she's fine, play with DD all day, and then crash and need medication/therapy for her arms/back/shoulders the next day.  I'm fine with my ILs coming down and all of us hanging out with DD because if MIL gets tired, one of us can step in.

So, I think DH has this vision of his parents helping out equally as my parents and being super involved with taking care of DD.  He thinks my parents live too far away, although my mom has been saving her miles to come down whenever we want her to.  My mom handled DD great for the first week - my mom is in great health, active, etc.  I just think she's a better choice for this situation, but I'm not sure how to approach the subject with DH.  He already suggested having his mom come down to watch DD, and I told him we could discuss it when he got home because I didn't really want to get into it over the phone while he's at work.  Any suggestions on how to have this conversation?

Re: MIL babysitting issue

  • I would approach it as a safety issue both for you DD and you MIL.  Safety of your child should come first.  My own mother is not in the best of health and she won't be watching our ds.  It's nothing personal.  It's just physically too much for her.
  • imagebeyoga:
    I would approach it as a safety issue both for you DD and you MIL.  Safety of your child should come first.  My own mother is not in the best of health and she won't be watching our ds.  It's nothing personal.  It's just physically too much for her.

    Ditto this.  As much as you love MIL, you need to put your child first.  And - if MIL gets too tired, to sit two days in a row, who is going to call in sick?  Will it be your DH?  That could be 2-3 days.  Plus, how is she compensated for missing her part time job? 

    I would say "H, I love your mom, and I'm happy that she wants to watch DS, but a week of DS is physically too much for her.  It won't work, and I won't be comfortable leaving DS with her."

    As a solution - - would your mom mind "sharing" child watching if she comes down?  For example, if she comes for the week, but MIL joins her for a few mornings a week?  Would they get along and not be territorial?  Maybe your mom could leave DS with MIL one early afternoon, and meet you for lunch! 

    Good luck.

    image "Before you diagnose yourself with depression or low self esteem, first make sure you are not, in fact, just surrounded by assholes.
  • Your nanny gets 2 weeks of vacation...  how much do you get?  Can you or H take a week of vacation to spend at home with your daughter?  That would fix the problem. 
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • imageWahoo:

    imagebeyoga:
    I would approach it as a safety issue both for you DD and you MIL.  Safety of your child should come first.  My own mother is not in the best of health and she won't be watching our ds.  It's nothing personal.  It's just physically too much for her.

    Ditto this.  As much as you love MIL, you need to put your child first.  And - if MIL gets too tired, to sit two days in a row, who is going to call in sick?  Will it be your DH?  That could be 2-3 days.  Plus, how is she compensated for missing her part time job? 

    I would say "H, I love your mom, and I'm happy that she wants to watch DS, but a week of DS is physically too much for her.  It won't work, and I won't be comfortable leaving DS with her."

    As a solution - - would your mom mind "sharing" child watching if she comes down?  For example, if she comes for the week, but MIL joins her for a few mornings a week?  Would they get along and not be territorial?  Maybe your mom could leave DS with MIL one early afternoon, and meet you for lunch! 

    Good luck.

    Ditto to all of this.

    My parents, where BOTH of them watch DS for 2 days a week, admit that the 2 days is tiring. They are in good health and LOVE watching DS, but they fully admit the 2 days is "enough" (on top of other babysitting they do for us here and there).

    I'm GLAD they can admit to this. 

    My IL's are similar to yours - not in good health and other reasons why we just don't feel they can watch DS.  We would LOVE for them too- having 2 sets of grandparents would be great.  But in the end- this is about DS and his well-being.  Il's would never intentionally do anything to hurt DS, but there is just too much room for something to happen.

    Luckily DH is on the same page as me. 

    So I agree- focus on the safety aspect of it. For both your DS and his mom.

    In the end, access to your child isn't about "equality".  It needs to be about what is best for your DS.

    ETA:  Sorry, I meant DD.  ;)

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • I think that the way you said it to us is just fine.  Why would your husband be upset over that?
    image
  • Would your FIL be able to come with her to help out?  I agree with pp's, your child's safety comes first. Sorry, that's a tough one.
    image
  • Thank you, I will definitely focus on the safety issue.

    I'm not afraid DH will get upset about it, but I know he's having a hard time coming to terms with his mom getting older, health declining, etc..  So, I just wanted to figure out a more tactful way to discuss it with him.  I guess it helped writing it down.

  • To me, it isn't just a "yes, she can' or "no, she can't" thing. If your MIL wants to visit for the week and help-out while your nanny is on vacation, why not think about what you would need to make it work? Like taking turns with taking vacation days, hiring a mother's helper, etc. Sure, your mom was independent and just as good as a nanny, but you don't need a huge discussion that your MIL isn't. Just move forward with plans as a matter of fact.
    My darling daughter just turned 4 years old.
  • What if you and your H took turns taking half days off work that week?  That way MIL could be with your DD during the morning for a few hours then one of you can come home around noonish and take over, without missing TOO much time at work if either of you can't swing taking the whole week off?  That way MIL can still get her time in without becoming "over tired?"
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • How does your DH know his Mom would even want or be able to take time off of work? Would he expect her to drive the 3 hours round trip every day? Be there in time for you to leave in the morning? Is he trying to make things fair in his mind with the amount of time spent with DD? I'm curious if this is even an issue for his folks who might appreciate not having to be responsible for a child on their own at their age.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards