Austin Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Car Question + Poll

I drive a 10 year-old accord, with 140K miles on it.  Luckily, it's still in good mechanical shape, with periodic visits to my mechanic.

A few weeks ago, I got rear-ended at a yield sign by another accord.  The damage to my bumper is noticeable, and the appraiser thought that the bumper would need to be replaced.  It's quite scraped up around the license plate area, with a few small holes.

But, I'm wondering:  is it worth repairing?  I plan to keep driving my car for at least another year, because that makes the most financial sense to me.  Right now, the trade in value on a car my style/mileage in "fair" condition is about $1900.  Obviously, that amount is going down each day.  Maybe I should just cash the insurance company check and go along my merry way?  WWYD?

[Poll]

Re: Car Question + Poll

  • Oh gosh, that is tough.. I think I'd opt to get it fixed - I'm sure even if you sell it in a year (say, to a high school kid), it'd sell easier with a repair.  You could totally market it as having a brand new bumper!  However, if you are planning on just hanging on to it, I'd keep the cash.

    My first impulse however is to say take the money and run.:)

  • I'd get it fixed. It sounds like the type of damage that could get worse over time and rust, unless it's a plastic bumper.  If it's still in good mechanical condition, you'll be able to sell it whenever you're ready to with a little more ease having the body in pretty decent condition.
    We have so much time, and so little to do! Strike that, reverse it.
    My Bio (wedding pics added 7/6)
    My 101
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • It depends, are you going to try to sell the car or trade it in?

    If you plan to sell the car yourself, fix it. You'll likely get more that way. 

    If you're going to trade in the car, I don't think bumper damage will make a bit of difference. Both MH and I traded in our 10 year old cars a few years ago, and the cosmetic condition didn't seem to matter much. And we also didn't get very much, simply because they were so old. When you go that route, the $100 or so you might get for a more attractive car just feels like it's in the noise.


    image
  • imageChicklit:

    It depends, are you going to try to sell the car or trade it in?

    Good question!  I am most likely to trade the car in, since I can't imagine I'd want to deal with the hassle of selling it myself.  I mean, I've already avoided the hassle of getting it fixed for several weeks, now.  I call it my "hassle-free" lifestyle, but really I'm just lazy about exerting effort into tasks I think might be unpleasant.  Embarrassed

  • Hmm.. in that case, my vote changes to take the money and save it for a downpayment on top of the trade. :P
  • imageOrangeFelt:
    Hmm.. in that case, my vote changes to take the money and save it for a downpayment on top of the trade. :P

    Ditto! I wouldn't bother with fixing it unless you were going to try to sell it.  

    Business Cat. image
  • I would definitely take the money and run. Especially since you are planning on keeping it a while longer and will most likely trade it in. And if you haven't gone to get it fixed yet, it must not be too bad or bothering you, so I wouldn't worry about it Wink
  • I voted take the money and run. I have a 16-year-old Civic that I actually ran into a wall (not that hard -- just tapped the gas instead of the brake while parking) several years ago. The bumper is scraped up and it messed up my license plate, but it hasn't gotten any worse or caused any real problems with the car aside from the radiator needing to be replaced. Since then, I've even had a guy changing my oil ask if I'd ever consider selling the car to him. So I'd agree that it's not worth repairing because the bumper damage won't really affect the value of the car that much when you eventually sell it or trade it in -- the main issues are overall mechanical condition and mileage. A lot of Hondas are only middle-aged at 150k miles! :)
  • can you take a picture of the damage and show us? 

    I was driving on the freeway yesterday and there was a BMW X3 right in front of me - the entire bumper almost came apart. Indifferent  one of the sides of the back bumper was coming apart, bits of the plastic (or whatever it is) were flying off.  it was kind of crazy!

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • for your safety (since you'll be holding on to the car for a while longer), get the bumper replaced with the insurance money. this is JUST in case you get rear-ended again - you'll want that bumper to hold up to another impact.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards