Minneapolis/St. Paul Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

MIL vent

...because my sisters and friends IRL aren't sharing my outrage fast enough Stick out tongue

Okay, so MIL has been convinced for years that DH's allergy meds are going to kill him (he takes Zyrtec D bc he's allergic to cats, trees, mold, pollen, dust, and a handful of other REALLY common things).  Whatever.  So now, he just got diagnosed with some new fun stomach stuff.  Some of it can aggravate asthma, so that's part of why he has attacks maybe once a week (mild).

Now she's convinced that it's our cats that are causing this, and we should really consider getting rid of them. (Allergy side note - allergies can vary based on the type of cat.  Most importantly, you can get used to a particular cat(s), and that cat's dander won't bother you anymore, or at least not to the same degree - he doesn't even always remember his meds at home and he's fine)

Yep, she's serious.

Never mind the fact that no doctor has made any connection between any of these new things and his allergies.  And the fact that his allergies when we're at home are now quite calm.  And the fact that he says his allergies are much better now than they were when he was a kid - you know, when she was in charge.  And you know, totally forget the fact that we love them.  They're just cats, you know.

But we should totally consider getting rid of the cats, and it was really selfish of me to force him to live with them. 

This has been a running joke in our house for the past week, because OMG.

So now, he just got off the phone with her, because it's her birthday and he had to call.  She was back on it.  She wants him to live for a month without the cats and see how he feels.

SHE SERIOUSLY JUST OFFERED TO PAY FOR HIM TO LIVE IN A HOTEL FOR A MONTH.

There are no words.

Re: MIL vent

  • Lordy, she must hate cats!  Does she think the cats are causing the stomach problems??  I've never heard of anyone's cat allergies manifesting as stomach problems.

    Probably best not to leave you MIL alone with the cats... or allow her into your house when you're not home...  I'd be afraid of her...doing something...to the cats, if she's that obsessed about their potential dangers.

     By the way, has your husband considered allergy shots?  I'm allergic to all that stuff too (minus the cats, thank goodness), and the allergy shots seem to be helping a lot.

    Also, my husband was super super super allergic to cats, and he lost his cat allergies completely after being forced to live with two cats for about 6 months (he was living with a friend at the time).  He took medicine for it and was able to survive living with them.  Then we decided to get our own cat, he discovered he no longer needed the medicine at all!  He can even be around other people's cats now... pretty amazing difference.

  • You should ask her for money for a hotel and then tell her you used it to get more cats.  Devil
    image
    Tired after a long morning of hiking and swimming.
  • imagelittlemissflip:

    Lordy, she must hate cats!  Does she think the cats are causing the stomach problems??  I've never heard of anyone's cat allergies manifesting as stomach problems.

    Probably best not to leave you MIL alone with the cats... or allow her into your house when you're not home...  I'd be afraid of her...doing something...to the cats, if she's that obsessed about their potential dangers.

     By the way, has your husband considered allergy shots?  I'm allergic to all that stuff too (minus the cats, thank goodness), and the allergy shots seem to be helping a lot.

    Also, my husband was super super super allergic to cats, and he lost his cat allergies completely after being forced to live with two cats for about 6 months (he was living with a friend at the time).  He took medicine for it and was able to survive living with them.  Then we decided to get our own cat, he discovered he no longer needed the medicine at all!  He can even be around other people's cats now... pretty amazing difference.

    I honestly don't know what her logic is connecting the two.  But she's convinced it's their fault somehow. Confused

    I don't think she'd do anything, but I've told DH he needs to be FAST on the responses when we see them in two weeks otherwise there's no way I'm going to be able to be civil.

    He did the shots for a while, but had some issue with them - I can't remember what.  If he ever had a serious problem, that's probably what we'd do again.

    We've definitely seen the same effects with our cats.  He had an adjustment period when we got our first cat, and again with the second, but that was TWO AND A HALF YEARS AGO. So we're fine now.

  • imagejennyk213:
    You should ask her for money for a hotel and then tell her you used it to get more cats.  Devil

    Yes 

  • I'm sorry; that's really outrageous.  A lot of people have no concept of what it means to commit to an animal and that you simply don't get rid of a pet. 

    I think your DH just needs to tell her that you two are committed to the cats and that you simply will not get rid of them, so she needs to stop talking about it.  And then, when she brings it up again, tell her "Mum (I envision him saying Mum because he's British :) ), I told you the cat discussion is closed.  Would you like the pepper?"

    That said, it isn't entirely crazy for her to have theorized that the issues are connected.  Our bodies are sort of crazy, interconnected machines, and I sometimes think Western medicine doesn't pay enough attention to how everything works together.  OF course, I still don't think you should get rid of the cats.

  • Even if you did lose tye cats, the house would have to be cleaned from top to bottom. Every single surface. The protein that causes the allergies is in the saliva. Simply removing the pets doesn't work for truly severe allergies. At any rate, I have cat allergies and 3 cats and I manage just fine.
    image
    Lilypie Premature Baby tickers

    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • I'm reasonably sure the dust/mold/pollen/tree/grass issue is WAY worse than the cats anyways.

    She's freaking nuts.  

  • FWIW, several sources in the medical community have told me immunotherapy (allergy shots) actually aren't all that effective for animal allergies.

    Many people don't get the idea that animals aren't disposable.  

    She's being ridiculous.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Wow do you have the same MIL as my bff?  My bffs DH is/was very allergic to cats but he was smart enough to know that if he wanted her, her cat was part of the package deal. He took allergy meds and 2 years later he doesn't take meds anymore and isn't allergic to their cat.  Yet, the MIL still says they have to get rid of her.  People can be such idiots.
    Never, never be afraid to do what's right, especially if the well-being of a person or animal is at stake. Society's punishments are small compared to the wounds we inflict on our soul when we look the other way."
    - Martin Luther King Jr.
    BabyFruit Ticker
  • I don't really care for cats, but it shouldn't matter how she feels about cats. It should matter that they are important to you two. Also, I'd be most upset about offering to pay for a hotel room. That makes me wonder if she has more of a problem with you than the cats.  I think that's something your dh needs to deal with
  • That's awful and I would have a hard time keeping my mouth shut around her. 
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Thanks for making me feel sane, guys!

    I'm just so glad that DH is on my side and knows she's totally nuts.  It's going to be ...interesting... when we see them next.

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards