October 2008 Weddings
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

What do I do?

Ok so a little back story. My sister is getting divorced. She had an affair with this guy and now they are together. She still lives in the house with my BIL who I loved. Anyways, she is now pregnant with twins and is due in August. She told me tonight that the new BFs mom wants to talk to me about having a baby shower for her. Well, I did this for her already for my nephew when he was first adopted. I don't like when people have second showers. I also was upset about the whole divorce and the fact that she lied for so many months. So what do I do? Do I look like the jerk sister and say hey I've done this already? Or do I bite my tongue. I should add that I might lose my summer school job so we are already trying to come up with that extra money.
image

Re: What do I do?

  • I would just say that you aren't in the position to host a shower right now.  She can take that as she wants.
    image
    Mrs. Little Drew 10/25/08
    Blog
    TTC since 1/2010 - Dx with Stage IV Endo
    11/10 - 100mg Clomid + trigger + IUI + Estradiol + Progesterone = BFN
    12/10 - Unmedicated cycle due to RE not doing treatments in December = BFN
    1/11 - 100mg Clomid + trigger + IUI + Estradiol + Progesterone = BFN
    2/11 - Same sh!t, different month = IUI cancelled due to no response = BFN
    IVF #1 - Start stims (Follistim) 5/10, add in Ganirelix 5/14
    ER 5/21 - 13 retrieved, 7 mature, 5 fertilized; ET 5/26 - transferred one perfect 1AA blast. 3 snowbabies.
    Beta 6/3 - 15.8; Beta 6/7 - 21.8; Beta 6/10 - 7 :(
    FET - Transferred 1 AA blast 7/11. Beta 7/20 - 311! Beta 7/22 - 784!! First u/s 8/10
    *~PAIFW/SAIFW~*
    BabyFruit Ticker
  • I agree with Tania.
    10.25.08
    Alexander David
    11.25.09
    image
    my blog
    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
  • I agree with Tania's suggestion. If it could potentially put you guys in a hard spot financially I wouldn't do it even if you wanted to do it. 
    Campbell James - 3.6.2010
    imageBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker Wives Unscripted My Blog
  • imageFutureMrsNAH:
    I agree with Tania's suggestion. If it could potentially put you guys in a hard spot financially I wouldn't do it even if you wanted to do it. 

    this 

    Jess and James 10.18.08
    Zoey Emma 08.18.10
    image
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I would just be honest with her. Just say that you can't afford it right now.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I guess I'm having a harder time with the second shower and the whole divorce/affair situation.  Of course I was planning on getting her something (most likely a double stroller) but I just see it as kind of gift grabby.  Wow, I sound like a bad sister.
    image
  • If you don't want to do it, don't do it. You do not sound like a bad sister

    Berly's Thoughts updated 4/2/2011
    Do you like jewelry? Buy 2 get 4 half off, your half off items are your most expensive items
    "One of the most courageous things you can do is identify yourself, know who you are, what you believe in and where you want to go." ---Sheila Murray Bethel
  • You are not a bad sister. I would be the same way with one of mine. I agree with Tania's suggestions. Even though it is not mainly about the money for you, do not tell the mother that. Just use the money as an excuse.
    I heart Ben!!
    October 11, 2008
    image
    imageLilypie First Birthday tickers
    Trusty Gal blog|Trusty Tales
  • imagemoviesprincess:
    You are not a bad sister. I would be the same way with one of mine. I agree with Tania's suggestions. Even though it is not mainly about the money for you, do not tell the mother that. Just use the money as an excuse.

    This.

    Weigh In #7 -Fat and Sassy Em


    Welcome to the dark side
    image
  • Everyone's given you good advice on how to ANSWER her, but you still should work on your own feelings, or they're going to keep coming up as a barrier for you, and could impact your relationship in the short or long run.

    Who knows what kind of conversation happened between your sister and her BF"s mom?  Does his mom have other grandchildren? If not, she may view this as her first opportunity to go to a shower for grandchildren. 

    And, to be honest, as much as it's a second shower for *her*, it's not a second shower for her with the same father. It's a bit different, and traditional rules we all grew up with an feel comfortable with don't always apply to the modern world. 

    Even if *you* don't throw one for her, someone might, so you may just have to figure out how to get on board with the notion that the life you imagined to have with your sister -- this one husband, raising kids and families together with you and your own family -- isn't what's going to happen in the future.  And that means that some things are going to come up -- like a different family wanting to have a shower -- that might feel out of whack.   

    Your sister is going to need support from the people who do and who do not know her well, who will judge and question for the next many months, maybe longer.  Be the sister you'd want to have if you found yourself on the path you never thought you'd be on.  

    That doesn't mean "throw her a shower". It means "find the best way to make sure she knows your still her sister, you still lover her, and you've got her back."   It doesn't mean spending money, but it does meaning making sure you're honest with yourself and with her about what you're struggling with and where you're trying to get to, for you, for her, and for you soon to be nieces or nephews.   One step at a time, and you'll get there, and learn to love her and her new life, regardless of whether or not she made the same choices you think you would in her shoes,

    Good luck! 

  • What pp said, just say you can't afford it.  I would have a hard time with it too.

    I mean if you wanted to be somewhat generous you could maybe volunteer to bring a dish, but I wouldn't go further than that.

     

  • What everyone else has said - say you can't afford it at this time.  I'm with Shaina and volunteer to bring a food dish and go over a little early to help decorate and setup if they need the help.

    I also agree with Kathy, you need to resolve your feelings with the new relationship.  We're in a similar situation with DH's sister, except there are no kids involved and she doesn't still live with her ex.  She's marrying the guy she had a year long affair with next month (They've been together for 2 or 3 years now).  We all really loved her first husband and have had a hard time adjusting to the new guy.  He is a nice guy and treats her well and make her happy.  And that is what we try to focus on.  We do still have the fact that this is the guy (even though SIL persued him) that broke up the first marriage in the back of our heads every time we see him.  It is hard to get past but eventually it gets easier.  Good luck.
    imageimageBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker Pregnancy Ticker
  • eh- i don't think whether or not you want to throw your sister a shower should be a whole 'dig deep down and get in touch with your feelings.'  not everything is so cut and dry.  you have a right to have mixed emotions and one day maybe you'll get over it but maybe you won't.  i personally find it difficult to forgive so easily when someone does something i am so strongly against (whether it's their life or not.)

     

    Jess and James 10.18.08
    Zoey Emma 08.18.10
    image
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Thank you to everyone for our advice. Kathy, I know some of it stems from my feelings. She told me one before I wasn't being supportive right after it all came out. I told her then that I didn't agree with her decisions. I think I'll probably offer to help logistically with it and maybe offer to make desserts. It is the first grandkid for the mom so I knew something would come up. It is still a few months away. Thanks again, I love having people to ask.
    image
  • kathy is wise...
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards